Jeff Schultz

By Pabst

February 12, 2009 2:03 PM | Link to this

I’ve been riding the fence about this one. Brooking is one of my favorite Falcons of all time, and I would like to see him stay a Falcon, but if he tries to demand a big contract i say let him walk. Hopefully both he and Lawyer will be willing to come back to help a young inexperienced team. As always, GO FALCONS!

By LAWTON

February 12, 2009 2:06 PM | Link to this

from a nostalgia point of view, i would miss brooking. from a play point of view, he was suppose to be gone at least 3 years ago. people are tired of seeing him pile on piles late after the play has already been stopped, and he has NEVER been a straight up hitter, in fact, he mostly gets run over.

By leland

February 12, 2009 2:19 PM | Link to this

Dear Mr. JS—did you see Mr. Bradley’s picture on his new blog? Your pal, Leland

By mad dog

February 12, 2009 2:21 PM | Link to this

I dont believe he is worth a big contact,in fact if there is a younger player to take his place I would let him go. He was very good for a lot of years, but these players dont know when its over. I think the team should go with younger players as planned, and go after a good defensive tackle through free agency or by trade.

By Phillip

February 12, 2009 2:27 PM | Link to this

Keith Brooking has been a great Falcon but everybody reaches that point of decline - and Keith has reached his. Brooking was a liability in coverage all season long. The Vikings Tight End abused Brooking and so did Chicago’s Tight End and so on. Simply put, Brooking is a “net minus” on the field now - experience or not.

Keith, its just time to “hang it up” - you are in the bottom 10%-20% of all linebackers in ability now. Dale Murphy went on the decline once as well…if you want to go sit on the bench for the vet minimum here or somewhere else be my guest - that is your prerogative.

By The Grinch

February 12, 2009 2:27 PM | Link to this

Before all the cretins and Brooking haters show up and pollute the place, I must say Keith’s one of my all time favorite Falcons. No, he isn’t flashy. But he plays hard every game, doesn’t make many mistakes (I think that’s one reason this last one’s been so magnified), doesn’t whine or complain despite having played on some truly dreadful teams in some very crappy situations, and has quietly conducted himself with class and dignity while representing an organization who desperately needed someone to fill that role.

I don’t know what the future holds for you here, Keith, but I personally hope you’re back. If not, thank you for being an excellent player and role model during some tough times for this city. I’ll never regret buying a “56” jersey like I have some other numbers here in this town, football and baseball.

Now, time to leave before all the poo-flinging begins.

By Phillip

February 12, 2009 2:29 PM | Link to this

Keith Brooking has been a great Falcon but everybody reaches that point of decline - and Keith has reached his. Brooking was a liability in coverage all season long. The Vikings Tight End abused Brooking and so did Chicago’s Tight End and so on. Simply put, Brooking is a “net minus” on the field now - experience or not.

Keith, its just time to “hang it up” - you are in the bottom 10%-20% of all linebackers in ability now. Dale Murphy went on the decline once as well…if you want to go sit on the bench for the vet minimum here or somewhere else be my guest - that is your prerogative.

By Frank

February 12, 2009 2:40 PM | Link to this

He misses tackles. Can’t cover any receiver. Doesn’t have the speed. Sorry but being popular in “memory” isn’t enough. Go play somewhere else.

By Frank

February 12, 2009 2:41 PM | Link to this

He misses tackles. Can’t cover any receiver. Doesn’t have the speed. Sorry but being popular in “memory” isn’t enough. Go play somewhere else.

By Dolemite

February 12, 2009 2:42 PM | Link to this

Brooking ended up being an “easy target” due to the fact that he was single-handedly responsible for putting the brakes to the momentum that the team had gained at the end of the game. Ryan seemed to have recovered from the early 2nd half “yips” and was poised for yet another amazing comeback. Regardless of what you think, three minutes is an eternity. Also lost in your commentary is the astronomical number of arm-tackle attempts made by Brooking throughout the game. It was obvious that he was exhausted early, but he remained in - to be taken advantage of. As an 18-year season ticket holder I appreciate his contributions, but it is time to move on. When Jessie Tuggle retired, he had more left in the tank than Brooking had three years ago. Hopefully, Keith will also make the decision to go out with dignity.

By D. Bell

February 12, 2009 2:43 PM | Link to this

He has lead the team in tackles for almost a decade. He has the second highest number of tackles in the league during a six year period.

He may be slowing down, but he’s still the best linebacker this team has right now. Some of the young guys have shown potential, but Boley should be out.

By Cairo

February 12, 2009 2:48 PM | Link to this

Jeff,

What a wasted article. Oh well! It must only mean the handwriting is on the wall. Highway by his own admission quit on the team in a PLAYOFF game. Hold up actually he quit the last 3 seasons. What the others have seen is a mirage… Just like the last 8 years of the BUSHIT.

By Jamie

February 12, 2009 2:53 PM | Link to this

I sure hope Keith is able to finish his career with the Falcons. He has done more than any other player in that position to get the Falcons to where they are today. One play or even one game shouldn’t help decide his fate. Keith has been a strong power not only in the games but with the team in keeping their spirits up and keeping them together as a true “family.” Atlanta needs to keep Keith until he’s ready to retire, so that hopefully we can see one more Super Bowl in his career. He sure deserves it! Thanks, Keith, for all you’ve done and all you, hopefully, will still do in the future for the Atlanta Falcons.

From a longtime true fan!!

By Kyle

February 12, 2009 2:54 PM | Link to this

Brooking is a likeable enough fellow (even for a Techie) but I’ve never been a huge fan. He is a consistent tackler (but 6 yds upfield). I want someone in that position that can stuff the run (and at times behind the LOS). Thanks, you’ve been very serviceable, now go enjoy retirement.

By nick s

February 12, 2009 2:57 PM | Link to this

They should keep Brooking and use him like they’ll probably continue to use Milloy: as a mentor to the younger linebackers…He doesn’t have to be an every-down linebacker…He can be used more-so in the run packages.

By U funny ppl.

February 12, 2009 2:59 PM | Link to this

I agree with some of these posters. The memories and all that is great, but all great things must come to an end. I watched every single game this year and I pay very close attention to what goes down on the field, simply put, Brooking is no longer worthy of being a full-time starting LB in the NFL. I love the fact that Brooking has spent his entire career in the Great state of Georgia but the time has come. Congrats to Brooking on a good career.

By Cairo is an idiot...

February 12, 2009 2:59 PM | Link to this

Bushit, wow, aren’t you a clever one. Did you come up with that amazing zinger with your incredible wit? What am I thinking, of course not, you’re just regurgiating left wing idiocy you found on some ridicilous blog somewhere.

I will say this, I’ll take the last 8 years any day then the next four with this big eared moron running this country.

By Phil

February 12, 2009 3:03 PM | Link to this

Brooking is a joke. He can’t cover, can’t tackle, gets faked out of his shoes, asleep at the wheel, just seems clueless out there. Time to move on.

By Andrew

February 12, 2009 3:03 PM | Link to this

Bye!

By Phil

February 12, 2009 3:04 PM | Link to this

Brooking is a joke. He can’t cover, can’t tackle, gets faked out of his shoes, asleep at the wheel, just seems clueless out there. Time to move on.

By Butters

February 12, 2009 3:06 PM | Link to this

Oh hamburgers!

By Jdub

February 12, 2009 3:07 PM | Link to this

we have James Lofton…

By hollywould

February 12, 2009 3:09 PM | Link to this

Jeff,

Good article. I have been a sth since the dome opened and have appreciated most of Brooking’s work. However, it is time at least to be at best the 4th or 5th backer. The speed is not there to hang with the young backs and tight ends. He seems to realize part of that. He has done a lot for Atlanta and georgia but this is about WINNING. There is a short window in the NFL to keep your team together and now is the time the Falcons need to go for it. The defense has to be upgraded and if that means no Brooking so be it. Thanks for the years Keith.

By Jdub

February 12, 2009 3:10 PM | Link to this

we have James Lofton…

By Spud Webb

February 12, 2009 3:11 PM | Link to this

I think if Mr. Brooking was a bit friendlier to the fan base he wouldn’t have recieved as much criticism as he’s gotten. Never has appeared to be a nice guy. That said, thanks for the 11 years Keith. Good luck, try signing with NE, not a bad gig, they like older LB’s, for a reduced rate. Bye.

By Who is the bozo Schultz???

February 12, 2009 3:12 PM | Link to this

Schultz: But Brooking is an unrestricted free agent and general manager Thomas Dimitroff wants to rebuild the defense.

You should really know your s** before you call someone a bozo…he is still under contract.

How does it feel Jeffrey to get owned by a message board bozo? Christ, they pay you retards…unreal.

By Who is the bozo Schultz???

February 12, 2009 3:12 PM | Link to this

Schultz: But Brooking is an unrestricted free agent and general manager Thomas Dimitroff wants to rebuild the defense.

You should really know your sshitt before you call someone a bozo…he is still under contract.

How does it feel Jeffrey to get owned by a message board bozo? Christ, they pay you retards…unreal.

By Dogbyte

February 12, 2009 3:13 PM | Link to this

Brookiing is a class-act and he doesn’t make excuses or whine. He has lost a step and maybe some of his passion for the game. That said, I hope a deal can be struck to keep him as a mentor while preserving his dignity. He has earned that right.

By Minnesota Jacket

February 12, 2009 3:13 PM | Link to this

Brooking I followed you at Tech being a Tech fan I have every piece of autographed memorabelia I could find with your name on it, your the soul reason I stuck with this team over the past years when god knows I had better things to do. Your a good man and an asset to the team no matter what people on here are going to say, remember its always easy to point out the 10 negative plays rather than the 100 great ones!! Go Tech

By RoundDawg

February 12, 2009 3:14 PM | Link to this

One of the most overrated players in Falcons history. Please let him go.

By Ryno

February 12, 2009 3:15 PM | Link to this

Only for League minimum and only keep him in on run downs. Every team needs depth at LB - but only if the price is right!

By GB

February 12, 2009 3:16 PM | Link to this

He’s a hell of a sight betgter than Boley.

By nick s

February 12, 2009 3:17 PM | Link to this

They should keep Brooking and use him like they’ll probably continue to use Milloy: as a mentor to the younger linebackers…He doesn’t have to be an every-down linebacker…He can be used more-so in the run packages.

By Lucius

February 12, 2009 3:24 PM | Link to this

Boo Hoo! Brookings gave up on Vick now the Falcons are giving up on his poor pass covering behind!

By Levi Shutt

February 12, 2009 3:27 PM | Link to this

He IS the Atlanta Falcons. The man is an American Hero. Nothing less….

By WT

February 12, 2009 3:28 PM | Link to this

Phillip, did I miss something the past 11 yrs.? When was KB ever a great ball player? Oh…ok, when I went to take a leak, or get more libations, because I really miss anything great he may have done! I just know everytime I saw KB, he was running behind someone…after they’ve run past him!

By Truth or Consequences

February 12, 2009 3:29 PM | Link to this

I have suggested on here before that it would be nice to see the “credentials” of these gonad-less idiots that make blanket statements about the athletic prowess of long-time NFL players. Why no answer? Because these slugs have only tackled and subsequently piled-on their partner in a tickle pile.

By Ray

February 12, 2009 3:29 PM | Link to this

He should have been gone at least three years ago. He’s too slow and cannot tackle. So long bum!

By David

February 12, 2009 3:29 PM | Link to this

Newnan is better than East Coweta.

By Najeh Davenpoop

February 12, 2009 3:32 PM | Link to this

How dare Keith Brooking criticize himself! He must be racist against white people. There’s no other explanation.

By PMC

February 12, 2009 3:35 PM | Link to this

His Durability, Leadership and Toughness are overlooked by most of us even me sometimes. I hope he can continue to play here if they can get a deal done but this defense does need Playmakers who do show up in the highlight reels.

He had a better year overall this year than he’s had in the last few.

By BugKiller

February 12, 2009 3:35 PM | Link to this

There’s a reason why I call James Laurinitis of Ohio State the single-most overrated player in college football the last couple of years:

It’s because he’s a Brooking clone.

Against inferior competition, the both look great, but against equal competition, they get their lunches handed to them.

Neither of them have the ability to cover backs in the flat.

And that is EXACTLY what weakside linebackers are supposed to be able to do. How many times not only this year, but even in the Mora years, did we see Keith totally whiff on tackles when a back got a pass in the flat right in front of him?

Good running backs have OWNED Brooking.

How many times did have we seen Laurinitis and Brooking make tackles 8 yards up field because they can’t get off the blocks of talented players?

Remember the LSU BCS Game two years ago? LSU specifically targeted Laurinitis the same way the Saints and Tampa and Carolina have been targeting Brooking for years!

How many piles do these two overrated players jump on after someone else had already made the play?

And why the hell does EVERYONE say Brooking’s natural position is at Will?

Again, he is owned by running backs. All of them. He is owned by tight ends up the seam, and has been his whole career.

Just like Laurinitis.

The only chance Brooking has of actually making a contribution to a team is going to a 3-4 and moving inside.

A team like the Patriots would be the perfect place for him, but they like their players to play smart and NOT miss assignments, something he’s done more often the last few years than just that one time in the Arizona game.

Brooking has been lucky as hell to play for the Falcons, because in a better organization (the Patriots, the Colts) he’d have been cut years ago.

And to the team that drafts Laurinitis, well, it’ll just continue the trend of OSU players BUSTING in the NFL.

By Reno 911 (Message Board Bozo #53142)

February 12, 2009 3:36 PM | Link to this

Holy cow, where you at Crabapplejoe??!!! Aren’t you going to rip Brooking into pieces? Hasn’t he read your lengthy explanations of how he didn’t do anything wrong on the fatal third-and-forever completion?! Please set him straight like you did all of us, because he clearly doesn’t know what he’s talking about.

(ps- I actually really like KB, I just think he’s lost a step or five.)

By BugKiller

February 12, 2009 3:37 PM | Link to this

There’s a reason why I call James Laurinitis of Ohio State the single-most overrated player in college football the last couple of years:

It’s because he’s a Brooking clone.

Against inferior competition, the both look great, but against equal competition, they get their lunches handed to them.

Neither of them have the ability to cover backs in the flat.

And that is EXACTLY what weakside linebackers are supposed to be able to do. How many times not only this year, but even in the Mora years, did we see Keith totally whiff on tackles when a back got a pass in the flat right in front of him?

Good running backs have OWNED Brooking.

How many times did have we seen Laurinitis and Brooking make tackles 8 yards up field because they can’t get off the blocks of talented players?

Remember the LSU BCS Game two years ago? LSU specifically targeted Laurinitis the same way the Saints and Tampa and Carolina have been targeting Brooking for years!

How many piles do these two overrated players jump on after someone else had already made the play?

And why the hell does EVERYONE say Brooking’s natural position is at Will?

Again, he is owned by running backs. All of them. He is owned by tight ends up the seam, and has been his whole career.

Just like Laurinitis.

The only chance Brooking has of actually making a contribution to a team is going to a 3-4 and moving inside.

A team like the Patriots would be the perfect place for him, but they like their players to play smart and NOT miss assignments, something he’s done more often the last few years than just that one time in the Arizona game.

Brooking has been lucky as hell to play for the Falcons, because in a better organization (the Patriots, the Colts) he’d have been cut years ago.

And to the team that drafts Laurinitis, well, it’ll just continue the trend of OSU players BUSTING in the NFL.

By GB

February 12, 2009 3:37 PM | Link to this

How many Pro Bowls did he play in? His peers must have thought pretty highly of him. He was a good linebacker until they had to move him inside.

By Bobby Petrino

February 12, 2009 3:41 PM | Link to this

Give him a tryout at quaterback.

By WHITEMENCANJUMP.

February 12, 2009 3:46 PM | Link to this

OK,the only thing brooking have is stats not highlights and game changing plays.Im trying to figure out why the team kept him this long,he didnt make a difference in the last 8 years.That means the coaches dont have an eye for talent or decline or sorry brookings had favortism.If you people watched the same games i have threw the years any other team would have yanked him out years ago.

By BAMA STAN

February 12, 2009 3:47 PM | Link to this

How refreshing - a professional athlete that is stand up.

Seriously, how many players would be pointing fingers at coaches or other players - or trying to come up with a lame excuse.

This guy is being truthful as he understands one play or a series of individual plays can define a career.

If you do not think so - think of Brian Bosworth (Bo Jackson), Lynn Swan ( his two incredible highlight catches in the Superbowl against Dallas). Franco Harris (emaculate reception) - get my drift??

Kudos to Brooking for being a professional.

With that said - I hope the Falcons sign him - but he needs a massive reduction in pay.

By Pete

February 12, 2009 3:49 PM | Link to this

Stick a fork in Brooking.

He’s done.

By caz1158

February 12, 2009 3:53 PM | Link to this

Brooking has had a solid not so spectacular career. It’s unfortunate that many players are judged not solely upon what they do on the field,but by how much money they make. With that said, I believe his productivity has diminished. If the Falcons can improve the defense by replacing Brooking,then that makes sense. I wish Mr. Brooking well & thank him for his time here.

By Wink from Lithonia

February 12, 2009 3:53 PM | Link to this

Keith Brookings time is up. We all can agree that Boley had a bad year as well. We also can agree that Anderson is a BUST as a Defensive End. Anderson did not get a sack his rookie year as a starter. Here is a veteran middle linebacker or outside linebacker that did not get a sack all year, why should he be spared the term BUST at his position. Let’s agreed that that too is unacceptable.

The comparison does not stop there…Anderson can’t tackle the quarterback and neither can Brookings…did you see how running straight at McNabb, Brookings ends up on the back side of McNabb reaching for his ankle. He should have drilled him right between the numbers.

The one sack Anderson could have had his rookie year it was Brookings who knocked him off the tackle. Age catches up with all atheletes eventually. It not even fair to think Brookings will be able to pass protect any Rookie Tight End in the upcoming draft that we would face…he can’t keep up…periord.

Does that say is career was a waste, heck no, but the time is long past where he is an every down linebacker. I don’t know maybe it’s me, but I would take a nasty tempered linebacker in the mold of Ray Lewis, Mike Ditka, Urlaucher…nothing wrong with being a nice guy like Brookings is, just not on the field. Hech Mike Singletary is a nice guy, I just don’t want to run into him on the field….you know what I am talking about…you have seen those linebacker eyes…if you are a real football fan…I sure you have. That’s the breed of linebacker we need…inject some FEAR!!!!

By Pitbull

February 12, 2009 3:53 PM | Link to this

Keith Brooking is the only Tech player that I wish had played for the Georgia Bulldogs. He has heart.

By CRABAPPLEJOE

February 12, 2009 3:56 PM | Link to this

Brooking is gay like me,thats why he likes jumping on the pile after the play is over.

By Plato

February 12, 2009 3:57 PM | Link to this

I can still play too, and I’m just 49!

Brooking would have been a decent linebacker if first downs were 30-yards instead of ten. He’s the master of the ten-yards-and-a-cloud-of-dust tackle.

By Forever

February 12, 2009 3:57 PM | Link to this

If the Falcons could cut Jesse Tuggle after a pretty good season, they can let Brooking’s contract expire after several mediocre seasons. The reasoning is the same for both, time to rebuild with youth.

By jag count

February 12, 2009 3:59 PM | Link to this

Pat Dye Jr said it himself brookins is a blue collar worker but not a superstar that scares people. this guy is the 2nd highest paid lb in the league you pay superstars that kind of money you pay blue collar workers league minimum. get rid of him like you would anyone else

By Jeff Schultz

February 12, 2009 4:00 PM | Link to this

Lawton: I don’t know that I’ve seen Brooking get run over much – he’s more often plagued by lost speed. He can’t cover RBs like he used to. Just my opinion. …. Leland: Thanks so much for your interest. [Here’s a link to my new glamour shot.] (http://blogs.ajc.com/jeff-schultz-blog/). Isn’t it spiffy? Seriously, technical problems right now force me to use the old ugly mug, not the new ugly mug. …. Mad-dog (and others): I’m sure if Keith is re-signed here, it won’t be for a “big” contract. … Phillip: Unless there are no offers from 30 teams, I don’t see Brooking retiring. At least, he didn’t sound like he was ready for that when I talked to him. … Spud Webb: Are you serious? Not friendly to the fan base? I’m curious where that comes from because, if anything, I’ve had the Falcons keep him in part because he’s perceived as such a great ambassador for the team. Did you have a bad experience with him or something? … Who is the bozo: Not, you’re wrong buddy. His contract is expiring. He had a year left on the 7-year deal but it voided because of playing time. So he’s free. So now who’s the bozo? …. Najeh: You made me laugh. … GB: I meant to put it in the column but I left it out: Brooking has played in five Pro Bowls (and was on the All-Pro team twice). But those Pro Bowls were 2001-05. He has not made it the last 3 seasons. … Petrino: Thank you. Tip your waitress. … JS

By Tami

February 12, 2009 4:05 PM | Link to this

I agree with most here on this blog. Brooking, from a sentimental angle, should be allowed the one more season he’s asking for. But, I also agree that it shouldn’t be at a high price but a fair one. By fair, I mean that he shouldn’t be offered something ridiculously low that would insult what he’s meant to this team throughout his career. But, he also shouldn’t be paid so high an amount that it takes away from what can be spent on improving the defense.

I personally would really like to see Brooking play one more finale season so that the fans have the opportunity to say “so long”. Someone with his dedication and loyalty to the team earns that right. The business of running any sports team, though, doesn’t always allow this as it should.

By Football Ken

February 12, 2009 4:06 PM | Link to this

Hey David,

East Cowetea OWNED Newnan during Brooks time, and how many Cougars went to the League during that time. EC sent 4.

By Kaz

February 12, 2009 4:06 PM | Link to this

Keith Brookings does not make game changing plays. For someone that was paid that much money, that is not acceptable. He is a good guy with a great heart,but who has never been a good cover linebacker or a player teams gameplan around. He finishes off plays, which makes him slightly above average in this league. Tackles are not like interceptions, fumbles, and even pass defended. Its a stat that says that you completed the play, on the same level as appearances for a relief pitcher.

Love you, but you gotta go!

By Football Ken

February 12, 2009 4:07 PM | Link to this

Hey David,

East Coweta OWNED Newnan during Brooks time, and how many Cougars went to the League during that time. EC sent 4.

By caz1158

February 12, 2009 4:09 PM | Link to this

Hey Wink-I agree,I believe we need to get more athletic in both area’s.We need to get Abraham some help,maybe then he won’t see as many double teams. Maybe someone with a nasty edge,someone that could give this defense a identity!!! They played pretty solid this year,but I think all would agree there’s room for improvement in more than one area.

By Chess

February 12, 2009 4:12 PM | Link to this

I saw Tampa Bay run the same play right a Brooking for 8 yards a pop. Some on the same series. Warrick Dunn abused him. I like him but its time. I need a tackle for a stop for a LB. Not gains.

By bravoshawkin

February 12, 2009 4:15 PM | Link to this

what the hell are you guys talking about? I’m a georgia native, and die hard Mississippi State Fan. Everybody and their godforsaken mother b*** and complain of people not finishing his career with one team. Brooking is and always will be a Falcon. He is a warrior, and anybody who forgets what he does for this team is a damn moron.

By caz1158

February 12, 2009 4:16 PM | Link to this

It’s to bad sentimental does’nt win games Tami! You can’t hide a player in decline. I don’t think Mr. Brooking would accept a job as a back-up,with a big reduction in salary. He has had a solid career,lets leave it at that,and thank him.

By AtlMike

February 12, 2009 4:18 PM | Link to this

Please let Brooking go NOW! Do not waste anymore money on him. Can’t you all see how slow he is? He likes to jump on the pile after everyone else has already tackled the guy. LET BROOKING GO NOW!!!

By johhny

February 12, 2009 4:19 PM | Link to this

Keith should get himself a big ol boner!

By Leon

February 12, 2009 4:20 PM | Link to this

Dang right Brooking can still play! If you need a tackle made 10-15 yards past the line of scrimmage or a have pile that needs to be jumped onto he’s your man.

By caz1158

February 12, 2009 4:26 PM | Link to this

Hey Bravo-I think the main sentiment here is,Brooking has had a solid career. I commend him on staying with one team,but it’s time.

By Brendan

February 12, 2009 4:27 PM | Link to this

Amen, Leon. Leon’s got it right. That’s what Brooking does/brings for the Falcons. It’s time to find better, and forget about the Falcons having “a local boy” on the squad, for P.R. purposes.

By ttough44

February 12, 2009 4:29 PM | Link to this

Hey What about #98? When is he gonna show up?! Brooking, thanks for the contributions over the years. I wish you well with the Falcons or whomever.

By caz1158

February 12, 2009 4:33 PM | Link to this

Whose P.R.? Kiddin,totally agree! P.R. has never made any tackles or won any games. Time for the Rolex Keith, I know of some nice retirement communities in Fla., I’ll forward the brochures. Take Care

By Jeff Schultz

February 12, 2009 4:46 PM | Link to this

So of all the things I expected in the comments section today, East Coweta-Newnan smack talk was not one of them. …. For those who’ve wondered about Brooking as a backup: That’s a call not only he’d have to make but the team. That’s a question concerning both Brooking and Milloy: If you did keep them (or one of them), do you spot them only in certain situations and downs? Can you have a guy like that on the roster as a part-time player? I really think a lot of this is going to depend on who else the Falcons can get on the open market and at what price. … Caz1158: Keith’s already got a place in Destin. … JS

By The BIG Boss Man

February 12, 2009 5:02 PM | Link to this

I really don’t understand the borderline hatred that some folks in Atlanta seem to have for Brooking.

By all accounts, he has given the team 100 percent on the field, and he’s never done a thing off the field to embarass the franchise or the city.

Obviously, he’s near the end of his career, but Brooking deserves the respect of ALL Falcon fans.

Of course, he can take some consolation from the fact that a significant percentage of his detractors are the kind of people who admire criminals.

By Halsey

February 12, 2009 5:06 PM | Link to this

I like Brooking, but he worried too much about critics. Most of his critics are either Billy Bob UGA fans or Jerome from South Atlanta who thinks all white players are ‘rudys’.

It’s true.

By falconfanatic365

February 12, 2009 5:09 PM | Link to this

Exactly, Vick defending message board bozo’s and people who just want to cut everyone are the Brooking bashers. How can anyone deny at this point that Dimitroff and Smith hit homeruns on every move they made. Yet they still paid Brooking to be one of the highest paid players on the roster. You can’t tell me that one year later he’s unworthy of a cheap short term contract. Negative people just need someone to hate. Second in the NFL in tackles over the last six seasons? What else do you people need? I say start him next year but keep him off the field on third downs. He’s still efficient against the run and is a great leader. He could probably be added as one of the best special teamers on the field if they’d limit him to projected running plays on defense.

By TheAntiMe

February 12, 2009 5:14 PM | Link to this

Keith Brooking has definitely lost a step or two over the years, but he is an experienced veteran who does make a lot of tackles. He was one of the Falcons greatest, back in the day.

Although Brooking will never again be the irresistible force that he once was back in 1998 during the Birds Superbowl run, he certainly is not nearly as lousy as some folks would have you believe. His team-leading tackles numbers are legitimate proof of this.

By Charles

February 12, 2009 5:20 PM | Link to this

K Brookings has been a good LB. Not great, not very good. just good. not one who because of his play has earned the right to be an alltime falcon like Tommy Nobis or Jesse Tuggle and certainly not deserving of the contract he signed years back. A hometown guy yes but the fact is HE DOES NOT and never did make plays, game changing plays. if in his decline he had the capicity to make plays i’d be for keeping him at a reduced price. but let’s face it. he is now a liability and not worth keeping - even if its at a cheap price.

By falcon fan

February 12, 2009 5:25 PM | Link to this

I like keith to, but didnt he sound a lot like brett favre in that interview? Maybe its time to start thinking about hanging `em up. The falcons need to move on. Thanks for some great times keith.

By MountainDawg

February 12, 2009 5:36 PM | Link to this

Brooking has been a solid player & Falcons mainstay for quite a spell. For most of his career he was grossly underrated IMO. In his prime, he was a top 10 NFL LB. Even as a die-hard Dawgs fan, he’s always been one of my favorite Falcon players. He obviously doesn’t have the speed from his earlier years, and yes…had an awful game against the Cards. However, I hope he & the Birds can work out a deal & keep him aboard (maybe as 2nd string). I don’t see him getting “big buck$” from the Falcons or any other team.

By BugKiller

February 12, 2009 5:37 PM | Link to this

Wow… the kind of revisionist history going on here could fill one of what passes for the new breed of anti-American U.S. History textbooks taught in high schools across the country the last decade or so thanks to organizations like ACLU, etc.

But I digress…

… TheAntiMe… Keith Brooking was far from an “Irresistible Force” during the Super Bowl season.

He wasn’t even a starter!!!

Come on, people! I’m not a Vick lover, I’m not a black dude, and even I can see that Brooking has been more hype that substance his whole career, and again, if he’d played for an organization not nearly as dysfunctional as the Falcons, he’d have been cut about 3 years ago.

As for Dimitroff keeping him instead of cutting him, it had everything to do with two things 1) the cap hit for cutting him wasn’t worth it; and 2) as overrated a player as he is, he’s an excellent leader and locker room presence (which is why I believe he’d be an EXCELLENT coach).

Dimitroff didn’t keep him because he’s talented. The Vick situation has tied up so much money they couldn’t pursue an excellent veteran in free agency to take his place. Cutting him wasn’t worth the hit. There wasn’t a place in the draft to take a really good Will LB (there will be in the 2010 draft when Renne Curran becomes available).

And unlike Brooking, Renne Curran is the real deal. He makes stops in the backfield or at the line, not 8 yards down the field. He knows how to wrap up. He isn’t made a b!tch by backs in the flat like Brooking. And he can cover fairly decently when asked.

So, if I were Dimitroff, I’d actually re-sign Bolley to a cheap one year offer sheet, giving both the ability to cut bait after the year is over, cut Brooking, then draft Curran in 2010.

That’s a plan we can get behind.

By andy

February 12, 2009 5:37 PM | Link to this

Brooking a great Falcon? Are effing kidding me?? Can anyone tell me when Brooking ever made a big play for the Falcons? Never, end of story. This guy is most overrated player in the NFL for years. The LBs hasn’t been the same since Jesse Tuggle retired

By The Dean 21

February 12, 2009 5:43 PM | Link to this

You would have to determine his worth to the team and make a decision from there. I can recall the New Orleans game which stands out in my mind with Reggie Bush being pushed in the end zone by Brooking. Of course the latest Brooking highlight reel is the 3rd and 16!!!!!!! This stings very badly because who knows, that play may have cost us a Super Bowl visit. But it’s time to move forward now and cut our losses with one Brooking being released!

By caz1158

February 12, 2009 5:48 PM | Link to this

JS-no hate here,I appreciate all Brooking has done.But as in life its time. Thanks for a solid career. In regards to retirement home-all in jest. Any way I was thinking more in lines of that Arnie/Nancy Lopez place!!!Kiddin

By Harry Rand

February 12, 2009 6:00 PM | Link to this

At reduced pay he definately should come back, he’s always give it everything unlike Ed Hartwell which you can get on the open market, fortunately J. Abraham .made up for that in a big way.

By Reno 911

February 12, 2009 6:01 PM | Link to this

TheAntiMe: Slow down, brother. I’m not so sure I’d call Brooking’s 33 tackles in 1998 an “irresistable force”. I like the guy, but let’s not invent history. Brooking was a rookie backup that year. ‘98 stats: 26 solos, 7 assists, 2 FF, 1 Int. The problem is, TheAntiMe, what the Falcons would need from Brooking in 2009 is to be EXACTLY what he was in 1998, which is a backup. I like KB. But I love the Falcons. Everyone who overlooks KB’s shortfalls and continues to nod toward “history” ignores the fact that, late in the 2009 season with a playoff spot on the line, the Panthers aren’t going to ease off and decide NOT to run Deangelo Williams into the flat to burn KB out of respect to his contributions to the Falcon’s organization. Thank goodness we have Dimitroff.

By Chuckd

February 12, 2009 6:05 PM | Link to this

I think Arthur Blank made a mistake when he signed KB to that 42 million dollar contract in the first place. The Falcons needed help in so many areas at that time. The team could have paid two maybe three players to help in areas that would have improved the team that year. I think that the Falcons and Arthur Blank should get players that can bring a tougher edge to this team. KB was not and is not a player with a tough edge to him. Any other team in the league he would have not been a starter and would not have been around this long. Get him out of town now and let’s move forward.

By caz1158

February 12, 2009 6:08 PM | Link to this

Don’t get started on Mr Blank-Perfect example of heart in the right place,but clearly no clue inregards to personell decisions.

By falcon21

February 12, 2009 6:12 PM | Link to this

Reno 911, good one. That’s all I’m gonna say.Don’t want to make Joe mad.

By Time4Brooking2Go

February 12, 2009 6:18 PM | Link to this

Brooking is no superstar…believe you and me. IMO he has been an average LB his entire NFL career. Some of you can quote stats all u like but he is not the type of LB that can change a game, that can lead a defense to step its game up. I’ve watched him just like the rest of you since his rookie year in 98, again very average. And the older he gets the worst he’s getting. He has always been the weak link that teams matched up their RBs and TEs against because they know he’d always get burned. This is a business and it’s time to upgrade to keep this team going in the right direction with the youth that will take the Falcons toward that SB we’ve all long for. This is my opinion and the rest of you whiney Keith huggers can just keep dreaming.

By falcons fan

February 12, 2009 6:28 PM | Link to this

i like u brooking, but because our defense is not in the top 5, ur weakest is more exposed. 11 years u’ve had a good career, take less money or good to another team where u feel you can play at a higher level and be fairly paid, probably one with a better defense to make up for the 11 yrs of a great career and older age.

By cutter

February 12, 2009 6:34 PM | Link to this

If brook thinks he can still play, we should release him and let him play elsewhere. i dont see much demand for a 33 yr old declining linebacker but i wish you luck brook.

By Phillip

February 12, 2009 6:53 PM | Link to this

To Keith’s last comment in the Schultz blog, “But I know I can still play. I just think I should be judged by my body of work, not one play or one game.”

Keith, we are judging you by your “body of work the last 3 seasons - they have been very poor. You had some very good seasons but they are long past. You were paid like a “top 3” linebacker in the game for the last 5 years but you have not played at a level close to your contract - while you have a lot of tackles, you do not impact a game and no offense has ever had to gameplan against Keith Brooking. Simply put, you are not even an average NFL linebacker anymore. We appreciate what you did and the career you had for the Falcons but its time for you to go - you really should retire, but if you will not, you can do like Favre and play one year for another team and then retire. You won’t start for a winning team anymore. I know its sad……but its true.

By Algonquin J. Calhoun

February 12, 2009 6:59 PM | Link to this

If he is not re-signed, New England will gladly take him and head for another Super Bowl. There’s a difference between old and old and in the way. Brooking is merely old!

By Max

February 12, 2009 7:01 PM | Link to this

I love Keith Brooking and the way he plays. He’s hard nosed, he’s loyal, he works hard, and he doesn’t showboat- he’s all about the team. While age may have caught up to him just a bit, he still plays at a high level and he brings a lot of intangibles to this team- leadership, experience and a good work ethic. Bring him back!

By HB

February 12, 2009 7:34 PM | Link to this

HEY HEY GOODBYE

By VICK SUPPORTER 2

February 12, 2009 7:45 PM | Link to this

MORE MONEY FOR D HALL

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=3902683

DARN IT & HE SUCKS :)

THOSE V-TECH GUYS :)

By Dledbetter4300

February 12, 2009 7:54 PM | Link to this

Hey Jeff,

Maybe Pat Dye will read this and finally call D. Led back!!!

Hey, Pat holla @ D. Led!!!

You have the digits!!!

D. Led

By TheAntiMe

February 12, 2009 8:20 PM | Link to this

That’s right, I forgot. Keith Brooking has always been a lousy player. That’s why he played in 5 straight Pro Bowls and is probably why he was often named as the next-best LB behind Brian Urlacher by NFL analysts in his early years, my bad.

By Sly Ty

February 12, 2009 8:29 PM | Link to this

Brooking has been a great warrior for Georgia Tech, and the Atlanta Falcons. He never got into any off the field crap, and he was/is an ambassador for the team. He is a good American, and has been a Standout Football player for our entire State. He has worn down literally (used to be around 6 feet 4 inches), but all the years of big hitting/tackling have worn him down. He was taught by Jesse Tuggle, and that is why he was productive for so long. I wish him well, he could very easily be a linebacker coach somewhere very soon. Thanks Keith for your hard work and dedication to the city and state.

By Maestro

February 12, 2009 8:40 PM | Link to this

At last we come to the end of the Keith Brooking era. I am the biggest Falcon fan in THE WORLD which means I am the biggest critic of our so-called “Falcon greats.” Just so I’m not accused of hatin’ just to be hatin’, Jesse Tuggle wasn’t so great. Just like Brooking he may have made a lot of tackles but look at where they took place: five to ten yards downfield. How many tackles did he make BEHIND the line of scrimmage? Not many. Michael Boley who I thought was going to have a break out year wound up being replaced on obvious run downs. Linebacker was the defense’s Achilles heel and was exploited. Every great defense is anchored by linebackers who are playmakers, not guys like Brooking who can’t remember the last time he had a sack or made a play that had impact on the game. TD has pushed the right buttons so far, I say go out and find playmakers for the defense, especially at linebacker sans Keith Brooking.

By TheAntiMe

February 12, 2009 8:41 PM | Link to this

You know, it just occurred to me that the “washed-up former star” syndrome seems to be the theme of the day. Maybe the Falcons can trade Keith Brooking to the Braves for Tom Glavine.

It probably wouldn’t work out so well, but it just might be kind of fun to see Brooking on the mound and to see Glavine trying to cross-check some 250 lb. Running Back coming at him with a head of steam.

By mrdonut

February 12, 2009 8:45 PM | Link to this

Brooking needs to go. He’s never been a team leader in the clubhouse and now he’s lost more than a step on the field.

By falcon21

February 12, 2009 9:01 PM | Link to this

TD is the man who will make the decision and he will make the decision from his head and not his heart. He does not give a dang what we think. Good luck KB, you are gone!!!

By Terence NoMoore

February 12, 2009 9:02 PM | Link to this

Keith Brooking…. great guy, but goodbye. The NFL is a business and with all due respect for KB his tme is up. He has really underoerformed for the past 3 maybe 4 years. Like many of the more knowledgeable bloggers have stated repeatedly. It is sad but it’s time to upgrade the position. I am in sales and have bee for 20 years. I am always in the top 10% of the company leaders and I am also liked by many of my colleagues, and respected by management for the skils I posess but, if my production slips noticeably and repeatedly I get called in and evaluated. I am willing to bet that KB has ben or will be evaluated by the curent coaching staff and management. The only reason that KB was not released in the past few years is simple… that fat $42 million deal, and now thats history. I am betting man and, willing to bet my left nut we will NOT see Keith Brooking in a Falcon uniform next season. Bottom line is he’s done as a starting NFL linebacker. Thank you Keith but it’s time for a new gig or simply ride of into the sunset and enjoy the $50 millionyou earned as a player and go play with your kids while you still have the physical ability.

By SirReal

February 12, 2009 9:09 PM | Link to this

People are whining about how we’re not treating him right. “KB did this” or “Brooking is the heart of the Falcons D”. HA!!!! That’s major cattle-crap!!!! LOL It’s like this, let him retire. At the end of the day, I guy still has millions of dollars while many of us struggle to make ends meet. We forget to put that into perspective. Yeah, they get paid big bucks to “entertain” us, etc….but what happens after the final whistle blows. Life goes on….and Brooking should too. Have a good life, make some sound investments, and enjoy the fruits of battering your body as a gladiator. Congrats Keith, you made it through the gauntlet w/o too many dents. Take care!! It’s been fun!

By Joey Porter

February 12, 2009 9:11 PM | Link to this

Keith is the man. TD needs to sign KB right away.

SORRY ARSE ATL FANS ARE LOSERS AND CANNOT HELP THEMSELVES. THUS THEY MUST SIGN KB TO PROLONG THEIR ETERNAL MISERY.

By falcondawg

February 12, 2009 9:44 PM | Link to this

Keith’s play will always be remembered. One thing i can say he really gave it all he could, I respect that. However if we are really building into the future then the sad truth is for money reasons we have to let him go. The same with Lawyer.This is business no reason to take it personal he needs to look at farve and understand his time has come. Especially on the defensive side of the ball, his speed has gone and his coverage ability has disapeared. I think Keith will be always be a falcon in the eyes of the people in atlanta. Maybe he can continue to help the team in coaching the young backers in the future.

By Turner

February 12, 2009 9:46 PM | Link to this

Brooking is washed up. He misses tackles after tackle. He doesn’t wrap up at all and always is 5 minutes late to every play. He has heart but so does every other football player in the league to. He needs to get ready for an anchor job on Sunday!He definitely is not worth mega millions. I would sign him year by year, pending on ur performance. Otherwise Bye Bye!

By Turner

February 12, 2009 9:47 PM | Link to this

Brooking is washed up. He misses tackles after tackle. He doesn’t wrap up at all and always is 5 minutes late to every play. He has heart but so does every other football player in the league to. He needs to get ready for an anchor job on Sunday!He definitely is not worth mega millions. I would sign him year by year, pending on ur performance. Otherwise Bye Bye!

By Navarro_#74

February 12, 2009 10:09 PM | Link to this

I think it’s funny everyone is talking crap about him making tackles 6-yards down the field and stuff. Would you rather him just let them go until someone else manages to make that tackle farther down the field? Obviously the rest of our Defense can’t seem to stop them any quicker.

By KEITH DIVE ON THE PILE

February 12, 2009 10:31 PM | Link to this

CRAP IS THAT KB RUNS DOWN THE FIELD AND DIVES ONTO THE PILE AFTER HIS TEAMATES HAVE MADE THE TACKLE,HURRY UP AND SEND HIS A$$ BACK TO GA TECH,BEFORE THESE HICKS UGAY FANS GET MAD!

By UGADawg16

February 12, 2009 10:38 PM | Link to this

“Football teams do not lose games because of one player or one play.” I am a Dawg fan so I of all people would be one of the first to criticize Brooking HAD HE DONE ANYTHING TO DESERVE IT. He hasn’t…he’s been a rock for a team that has had precious few. I know it’s business but I truly hope he gets to finish his career as a Falcon. Brooking is past his prime, no doubt - at his age he’s supposed to be, but I have a feeling of loyalty that I guess is outdated and not shared by many. Yeah, I know he went to Tech, I just try not to thank about it on Sundays. There has never been any doubt in my mind about this guys heart or effort, a rarity now days that is not lost on me. I hope his time in Atlanta is not done, but if it is, then thank you for the last 11 years Keith.

By Reggie Watson A falcon season ticket holder 4 a long time 1991

February 12, 2009 10:50 PM | Link to this

Kieth Give it up. Every RB in the league has ran passed you down the field and cought a touchdown on you every since you entered the NFL. YOU CAN’T COVER. You Suck!! You Guy’s who want to give him another year must be fools.You wouldn’t give Vick another chance, why in the F@#k would you give him one. We need a New LB, and take that sorry a$$ Jamaal Anderson with U!!

By The Chief

February 12, 2009 11:21 PM | Link to this

Give him one more year.

By Spivedog

February 12, 2009 11:39 PM | Link to this

He did not make ONE play this year. NOT ONE. The last play of the Arizona drive was a microcosm for Brooking the last three years. I seriously do not think he could start for UGA or Ga.Tech this year, much less for the Dirty Birds.

Too wong foo, Keith, thanks for everything, you pile jumper!

By Aghast

February 13, 2009 6:52 AM | Link to this

I’ve watched Keith since his 9th grade year at East Coweta, and I’ve always been a fan. Blue collar describes him to a “T”. I will agree that his best years are behind him, but he’s been one of the best role models the Falcons have ever had, and that’s something special in current “me first” era that we live in. Give the guy a break show him some respect - he at least deserves to leave with some dignity in tact. I personally hope he returns to Coweta County, as he’s done more for the community than any other person I know of.

Keith, I’ll always be a fan. Whatever comes your way, I wish you the best of luck..

By Kaz

February 13, 2009 7:49 AM | Link to this

I appreciate the love for Keith. His off the field work is great. I think he leaves a warm spot in people’s hearts. I actually think he is one of the gems of the Falcons organization when you talk about what’s good about the team. All of those things are true.
However, our emotions about his personal qualities and envy and disgust of Vick lovers can not cloud your judgement. I thought Vick could do no wrong until I saw Matt Ryan. Unwavering Brooking fans will change when Tom D. brings in a linebacker that changes games. You’ll see.

By Van

February 13, 2009 8:09 AM | Link to this

Hey Cairo, Quick. Who was the last linebacker not nameed Brooking to lead the teanm in tackles? You say he’s done. I say your tired stuff needs to go along with him if he is done. You are a really great ambassador for this team bud. Brook’s got you beat on this one. What world are you living in? He’s been bad for 8 years? Class, and leadership. KB has that. Where’s yours?

By kclubmember

February 13, 2009 8:29 AM | Link to this

Keith Brooking has never made a significant defensive play since he entered the NFL.He’s too light to play linebacker,too slow to cover any running back or tight end.Brooking has been a special teams’player starting on defense,and he has played the best ball

By Jeff Schultz

February 13, 2009 8:52 AM | Link to this

Interesting comments by everybody. Pretty much what I expected – at both ends of the spectrum. But kclubmember: Your comment, “Keith Brooking has never made a significant defensive play since he entered the NFL.” I don’t know what you count as significant. But when you get voted to five Pro Bowls and two All-Pro teams from 2001-05, that statement seems kind of nonsensical.

By jimmy

February 13, 2009 9:03 AM | Link to this

Being the leading tackler means nothing when they are 10-15 yards down the field. He was good in his prime, but he is done. He has very few tackles for losses and can’t cover anymore. Retire as a Falcon and move on to broadcasting.

By Angela

February 13, 2009 9:46 AM | Link to this

Good-bye Mr. Brooking, time to pack your bags and keep it moving!

By Angela

February 13, 2009 9:49 AM | Link to this

Good-bye Mr. Brooking, time to pack your bags and keep it moving!

By Sandy Hutcheson

February 13, 2009 9:58 AM | Link to this

Keith Brookings your efforts on the field and off the field are appreciated. I look forward to another year of “56” football. By the way, how many Pro Bowl’s have you attended??

By **Frederick (Bailey) Douglass**

February 13, 2009 10:03 AM | Link to this

“Message Board Bozo”

I’m offended!

JS, you can’t insult the community that your are speaking to…and get away with it. This is why Ledbetter has a better web-column than you. He is ONE OF US.

Let’s break it down. Writers and pundits have a fascination with the traditional NFL linebacker…in the likes of Tommy Nobis, Butkus, Jack Ham, etc. etc. When one comes along that “looks” like this legacy, you guys get all excited and make him more than he is. See: Brooking, A.J. Hawk, Poluszny, Bosworth, Dan Morgan, Laurinaitis. These guys may get a pro bowl nod here and there…but none of these LB’s are game changing. They simply look the part…with their blond hair, number in the 50’s…catching running backs all over the field (no tackles moving forward).

Brooking has been durable…but you know why?? Like my boy Westside J says…Because he does not throw his body around like the Steelers #43, our own Milloy, like Kerney did when he was here, like Jack Ham, Nobis, or my man Butkus. On a team with higher expectations, Brooking would have been covering punts or trying to block extra points. Could you see him lining up for the Steelers, Bucs or Ravens? HELL NO. They would have cut him 3 years ago.

My point: The Falcons must choose between loyalty and getting a stop on 3rd and 16 when they need it. You say one play does not determine a game…I say, in a game of inches (see #10’s Super Bowl catch), indvidual plays make the difference in games. Trust me JS (I won’t call YOU out of your name), #2 would have taken us down to win: 31-30. The way you “win” plays is to have high caliber players at every position. Having #56 on the field finally bit the birds in the…wings, when they needed him most.

By tony

February 13, 2009 10:06 AM | Link to this

GREATEST PILE JUMPER SINCE JUNIOR SEAU. SPECIAL TEAMS IS WHERE YOU BELONG. MOP UP DUTY AT BEST.

By Jacob Wright

February 13, 2009 10:08 AM | Link to this

Home Town Hero sucks! Get his sorry tail outta here now!!!!!

By BH

February 13, 2009 10:19 AM | Link to this

Keith Brooking is pure garbage on a garbage team.

By kclubmember

February 13, 2009 10:36 AM | Link to this

To Jeff Schultz:Keith Brooking is a joke at the linebacker position.All of the coaches in the NFL know Brooking is a defensive liability.The game is too fast for his cerebral cortex.Being selected to the Pro Bowl isn’t as significant as winning a championship.

By Carla, Georgia Peach

February 13, 2009 10:42 AM | Link to this

Keith Brooking did not play good at all the whole season; not just the last game! Everytime the defense was getting up off of the ground he was standing up looking down at them! It was as if he was trying to save himself from being hurt!

By cc

February 13, 2009 10:59 AM | Link to this

we should replace brooking in the starting lineup but keep him on the team as a back-up with a reduced salary. he can still play but he isn’t ‘the man’ anymore.

By Vicki

February 13, 2009 11:08 AM | Link to this

Keith Brookings is a leader on that team….and everyone knows it. We made the playoffs………which was totally unexpected. What, we didn’t win the super bowl…so the team is bad…..and now let’s start ripping players apart one by one. Atlanta is just not a good fan city….whine…whine…whine….I am proud of the Falcons this year!!!

By Gunner

February 13, 2009 11:45 AM | Link to this

I SAY GIVE BROOK A BREAK.

HE’S GIVEN A BUNCH OVER THE YEARS.

By Love My Falcons

February 13, 2009 11:55 AM | Link to this

I totally agree with Dolemite that Tuggle(my favorite falcon of all time) had more when he retired than Brooking. But I too am a big fan of Keith Brooking…I appreciate his fire. I appreciate the large fan base that he has. But all things have a season and I have to agree with my friends that Keith is in the winter of his. It would be nice to seem him remain a part of the team for 09 but definitely not a starter.

By Martin

February 13, 2009 12:22 PM | Link to this

IF…we sign free agent Karlos Dansby and draft an OLB on the first day, then we can let both Brooking and Boley walk. Otherwise we should keep them both for one more year and draft a 3rd or 4th round OLB to replace Wire.

By Martin

February 13, 2009 12:24 PM | Link to this

IF…we sign free agent Karlos Dansby and draft an OLB on the first day, then we can let both Brooking and Boley walk. Otherwise we should keep them both for one more year and draft a 3rd or 4th round OLB to replace Wire.

By Dean

February 13, 2009 12:32 PM | Link to this

Pitchers and Catcher report TOMORROW!

By maddoxh

February 13, 2009 12:41 PM | Link to this

I am a big fan of Keith Brooking too. But I believe his time is up for being a starter. Im tired of hearing “Tackle by Keith Brooking….1st Down”.

By Eric1

February 13, 2009 12:43 PM | Link to this

If he can’t play for the Falcon’s, he can most definitely play for me!!

By WR

February 13, 2009 12:49 PM | Link to this

JS, you make a good point as do many of the bloggers about Keith Brooking. As far as pro bowls and all pro selections, Keith has been the best linebacker that the falcons have had for many years and thats not saying much when considering the group as a whole. Going even further name at least 3 good not decent defensive players they have had on their team in the last 8 yrs, yes over the last few years abraham and lawyer have been pretty good but I’m speaking more toward those pro bowl and all pro years, and coincidentally why is it that upon their arrival his skills just happened to diminish. I’m not taking anything away from brooking, he has been a good falcon both on the field and off, a blue-collar player without much help, but when the help arrived his ability to make game changing plays should have increased but they actually diminished. So the question is was he on the down-side of his career when they arrived or did their arrival and plays take away from his one man show of heart and intensity, not greatness. If your an opposing team and one player from another team constantly is making the majority of plays, of course you recognize him. If going on the standard of character and work ethic, brooking is a pro-bowler and all-pro, if going by the standard of game changer he is far from it and has always been so. By the way, most of the people who complain about vick-lovers, loved him too, myself included, what he did with dogs doesn’t take away from what he did on the field. As much as I loved to see vick play, if I could I would say thanks for the screw-up because without such screw-up, we miss out on Ryan, likewise to keith, it would be nice for you to finish your career with the falcons, maybe as a back-up, but the time is now to add a game changing linebacker, which the falcons haven’t had in years.

By Chris Broe

February 13, 2009 1:23 PM | Link to this

Brookings only talks freely now because of the preemptive pardon Bush gave all the Falcons for blowing the playoffs.

By GREEN Tea

February 13, 2009 2:11 PM | Link to this

I say give the honkey another chance. Dimitroff will not pay him more than he is worth if Brookings is gonna stay with the franchise. I just look at examples of this with New England and can’t give you an example where they held on to dudes wanting more money than they were worth. OR giving them more money than they were worth for that matter. He has all the respect in the world from me. I don’t fault him for signing for the $42M, myself along side every other blog poster on here would do the same exact thing and if ya say different you’re a damn lie. Brookings is what sports should be all about in my opinion, hard work, hustle, heart, and loyalty. YES, he has lost a step (or 4 or 5) but I don’t see him playing as much next season as I KNOW Dimitroff will do something about the lack of quality play from the LB corp as a whole. You know it too. YES, the 3rd and 16 had me cussing Brookings for weeks and I do for the most part pin that loss on him. Yada yada you can’t blame one guy for a loss I don’t buy into that. But as far as cutting him I say that’s getting ahead of ourselves a bit. Sign him for wayyyy less and let him continue to be a POSITIVE INFLUENCE on these young kids on defense. It’s a must with them building this franchise up using so much youth. If you don’t have this you get what we had a few years ago and I don’t think anyone wants that for the Falcons again.

By Hip Hopcracy

February 13, 2009 2:25 PM | Link to this

Any amateur GM’s out there who could tell me whether we have enough salary cap to sign both Asomugha AND Haynesworth as free agents?

And then we could draft a TE like Pettigrew in the first round.

By Dawg4Life

February 13, 2009 2:35 PM | Link to this

All you Brooking apologists need to go watch the CFL or something. Brooking has spent the better part of the last three seasons getting smoked by every TE in the league, showing up to plays 4 steps late, and dropping sure INT’s. He is not fit to be an NFL LB anymore, if he ever was. I knew it was over for #56 when he got completely juked out of his shoes by JAKE DELHOMME. The tackles he makes are 15-20 yds down the field. Half of you people on here are defending him because he is a “nice guy, that comes on Q100”. He is a nice guy, he just can’t play football and anyone saying that we need to sign him again are dead wrong. This team is moving forward, and they don’t need some washed up, has been that makes rookie mistakes in key situations. Forget about the Pro Bowl selections because they don’t mean squat. That is obvious when Abraham was left off the roster. I guess being 2nd in the NFL in sacks playing every third down doesn’t mean as much as whiffing on every tackle and letting Visanthe Shiancoe torch you for an entire game….

By darrell starks

February 13, 2009 2:51 PM | Link to this

ERIC1 YOU CAN have brooking we will miss him but the SHOW MUST GO ON LOOK WE ARE trying to win superbowls AND IN ORDER FOR US TO DO THAT WE NEED player and especialy on defense where this team has been LACKING FOR YEARS AND IF WE MAKE ONE BIG SPLASH AND SIGN HAYNSEWORTH THEN WE DONT HAVE TO waste a pick on DT our first pick SHOULD BE LB JAMES LAURINAITIS FROM OHIO STATE OUR LB BRIAN CUSHING FROM USC THAT WILL BE STARTE FOR SOMETHING GOOD TO COME for this team. GO FALCONS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

By Williams

February 13, 2009 3:27 PM | Link to this

Brooking should have been gone lol about 5 years ago.He couldn’t cover a mice if he was on top of it.Brooking was ok in his early years but just on the field in his later years.Brooking was too overrated as one of the best linebacker in a game.I hope he retire because I heard he can’t hunt pretty good but not hunt down running backs and other backs lol.Good Bye!!!

By Lern too spel

February 13, 2009 3:51 PM | Link to this

Terence NoMoore - top 10% in your company? With a quick glance at your entry I counted at least 12 spelling and gramatical errors. No one that read your entry believes you are in the top 10% in any field. Maybe your time is up and YOU should retire.

By FALCONS SORRY

February 13, 2009 4:34 PM | Link to this

THE SORRY FALCONS BETTER NOT EVEN THINK ABOUT TRADING MV7! MV7 BUILT THIS WHOLE SORRY TOWN IT AINT NOTHING WITHOUT HIM!! THE FALCONS ARE THE SORRYEST TEAM IN FOOTBALL AND IT IS A SHAME HOW THEY TREAT THE GREATEST PLAYER THEY EVER HAVE!!!! GO SOMEWERE THAT YOU BE LOVED FOR THE GREAT PLAYER AND PERSON YOU ARE MIKE!!!!

By tim tuel

February 13, 2009 5:02 PM | Link to this

I know pro sports are a bussiness but must all the hometown heroe’s go after thier admitted best years are behind them?I just read your piece on Brooking and remember the yowls about Smoltz.Keith has been a talent at his profession and an asset to Atlanta for years and being a tech fan you can add a few on for me prior to the falcons,remember the crunching hit’s,the energy he brought to the defence.Dont let one bad game overshadow his talent and dedication to this city.He’s still an asset to the birds and this town

By Mookie

February 13, 2009 5:26 PM | Link to this

Hey FALCONS SORRY, go rob a liquor store already you bum…

By VICK SUPPORTER 2

February 13, 2009 5:30 PM | Link to this

CAROLINA & TAMPA

———YOU ARE ON THE CLOCK————

VICK THE RETURN HAS STARTED

By Najeh Davenpoop

February 13, 2009 5:30 PM | Link to this

Move over, Brooking, and let Ray Lewis in…

And whoever be jacking my screen name, I will let the AJC deal with you.

By Mookie

February 13, 2009 5:37 PM | Link to this

And YOU Vick supporter 2. I hope your sorry a$$ goes to what ever publication the city has that Vick goes to with your ignorant posts. You are a waste. Maybe you and FALCONS SORRY should team up and rob that liquor store. I’m sure he’ll need a lookout guy or a driver.

By JJ

February 13, 2009 5:38 PM | Link to this

“darrell” - I agree with some of your points but it’s difficult following your thoughts! Are you afraid of the comma/period keys? It really makes comprehending your ideas easier! “falcons sorry” - you’re hilarious! Please keep blogging, you may reach VS2 status with your keen intel!!!

By JJ

February 13, 2009 5:51 PM | Link to this

VS2

do you think he’ll be suspended from the nfl this year?

do you think anyone will trade picks for him until that info is known?

do you think your prediction of 2-14 was a little off for the falcons?

By Sage of Bluesland

February 13, 2009 7:50 PM | Link to this

That was, without a doubt, one of the most pathetic articles I’ve ever read—and being a long-time reader of the AJC, that’s saying something.

Good ol’ Keith…Our precious Hometown Hero…The vaunted local-boy-done-good…The Tankler…The Green-Dot Express…The eight-yard-downfield-pilejumper…

In the end, the most overrated linebacker I’ve ever seen “play”.

He couldn’t shed blocks at the point of attack and grabbed ankles eight-yards-downfield while at Tech, and SURPRISE, he did nothing but this while with the Falcons.

The most overpaid linebacker I’ve ever seen “play”.

The fraud which has been perpetrated on the SHEEP has been laughable, to say the least…When I see all those #56 jerseys in the stands, I simply laugh at the ignorance of those who actually believe everything the organization shovels out to them!

The emotional nonsense is beyond extreme in here when it comes to good ol’ Keith…You can’t help but get some sheep feces on you…

Schultz, usually I agree with you, but you are dead wrong on this one. Our precious Hometown Hero has been part of the PROBLEM in Falconsland for many years—as opposed to being part of the SOLUTION.

Stop with the woe-is-him emotional tripe—it’s beyond pathetic.

By Ga Boy

February 13, 2009 8:27 PM | Link to this

Did you people just finish a case of idiot. Brooking is a stud. Can you name any other player who has: led their team in tackles for the last 6 seasons? Made the probowl from 3 different linebacker positions? Or a linebacker that hasnt missed a game in 8 years?

The answer to that question is NO!!! KEITH BROOKING has still got game and if we dont resign him I hope he proves it by signing for a division rival. Sometimes we dont know what we have until its gone.

And for the last game, all falcons played like $hit, i dont see anyone crucifying Ryan, White, Abraham, and Michael Turner the Burner. They all were major non factors.

Knock em out Keith and thanks for the memories.

By TPM

February 13, 2009 9:04 PM | Link to this

Keith Brooking is excellent at jumping on the pile at the end of the play. He also has a strange habit of celebrating after every tackle, even the onces that result in positive yards.

By Sage of Bluesland

February 13, 2009 10:06 PM | Link to this

The height of ignorance: our precious Hometown Hero NEVER played strongside linebacker.

Never.

Try again—and leave the emotional tripe out of it…Without it, you have NOTHING…

I just don’t know what this team will do without his, umm, “leadership”…It’s been SO valuable and tangible in the past, hasn’t it?

(for instance, when DeAngelo Hall was melting down in 2007 against the Panthers at home, WHO was there calming him down? It WASN’T the precious Tankler—it was Alge Crumpler—at least trying to be a real leader…Keith was nowhere to be found—no surprise as that is where he usually is on Sunday)

Stop the fraud, for Heaven’s sake. The sheep really look silly, don’t they?!

By Najeh Davenpoop

February 14, 2009 9:47 AM | Link to this

Other Najeh at 530 yesterday

You are being officially ignored.

By Chris Broe

February 14, 2009 10:18 AM | Link to this

Why is it that babies come in packs of eight when there’s only womb for one or two buns-in-the-oven? I always end up throwing away several perfectly good babies. I waste a lot of bath water that way, too; and that’s such a shame during this drought.

By John Quest

February 14, 2009 10:38 AM | Link to this

Dion Sanders tackles better than the current Keith Brooking. Keith is even late for the pile-ons!

By nativefalcon

February 14, 2009 12:57 PM | Link to this

If Brooking came back in a reduced role and was more of a mentor, or even better yet a coach. I would be all for that. But if he wants tons of money, gotta let him walk. I am one of the biggest brooking supporters, but you could tell from the football point of view he has lost a step. Those wasted years they had him at Middle linebacker didn’t help. I would like to see him back and I bet its not even about money now with him, he’s got plenty, its getting a super bowl ring.

By falcon21

February 14, 2009 1:48 PM | Link to this

You got it right John Quest, naivefalcon is the one that can’t figure it out.

By Birdy Bozo

February 16, 2009 9:39 PM | Link to this

Jeff Schultz,

Brooking = fraud

Period. End of discussion.

By STILL LOYAL

February 17, 2009 11:36 AM | Link to this

Cairo Is An Idiot must be a RED Neck

By Zoomie

February 17, 2009 11:38 AM | Link to this

Just catching up on my Falcons news after a long weekend out of contact. A lot has been said about Keith Brooking and not enough said about Jeff Shultz (back to that in a moment). Keith Brooking, by his own admission, doesn’t contribute at the level he once did. He seems to be signalling a willingness to play for less. I think he should be allowed to do so — both he and Lawyer Milloy can still be used in the running game, but should be pulled in obvious passing situations. If he’s willing to play for less, we should show him the same loyalty he’s shown us through some horrific times. Now, on to Jeff Shultz: it is the height of arrogance for you to insult your readership with a comment like “message board bozo.” We’re true Falcons and football fans who come here to stay abreast on what’s happening with our team and taking advantage of the opportunity to put in our two cents worth. Pay heed to history, Jeff. Folks with the “let them eat cake” attitude usually don’t fare too well in the end.

By Zoomie

February 17, 2009 11:42 AM | Link to this

Just catching up on my Falcons news after a long weekend out of contact. A lot has been said about Keith Brooking and not enough said about Jeff Shultz (back to that in a moment). Keith Brooking, by his own admission, doesn’t contribute at the level he once did. He seems to be signalling a willingness to play for less. I think he should be allowed to do so — both he and Lawyer Milloy can still be used in the running game, but should be pulled in obvious passing situations. If he’s willing to play for less, we should show him the same loyalty he’s shown us through some horrific times. Now, on to Jeff Shultz: it is the height of arrogance for you to insult your readership with a comment like “message board bozo.” We’re true Falcons and football fans who come here to stay abreast on what’s happening with our team and taking advantage of the opportunity to put in our two cents worth. Pay heed to history, Jeff. Folks with the “let them eat cake” attitude usually don’t fare too well in the end.

By zman

February 21, 2009 4:17 PM | Link to this

some of u need 2 check ur falcons history brooking held that team together through countless losing seasons.he is an above average player who leads the team in tackles almost every year.keith along with lawyer milloy and john abraham are the backbone of our defence not to mention great locker room leaders which every team needs.so the falcons need 2 give him what ever he wants becuase he has proved that he’s worth it.

By Falcons Fan

February 25, 2009 6:52 AM | Link to this

Please do the right thing and let Brooking go.

No one is going to pay him to play full time in the NFL . He served his time too long past. He made his gamillions.

Thanks Brooking

Now go fishing