You've got a dilemma: Part of you wants to go into management consulting
to learn about business strategy and make piles of money. Another part
of you wants to save the rainforests, help the homeless, or help facilitate
the peace process in Northern Ireland. Being a good consultant and trying
to make the world a better place are two very worthwhile endeavors. But
who's got time to do both?
You do–if you make it your top priority. Dale Caldwell went into consulting
to learn how to better serve his community. As the founder of the National
Association of Black Management Consultants and a global recruiting director
at Deloitte, he was a driving force behind diversity-improvement initiatives.
He recently left the firm to become executive director of the Newark Alliance,
a nonprofit organization devoted to urban renewal in Newark, New Jersey.
First, what does management consulting have to do with urban renewal?
For one thing, many of the minorities in management consulting lived in underprivileged
urban areas and wish to go back to help those communities. Take me–I was
born in Boston, lived in Harlem, lived in Roxbury, and went to high school
in New Haven, Connecticut.
Second, our business-school educations and consulting backgrounds have equipped
us with unique analytical and problem-solving skills that can be very powerful
when applied to urban development issues. In a way, becoming a consultant
is like contracting a disease–it makes you a compulsive problem-solver.
If there's a cause you have a passion for, you can't help but apply your
consulting knowledge to it.
In 1995 you founded the National Association of Black
Management Consultants. What does your organization do?
The mission of the NABMC is twofold: The first is to work with individuals
and corporations to increase the number of minorities in the consulting profession.
And the second is to use the same type of strategic approach that consultants
use to help clients to address the problems of urban areas. The NAMBC also
publishes a magazine called Management Consulting that puts a spotlight on
issues affecting minority consultants.
What inspired you to start the NABMC?
In 1994, as a senior manager at Deloitte, I attended the National Black MBA
Association conference in San Francisco. During a lull in the activities,
I walked around the conference center and mentally tallied the number of
African-American partners and senior managers working at the various competitor
firms. Of the 12 major firms I surveyed, I came up with 11 black partners
and 24 senior managers, and that was out of thousands, which was dismal.
But as blatant as the problem was, to my knowledge there was no organization
out there that was addressing it.
Having been in consulting for a while, I recognized how influential consultants
are in the business world. There's not a merger or an acquisition that goes
by without some input from consultants. And yet minorities–Africans,
Hispanics, and Native Americans–really haven't been a part of that,
because their numbers are so small. So I vowed to start the National Association
of Black Management Consultants by the next conference. We had our first
meeting at the Ritz-Carlton in Boston a year later. There was a lot of interest
in the organization and we had a good turnout-a couple of partners from some
other firms and several senior managers.
Why are there so few minorities in management consulting?
Unfortunately, many of the MBA programs are not filled with minorities, and
as a result the management consulting profession is not that diverse. What
a lot of people don't realize is that a lot of minority MBA students who
get into the Whartons, the Harvards, and the Stanfords, for financial reasons,
may go to some of the schools not ranked in the top ten if they get a free
ride.
At Deloitte, I created what we call the Diversity Blitz in which we reached
out to programs other than the top ten to identify high-talent minority MBA
students, and put them through an accelerated on-campus recruiting process.
We were successful in extending offers to a higher percentage of minorities
than were in the class. We didn't reduce the quality of the people that we
were bringing in, but we increased the pipeline.
Because Deloitte was so successful with its Diversity Blitz, the NABMC is
encouraging other firms to implement similar programs. We work with the Consortium
for Graduate Study In Management, which provides scholarships for high-talent
minorities to attend certain state schools with strong business programs.
W
hat is the biggest challenge facing minorities in
management consulting?
It can get very lonely. For instance, you may be staffed on a string of projects
in which you might not see any other people of color. Once I was on a project
in Wyoming and I was the first African American that my clients had ever
met. They were a good bunch and it was nice educating them about another
culture, but it was also a challenge.
What are firms doing to make minority employees feel more welcome?
Many firms, including Deloitte, have diversity programs and hire directors
of diversity to oversee issues such as minority retention, development, and
promotion. Firms have also started affinity groups. I started a group within
Deloitte–the Association of Black and Latino Employees. Affinity groups
are good at getting people together. Some minorities feel that if they're
a part of these types of group, then they'll be labeled and it will impede
their career advancement. My experience has been the opposite. Affinity groups
are a great place to develop some informal mentors, to get to know folks
and develop a network. It's also a great way to educate the firm about the
particular issues of that group.
How did your consulting background help you get the job you have now?
The Newark Alliance is a catalyst focused on improving the quality of life
in Newark, New Jersey, especially education and economic development. We
are implementing so many programs ourselves, and my job as executive director
is to prioritize projects and develop a strategic approach. There are so
many good things going on in Newark, you have to be able to sensitize to
that and come up with a strategy to move the city to the next level.
Without consulting training, there's really no way that a person can develop
an implementable strategy. I feel very lucky. Wharton taught me a lot of
theory, Deloitte Consulting has provided some real training in taking that
theory and applying it, and now I'm able to use it as part of an effort to
revitalize an urban area, which can hopefully be a model for the rest of
the country.
Do consulting firms offer opportunities to do pro bono work?
Yes, although some firms are more active than others. McKinsey is really
the leader when it comes to pro bono projects. They will dedicate staff to
those issues. For instance, after the LA riots, they had a partner and managers
assigned to helping develop a strategy to revitalize Los Angeles. And it
was treated very much as a project. The consultants who worked on it got
evaluated just as they would have been for any other client project, and
it didn't slow down their progress within the firm. Monitor Group also does
that kind of work. Deloitte will support people within the firm who want
to take on side projects like that on their own – Deloitte will do
it occasionally on its own – but it's not a big part of the firm's
practice.
You switched from management consulting to nonprofit
management, which seems like a pretty dramatic and unusual career change.
What advice would you give to people just entering the consulting field who
are interested in doing something different down the road?
Know where you want to go. It's very important to know your long-term goals.
I tell that to young people especially. Too many people get into management
consulting thinking, well everyone else wants to be a partner, so I want
to be a partner. But that may not be what you're passionate about. You have
to figure out what you're passionate about, what you spend your free time
thinking about. If you want to have your own business, you have to be thinking, "How
can I use this consulting experience to set myself up to run a viable business?"If
you want to go into industry, you should be thinking, "What functional
and industry focus should I cultivate as a consultant?"
I was interested in economic development, and so as a consultant I focused
on the public sector–helping states, counties, school districts, and
public hospitals improve operations and maximize revenue. One of the projects
I worked on at Deloitte as a senior manager was developing a strategic plan
for the city of Philadelphia. That was perfect training for what I'm embarking
on now with the Newark Alliance. Every day I was with Deloitte, I was moving
towards where I wanted to be. I feel like I didn't waste any time by being
there. If you have a passion for something–if you really feel a calling
in life–it's up to you to follow through with it.
Author Bio:
Aparna Kumar is a writer and editor in San Francisco, and a former WetFeet
editor.