Atlanta among cities where condo market glutted
Condo prices in Atlanta down 12 percent over last year


WSJ
Published on: 03/24/08

The condominium market is about to get worse as many cities brace for a flood of new supply this year — the result of construction started at the height of the housing boom.

More than 4,000 new units will be completed in both Atlanta and Phoenix by the end of the year. Developers in Miami and Fort Lauderdale, Fla., are readying nearly 10,000 total new units in a market already struggling with canyons of unsold condos. San Diego, another hard-hit region, will add 2,500 units, according to estimates provided by Reis Inc., a New York-based real-estate-research firm.

THE ECONOMY
Latest Headlines:
More Business news
Foreclosure news, tips
Search pending foreclosures
Find metro gas prices
31 ways to save

Markets »

The new building comes on top of unprecedented supply. The U.S. finished 2007 with a supply of condos large enough to absorb 10 months of demand, the highest level since the National Association of Realtors began the tally in 1999.

The deluge means bad news for developers and potentially lower prices, including in cities such as Atlanta and Dallas that have avoided the worst of the housing bust. If defaults and foreclosures rise, lenders will feel the pain too.

Regulators have been sounding the alarm for weeks about the exposure of small and mid-size banks to commercial real estate, which mostly means construction loans to developers of condos and single-family housing.

Lenders of all sizes have $42 billion of condominium debt on their books, according to Foresight Analytics. In just three months — between the third and fourth quarters of last year — the delinquency rate rose to 10 percent from 5.9 percent, says the Oakland, Calif., research firm.

The news isn't bad for everyone. Vulture buyers have started to circle, hoping to take advantage of foreclosed properties that banks may start dumping at fire-sale prices. Also, some condos are being converted to rental units, increasing supply for renters and putting downward pressure on prices.

It may seem surprising that anyone would want to add supply to a market whose troubles have been well-publicized for many months. But the economics of condo building encourage developers to bring half-finished projects to completion, even when prices and demand are plunging.

Developers usually put up their own money for a project first, then spend borrowed funds. Once developers have spent their money and have commitments from lenders, they have a strong incentive to keep building to finish the project.

"These developers had millions of dollars tied up and they had them financed so they just moved forward," says J. Ronald Terwilliger, chief executive of Trammell Crow Residential, which builds many rental apartment buildings and also some condos. "What they hope is that by the time the project is finished the market comes back."

However, developers and lenders can more easily shelve projects that are still in the early stages. Many developments nationwide are being canceled, suggesting that by next year or 2010, the number of new condos coming onto the market may slow to a trickle.

One big question hanging over the market is how many of the buyers who have put down deposits during construction will show up to close the deal. Some deposits were as little as 3 percent of the purchase price. The price of a condo has frequently fallen more than the amount of the deposit, giving the buyer an incentive to forfeit the deposit.

For example, if a buyer put down $50,000 for a unit priced at $500,000, and the value falls to $400,000, the buyer is apt to walk away — or find some fault with the unit and sue the developer to get the deposit back. Furthermore, some buyers who still want to move in are finding that they no longer qualify for mortgage loans.

In Miami, only 57 units in the 118-unit Onyx on the Bay have closed since August 2007, leaving the remaining 61 units in the possession of the developer, according to Miami-Dade County records. Willy Bermello, the Onyx's developer, could not be reached.

The deteriorating economy isn't helping. "When the world goes to hell in a handbasket, the last thing anyone wants to buy is a condo," says Cathy Schlegel, a mortgage-loan broker in Fort Worth, Texas, whose condo in a high-rise called The Tower sat on the market for 14 months before she finally sold it at a loss in February.

The rising supply is a reflection of the picture in 2004 through 2006 — a time of huge demand for condos. Speculation was rampant as investors believed empty nesters and young professionals seeking an urban experience akin to what they watched on "Friends" would prop up the condo market for years.

Most projects take about three years from the time they are marketed to potential buyers to the time they are ready to be moved into. Deposits help developers get a construction loan that is to be paid off when the buyers close on their new condos years later.

However, cancellations are rising, meaning developers may not be able to pay back their banks. Peter Zalewski, founder of Condo Vultures Realty LLC in Miami, says condo developers he is working with are expecting 20 percent to 40 percent of buyers who put down deposits to walk away from the deal. In some areas, such as inland buildings and new projects along the river in Miami "walkaways" are expected to be even higher.

Unlike single-family housing, condos tend to be concentrated in certain areas, meaning the pain is limited to pockets of the country.

In Jacksonville, Fla., developer Cameron Kuhn had planned to redevelop the SunTrust office tower into office condos as part of a larger complex that included residential condos. Now the condo tower is on hold, dashing city officials' hopes that the project would help to bring parking, residents and more life to the downtown.

Prices of condos have been steady in some areas and fallen elsewhere. The median condo sales price in the Cape Coral-Fort Myers area of Florida fell 26 percent to $202,300 in the fourth quarter of 2007 from $273,400 a year earlier.

Prices dropped nearly 20 percent in Tucson, Ariz., and 12 percent in the Atlanta area during that time, according to National Association of Realtors data. Inside the newly minted Quantum on the Bay in Miami, prices for two-bedroom units have fallen from the high $700,000s to around $500,000.

One option for a developer is to convert the condos to apartments. However, these projects are usually financed with the presumption that sales of individual condos pay off more than rents from a comparably sized apartment building. Also, lenders typically expect developers to pay off condo construction loans with the millions of dollars they receive when closing on the sales. Such a quick payout isn't possible if the developer is only receiving monthly rental payments.

Mr. Terwilliger says Trammell Crow plans its condo developments with an eye towards converting them into rentals if necessary. But its profits are cut when it does that because the company typically spends more for land and amenities when developing condos, he says.

A project called ATLofts at the mammoth Atlantic Station project in downtown Atlanta presold about 80 percent of its 303 units in a mixed-use building that had condos above retail space. But the project ran into water-infiltration problems. That gave buyers an out.

The developer, Lane Co., ended up turning about half the units into rentals. The developer of the retail space, Atlantic Town Center, bought the remaining 156 units as condos. Today, only 52 of those have sold, according to Haddow & Co., an Atlanta-based real-estate consulting company. An Atlantic Town Center spokesman predicted the remaining condos will sell "considering the prime location."

As more condominium projects get into trouble, investors are looking to pounce. Some 700 people showed up for a distressed-real-estate conference this past week in Miami where the condo glut was the dominant discussion subject.

Valet parking attendants had to wave participants away from the hotel and toward a parking lot at a shopping center, and attendees overwhelmed the conference halls, forcing many to watch the proceedings on screens in adjoining rooms.

Peter Grant contributed to this article.

Comments

By cmuknyi lefjbmxi

Apr 27, 2008 6:39 PM | Link to this

rpxzkec fnki gpcbfuwq gpzorisft kqjysbrem erpizokc sckhpv

By cmuknyi lefjbmxi

Apr 27, 2008 6:38 PM | Link to this

rpxzkec fnki gpcbfuwq gpzorisft kqjysbrem erpizokc sckhpv

By cmuknyi lefjbmxi

Apr 27, 2008 6:37 PM | Link to this

rpxzkec fnki gpcbfuwq gpzorisft kqjysbrem erpizokc sckhpv

By ZJ

Apr 18, 2008 9:44 PM | Link to this


In case you didn't know the Midwest, including Chicago, had a dreadful winter. Living in Atlanta is such a blessing compared to those hellish winters.

I'll almost take a condo on Buford Highway compared to anything on Lake Shore Drive in Chicago.

There's fantastic condo deals. Several one-bedroom condos at the Oaks in Buckhead are listed in the 180s. One is on the 18th floor.

Myers Park, out in Duluth close to the exclusive gated St. Ives, has one very upscale all-brick townhouse listed at $329,000. A couple of years ago it was in the mid to high 400s.

Buying a new condo is not always a smart choice. The condo fees will most likely go up. The builder probably cut corners when the bubble burst. Is the construction shoddy? You don't know. There's a lot of unknowns.

All of the construction problems, minor or major, have been fixed with a 5-year, or 10-year old condo. You know how much money is in the reserve fund and you know every assessment and the dollar amount. If there's lots of assessments, you don't buy.

Buying a new condo is a roll of the dice. A builder throwing in a few goodies may not save you a lot money when all is said and done.

And if you think I'm a real estate agent, you're mistaken.

By JT

Mar 30, 2008 2:15 PM | Link to this

I just bought a condo on the Midtown Mile and I love it.

I didn't buy my condo b/c of a trend or b/c of what i saw on "Friends", instead I bought it b/c i didn't want to LIVE in traffic.

I wanted the freedom of living next to shopping, MARTA, the Arts district, the park, dining, the GA DOME, Turner Field, Zoo Atlanta, etc.

I am happy to be LIVING in the heart of the city. Just like regular homes, the market is experiencing a downturn, but in the end at least I don't need my car.

How many ppl in the metro area can make that claim?

By Drew

Mar 26, 2008 2:31 AM | Link to this

I suspect the urban condo market will recover sooner than the suburban housing market. Oil and gas prices continue to rise, and with China and India growing, there's no reason to believe that gas prices will stop rising anytime soon. Meanwhile thousands of people continue to flock to the Atlanta region, congesting the roads even more. A car-dependent lifestyle will continue to become less and less attractive in the coming years, driving more people to live in transit- and pedestrian-friendly environments, of which Atlanta's condos are a part.

By ZR

Mar 25, 2008 12:38 PM | Link to this

To add to my previous comment. I also wanted to mention, for those of us that buy condos because a single family home isn't affordable or desirable. That homes aren't exactly flying off the shelf either, and the value has dropped as much as condos. Home Builders are in the same mess. Also I think alot of the condo buyers that are loosing their shirt are selling way too soon. You need to be in a property a minimum of 5 years to see a profit unless it is a super hot market like it has been been in the past.

By ZR

Mar 25, 2008 11:27 AM | Link to this

I am selling a loft now and will do well when my unit sells. Others in my building have sold recently. The market is slow and I know that it is going to take alot longer. I chose it because it is not cookie cutter and has a wow factor. The right buyer will see that and know that they are buying something unique.

I am looking to buy a condo in a highrise with a view. I will only buy something that is similar, a great buy, with a wow factor. A great view of something, a good floorplan, a good building that is not transient and has a strong association, that will keep it looking new. And once I get in there I will do some remodeling to make it stand out from everyone else. I think if you shop wisely with these things in mind you will be ok.



By Artie

Mar 25, 2008 11:21 AM | Link to this

Yep, I know of certain condo developments in town that are not selling to the point that the developers are renting out their unsold units. This is potentially VERY BAD for current owners because lenders will not finance potential buyers if the percentage of units as rentals is above a certain level (like 10 or 25%). Essentially, the current owners are left in limbo.

By Sean

Mar 25, 2008 11:12 AM | Link to this

The condos in Atlanta were overpriced anyway. This is not Chicago or New York. One would have to be stupid to invest in a condo in Atlanta.

[1 2 3 4] next

Commenting is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. M-F, except on Tuesday when it's open until 9 p.m.

Post a comment



Remember me?

You may use the following formatting:
Bold: **this text will be bolded** = this text will be bolded
Italic: *this text will be italic* = this text will be italic
Link: [text to be linked](http://www.ajc.com) = text to be linked



There will be a delay of up to 5 minutes before your comment appears.


*HTML not allowed in comments. Your e-mail address is required.

Request a comment be removed

 

Inside AJC.COM

Best concert photos

Check out Jeezy's performance at The Tabernacle.

Dining out

Forget waiting in line! Make online reservations.

Weekend plans?

Beat boredom with our "Weekend Best Bets."

Cheer on your team!

Find a local place to root for your alma mater this season.

Pet problems?

Let our experts tame even the wildest house pets.

Laugh out loud!

Video:  Get your lunchtime laugh with Atlanta's hottest comedians.

How to hit the grits

Video: Tips on conquering the grit pit at the National Grits Festival in Warwick, Ga.

Best of the Big A!

Your chance to nominate and vote for Atlanta's best food fun and venues!

Zoo Atlanta

Lions and tigers and bears — oh my! Here's your guide to Zoo Atlanta.

Search AJC Archives

1985 to present     1868 - 1939 Advanced search

Kudzu.com services Find the right people for the job

Keyword     Business Name

AJCPets » The community for Atlanta pet lovers

Do Good Search for non-profit causes near you