Powered by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Get Schooled

Posted: 11:40 p.m. Wednesday, Jan. 1, 2014

Allowing Dunwoody to form its own school district is mistake, return to 'bright dividing lines' 

  • comment(274)

Should we allow new cities to create their own school districts?
Should we allow new cities to create their own school districts?

By Maureen Downey

Earlier this week, I ran a guest column by Erika Harris urging support for a proposed constitutional amendment allowing newly formed cities in Georgia to also create their own school systems.The issue looms large in DeKalb County where the city of Dunwoody is weighing breaking from DeKalb Schools. But it can't do so without a change to the state constitution, which is what House Resolution 486 proposes.

Likely to be debated this legislative session, the resolution states: Proposing an amendment to the Constitution so as to authorize any municipality created on or after January 1, 2005, and any municipality which is contiguous to a municipality created on or after January 1, 2005, irrespective of whether such municipalities may be in different counties, to establish individually or collectively by local law an independent school system; to provide for related matters; to provide for the submission of this amendment for ratification or rejection; and for other purposes.

Here is a response to Harris' column by Pine Lake Councilman George Chidi,  CEO of the competitive intelligence consultancy Neon Flag and a Georgia Tech MBA. Chidi is part of the Peach Pundit team blog and an associate editor for RawStory.com.

By George Chidi

 I’ve read Erika Harris’ piece advocating for a new school system for Dunwoody. You’ll probably have people lined up around the block looking to write the counter-argument. I’d like to offer mine.


Put simply, it says that Georgia is just fine with inescapable ghettos. It’s a return of bright dividing lines, like Ponce de Leon once was in Atlanta, with a photogenically multi-racial middle-and-upper class community who can reach for the American Dream on one side, and a mostly black, uniformly poor people who can’t on the other side.


It spits on the grave of Martin Luther King, Jr.


That’s a strong statement. And it may seem unacceptably facile to frame the question as a racial issue. The new Dunwoody district would be about 50 percent non-white, after all. But neither this issue nor King’s legacy was solely about race. A separate Dunwoody school system – and the cascade of newly separated systems the amendment creates – exacerbates a class problem that metro Atlanta too often ignores.

The amendment would allow any new city and any municipality which is contiguous to a municipality created on or after January 1, 2005 to form a new school system. Look at the proposed incorporation lines for Lakeside and Tucker. Then look at the plans Clarkston, Avondale Estates and Stone Mountain have for annexation. Clarkston goes north to the proposed Lakeside border. Stone Mountain has all of Smoke Rise on the table, connecting it to either Lakeside or Tucker. And Avondale Estates looks like it is coming really close to the Lakeside line. 

Given the rejection of the Druid Hills independent cluster by the DeKalb board of education a few weeks ago, I might expect its proponents to start thinking about incorporation.

Funding per student falls – if all of the possible cities choose their own districts – by about $1500 per student, in my estimation. Perversely, it costs less to educate students in systems in wealthy neighborhoods because the administrative costs and special education costs tend to be lower. Dunwoody and the districts that could form might pay about $8000 per student in the districts that leave, while the remaining DeKalb system would have costs of about $11,500, given the number of special needs students, school resource officers and other costs. (I am not accounting for the obvious and unacceptable bloat in the DeKalb public school system. Call it $250 a student.)


Put it like this -- the remaining two-thirds of the county would be covering two-thirds of the students on roughly one-third the tax base. It's an implied tax increase of 100 percent or a service reduction of one half of the rest of the county’s school taxes. 

Take the the average home in zip code 30083 – an area in central DeKalb County near Pine Lake. A typical home is worth about $70,000 right now. (Compare that to averages closer to $175,000 in the areas looking to incorporate.) A homeowner there would pay about $300 a year more for school taxes on a $70,000 house. At current interest rates, the implied loss of net present value for a $300 extra annual cost is about $10,000.

Roughly two thirds of the houses in zip code 30083 are under water. Take $10,000 out of their equity, and the figure becomes 85 percent. It means most people couldn't afford to move without losing their house to foreclosure. Dunwoody’s move to separate its school system would trap everyone else in a place with underfunded, underperforming schools.

Harvard and Stanford released a study earlier this year looking at every metropolitan statistical area in the country, to see where someone born in poverty has the best and worst chances of rising to the top quintile of income. Atlanta placed dead last of America’s largest 50 metro areas, and 99th out of the top 100.


The key correlation wasn’t race. It was how much mixture people in poverty had with the middle class and wealthy families, how much time they spent working together, playing together, going to church together … or to school together. We live in one of the most economically segregated places in the country, with more concentrated wealth and concentrated poverty than almost any other metro area in America.


A separate Dunwoody school system reinforces that problem, when we should be fighting it.


This isn’t exactly a black-white thing for me. Wealthy black families have exactly the same opportunities to educate their children that wealthy white families have. The evidence right now is that poor white families in metro Atlanta are just as screwed as poor black families in terms of being able to move up the economic ladder.


But most of the poor in DeKalb are black and Latino. And this move is going to have a disproportionate effect on people of color. I suspect that’s what it will come down to in court. As a city, Dunwoody can zone to keep low-income families from being able to move in. The net effect will be to push poorer (read: black) families over time into the now-further-weakened DeKalb County school system.


I understand why Dunwoody wants it. The majority of the DeKalb County Board of Education was useless and potentially corrupt. The county should be taking much more visible steps to fight corruption and to win back the public trust. And it’s not. Too many county leaders appear to be in a state of denial, ready to denounce accusers as simply racist.


But the new board is very strong. Kicking the legs out from under it now would be an unforgivable blow to the majority of the system’s students, just when things are looking up.

Maureen Downey

About Maureen Downey

Maureen Downey is a longtime reporter for the AJC where she has written editorials and opinion pieces about local, state and federal education policy for 12 years.

Connect with Maureen Downey on:FacebookTwitter

Send Maureen Downey an email.

  • comment(274)


Today on MyAJC.com

Bulldogs cruise to 34-0 win

Richt deserves credit for keeping Dogs together

Georgia sat at the rarest of sports’ intersections the past two games, losing its best player to a suspension, but flourishing in adverse circumstances and playing its best football of the season.

Most reliable vehicle brands

Photos: Most reliable 2014 vehicles

Consumer Reports’ list of most-reliable 2014 vehicles is out, with Toyota and its companion Lexus brand dominating several categories.

July 28, 2014

Supreme Court sets hearings for stadium challengers

Challengers to both the Falcons and Braves stadium financing deals have been granted hearings before the Georgia Supreme Court in which they’ll argue against local plans to issue taxpayer-backed bonds for stadium construction.

Comments  (9)  

Subscribe to the AJC on your device

24-hour Digital Pass: Flashback

See Flashback Fotos on myajc.com for only 99 cents. Visit the MyAJC archives for a historic look at Atlanta from Midtown in the 70s to Auburn Avenue and even life here before traffic jams on the interstates.

In your community

Annual Woofstock event in Suwanee

Volunteering in Atlanta

Learn how to volunteer in Atlanta and north Georgia, browse volunteer events and search local groups who need volunteers in the arts, community, food programs, housing, animal rescue and more.


Mark Arum Weekend Construction Outlook

Updated every Friday, Mark Arum tells us where we can find construction, events and anything else to slow us down on the roads this weekend.