DO-IT-YOURSELF

The pros, cons of gutter guards


McClatchy-Tribune News Service
Published on: 07/31/08

Q: I have a two-story house with rain gutters that are too high for me to clean safely. I'd like to install a gutter cover system that will eliminate cleaning. Which is the best?

A: There are many gutter-cover systems, some of which are claimed to be free of maintenance or cleaning, but I can't presume to say which is the best. Most of the systems you are considering put a solid cap or cover on the gutter that has an opening only in the front edge — generally a slot or series of slots. Leaves and debris are supposed to wash right over the cover and fall to the ground, while the rain water enters the gutter through the slot or other opening.

RELATED:

See more Home stories

A number of readers who own this type of system have written to me, and the reports were generally favorable. However, there were some complaints that indicate some systems don't always work as claimed and might not be maintenance-free. In heavy rains, some readers said, water cascading down a roof valley or steep roof tended to overshoot the gutter, pouring water close to the foundation. Other readers said small debris such as pine needles and maple seeds tended to get inside the gutters, which eventually required cleaning.

I have tried several different types of screens on my gutters. These have many perforations that are supposed to let water enter the gutter, but keep out debris, which theoretically washes off. These also proved to be not maintenance-free. Some leaves and twigs stuck in the perforations, and small stuff such as seeds accumulated on the surface and had to be scraped off.

Getting gutter covers installed can be quite expensive. It might pay to get several estimates from leading gutter companies in your area and compare the cost to hiring outside help to clean your existing gutters periodically.

Q: I need to dig a number of post holes for a fence, and am using a clamshell-type hole digger. The soil is very hard and dry and digging a hole is tough going. Do you have any tips?

A: The clamshell digger is a great tool if you are working in soft ground. For hard, dry, rocky soil, you need some extra help. I use a long, steel digging bar to loosen the soil, then ram the clamshell blades into the hole to pick up the loose stuff. My digging bar is almost 6 feet long and weighs at least 15 pounds. Even this can be hard going at times. When the going gets really tough, I fill the hole with water. Give the water plenty of time to soak into the hard soil, and when you return to the hole you will find the digging much easier.

Vote for this story!

Inside AJC.COM

Premiere party!

Premiere party!

The W Hotel in Buckhead served as party-central Tuesday night for all things 'Housewives: Season 2'.

Private Quarters

Private Quarters

Haley Kilpatrick describes her home as "(telling) a story of who I am and where I come from."

Can you see the change?

Can you see the change?

What's altered in the two photos? See how you score when you play the Find 5 challenge!

Win free concert tickets!

Win free concert tickets!

See singer (and Dancing with the Stars alum) Sara Evans at the Mable House Barnes Amphitheatre.

Best peach cobbler

Best peach cobbler

Some imitate, some know how to bake the state's most celebrated dessert. Whose is best?

Camp stories contest

Camp stories contest

We want to hear your best stories from your childhood days at summer camp.

Kudzu Services » Find the right people for the job