Home > Gwinnett > Rick Badie / My Opinion > Archives > 2007 > September > 08 > Entry
“Blame the Illegals”
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Some people don’t mind expressing their hatred when it comes to illegal immigrants.
I got some gems in my blog after Thursday’s column about the dwindling number of day laborers at a doughnut shop off Jimmy Carter Boulevard.
“Illegal immigrants are the bane of the American existence,” wrote someone who identified himself or herself as “Alexis.” The writer is embarrassed that his or her subdivision - Sugarloaf Country Club - is so close to “nasty ghettos” that have been inhabited by ” barrio thug invaders.”
Unless there are two Sugarloafs in Gwinnett, that would be the same address of “Mansion Madam” Lisa Ann Taylor, who faces charges of cocaine and marijuana possession, conspiracy to distribute cocaine, prostitution and keeping a place of prostitution.
I’ve come to expect such nastiness anytime I write about the immigration issue. Gwinnett apparently was quite heavenly before the floodgates opened and cheap illegal labor poured in to cut the grass at places like Sugarloaf.
Illegal immigrants, it seems, have ruined this once-beautiful county. Single-handedly, I might add.
In truth, though, some of us suffer from a chronic disease called “Blame the illegals.”
Car won’t start? Blame the illegal immigrants.
Late for work? It’s an illegal immigrant’s fault.
Son hooked on crystal meth? It’s them illegal immigrants.
Marriage sucks? Blame an illegal immigrant.
Yes, I’m being silly, but you get the point.
Without question, the issue of illegal immigration - its causes, impact on community, and resolution - is important. Too bad the most vocal among us find the topic hard to discuss cogently, without resorting to hatred and name-calling.
Truth be told, those kinds of attitudes are probably based on perceptions and conventional wisdom that’s unsubstantiated but accepted as gospel. Truth is hard to get at.
Joshua Holland has written the best analysis I’ve read on the immigration issue. His article, called “Toward a Real Immigration Debate,” can be read at www.alternet.org/workplace/34713/. Be forewarned, though: It may not support your views, regardless of whether you’re pro-immigration or anti-immigration.
As for my Thursday column, the majority of people who posted comments, called or e-mailed were quite civil. It wasn’t because they held soft spots for illegal immigrants. They simply don’t group all Latinos under one roof or make sweeping generations. They viewed the average illegal immigrant as everyday people doing what they can to make a living and raise a family.
Guy Stevens, 80, of Norcross put it best.
“Suppose you live somewhere and don’t have a job, but across the road there are plenty,” he told me.
“What would you do?”
Stevens doesn’t understand all the vileness. He’s old Norcross, a 1944 graduate of Norcross High. He lives off Beaver Ruin Road, a native who didn’t pack up for Jefferson, Ga., or Jackson County when Hispanics started moving in.
To stay fit, Stevens plays golf and works out several days a week at Bally Fitness in Norcross. After his workout Friday morning, we met for breakfast at a Waffle House on Jimmy Carter Boulevard.
Over grits and coffee, we talked about a little bit of everything, most of it related to Gwinnett - changes in his lifetime. This notion of nostalgia for the good old days doesn’t stick with Stevens.
“In the good old days, I walked two miles to school,” he said, chuckling. “We didn’t have electricity or paved roads. I remember my father would have to leave his car on Buford Highway and walk home when the road got too muddy.”
Stevens thanked me for the points I raised in Thursday’s column, which labeled illegal immigration a problem, but certainly no greater than foreclosures and overdevelopment in the region.
All Hispanics are not Mexicans. All Mexicans are not illegal immigrants. And all illegal immigrants shouldn’t be pegged the scapegoats in this mess of a county.
Stop the blame.
And the hatred.
Rick Badie’s column appears on Sundays, Tuesdays and Thursdays. Contact him at 770-263-3875 or e-mail rbadie@ajc.com.





DEL.ICIO.US