AJC > Sports Thrashers > Blog > Archives > 2006 > September > 25

Monday, September 25, 2006

Pass the Kool-Aid

OK, if I hear you guys correctly, you’re saying that the Thrashers defense is so much improved that the team can withstand a moderate dropoff in offensive production and still be a playoff team. If you guys believe it, then I’ll believe it, too, I guess. I trust your opinions.

But here’s why I have a problem with it. Last season, the team’s mentality seemed to be: Let’s be a high-scoring offensive-minded team because our defense is so middle-of-the-road. And you have to admit that the offense won a heck of a lot more games than the defense last season. And, yet, this season the mentality seems to be: We don’t need a top-shelf offensive center because we’ve loaded up on “defensively responsible” forwards, Lehtonen will cut our goals-against and our defense continues to get deeper.

That’s virtually a 180-degree shift in team philosophy. And I don’t like those.

And when we talk about this ‘deeper’ defense, we need to be clear about what we’re talking about. We’re talking about five of the same top-six that played last year and a battle for the 6-7 spots between a bunch of guys who all look good but are largely unproven at this level. So if the defense was so average last year, why are we entering the season saying it’s markedly improved? I’m not saying it can’t or won’t be better, but I just don’t think it’s automatic. I feel like I am watching the same d-men as last year … because I am.

But, like I said, if you guys are OK with it, then count me in. I don’t claim to be an insider or guru of any kind, just another loud-mouth idiot on a barstool.

OK, so speaking of the defense, two quick thoughts:

  • Does it bother anybody that we have only one right-handed shot on the entire list of 14 possible NHL defensemen? Don’t you need a righty to play the right point on the power play, to send passes over to Ilya without having to twist his body around? I’m not saying, I’m asking. Isn’t the right-handed d-man a valuable, valuable commodity? Hnidy’s the only one we’ve got. I’ve read that upward of 70 percent of NHL defensemen shoot lefty, so obviously it’s a common dilemma. Overall in the NHL, I think more than 65 percent of the players shoot lefty. Less than 10 percent of the adult population are left-handed, I think, so it’s a funny phenomenon. Actually, there are reasons for it. It has to do with natural right-handers players learning to play left-handed so that their dominant hand (the right) will be the hand on the top of the stick in the event of all the one-handed lunging and scuffling you do over the course of a game. I’m right-handed and I play right-handed, and I have definitely noticed a lack of coordination when I let go with my bottom hand (my dominant right hand) and try to do things with only my left. (That ‘lack of coordination’ I speak of is in no way due to the fact that I suck at hockey, so don’t even think it. It has everything to do with this righty-lefty gobbledy-gook I just mentioned.)

  • It will be interesting to see what this separated shoulder does for Coburn. I can’t imagine they’ll rush him back and risk damaging a long-term prospect, especially with so many other comparable players competing for those last two spots. The injury probably did Hartley a favor, because now he can send Coburn back and say ‘Get back to us when you’re 100 percent,’ giving one of these other guys some valuable time in the interim.

    I have to go now. Chris Berman just starting reciting the lyrics to “City of New Orleans” at halftime of the Falcons game. I’m gonna go throw up and then throw my TV out the window. Or maybe I’ll throw up on my TV and then throw myself out the window.

    Permalink | Comments (15) | Post your comment |

  •  

    Kudzu.com: Mosquitos are breeding.  Ready for the bites?
    Today's deal from DealSwarm.com

    Local sports videos





    AJC Breaking News Updates