Both sides have launched attack ads in the race for Georgia's 6th Congressional District. Recently, Democrats accused Republican Karen Handel of wallowing in administrative bloat. (We rated that Mostly False).
Now, the Congressional Leadership Fund, a super PAC aligned with House Speaker Paul Ryan, has an ad that paints Democrat Jon Ossoff as beholden more to people in California than voters in Georgia. It is running in the Atlanta area as part of the super PAC's $6.7 million independent expenditure.
Shot against iconic backdrops of San Francisco, actors speak cheerfully about Ossoff.
A young woman with a floppy hat and a big “Cut the military now” button says, “There’s a reason Bay Area liberals have contributed more to Jon Ossoff’s campaign than people in Georgia. He’s one of us.”
Another young woman stands in front of the Golden Gate Bridge and says “San Francisco hearts Ossoff.” With a coy toss of her ponytails, she makes a heart with her hands and presses them to her chest.
Set aside the political snark and you have this claim: San Francisco “Bay Area liberals have given more to Jon Ossoff’s campaign than people in Georgia.”
Is it so?
The Congressional Leadership Fund said it got their information from the Mercury News, a prominent local paper. An April 12 article said, "Ossoff reported 2,628 individual donations from people living in the nine Bay Area counties, significantly more than from all of Georgia — although of a smaller total value."
Here’s how the numbers shook out at the end of March when the data behind the article was collected. (The dollar total for Bay Area residents wasn’t in the article. We calculated it based on the same data.)
Georgia, 1,578 donors, $600,141;
California, 5,822 donors, $547,857;
Bay area, 2,628 donors, $290,229 (PolitiFact calculation)
So the article doesn’t back up what the ad said, that people in the Bay Area gave more to Ossoff than people in Georgia. The number of donors was higher, but they did not give more than donors in Georgia.
In fact, as the original article noted, Georgians gave more money to Ossoff than people from California. As for people in the Bay Area, we found that they gave half as much compared to voters in Georgia. More people from the Bay Area contributed than from Georgia, but that’s not what the ad claimed.
Of course, it's also important to note that the ad relies on information that is now nearly two months old. There's only so much more to learn. The last public report was on April 16. With help from staff at the Center for Responsive Politics, we updated the totals. Georgia remained in the lead, by about $640,000 compared to about $321,000 from the Bay area.
It's also worth noting that donations under $200 do not have to be itemized under Federal Election Commission rules, so we don't know where those donors live. That accounts for about two-thirds of Ossoff's donations through the end of March.
Our ruling
The Conservative Leadership Fund is running an ad that says “Bay Area liberals have given more to Jon Ossoff’s campaign than people in Georgia.” In fact, based on data available through mid April, people in Georgia have given Ossoff twice as much money as people in the Bay Area.
Bay Area donors outnumber Ossoff’s Georgia donors, but the ad did not describe the donations in those terms.
We rate this claim False.
“Bay Area liberals have given more to Jon Ossoff’s campaign than people in Georgia.”
— Congressional Leadership Fund on Monday, May 22nd, 2017 in an attack ad
About the Author
