I haven’t been remotely close to correctly predicting Atlanta United’s starting 11 in its past two games.

I keep trying to force Kenwyne Jones into the 11 and manager Gerardo Martino, who is obviously a little better at this than I am, keeps putting Hector Villalba as the lone striker. Three Villalba goals in three games, and two ties at Seattle and at Toronto, supports his decisions.

So, who will start for Atlanta United against Montreal?

I’ve finally learned my lesson about Villalba, but that doesn’t mean I’m any smarter.

Originally, I went out on a very thin limb and (incorrectly) put in 16-year-old Andrew Carleton in at right midfield in place.

I reasoned that not only is Carleton pretty darn good, Yamil Asad can't play because of the red card in the 75th minute against Toronto. So, he's out.

Jacob Peterson didn’t play last week because of an injury. He is back but is listed as questionable.

Add in that Carleton made the trip to Seattle but wasn’t in the 18, and then made the trip to Toronto and was in the 18 and it seems somewhat logical that this week he will make the 18…and the 11.

But he will be training with the U18 U.S. team, which I had forgotten.

His speed would be invaluable if Atlanta United tries to flip the field with the quick counter-attacks proved so effective in scoring two goals against Toronto.

Anyway, I’m putting Peterson back in at the wing.

The rest of the lineup will be mostly the same.

About the Author

Keep Reading

Atlanta United forward Emmanuel Latte Lath (left) scores a goal during the Leagues Cup match against the Pumas UNAM at Inter&Co Stadium on Saturday Aug. 2, 2025, in Orlando, Fla. (Mitch Martin/Atlanta United)

Credit: Mitch Martin/Atlanta United

Featured

Fulton DA Fani Willis (center) with Nathan J. Wade (right), the special prosecutor she hired to manage the Trump case and had a romantic relationship with, at a news conference announcing charges against President-elect Donald Trump and others in Atlanta, Aug. 14, 2023. Georgia’s Supreme Court on Tuesday, Sept. 16, 2025, upheld an appeals court's decision to disqualify Willis from the election interference case against Trump and his allies. (Kenny Holston/New York Times)

Credit: NYT