Tech

By Big B 99

September 26, 2008 9:31 AM | Link to this

Jaybo did a great job against Miss St, and he’s proven that he’s a capable backup. Josh is and should be the starter when he’s healthy. I think that Josh has taken a leadership role on the team, and I think given a little more experience in the system, he could be really good. All that said, if Josh isn’t able to go, then Jaybo should be the starter. I also think that you could bring in Calvin Booker some, and throw the football. He’s got a big time arm, and might be more effective than the other Qb’s in a obvibous passing situation, like 3rd and 15.

By Sam

September 26, 2008 9:36 AM | Link to this

I am not an offensive Coordinator, but I was just wondering if it was possible to have Jaybo and Nesbitt in at the same time, and do a couple of option type plays to draw defense close, and then, Jaybo Options to Nesbitt behind the line to throw a bomb to Bebe….that’s all…maybe i just need to calm down a little bit.

By Hairy Larry

September 26, 2008 9:39 AM | Link to this

Absolutely! This guy (Jaybo Shaw) could be even better than Nesbitt just due to the fact that he knows this offense better and would be less prone to mistakes (fumbles).

By GT45

September 26, 2008 9:46 AM | Link to this

Leave Nesbitt on the bench against Duke, and, if he is 100% healthy, play him about a half against GW. If we get a big lead against Duke, let Dykes and Book get reps. We need all the experience we can get in this O. Jaybo will be fine. He is tough, and has football savy. He’ll play his fair share this year. To change the topic, what about So Cal? Did anyone listen to the announcers ALL game long? Make me puke!! Carroll got out coached and out played. It look like men against boys, out there, and the boys took the men to the woodshed! Typical USC implosion, but at least we don’t have to hear about how GREAT they are any more! Go Jackets-

By OldGold

September 26, 2008 10:00 AM | Link to this

Jaybo is an awesome QB and keeps us all out of heart attack mode while maybe the best athlete on the team out for a couple of weeks in Nesbitt. I agree with one of the people above in that Calvin Booker can be a great help in this time as well as others. He’s a confident senior who can chunk the ball a long way and land it on a dime.

By jabster

September 26, 2008 10:03 AM | Link to this

Whatever you do, don’t bring back Nesbitt too soon and have him get hurt bad. Jaybo has proven that he is at least competent and putting up a good offensive performance against Puke and GW shouldn’t be a problem.

I’m more worried about defending against Puke’s passing game…that needs to be our #1 focus this week…we should know more after this weekend’s game with the Cadavers.

Yes, I know Duke-UVA will be a sorry game but it is must-see TV (if you’re one of the dozen or so that can get ESPNU, although I would imagine Raycom will have it too) for the Jacket Nation, or at least for the coaching staff if you have better things to do.

I’m predicting Puke to go 5-7, with wins against the Cadavers, the Wufs, and Carowhina. Let’s make sure that Tech is one of the 7.

Geez, I can’t believe I’m talking about DUKE…

By GTville

September 26, 2008 10:04 AM | Link to this

Jaybo will be fine against the next 2 opponents. Both he and Nesbitt will be great by the end of the year.

USC will drop to 3 or 4 in the polls and be well positioned for the title by the end of the season. One small loss early in the season against a very good team does not matter if you are a media favorite.

By Jason

September 26, 2008 10:13 AM | Link to this

Duke may be tougher than most people think. But I feel good about Jaybo being able to command the field and spread the ball around. I wouldn’t even consider bringing Josh back until Gardner-Webb, and that would only be for a few series to knock the rust off. Clemson will be very difficult and we need everyone healthy.

Nesbitt is the clear number one, Jaybo is a good backup.

By LongBeachJacket

September 26, 2008 10:14 AM | Link to this

Jaybo proved he can step in and handle the offense with precision (against MSU).

Nesbitt is bigger and a bit “scarier” to opponents on the move when a play blows up or protection breaks down. He’s still mastering the offense, but has done very well overall thus far. Of course Jaybo had a beautiful TD run on a great option read…so he is a threat to go all the way, just not quite as athletically agile on the improv runs (see Josh vs. BC).

Great that Josh can take time to heal up and protect against a reinjury.

When he’s back, he should be the clear #1, but Jaybo should probably continue to play significant minutes to mix it up a bit.

With Coach Johnson’s system and the number of hits these QBs are going to take over a season, it is almost essential to have two guys who are #1 and #1A.

And, by the way, if we have to put Dykes in there as a filler, he seems at least capable and Booker for certain situations and packages (with his cannon arm) provides some interesting possibilities.

The whole QB situation is reflective of the total team concept and the remolding of this team by Coach Johnson and his staff.

Josh got injured early last Sat. Jaybo came in and kept it going. Dykes and Booker took turns later on and looked just fine. Booker showed that arm strength on the pass that is only rivalled by Nesbitt’s among the four.

A great situation at QB. An unBEElievably pleasant surprise.

Get healed up Josh. Get some rest (others).

Hit the books in the classroom the same as on the field! There is no other option…than THE PERFECT OPTION.

GO JACKETS!!!

By GT FAN PA

September 26, 2008 10:19 AM | Link to this

I feel very confident in Jaybo. He seems to make the reads better and is willing to pitch it when getting hit- I think he should play the next two games if Nesbit is ok play him a quarter or half in the GW game. (That’s my armchair coaching for the day)

As for USC they should drop way down not 3 or 4 spots- Penn St crushed Oregon St already this year. Then again Miss St held “a top ten” team to 3 points and we crushed them-Go Jackets. THWG

By CPJ=DaMan

September 26, 2008 10:31 AM | Link to this

Jaybo certainly runs the offense a little better, but Nesbitt is just a downright play maker. The more reps he gets, the better he will run the offense. The one thing about Nesbitt though is that he scares the crap out of me when he pitches the ball. He still doesn’t look comfortable with it, and it looks forced. Shaw on the other hand pitches with ease, and really sells the play.

Besides that, Nesbitt is the better qb, and will continue to start as long as he is healthy. Im fine with him sitting out against Duke and GW…just as long as we don’t overlook Dukes passing. Im pretty sure that with PJ we don’t have to worry about coming out flat b/c the players would be down right afraid too (in a good way).

GTville you can’t really say that Oregon State is a very good team can you? Stanford beat them, then Penn State blew their doors off. Yes, they looked pretty good last night, but calling them a great team is incorrect. I think USC should drop to 7 or 8, but probably end up at 4 or 5 b/c they are the medias favorite. And it wasn’t a small loss, they got absolutely dominated in the first half.

By Carolina Jacket

September 26, 2008 10:41 AM | Link to this

So we don’t take any team too lightly. Strange things happen. Also, I agree 100%, lets keep the dialogue respectful and civil.

By JIMMY STOVALL

September 26, 2008 10:43 AM | Link to this

I THINK SHAW IS A GREAT BACK-UP.NESBITT HAS PROVEN HE CAN GO ON THE ROAD & MATCH HOME TEAMS INTENSITY.NESBITT’S JOB SHOULDNT BE UP FOR DISCUSSION.SHAW DOES’NT HAVE ENOUGH PLAYMAKING ABILITY AS NESBITT.NESBITT IS A MUCH MORE PHYSICAL THREAT.HIS LEADERSHIP IS INCREDIBLE.SO LETS BE PATIENT & WAIT ON OUR GIFT TO THE YELLOW-JACKETS RETURNS.

By MisterT

September 26, 2008 10:46 AM | Link to this

“Obvious passing situation.” I don’t think we have “obvious passing situations” with this offense. That in itself makes the treat of a pass by Josh or Jaybo even more of a threat.

While it is predicated on the run, the design is for those runs to be long gainers. I would like to see the stats on how many 20+ yard gains we have had this year.

When I was in high school, our team switched to a wishbone offense…no new coaches, but we graduated a number of key players that left us better suited for finesse offense. The coaches preached that every play was designed to score. It was very effective when the QB made the correct read and everyone, including WR’s, held their blocks.

Lot’s of big plays. I would venture that we in HS and GT today, probably have as good of a percentage of 20+ yards/play running as we/they did/do passing.

this is not 3 yards in a cloud of dust. I don’t think anyone sees the Tech offense that way anymore.

Jaybo probably runs the offense better now, but Josh is definitely the more gifted athlete. If he gets his head around the reads and gets his “dealing” the ball down, he will be scary good.

By GT_THWG

September 26, 2008 10:53 AM | Link to this

Jaybo can get the job done. He should start if Nesbitt isn’t 100%. We will need Nesbitt against Clemson much more than we will against Dookie. Let’s all hope Nesbitt heals up and can get back out there for us.

By GT GRAD

September 26, 2008 10:53 AM | Link to this

Shaw appears to be capable and will only get better as he gains experience and age/size/strength.

I say play Shaw if Nesbit is hurt or if there is a chance he might make his hamstring worse by playing.

If Nesbit is close to 100%, we should still play both if the game scores and situations allow this approach. This will limit/reduce injuries to Nesbit and provide much needed game experience for Shaw.

GT Football has a bright future!!

By Jaded Jacket

September 26, 2008 11:01 AM | Link to this

Nesbitt at A-back when he returns? If Jaybo has another good game.

By jabster

September 26, 2008 11:04 AM | Link to this

Carolina Jacket:

Puke is much improved this year and Cutcliffe will have them going to bowls sooner rather than later. We need to play every game like we mean it and not overlook anyone.

Wasn’t Cutcliffe #2 on our list behind CPJ and wasn’t CPJ #1 on Duke’s list? That ought to tell you where Duke is headed. I don’t anticipate a return to the Spurrier days just yet but this will be the closest they’ve been to that.

I still predict 5-7 but they may get an upset or two. Caution, preparation, and dedicated play is in order.

By Jack G

September 26, 2008 11:11 AM | Link to this

We need Both Nesbitt and Jaybo. Maybe 3 or 4 more QB’s. Love CPJ offense, but it is hell on the QB. All those hits take a toll. A passing attack will ease that up a little. Keeping the defense loose and guessing will slow them down a bit.

By MisterT

September 26, 2008 11:17 AM | Link to this

I really would rather not have Josh sit out for three weeks. He needs reps to get this offense down.

If he needs one more week to heal that is fine, but I would like to see him at least play the first half against GW. This offense is about reads and timing. He can’t get that watching film or watching practice. If he is 90% healthy next week he needs to start at least a quarter.

By KC Kid

September 26, 2008 11:21 AM | Link to this

It’s a luxury to have Shaw and Nesbitt, and both of them are young. I was extremely impressed with Shaw at one of the scrimmages this summer. I was hoping they could red shirt him but no such luck. It’s obvious he knows the offense.

In this offense, they’re both going to get beat up. Hopefully at least one of them is good to go every game. In my mind Nesbitt is still the man, but it’s great to have Shaw ready to go.

It’s been a nice start to the season. If the Jackets can beat the teams they’re supposed to beat and win one or two of the games nobody thought they would, it will be a terrific start to the Johnson era. Thanks coach, it sure is fun to watch!

Go Jackets!!

By addicted

September 26, 2008 11:24 AM | Link to this

Nesbitt is the clear #1. Remember, he has never played in such an offense before, and barely practiced in Spring (due to injury). He has only got reps in Fall practice, and has made immense strides since then.

Also, Nesbitt looked pretty darn good against Miss State too, until his injury. He would have taken the ball home in the run if he had not pulled his hamstring. The OLine was playing a lot better this game than anything we saw in earlier games.

While I really loved Shaw’s play, I really doubt he would have done as well as Nesbitt in the games against BC and VT where often the defensive linemen were making it to Nesbitt before he could even fake the handoff to the B-Back.

By TNAT

September 26, 2008 11:26 AM | Link to this

Am I the only one who thought Jaybo is not even close to an adequate passer yet? Against Miss St, he was missing his receivers by 4 or 5 yards, and the only reason he threw a TD pass was that BeBe made a ridiculous play to come back for the ball and maintain possession. I think he will develop the arm strength and accuracy as time goes on, but right now he is not ready to be a big time college quarterback.

By Geori

September 26, 2008 11:29 AM | Link to this

Don’t be afraid. David Cutcliffe is not a very good coach. He has ridden the coattails of the Manning boys for too long. He was never seriously in the running for the GT job.

By Scott

September 26, 2008 11:36 AM | Link to this

You asked, “Will he (Shaw) make a lot of freshman mistakes on the road? ” Well, we won’t be able to find until Clemson in 4 weeks. By that time Nesbitt should be cleared to play and will be the starter.

By ChattHills Jacket

September 26, 2008 11:41 AM | Link to this

Everybody needs to get in at QB because we will need all of them once in awhile. I like Shaw or Nesbitt but realize that we have not even opened up the passing portion of the offence really. The QB that can keep fumbles down and read the pass option should be the starter. Get all 4 in the games as much as possible in my opinion.

By BuzzFactor

September 26, 2008 11:41 AM | Link to this

looks liike most agree that Nesbitt is the man, and we don’t need to rush him back too soon… and Shaw is very capable and smooth running the O. Let Shaw get most of the reps vs Duke and only play Nesbitt if he is 100%, but don’t play him too much if at all. Shaw is going to be great but it’s Nesbitt’s spot. I would like to see Shaw continue to get reps when possible though.

I hope the pass D looks good against Duke. A couple of picks would be great. We do need to be cautious bringing anyone back from injury too early for Duke or G-W. Lets try to be near 100% healthy for Clemson.

What is the depth looking like behind our D’s front 4? Just curious as to what we have behind those 3 NFL-bound seniors…

By Link

September 26, 2008 11:44 AM | Link to this

Shaw is a capable backup, and I think it’s fine for him to be started against Duke and Gardner Webb. Don’t push Nesbitt, give his leg time to heal. It’s not like benching Nesbitt will prevent him from getting any awards this year or anything. We saw last weekend that we don’t need him for Duke or Gardner Webb. If Shaw can get the job done, save Nesbitt’s strength for Clemson, Miami, and FSU.

Honestly, I could see Georgia Tech using a two QB system for the rest of the season. The option is very demanding on quarterbacks. Nesbitt played his heart out against Virginia Tech but it was obvious he was spent by the end of the game. Why not alternate? Keep the QBs fresh and you lessen the probability of a turnover.

By Born2Buzz

September 26, 2008 11:45 AM | Link to this

Nesbitt doesn’t play unless he’s 100%. If he is, Jaybo goes back on the bench. If not, Jaybo plays and does just what he did against MSU. I believe he proved what he can and can’t do against MSU.

Kind of a poor blog Larry.

By The Big Bug

September 26, 2008 12:10 PM | Link to this

IMHO, Shaw’s precision at running the option were directly responsible for the long gains by Dwyer etc. When Nesbitt pitches,it causes acute sphincter retraction. Net result, zero turnovers.The MSU game was the best they have looked this year. I think Shaw has earned the starting job.

By George P. Burdell

September 26, 2008 12:32 PM | Link to this

I’m glad Shaw was there to go in and he did a great job, but he is nowhere near the passing threat that Nesbitt has shown. Even when Nesbitt doesn’t throw much, he makes the defense respect his ability. He also has more ability to get away when the play breaks down. I’m afraid if Shaw is the QB, defenses are going to play straight man coverage and commit everyone else to stopping the run. PJ’s offense is good, but when teams are able to spread out close to the line of scrimmage, it becomes very ineffective. Nesbitt doesn’t have stellar passing stats, but he does put enough pressure with his pass and scramble abilities to keeep defenses on their heels. Shaw is great at the option, but he just doesn’t bring that same threat.

By John

September 26, 2008 12:39 PM | Link to this

I was at the MSU game and I personally have never seen a GT team play like that on offense - so, I guess that would mean that Jaybo Shaw must be doing something right. I don’t care who QB is as long as we win. Looks like we win with either one!

By Blue Fox

September 26, 2008 12:49 PM | Link to this

Josh has a pro arm, is faster on the straight-away, and is much taller/bigger than Jaybo, so “crispness” in running the option aside, Nesbitt is the superior quarterback. In addition, he’s older and more mature, and thus has the respect of his team mates in the critical quarterback leadership role that Jaybo will in time develop. CPJ, let Josh heal against Duke and, if need be, Gardner Webb, let Jaybo/Booker run the offense, and get “the man” back for the next big test, Clemson.

By BuzzFactor

September 26, 2008 12:50 PM | Link to this

Big Bug, I agree Shaw executes better, but Nesbitt is more athletic, with more potential for long runs. What I think we DON’T need is a quarterback controversy. I see what you are saying and I’m tempted to agree, but I’ll take the easy way out and trust the Coach on this one. He’s the man, it’s his offense, and he knows way more than we do about both guys. I think he’ll make the quarterback decisions along the way that will be best for the team. I like his game decisions, hell, I like everything he’s done so far. Jaybo will get his chances, and he knows what Johnson wants from him and if Johnson would even consider giving him the top spot. I would think we’ll see Shaw next Saturday get at least half the game, even if Nesbitt is 100%.

By The edge

September 26, 2008 1:35 PM | Link to this

Shaw has proven capable against what was touted as a good SEC defense. He has the little things those extras that Nesbitt still needs time to make habit. It is good to know Shaw is capable if needed.

By NYJacket

September 26, 2008 1:39 PM | Link to this

Jaybo will do fine. But, he is a freshman and freshmen make mistakes.

Hopefully, he will relax and just play the game.

When he was inserted against MSU, he didn’t have time to think too much and get uptight.

If Coach Johnson thinks he is ready to play he is ready.

By dogHater

September 26, 2008 1:53 PM | Link to this

Nesbitt is not a great QB. He doesn’t always make the right decision and does not have a great passing arm. HOWEVER, I think he could be a bruising, punishing tailback or B back. Give him the ball after he gets a running head start and see what he could do!!! Sam had the right idea…put both Jaybo and Josh in the game.

By surfrider

September 26, 2008 2:04 PM | Link to this

No question Nesbitt has proven he can run this offense and has big time potential. At the same time, I think there will always be a need for three QB’s to be game ready so if the number 1 QB is hurt with hamstring then that means #4 moves up to #3 and has to be ready. Anytime particularly at the QB position the backups can get game experience is a plus. Several good ideas have been mentioned including playing Booker a little bit in a passing package. Maybe another way to look at it is once a Qb gets say 10-15 runs the next guy comes in for awhile. What came out at me this last game was the way the ball was spread around. With the capable QB’s we have maybe putting in two at the same time to confuse the defense would be interesting and mixing it up where they line up differently periodically. It’s hard to fan criticize an offense rolling up 500 yards and scoring 38 points and almost winning two tough conference road games.

By Brewer for GT President

September 26, 2008 2:07 PM | Link to this

Shaw looks good but Nesbitt is still #1. I would love to see a trick play with 2 QBs, maybe sneak Booker on as a B-Back or A-Back, pitch to him and let him throw a bomb across the field… But CPJ is a smart man and I doubt there will be any ‘trickery’ until the team really has the basic offense down 100%.

By Whatever

September 26, 2008 2:53 PM | Link to this

He fumbled twice and threw the ball straight to MSU, but the DB’s took each other out. Jaybo is executing the option well, but Josh has the potential to take it to the house every time. His arm is twice as strong, and he can make something happen on busted plays. We’ll need that when we play the big boys (Clemson, Miami, FSU, UGAg). Jaybo looked better because the line, A-backs, and D Thomas were blocking like madmen. Jaybo is proficient, but Nesbitt has the potential to be the best QB that Paul Johnson has ever had. Let’s have a little foresight.

By GT

September 26, 2008 2:58 PM | Link to this

I am glad we have two like this in a tough position like quarterback in the option. I like Shaw giving the ball off more than Nesbitt, but Nesbitt throws it better than Shaw and neither one of them are shabby. I would imagine CPJ feels lucky his first year to have two qbs that can figure out this offense, Ball is still trying to figure his out after 4 years as a starter.

By Hal

September 26, 2008 4:01 PM | Link to this

Jaybo is an excellelnt replacement for Nesbitt while he recovers. But I tell you Josh Nesbitt is going to be great. He is the man and has the size an speed to make an impact. Don’t even think about Jaybo replacing him this year.

By question

September 26, 2008 4:12 PM | Link to this

With Nez hurt, whom else would be the man? Jay has some good OJT. Booker = pass. Does that have any surprise effect? Just like last year, Nez = run. No surprise.

PS Nice art about CTaylor the tackler!

By son_sir

September 26, 2008 4:13 PM | Link to this

I’m hoping Nesbitt gets that hamstring healed by Clemson. We’re going to need his athleticism in a big way then. Jaybo has proven he can run the offense with precision. A hamstring can be a tricky injury. Tweak it a little and come back too soon ….. the next wrong step and you’re looking at a 5-6 wk. recovery period. That little tweak should be healed by the Clemson game. I am very confident with Jaybo under center for a couple of weeks.

By Thanks

September 26, 2008 4:15 PM | Link to this

Larry you mailed this in. Have a good weekend.

By old gold engineer

September 26, 2008 4:18 PM | Link to this

Jaybo needs to work on his passing skills. However, he did a great job stepping in and running the offense last week. Glad to know we have a backup that can keep things rolling. Kudos to the offensive line for much improved blocking. Keep up the progress. Would love to see Mississippi State knock off LSU tomorrow like Oregon State pulled the big upset last night. That would make the victory last weekend look even better.

By NYJacket

September 26, 2008 4:19 PM | Link to this

I agree with Hal, Nesbitt is a threat to take it to the house every time he touches the ball. When he is healty there is no question as to who should be on the field.

By jacket

September 26, 2008 4:32 PM | Link to this

UGAG has been counting the final game with Tech as a certain win. But in the words of the great Al Ciraldo, “Hang on brothers and sisters!” Tech is as tough as any team on UGAG’s schedule, except Florida. I think we’re going go up to Athens and shock the world! They don’t want any part of us.

By west coast

September 26, 2008 4:40 PM | Link to this

Why is there a need to have a qb controversary? The media has given this kid way too much coverage for a freshman. Let him grow and continue to earn playing time. Let Johnson do his job.

By NYJacket

September 26, 2008 4:42 PM | Link to this

George P Burdell,

I know you have been around the flats forever, but what is the basis of your assertion that PJ’s offense is easy to stop by playing man to man pass defense and then “speading” out close along the line of scrimage?

This offense is designed to spread the defense out along the line of scrimage. That is what makes it effective. That is why the line has wide splits. And, since you are George P Burdell, I am sure you remember the wide slot I formations of the Dodd area with all the motion and the wide offensive line splits designed to do the same thing.

One defensive guy takes the bait and the ball is tossed to the other back and it is a long gain and maybe 6 points.

I’m really glad that the 4 experienced defensive coordinators we have played so far didn’t have your defensive insight.

The good news is that after 4 games I don’t see very many posts that claim this offense will not work at the BCS level.

It is really refreshing to see speculation as to how to stop it.

And, you can bet that a lot of future opponents are staying up late at night trying to figure it out.

And, with two effective QB’s they really have to worry.

But, that is the point with this offense. It is easier to find really good option type running QB’s who can throw effectively than it is to get a top pro style guy who can make a difference.

By SoGaBee

September 26, 2008 4:57 PM | Link to this

If Josh isn’t 100%, I have no problem with Jaybo starting. But we shouldn’t take Duke lightly — They have played no heavyweights, but they are putting points on the board — 30 a game - unlike the Duke of the past. Jaybo can play — my section was critical of him calling his own number against MSU but then he pitched it to Dwyer for 80+ and they saw the light. so go with the healthy guy on game day.

By I know my Football

September 26, 2008 6:08 PM | Link to this

First off I am not knocking off Nesbitt for one minute. He is a very exciting player and could play just about anywhere. Although, Jaybo just makes the offense look a lot more crisp. The offense runs very smooth with Jaybo at the helm. While I believe Nesbitt is the better athlete, Jaybo is the better QB in THIS offense.

By I know my Football

September 26, 2008 6:09 PM | Link to this

First off I am not knocking off Nesbitt for one minute. He is a very exciting player and could play just about anywhere. Although, Jaybo just makes the offense look a lot more crisp. The offense runs very smooth with Jaybo at the helm. While I believe Nesbitt is the better athlete, Jaybo is the better QB in THIS offense.

By I know my Football

September 26, 2008 6:09 PM | Link to this

First off I am not knocking off Nesbitt for one minute. He is a very exciting player and could play just about anywhere. Although, Jaybo just makes the offense look a lot more crisp. The offense runs very smooth with Jaybo at the helm. While I believe Nesbitt is the better athlete, Jaybo is the better QB in THIS offense.

By James

September 26, 2008 6:19 PM | Link to this

Jaybo looked great against Miss. State—If Nesbitt needs rest, don’t risk playing him. Duke is better this year, but not there yet, and if we play like we have been playing we won’t need Nesbitt’s play-saving abilities out there. Which brings up something interesting: it seems like Shaw is better with the pitches, but Nesbitt is just more athletic, and more of a playmaker. Both styles seem to work! And I just want to say kudos to Booker, who if you watch during the game is a real leader on the sideline, always going around and encouraging the other guys—even though his skills don’t really fit CPJ’s offense and he probably won’t see much playing time this year as a senior. Glad to see a great attitude from of him, and also that he’s willing to go in and complete a pass on short notice (like he did against M. State) when they need him to! Keep up all the hard work guys!

By Navy Fan

September 26, 2008 6:24 PM | Link to this

The advanage CPJ’s Off has is that is that the opponents only get to see it once a year and only have a week to prep. Don’t forget that Duke has already seen this offense when they played Navy 3 weeks prior. Don’t think that this will be a pushover game or GT fans may be unpleasently surprised.

When you play WF for the title game the same will apply.

Go Jackets.

By Mike

September 26, 2008 7:22 PM | Link to this

Jaybo is a slicker ball-handler, and makes quicker decisions on the ride and the pitch, but Nesbitt is something special as a runner. And he has a much better arm than Jaybo (not that Jaybo’s chopped liver in that department).

It looks like we have the luxury of letting Nesbitt take two games off, if necessary, to get 100 percent healthy. If he’s ready to go, though, he ought to start.

I don’t think playing Navy is that much of an advantage. You can prepare for it all you want; if it’s executed properly by good athletes, you’re going to get burnt. Navy didn’t have any problem moving the ball until Kaipo ran out of gas.

By GM

September 26, 2008 7:23 PM | Link to this

Nice to have 2 capable QBs. It’s almost necessary in this offense with all the pounding they take. PJ won’t bring back Nesbitt early, and hopefully Nesbitt won’t claim he’s 100% before he really is.

Anyone else a little concerned about the Duke game? Perhaps I just have a hangover from previous years. I’d like to think this team is completely different.

By AlabamaRamblinwreck

September 26, 2008 7:57 PM | Link to this

Navy Fan:

You make some very good points about Duke and Wake both playing Navy this year, and that will give them a good look at the option. Definitely a consideration.

Jaybo definitely knows how to run this offense. He does it well enough that I agree we should not rush Josh back before he is ready. BUT ultimately, we must have the athleticism of Josh against the faster, bigger defenses. He is able to break plays that Jaybo does not have the ability to break. On top of that, I think Jaybo needs to add some weight/muscle, or he will not be able to continue to absorb the hits he is taking. I think we go into the Duke game with Jaybo starting, but Josh ready if anything starts to go south. Hopefully, Josh will be close to 100%. Of course, Josh should not be needed for the GW game, but he should probably get 1 or 2 series just to get ready for Clemson.

Go Jackets!!

By techfanplus

September 26, 2008 8:04 PM | Link to this

No way if Nesbitt is healthy. He has not out performed Nesbitt and should do so before he takes the starting role.

By wrek

September 26, 2008 8:30 PM | Link to this

Your question can he be the man.

He has no choice.

By keytech

September 26, 2008 9:37 PM | Link to this

shaw is by for most the better q. b. .by the time the rest of you realize this its going to be to late.cpj=DAMAN you know what your saying’ I agree with you 100%.

By keytech

September 26, 2008 9:41 PM | Link to this

shaw is by for most the better q. b. .by the time the rest of you realize this its going to be to late.cpj=DAMAN you know what your saying’ I agree with you 100%.

By GT_90

September 26, 2008 9:48 PM | Link to this

What folks don’t realize though is that every game that Nesbitt misses, the less familiar he becomes running this offense in real-time games. So my feeling is that Jaybo will play but don’t expect Nesbitt to light up the boards once he returns. He could go back to fumbling b/c his timing will be off. I hope Nesbitt gets to at least split time the next two games so he can continue to get in game time experience to minimize the turnover problem he’s having. Overall….Nesbitt is the better athlete by far and by his senior year, could be running for Heisman.

By Tokyo jacket

September 26, 2008 11:32 PM | Link to this

CPJ’s offense reminds me a lot of the pick and roll in basketball. Malone and Stockton ran it to perfection in the 90s. It’s very similar in that if you have the right pieces, it can’t be stopped, even if you know it’s coming. Shaw is more Stockton while Nesbitt is more Jordan. Shaw is capable of running that play to perfection. But, if the play breaks down or you need to run another play, Nesbitt is definitely the better all around option. Plus, Nesbitt in time will learn to do what Shaw does. All that said, rest Nesbitt if he needs it. Shaw is a great luxury to have as a back up.

By the way, give Ball a break. I think he would have been phoenemonal in this offense and with a coach that can build up a player like CPJ. I wish him the best. He made a lot of mistakes, but played as hard as anyone on the field and tough too.

By son_sir

September 27, 2008 7:20 AM | Link to this

How powerful would this set-up be in a year or two ? ( QB-Shaw… A-back-#1- R. Jones; B-Back-Dwyer A-Back #2- Nesbitt ) Don’t tell me you haven’t considered that a time or two just for the fun of it. Nesbitt performs best in open space. Shaw would make sure he gets it in open space. Oh well…..just thinking out loud.

By exNFLplayer

September 27, 2008 7:33 AM | Link to this

Shaw has nowhere near the playmaking ability of Nesbitt nor the arm. You guys will have to throw the ball agianst some teams down the road. And if you can’t it’s going to cost you at some point in time.

By Jack G

September 27, 2008 10:33 AM | Link to this

Is this the same Hammy that caused Nesbitt to miss most of spring practice??

Does anyone remember Dodd’s belly series that were so sucessful??

By jay jarrell

September 27, 2008 11:55 AM | Link to this

Its great to have two Qbs that can play the game ,When in doubt play both.” Enough said” theres no need to choose between either.

By Buzzfan1936

September 27, 2008 1:47 PM | Link to this

Let Nesbitt rest until he is 100% - unless we are in danger of losing the game AND he is at least 80-90%. Jaybo looked great, but we don’t want to risk losing him as well, so play Booker and the other QB’s as much as possible to get ready for the big games down the road.

We need VT to lose 2 ACC games.

Good topic and well-written article, Larry. It is refreshing to see AJC giving some focus on Tech which is [or should be] the home town team to the major Atlanta newspaper.

By GTYJ

September 27, 2008 2:47 PM | Link to this

son_sir

Why would we put our biggest playmaker as a back up?

For the kicks and giggles?

By msim 84

September 27, 2008 8:07 PM | Link to this

I think it’s great that we have two very good quarterbacks, but having watched Jaybo throughout his high school career, I believe he is by far the better quarterback for this offense. Josh is very athletic, a superb rusher, and has a strong (albeit inaccurate) arm. The thing that bothers me is that he calls his own number too often. For instance, in the VA Tech loss, Nesbitt rushed for a record number of yards by a Tech QB … but he kept the ball 28 times! As a team, the Jackets ran for 278 yards, with Nesbitt accounting for 151 of that. In contrast, Jaybo directed the Jackets to 438 yards against a “superior SEC” defense. While his personal stats were not equal to Nesbitt, the team offense performance was much better.

In short, the Jackets offense certainly won’t be hurt by leaving Nesbitt on the bench to heal … and it may be better off by leaving him there even AFTER he’s healed completely. (Actually, Josh is too good of an athlete to stay on the bench. He needs to be in the game in either the A-back or B-back position.)

Go Jackets! THGW!

By Not Disappointed

September 27, 2008 9:13 PM | Link to this

go jackets!

By Zeb

September 27, 2008 11:41 PM | Link to this

We sure can use some help congratulating those Dawgs on their great game (wink) tonight. Lets go bother Them NOW.

By Pittjacket

September 28, 2008 12:19 AM | Link to this

Could we go 11-1 or 10-2? It could happen!

By keytech

September 28, 2008 12:43 AM | Link to this

Too,MR.msin84 you seem to see the same thing am seeing.I wish every one else could see this.but as all ways most are blind in recent years at GT.

By chris

September 28, 2008 3:56 AM | Link to this

I would actually prefer Jaybo to start Saturday vs. Duke if Josh isn’t 100%. We NEED Josh to be 100% starting with the Clemson game. Therefore I think it would be best to start Jaybo and have him play most of the game but have Josh ready just in case. If the game is in hand, leave Josh on the bench to rest up. In reality he could have another week of rest as the Gardner-Webb game should be a tune up…maybe he could get a quarter in this game to get him back in action. In the end we would have two healthy quarterbacks who we feel give us the chance to win, something we haven’t had since before the Joe Ham days.

By Terry

September 28, 2008 7:32 AM | Link to this

I agree with Chris. We need Josh to be 100% and if he isn’t then start Jaybo. However, we don’t need to start some quarterback controversy which could be devisive to the team.

Also, let’s stay focused on Duke. If we take them lightly, we could be the next upset victim. There were a lot of those this weekend, and it can happen to any team in any week when they get too full of themselves ( Wake, Cemson, VT, UGA, FL, Wis, etc). We need to prepare as though this were UGA coming to town.

By 110percentGT

September 28, 2008 9:15 AM | Link to this

AJC head line “UGA STICK WITH GYMNASTICS”, considering THE Last time Bama came to town, AJC lead with, “ACC STICK WITH BASKET BALL”

Fair and balanced?

By CPJ for pres

September 28, 2008 11:25 AM | Link to this

Can anyone else believe we are having a discussion about GT having two (maybe even 3) good options at QB? CPJ is giving us an exciting team to cheer for so let’s fill up the stadium and be loud Jacket fans.

By just a thought

September 28, 2008 1:03 PM | Link to this

no this sounds dumb but GT actually has a decent shot to run the table into the UGA game. That still might not get them to the ACC championship game because of the tiebreaker with VTECH ( /-: )

but we could realizstically be 10-1 going into the game against georgia and who knows this could finally be the year we beat them

and if we did we would be 11-1 and a diffinate BCS at-large pick

By Buzzfan1936

September 28, 2008 1:07 PM | Link to this

Wow! Duke wins big against UVA. This will be a tougher game than I thought. I think Jaybo may be the better QB and should start. Nesbitt has turned the ball over too many times both as a freshman and this year. The turnovers cost us the VT game.

By The Class of UGA Fans: Poor Alabama family

September 28, 2008 8:59 PM | Link to this

Know this is off topic but thought I would post this; An Alabama man talks about their experience at yesterdays game:

Georgia was one of the most hostile places to take a family. The fans are a Bunch of unsupervised, disrespectful college a**holes whose Mommy and Daddy send to Athens and they should be there with them to supervise. I had people barking in my nephews ,5 week old newborn daughters face. I then witnessed a group of Georgia fans actually “dismantle” a family’s Alabama tent (I mean mom dad and younger kids) and then witnessed an all out brawl> A Georgia fan shoved a 40’s ish women telling them to leave and all hell broke loose. I happened to be standing close to this with a two year old in a stroller that got literally knocked three feet over. (My child landed on the grass but was hysterical) I’m talking 40-50 year old parents of the dismantled tent Bama kids, college age kids, teenagers, fist to cuff fighting, as I am standing there holding my two year old- one of the Georgia fans spit at her (my two year old daughter). Needless to say, we left WITHOUT going into the game. Around 6:15- I couldn’t even imagine this place once it got dark! (Gave up our $440.00 worth of tickets because my wife, mother and father in law and kids were so upset). I will NEVER, NEVER, go to Athens again. I plan to write to the University as there was NOT A COP IN SIGHT. What a disgrace. I would be embarrased to be a Georgia parent, fan, player or alumni.

THUGS

I have since talked to several fans who had equally as disturbing stories- car flags broken off cars, cars keyed, tires slashed, beer being thrown on them as they walked to cars, a nine year old’s bama hat being taken off his head and thrown into the road. At last report a buddy from work left Athens this morning They left their own campus trashed. Kinda goes along with all the penalty’s on their football team. UNDISCIPLINED THUGS!!!!!

By jabster

September 28, 2008 9:00 PM | Link to this

Couple quickies:

SITYS about Puke. I hope they have our undivided attention now.

Effin’ Miami loses to the TMNTerps. There goes the chance for a 3-way tiebreaker…now VT HAS to lose 2x.

By athensDAWG

September 29, 2008 12:18 AM | Link to this

Woof Woof Woof Woof Woof. As a dawgs fan, I’m most ashamed of the way the Alabama fans were treated. Unfortunately, that is commonplace in Athens. Even when I go to the Tech stadium, I observe the Dawg fans being rude to the Tech fans. The foul language, beer tossing, public urination and violence are unacceptable. I apologize on their behalf. We left with our tails between our legs on Saturday. We talk (or bark) a big game, but truthfully we are very nervous about playing Tech each year…especially this year with them on fire. As for paying Athens a visit in November - don’t…and certainly not with a 5-week old baby. Gooo dawgs. Woof woof woof.

By flagboy

September 29, 2008 12:27 AM | Link to this

I’m in the Red Coat Marching Band and even though our football team lost, our band had a great show. Georgia Tech needs to watch out for Duke and realize that Shaw only had a good game because it was Mississippi State. Even Auburn can beat them. I don’t know if Georgia plays them this year, but if we do…we will beat them too. Georgia Tech looks good this year, but we’ll beat ya’ll too because we beat Hawaii last year and they are an international team! Everybody is going to lose once this year, so we will be back on top in no time because Richt will pull a Meyer and whine until we are elected number one.

By flagboy

September 29, 2008 12:30 AM | Link to this

Ya’ll need to quit complaining about what goes on in Athens and at SEC schools. It is not all true. You take a risk when you come here because fights happen when we drink. You have your own violence in the ACC - look at the shootout at Virginia Tech. Whatever! sic em!

By Ron

September 29, 2008 5:03 AM | Link to this

flagboy are you retarded, or just disrespectful?

By BuzzGT

September 29, 2008 9:23 AM | Link to this

I love the fact that we have two quarterbacks that can run the offense effectively. I am glad that the schedule will allow for Josh to recover. He is definately the number one QB. But, Shaw has proven that there is not much of a drop off at #2.

By Tech Dad

September 29, 2008 9:44 AM | Link to this

Of course the healthy quarterback should start, in this case Jaybo. We are going to need both quarterbacks before this season ends….so lets try to keep them both healthy.

By hedge puller

September 29, 2008 10:38 AM | Link to this

Miss State caught a bad break when Josh got hurt, because Jaybo knows the offense better. Jaybo ain’t gonna get you beat, whereas Josh is going to win you a game or two with his athletic ability. If Nesbit can take advantage of his downtime to learn more about the system while the hammer heals, he’s going to benefit and the team is going to benefit. Meanwhile, the team benefits while Jaybo is playing now. If Josh gets smarter while he’s injured, lookout opponents in the second half of the season. Booker has to keep working his hiney off and not give up. Quarterbacks take a ton of hits in this system. You don’t see any chickensh** QB slides on C PJohnson teams. Calvin, a suggestion just for you….from personal experience. When you can get into live practice drills, keep going until the whistle and maybe a tad afterwards and make downfield blocks and knock some guys off the pile and spear a few of them when they come in late to punish your ball carriers. You will make some enemies on your defense, but you will also get their respect and more importantly, the attention of the coach.

By Christie Blackley

September 29, 2008 11:15 AM | Link to this

So much of running the option is mental. Its obvious that Jaybo is just smarter than Nesbitt in reading defenses and making decisions. Nesbitt is more athletic but he just doesn’t understand the plan as well as Shaw. Shaw should start until Nesbitt improves the mental aspects.

By Christie Blackley

September 29, 2008 11:17 AM | Link to this

So much of running the option is mental. Its obvious that Jaybo is just smarter than Nesbitt in reading defenses and making decisions. Nesbitt is more athletic but he just doesn’t understand the plan as well as Shaw. Shaw should start until Nesbitt improves the mental aspects.

By Christie Blackley

September 29, 2008 11:17 AM | Link to this

So much of running the option is mental. Its obvious that Jaybo is just smarter than Nesbitt in reading defenses and making decisions. Nesbitt is more athletic but he just doesn’t understand the plan as well as Shaw. Shaw should start until Nesbitt improves the mental aspects.

By Not Disappointed

September 29, 2008 5:50 PM | Link to this

I think Nesbit will be fine when he comes back. Go Jackets!!!

By TechCrybaby

September 29, 2008 7:16 PM | Link to this

Give it to Jaybo. Don’t go out this Saturday, though, thinking that the Duke game is a sure win. The Blue Devils have a good passing quarterback. If you think a “W” is certain, take a look at what just happened to UGA.

By youngeno

September 29, 2008 7:49 PM | Link to this

Hey Mrs. Blackley. Take it from someone who has ACTUALLY run the option. The option offense is more about repetition and instincts. The more Nesbit runs the option, the better off he’ll be. The reason Jaybo runs it better is because he has been running it since he was in High School. Nesbit came from a High School that threw the ball over 40 times a game. Yes, I am a lil’ offended that you would say that Jaybo is smarter. They both attend GaTech, which doesn’t accept dumbies. Do some research before you make comments like that.

By Jimmy

September 29, 2008 8:55 PM | Link to this

If I were a Tech fan, I would never talk trash about other team’s fans. You guys will never live down when some ignorant Tech fans hung a banner over an interstate overhang, “Hokies, get ready for a real massacre.” REAL classy there. I know that doesnt represent all Tech fans, but neither does any fighting that happens outside of UGA’s stadium or any other team in the nation. Grow up!

By MidnightRambler

September 29, 2008 9:46 PM | Link to this

A banner like that would be a disgrace. I find it hard to believe. Can anyone else verify this?

By engineerjacket

September 29, 2008 11:57 PM | Link to this

Based on the screenname and content of those discussing the fans, they claim to be UGA fans. I agree - a banner like that would certainly be a disgrace. However, please go back and re-read the posts because all of the ones who identified their school were UGA fans, not Tech fans.