Weather

Partly Cloudy

81° F

Pollen 8

| Traffic

Experts say tornadoes in big cities still rare
Tough to know why: Do buildings impair cell formation, or will urban heat spur more storms?


The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 03/19/08

Of the thousands of tornadoes that have been spawned across the country in the past decade, very few have landed on major cities.

We remember the exceptions. Among them: Nashville in 1998, Fort Worth, Texas, in 2000, Atlanta this past week.


 
Chris Stanfield/AJC
Dan Patterson of Woodstock tries to make a call as he views downtown Atlanta through the Omni Hotel's broken glass at the CNN Center after Friday's tornado.
 
STORM AFTERMATH

IRS giving storm victims more time to file
Officials believe man killed in tornado was seeking shelter
Federal aid available in Fulton

PHOTOS:
One month after tornado
Oakland Cemetery
NW Georgia devastation
Scene downtown 3 days after
East Atlanta recovers
Cabbagetown
Vine City | Rome
Aerial view of damage
Downtown 1 | 2
Readers' photos 1 | 2 | 3

MORE:
Woman killed by tornado mourned
Landmarks damaged | Map

VIDEOS:
On YouTube
Aerials show downtown devastation
Atlantans survey damage
Storm hits

MORE ALERTS:
Get AJC breaking news & traffic alerts on your mobile device.

In the wake of Friday's direct hit on downtown Atlanta — the first since record-keeping began in the 19th century — this question, or myth, some might say, has been much discussed: Are tornadoes less likely to touch down in urban areas? If so why?

Among some weather watchers, there is speculation that a city's built environment might suppress the formation of funnel clouds, said John Trostel, deputy director of the Severe Storms Research Center at Georgia Tech.

The theory is that the smooth flow of air into a storm cell is disrupted by tall buildings.

But Trostel also points out that the heat-trapping quality of the urban environment ought to produce the exact opposite effect, which would enhance storm production.

Such an effect might help explain the observation that in Georgia, Fulton and Cobb are among the counties that produced the highest number of tornadoes between 1950 and 2006, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

But according to Trostel and others, that could also be a function of population, rather than incidence. More tornadoes get reported in more populated counties, where there are people there to report them.

Harold Brooks, with NOAA's National Severe Storms Laboratory in Norman, Okla., said the number of tornadoes occurring in urban areas is so tiny in any case that any ground effect from either heat or structures is lost among the statistical insignificance of the sample.

So the truth, it seems, is that cities are so relatively tiny, in comparison with the expanse of the countryside around them, that the odds of the already rare tornado landing on one are very steep.

"As far as we can tell," Brooks said, "metropolitan areas don't have any impact; you can't see any difference."

DOWNTOWN TORNADOES

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration says these cities have been hit by twisters in the past 30 years:

CityDateLevel
AtlantaMarch 14, 2008EF2*
JacksonvilleAug. 12, 2004F2
Fort Worth, TexasMarch. 28, 2000F2
Salt Lake CityAug. 11, 1999F2
Little RockJan. 21, 1999F3
NashvilleApril 16, 1998F3
MiamiMay 12, 1997F1
HoustonNov. 16, 1993F1
Huntsville, Ala.Nov. 15, 1989F4
Shreveport, La.Dec. 3, 1978F4
Shreveport, La.April 17, 1978F2

*Tornadoes are classified on the EF (Enhanced Fujita) or F (Fujita) scale of weak (0-1), strong (2-3) and violent (4-5).

Highest fatalities in city tornadoes

  • 255: St. Louis, May 27, 1896
  • 114: Waco, Texas, May 11, 1953
  • 79: St. Louis, Sept. 29, 1927

24 tornadoes have struck U.S. cities since 1871. The only cities to be struck more than once:

  • St. Louis: 4 (1871, 1896, 1927, 1959)
  • Shreveport, La.: 2 (April and December 1978)

— Source: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

Inside AJC.COM

Atlanta's best shoe store

Atlanta's best shoe store

Is it therapy to buy a pair of shoes? Discuss ... or nominate your favorite place to find those shoes!

More meat, please

More meat, please

McDonald's has unveiled a line of bigger burgers that will satisfy large appetites and scare cardiologists.

BET Awards

BET Awards

Photos: Janet Jackson, Monica, Maxwell, Jamie Foxx, New Edition, Keri Hilson, Ciara and more!

Private Quarters Splurge

Private Quarters Splurge

Husband and wife architects created a modern house that's still warm and inviting.

She lost 60 pounds!

She lost 60 pounds!

"My confidence is through the roof ... I can do anything," says Sonya Moste of Fayetteville.

Ultimate Braves fans

Ultimate Braves fans

Francoeur's Franks? Shef's Chefs? Just some of the passionate fans who have cheered the team.

Kudzu Services » Find the right people for the job