In a reversal that surprised many gay activists and flew in the face of changes seen in some other countries recently, India’s Supreme Court on Wednesday overturned a lower-court ruling, in effect making homosexuality a crime again.
The nation’s top court overturned a 2009 Delhi High Court decision that decriminalized homosexual sex between consenting adults. In Wednesday’s ruling, the top court argued that the lower court had overstepped its mandate and had no right to augment the law.
“It is up to parliament to legislate on this issue,” said Justice G.S. Singhvi, who headed the two-judge Supreme Court bench. Wednesday was his last day before retirement.
Given the slow pace of lawmaking in India, an upcoming election and polls suggesting the conservative Bharatiya Janata Party could unseat the ruling Congress Party in national elections, it’s likely the ban introduced under British colonial rule will remain in place for the foreseeable future.
Wednesday’s decision stunned gay rights and social activists who expected the court to reaffirm the 2009 ruling in keeping with many of its recent decisions, which have expanded human rights and personal liberties. Social activist groups referred to the decision as “disappointing,” “regressive” and a “black day for India.”
“I am shocked,” said Nitin Karani, a gay rights activist and former editor of Bombay Dost magazine, which focuses on India’s homosexual community. “The judgment not only affects gay rights but the human rights of all Indians.”
Hundreds of people gathered in Bangalore, India’s high-tech hub, after the court decision, holding black banners.
Supporters of the decision heralded it as a positive development for society.
“Homosexuality’s not natural, disturbs the continuity of life, leaves the future uncertain,” said Mujtaba Farooq, president of the Welfare Party of India, a Delhi-based Muslim political group. “This is the unacceptable influence of the West.”
Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code prohibits sexual activity “against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal.” Violators, including those involved in consensual relationships, face fines and up to 10 years in prison.
While the law has rarely been enforced, analysts say it allows the police to shake down and otherwise harass homosexuals.
India, despite having produced the Kama Sutra and being home to sexually suggestive temples and monuments, remains socially conservative. Homosexuality is still taboo in much of the country, even regarded in places as a form of mental illness, forcing many people to live double lives.
Kapil Sibal, India’s law minister, declined to comment on the judgment or whether the government would try to amend the law. The Congress Party is unlikely to tackle the issue anytime soon, however, given that it’s struggling at the polls and is wary of any issue that could provide political ammunition for the Hindu nationalist opposition.
Gay and human rights activists said they planned to appeal Wednesday’s decision under what’s known as a “curative petition” to a five-justice bench, a step they described as their last hope for a remedy anytime soon.
Emboldened by the 2009 law, social changes abroad and a rising middle class, gay rights activists have staged modest gay-pride parades in recent years and tried to broaden acceptance and expand their legal rights. A government notification to the Supreme Court said there were 2.5 million homosexuals in India out of a population of 1.2 billion, of which 175,000 were HIV-positive.
About the Author
