Is it the right time for U.S. to leave?

Yes. Dan Reiter. Chairman political science department, Emory University

It is time for the U.S. to leave Iraq. Internal security is improving. The U.S. and Iraq have agreed on a timetable for gradual withdrawal. The top U.S. military officer in Iraq, Gen. Ray Odierno, supports the withdrawal plan. Withdrawal from Iraq on a timetable negotiated with an elected Arab parliament will aid the U.S. in its diplomatic rebranding process, demonstrating that the U.S. is not an imperial power bent on occupying the Middle East and destroying Islam, but rather an active world citizen who respects the sovereignty and democratic process of other nations. U.S. forces in Iraq need to be sent to Afghanistan to fight the Taliban and al-Qaida, and to aid Pakistan’s fight against extremists. Iraq may not yet be perfectly democratic, stable and prosperous, but to oppose withdrawal because Iraq is “not ready” would keep U.S. forces there for years, if not decades.

No. Rep Paul Broun (R-Ga., 10th District)

As a former military officer, I am fully aware of the costs, both human and financial, associated with our mission in Iraq. A political debate about the reasons for our entry into Iraq should not overshadow a critical discussion on the consequences of a hasty withdrawal. Clearly, there has been steady progress in Iraq since the surge was implemented. There are already fewer troops in Iraq now than at peak surge levels and the strategy has always been to reduce gradually as security and political conditions improve. However, that decision should be based on the recommendations of generals on the ground in Iraq —- not politicians in Washington. Removing troops prematurely will undo the tremendous progress and sacrifices made since the surge was implemented. I believe the Iraqi people will achieve complete autonomy faster if American lawmakers follow advice from our military commanders on the ground rather than public opinion poll numbers.

Compiled by external content editor Tom Sabulis, tsabulis@ajc.com