An equal blend of caramel and vanilla extracts form the base cookie dough flavor in these marshmallows. With semi-sweet chocolate chips sprinkled on top of each square, the bitter flavor marries subtly with the sweet flavors of the mallow to make a soft but not overpoweringly sugary bite. Try these marshmallows in a cup of dark hot chocolate or in a dark chocolate s’more to cut the sweet aftertaste.

Size: 4.5 ounces

Price: $3.79

Available: Target and most grocery chains