Skip to Main Content
SPOTLIGHT

PSR has undefeated football teams getting lower seeds than teams they beat

Lowndes and Appling County are projected to finish 10-0 but get lower playoff seeds than teams they have defeated.
Todd Holcomb

Lowndes and Appling County just won marquee games between 8-0 teams, but both will be seeded in the playoffs below the teams they just defeated, according to the GHSA’s Post Season Rankings standings and Maxwell Ratings projections.

Lowndes and Appling County are among 25 teams Maxwell is projecting will get lower seeds than teams they have beaten with no other indirect results (such as three teams that are 1-1 against each other) to contradict those outcomes.

Others include North Oconee (projected No. 3 seed) ahead of Jefferson (No. 7) in Class 5A and Cairo (No. 5) ahead of Dougherty (No. 6) in Class 4A. Jefferson beat North Oconee last week. Dougherty beat Cairo earlier last month. Those were region games in regions that Jefferson and Dougherty won.

In some cases, there will be teams left out of the playoffs that beat teams that made it. One is Chattahoochee County (projected No. 32 seed in Class A) going ahead of Marion County (No. 36) and Crawford County (No. 41), teams that it defeated, and will finish ahead of Chattahoochee County in Region 4-A.

In the highest class, Lowndes beat Valdosta 32-31 last week, but the PSR standings show Valdosta (8-1) at No. 1 and Lowndes (9-0) at No. 3.

A similar scenario is playing out in Class 2A, where Toombs County (8-1) is No. 1 and Appling County (9-0) is No. 3 despite Appling’s 11-7 victory.

Lowndes and Appling County have played weaker schedules, and both are playing Top 10 opponents Friday — Lowndes vs. Colquitt County and Appling vs. Pierce County.

But even if they win those games, Lowndes and Appling will be seeded No. 2 or No. 3, according to the Maxwell Ratings, which compute the PSR and project how they will go with one week remaining in the season.

Appling County coach JD Sellers told AJC Varsity this week that he is not a fan of the PSR.

“I think it’s subjective,” Sellers said. “It’s impossible to know what teams are going to be like going into the year when schedules are made, so on and so forth. I prefer the traditional way where it was completely objective. It was how you finished, based on your win-loss record in the region, and then you went into the seeds based on that. That’s just my personal take on it, but that’s the rules of the situation, so we’ll have to line up and play however the cards fall.”

The PSR is computed using a team’s winning percentage, their opponents’ winning percentage and their opponents’ opponents’ winning percentage. In past years, the GHSA seeded based primarily or entirely on a team’s finish in region standings.

Below are the PSR standings as calculated by Maxwell with one week remaining in the regular season.

The list shows each team’s PSR current standings and its projected finish.

The GHSA’s published PSR standings are different and less accurate because of school athletic directors’ tardiness in reporting scores. More than 80 teams have inaccurate won-lost records in the GHSA’s standings, according to a Maxwell Ratings and AJC Varsity audit.