Four defendants have been convicted in the death of a 23-year-old man who was gunned down in DeKalb County at a “date” setup through the Plenty Of Fish app.

Jordan Collins, who lived in Gwinnett County, was shot, along with his brother, Chad Collins, 26, on Sept. 1, 2016 at their sister’s home outside Lithonia. They had invited two women over, thinking it was a double date, but the brothers didn’t realize two men were waiting to rob them outside of the home, the district attorney’s office said.

READ: Boy, 9, tries to save brother from carjacker at QuikTrip, cops say 

READ: Murder suspect ID’d after dropping passport at scene, DeKalb cops say

READ: Mom broken by death of DeKalb boy, 6, shot due to social media feud

Jordan Collins was shot while trying to defend himself and died; Chad Collins took several bullets while trying to help his brother but survived.

Before the trial, which concluded Wednesday, Clarissa McGhee, 22, pleaded guilty to aggravated assault. The jury convicted 28-year-old Demarco “Blazalino” Butler, 26-year-old Antonio “Killa” Avery and 22-year-old Nashea Poole on charges including murder.

The trio are members of the 9 Trey Bloods street gang, the district attorney’s office said.

The defendants will be sentenced at a later date.

Clockwise, the defendants are: Nashea Poole, Clarissa McGhee, Antonio Avery and Demarco Butler. (Photos courtesy of DeKalb County jail)
icon to expand image

Like DeKalb County News Now on Facebook | Follow on Twitter

In other news: 

A DeKalb County murder suspect is behind bars after police say he came to them trying to report a key piece of evidence missing.

About the Author

Keep Reading

A father and daughter ride bikes along 10th Street in Atlanta on a frigid Dec. 15, 2025, days before winter's official start. While forecasters predict overall warmer weather this winter compared to the norm, we still can expect some properly cold days interspersed throughout the season. (Ben Hendren for the AJC)

Credit: Ben Hendren

Featured

Yemaya Lyles (right) wipes away tears during a news conference in front of the Rockdale County Public Schools administration building on Tuesday, Dec. 19, 2023. Lyles' son, Antonio, was assaulted by a paraprofessional, who has since been fired and charged with battery. Lyles says her case against the school district has dragged on since then. (Miguel Martinez/AJC 2023)

Credit: Miguel Martinez