Countdown 2008: ROAD TO THE WHITE HOUSE

Foes of illegal immigration feel left out
Neither candidate for president comes close to pleasing hard-liners as Obama, McCain basically agree on paths to citizenship.


Los Angeles Times
Published on: 06/25/08

Washington —- In 2007, an increasingly powerful grass-roots movement celebrated its success in killing an effort to legalize millions of unlawful immigrants. Its influence spread as a procession of presidential candidates proclaimed their support.

But now there are just two candidates for the nation's top office, Democratic Sen. Barack Obama and Republican Sen. John McCain. And both have taken immigration stands that restrictionist groups find appalling.

Although heavily supported and highly organized, those who oppose illegal immigration suddenly find themselves without a champion.

"That's the reality we're dealing with: a choice we don't consider a choice," said Roy Beck, executive director of NumbersUSA, which advocates stricter controls on legal and illegal immigration. "These two guys were pretty much at the bottom of all the candidates. They're the worst, the bottom of the barrel, that ended up winning."

But a loose coalition of activist groups has rejected the prospect of sitting out the presidential campaign or waiting until next time. Instead, they have begun working to hem in the future president.

They have pushed for new city and state laws, helping spur hundreds of bills around the country in the past three months. They've held conferences to educate members nationwide and lobby local officials.

And they are working to promote the election of congressional candidates who take a hard line on immigration.

The strategy is to reshape the national political landscape to fend off future liberalization proposals.

"We're doing everything we can to dig in, in the states and in Congress," said William Gheen, president of Americans for Legal Immigration, a political action committee.

Activists change course

The groups see Obama and McCain as largely indistinguishable on immigration.

McCain, while toughening his stance recently, has backed proposals providing a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants.

Obama favors a similar mix of enforcement and legalization.

"The chances of influencing one of these two guys to take a pro-worker, pro-environment position are very low," Beck said. However, "bringing public pressure to bear to not dismantle enforcement and improve border security has some chance of success."

The staff of the Immigration Reform Law Institute has been working since 2002 to aid state legislators concerned about illegal immigration. With every step of the way, there have been legal challenges to the bills they have written, said institute director Michael M. Hethmon. But they have learned how to make their bills stronger.

"We were constantly learning," Hethmon said.

Working at state level

His group and Gheen's have developed a state-level legislative package that requires businesses to verify the legality of all new employees, bans public assistance for illegal immigrants and makes it a felony to transport an illegal immigrant.

They have helped turn that package into tough, state-level immigration laws by offering their help for free. The Immigration Reform Law Institute has worked on bills in Georgia, Virginia, Oklahoma, Arizona, Mississippi and Colorado, as well as South Carolina, where illegal immigrants are now barred from attending college.

At least 1,106 measures were considered in 44 states in the first quarter of 2008, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.

"We see this state and local activity as not only effective in itself ... but there's also the long effect as, one by one, these states line up," Hethmon said. "As these jurisdictions confront this issue, it builds up a positive and helpful kind of pressure on Congress."

NumbersUSA concentrates on elections but soon will expand its work to legislation, Beck said. For now, the group tracks the immigration positions of every candidate in every race and assigns them a grade that is distributed monthly to the organization's 640,000 members.

Beck boasted that NumbersUSA has an average of 1,300 members in every congressional district in the country but added, "We need more participation on the ground."

To that end, Beck is traveling to find people to serve as fund-raisers and local leaders in preparation for November's congressional races. He argued that a Democratic Congress "doesn't necessarily mean bad things for us."

Some freshman Democrats who won seats in Republican districts are tough on illegal immigration because "they need a way to show people that they're different from the party leadership," he said.

Beck once saw the same split among Republicans. While the Bush administration and much of the party leadership backed reform that would legalize illegal immigrants, Republican backbenchers increasingly shifted to the conservative stance.

"We've spent the last seven years separating the Republican backbench from the party leadership with tremendous success," said Beck, who said his sights are now on the Democrats. "We'll continue to push that line hard."

Vote for this story!

Search AJC Archives

1985 to present     1868 - 1939 Advanced search

Kudzu.com services Find the right people for the job

Keyword     Business Name

AJCPets » The community for Atlanta pet lovers