Register now, it's free!
Log In | Customer Care

ajcsportstalk

Talkin' sports

What's on this page →

The entry titled "Should Dogs be No. 1 in preseason?," and any of the comments about it.

Commenting is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. M-F

RSS feed

Comment Removal Request

Access Atlanta Blogs

News & Features

Opinion

Health

MOMania

Sports

Should Dogs be No. 1 in preseason?

By Jeff D'Alessio | Saturday, February 9, 2008, 04:14 PM

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Just 30 more Saturdays until another college football season kicks off at Sanford Stadium.

What are the odds that Matthew Stafford and Georgia will go into that Aug. 30 opener against Georgia Southern as the nation’s top-ranked team?

As we await the start of spring practice, we asked a few experts who they had atop their early fall ballots.

Georgia? Southern Cal? West Virginia? Missouri? None of the above?

NEAL McCREADY, AP Top 25 voter (Mobile Press-Register)

“I’d vote Georgia No. 1 today for a myriad of reasons. First and foremost, the Bulldogs have balance on offense. Stafford’s mistakes are going to be fewer and more far between as a junior, and Knowshon Moreno has the talent and personality to build an offense around. Mark [Richt] has recruited at such a high level over the past few seasons, and that depth of talent — as LSU proved last season — ultimately wins out. I love Georgia’s schedule. Tennessee goes to Athens, as does Alabama, and UGA isn’t going to be intimidated by Florida anymore. [Southern Cal] has to replace a quarterback and there is scandal hanging over that program. Everything lines up for Georgia.”

ERIC HANSEN, AP Top 25 voter (South Bend Tribune)

“I think there are a whole lot of teams that could make a pretty legitimate claim to be the preseason No. 1. Having said that, I’m going to go with Ohio State, in spite of their underwhelming performance against LSU in New Orleans. I think [Butkus Award-winning linebacker] James Laurinaitis coming back was key. I think they’ll be the best defensive team in the country and will be much improved offensively. The Sept. 13 matchup at USC is going to have a lot to say about the national title race. Otherwise, the schedule is favorable, with Penn State and an in-transition Michigan team at home. Potential pitfalls are at Wisconsin and at Illinois.”

BRUCE FELDMAN (ESPN The Magazine)

“I like Georgia for No. 1 at this point. The Dawgs have an experienced starting quarterback returning, a star to carry the offense in Knowshon Moreno and an O-line that really matured as the 2007 season went along. I also think the boost they get from finishing the year with such a statement game will help drive guys to believe that bigger things are coming. The schedule doesn’t break well since they have a bunch of tough road trips but LSU survived a loaded schedule so I’m not ready to dismiss Georgia for it.”

SCOTT RABALAIS, AP Top 25 voter (Baton Rouge Advocate)

“My vote would be for USC. I covered the Sugar Bowl, and USC’s blowout of an Illinois team that was light years better than Hawaii was more impressive than Georgia’s win. Much more impressive. Hawaii was nowhere near as good as the BCS interlopers we’ve seen in recent years from Utah and Boise State.

“Edge to Georgia over USC with [Matthew] Stafford returning at QB, but the Trojans are oozing talent. Both teams have something to prove — Georgia getting routed by Tennessee, USC losing to Stanford — but I think the Trojans have proven their worth as a consistent national contender moreso than Georgia has. Would loved to have seen them play in the Rose Bowl — would be just as interested to see them meet in Miami in January.”

WENDELL BARNHOUSE, Fort Worth Star-Telegram

“I would give Georgia a slight edge over USC because the Bulldogs have an experienced QB coming back. USC’s non-conference schedule is considerably more difficult. As of right now, I’d probably lean toward Georgia as the preseason No. 1.”

LENN ROBBINS, New York Post

“I’m going Oklahoma. Sam Bradford is the best QB [Bob] Stoops has had, the defense will be loaded again, and I like the way the schedule shapes up. Georgia is No. 2. Mark Richt has quietly emerged as one of college football’s most consistent coaches. USC has more talkent than the Falcons but it’s so hard to keep that level of consistency. I can’t get over that Stanford loss.”

STEWART MANDEL, AP Top 25 voter (SI.com)

“Georgia [is No. 1]. Of the teams that finished high last year, they have by far the most key players coming back, with the possible exception of Ohio State, but there’s obviously reason for skepticism there.”

MATT HAYES (Sporting News)

“USC — the safest surest thing at this point. Georgia would be a close second, but the Trojans have loads of skill players on offense, and a deep, athletic front seven on defense. Whoever plays QB — Mark Sanchez or Mitch Mustain — will thrive in that offense. Sanchez played well while John David Booty was injured, and Mustain and wide receiver transfer Damian Williams were terrific in USC’s weekly Tuesday scrimmage — which is, in a word, intense.”

BRET BLOOMQUIST, AP Top 25 voter (El Paso Times)

“Well, not Hawaii. At the moment, Georgia, followed by Florida and USC.”

Permalink | Comments (190) | Post your comment | Categories: UGA

Comments

By David Lee

February 9, 2008 4:33 PM | Link to this

NEAL McCREADY, he likes the Dawgs schedule and it lines up? We play all the top teams in the SEC and have to make a trip out to AZ state. This guy is some Britney Spears type drugs.

By tim

February 9, 2008 4:33 PM | Link to this

first!

By Jersey Dawg

February 9, 2008 4:35 PM | Link to this

it’s exciting to even be considered no. 1, but, we have a very tough schedule and I’m still not sure how the team would react to all the hype. But, love the Dawgs and excited about the year!

By uga121

February 9, 2008 4:37 PM | Link to this

hansen is an idiot…ohio has the strongest defense in the nation I’m sure that’s why they got killed by LSU. What a joke!!!

By FLA DAWG

February 9, 2008 4:42 PM | Link to this

I’m sure we’ll start the season in the Top 5 and hope we end the season #1!

LET THE BIG DAWGS EAT!!!!

By jim

February 9, 2008 4:43 PM | Link to this

Who cares at this point? Georgia will prove themselves on the field next season and people will be forced to see how great they are by the way they play. Georgia will take care of they naysayers and sit on top when final poll comes out. Until then, much to do about nothing.

By Dawgbyte

February 9, 2008 4:56 PM | Link to this

Robbins, New York Post: “…USC has more talent than the Falcons…”. Think I would try someone a little more knowledgeable.

By Dogs will Choke

February 9, 2008 4:59 PM | Link to this

I would have put them # 1 but I still cant get over the 16-12 loss to South Carolina and also the 2nd straight year in a row a$$ kickin from Tenn. ! So they are still overrated and the jury is still out!

By Jp

February 9, 2008 5:16 PM | Link to this

But the problem is Hansen is from Indiana. Of course he thinks a Big 10 defense can compare to the SEC. Man i’d like to see UGA go against OSU. We would destroy that offense and that defense is weak. We would score 35 on em easily. You can’t trust people from the midwest to have a fair opinion. There is so much bias in picking OSU #1.

By GW

February 9, 2008 5:18 PM | Link to this

I hope #1 come January 10. For right now, let’s drop the subject.

By reality check

February 9, 2008 5:23 PM | Link to this

It doesn’t matter where we start. The season will take care of itself. Last year we had so many questions to open the season, but not now.

Florida could come on, but at this point they have big question marks at running back and defensive tackle. LSU returns some impressive players too, and Georgia has to play them and Florida back to back on the road.

Georgia has great coaching to overcome the challenges we had the past two years. The biggest difference this year is more depth than I have ever seen at Georgia.

By Johnny Danger Dawg

February 9, 2008 5:31 PM | Link to this

I notice that almost every “expert” looks at the schedules to try to figure out each team’s chances of going undefeated. THAT’S NOT HOW PRESEASON RANKINGS SHOULD BE DETERMINED. The #1 team should be whoever STARTS the season with the best team.

By PTC DAWG

February 9, 2008 5:39 PM | Link to this

ANYONE who would vote Ohio State #1 is an idiot. The Big 11 Champion should be BANNED from playing in the BCS title game and the SEC Champion should get an automatic invite.

By Steve

February 9, 2008 5:48 PM | Link to this

Hey Tim you must have been asleep.

By mirandawasrobbed

February 9, 2008 5:54 PM | Link to this

I knew that the one guy picking Ohio State would make all the southern goobers go crazy. If I had to pick a pre-season #1 I geuss I’d go with USC and UGA at #2.

By Krogunner

February 9, 2008 5:54 PM | Link to this

Maybe when Georgia has won some championships (in our life time)their fans will realize it really doesn’t matter where you start. I say they start the year high and get their rears handed to them again by the ole Ball Coach. No matter how much experience, Stafford is still inaccurate and will still make his share of bone head plays.

Three loses and a trip to the Outback Bowl in 08 and a chance to watch the Gators win another title in Miami.

By the way, nice basketball program! Maybe one day you can run with the Big Boys and have a complete athletic program. No wonder there is so much venom on these blogs towards Florida.

Go Gators!

By Bayou Tiger

February 9, 2008 6:01 PM | Link to this