Falcons

By glw

August 18, 2008 6:17 PM | Link to this

I think the Falcons are making a mistake rushing Ryan onto the field. I dont know if it means he will be the opening day starter, but its looking like it. I think Redman is the best option right now. All teams start tied for first place. Having said that, you should go with Redman, he gives the team the best chance to win. He can make the throws, and has play making ability. If the team falters and is like 1-5 or something, and the offense is struggling, then I can see putting Ryan in. I would like to see what Shockley could do also, but doesnt look like he is going to get a legitimate shot with the first team.

By ChicagoPOW

August 18, 2008 6:18 PM | Link to this

I Whole-Heartedly believe that this was not the plan after the draft, and Dimitroff said as much in interviews. Redman was the guy.

But Ryan has shown up strong. What better time to find out if he can handle it than starting him in the ‘most regular season-like’ preseason game. Looks like it’s his job to lose. GO FALCONS!

By Taylor

August 18, 2008 6:35 PM | Link to this

I don’t think Ryan is necessarily being rushed, he has looked the best of all four Quarterbacks competing. It has been said all along that Ryan will be competing for the starting spot and would be handled no differently than a veteran QB, so I’m not suprised by this at all.

By Reg L

August 18, 2008 6:36 PM | Link to this

Let’s see what we have early in the game. I say play him…make him earn that ridiculous salary. Let him get a taste of what a real NFL sack feel likes…there will be plenty. He’s a tough kid…maybe he can hang. If he gets hurt, then I can see DJ do his thing…that’s what I really want.

By DawgBoy

August 18, 2008 6:37 PM | Link to this

The signs shoW lots and lots of PAIN! You think you can just get rid of proven athletes in skill positions and just replace them with rookies and x-tra round picks…If it was that easy it would be the rule! The forecast ain`t good….

By RealPro

August 18, 2008 6:40 PM | Link to this

WOW. A pick-six INT his first start in the Georgia Dome - what a confidence builder - But we’re gonna throw him into the fire, anyway, come Week1 of Regular Season??? NFL Rule: Never allow the Media and Fans to pick your starting Quarterback! But every single week, the AJC runs another QB Poll. Right.

Joey Harrington is our most experienced Veteran, is very capable of starting behind this improved O-Line, vs his former team the Detroit Lions. Joey has beaten out Redman in camp and pre-season. Joey knows Mularkey’s Offense, has played mistake free ball, and looked good in camp. But NO-oooo the AJC “experts” were down on him beginning last year. So NOW according to the article, it appears Smith and Dimitroff will cave in to the pressure? Sure throw your prize $72M rookie to the wolves. Harrington knows all about that!!

By Myrtle Beach

August 18, 2008 6:43 PM | Link to this

If they do start the kid, he’ll get killed just like Bartkowski did. This guy may turn out to be another Manning but getting killed because your line is horrible is not the way to go. He’ll have surgery before the 6th game and cost us years of what could have been a great career just like Bartkowski. Wait till we have a real line with some experience or at least let this line jell a little before you throw him to the wolves.

By GTMan

August 18, 2008 6:50 PM | Link to this

If my math is correct, It looks like DJ won’t make the team. I say it will be Ryan, Redman and then Harrington.

By Falcon Freddie

August 18, 2008 6:53 PM | Link to this

Hey, I saw the game Saturday, Ryan looked great. On that INT for the 68 Yard TD, the receiver must have been running the wrong route:) Ryan has so much poise and he’s such a good role model. We should get him out as soon as possible. ATL fans are pretty understanding and patient with QBs. This is what people all over ATL wanted, a traditional, Milk and Apple Pie drop back, stay in the pocket, articulate and intelligent QB. Don’t worry about the INTs, and losses, at least he’ll look good on the United Way commercials. LET HIM START! I can think of 72 million reasons!

By Phillip

August 18, 2008 7:03 PM | Link to this

I understand the “concerns” about starting Matt Ryan out of the gate but think these concerns are misguided. Everyone that does not want Matt Ryan to start out of the gate cites either 1) David Carr(who lost confidence) or 2) Falcons bad offensive line. Well, first I believe Matt Ryan is more prepared mentally to be a starter in NFL than David Carr was and to the second objection, the offensive line starters have looked “decent” so far. Will Matt Ryan struggle? Probably……Peyton Manning threw 28 INT’s his first year - 28!!!! But, Peyton Manning seems to be none the worse for wear and is arguably the best QB in NFL (probably 2nd behind Brady). As long as the Falcons can reasonably protect Matt Ryan, then I think he will be a better QB in 2009 after having played in 2008 than sitting for half the season. Matt Ryan has the mental toughness and will learn and come back stronger when he makes mistakes. Plus, he is the best QB on the team RIGHT NOW and is outplaying Redman, Harrington and Shockley - its obvious!

By Phillip

August 18, 2008 7:05 PM | Link to this

I understand the “concerns” about starting Matt Ryan out of the gate but think these concerns are misguided. Everyone that does not want Matt Ryan to start out of the gate cites either 1) David Carr(who lost confidence) or 2) Falcons bad offensive line. Well, first I believe Matt Ryan is more prepared mentally to be a starter in NFL than David Carr was and to the second objection, the offensive line starters have looked “decent” so far. Will Matt Ryan struggle? Probably……Peyton Manning threw 28 INT’s his first year - 28!!!! But, Peyton Manning seems to be none the worse for wear and is arguably the best QB in NFL (probably 2nd behind Brady). As long as the Falcons can reasonably protect Matt Ryan, then I think he will be a better QB in 2009 after having played in 2008 than sitting for half the season. Matt Ryan has the mental toughness and will learn and come back stronger when he makes mistakes. Plus, he is the best QB on the team RIGHT NOW and is outplaying Redman, Harrington and Shockley - its obvious!

By Trey

August 18, 2008 7:13 PM | Link to this

Joey Harrington has had tooooo many chances in this league!!!!! We don’t need to start the season with a QB who cannot make all the throws. He holds the ball too long(which shows he has trouble reading the defense). It’s time to let guys who are ready to play-play. If Ryan has shown more in practice and in games let him play. There is no proven method as to when to start a rookie QB. If all positions were truly open to competition when camp started and Ryan has earned it. You have to play him. Do what you say you are going to do and the players on this team and around the league will take notice.

By maddoxh

August 18, 2008 7:28 PM | Link to this

I believe that Redman is the best bet to start the season. I think Matt is ready but I would not start him immediately. Left the Offensive line get a few reps in before you put in the future of the Falcons. Im still waiting to see what Shockley does when his turn comes with the first team. But right now, it looks like they dont think he has what it takes.

By T-J

August 18, 2008 7:29 PM | Link to this

I like DJ Shockley and his 5.6 QB rating….

Pathetic!

Go Falcons…

By country boy

August 18, 2008 7:35 PM | Link to this

Like many other posts I think Ryan should start for Falcons around game 3-5. I am no expert but the O line looked OK. Two nice runs by Turner and new tackle Baker handled his pass rusher well. I said in April that drafting Baker was a good move. He started 4 yrs ( I think ) at USC in a pro style offense. I still think that when season starts he is the most ready Tackle in this years draft. Not saying he will be a 10 yr. Pro Bowler but he can help most of all the tackles drafted ahead of him right now.

By JT

August 18, 2008 7:43 PM | Link to this

Its really ashame that Harrington gets a start ahead of DJ. Harrington is as slow as molasses and when the rush is on, He’s going to freak out and throw interceptions. Looks like the falcons are going to go with Harrington as the third quarterback. The falcons lied. The coach said that all quarterbacks will get a chance to start. I don’t want to believe that the falcons are racists but not giving DJ a fair chance to start with the starting unit makes you believe it. I hope DJ gets a chance to play somewhere else and let the falcons know they screwed up keeping Harrington. I cannot take you for your word and trust you anymore. I was a falcon fan but you will not get my support anymore. You will continue to be losers!!!

By Singletary

August 18, 2008 7:46 PM | Link to this

Got the first two preseason games on TiVO waiting for me, so this isn’t football analysis, more like chess/war.

I’m just skeptical that we are risking longterm injury — a proverbial $72m Matty Slice — behind an improving line that hasn’t had a chance to gel from all reports.

Yes, I’m risking the counter Rumsfeldian argument of you go to war with the Army you have not the one you want…

By Big Falcon Fan

August 18, 2008 7:50 PM | Link to this

1. Joey H. sucks and needs to be waived.
   has a history of sucking, period.

2. Redman has looked overwhelmed this pre- season. He looked the best coming in to replace Joey H. last year.

3. Sorry Dawg fan, TJ has looked like crap this summer. He needs to be cut.

4. Sign Culpepper and start him for a year and let Ryan sit and learn.

By JOe

August 18, 2008 7:54 PM | Link to this

Matty Ice?? Bwaa ha haaaa!! Come on Atlanta… that is the STUPIDIST nickname ever. It’s like your franchise WANTS to lose!!

By davonelson

August 18, 2008 8:02 PM | Link to this

It would be a shame if the Falcon leadership bows to public pressure and stats Ryan right away. If he stumbles, which he is likely to do at first it will be much more of a downer for him and the team than having him come in to replace Redman later. They should be giving Redman playing time to get ready so the team has a chance jell and possibly win. Ryan looks like the real thing which would be a shame to ruin early.

By Darrin "The Vent King"

August 18, 2008 8:06 PM | Link to this

I don’t care who starts, just cut Joey “Blowey’….I take that back- I hope Matt Ryan does well and then cut Joey “Blowey”.

By Skip Floyd

August 18, 2008 8:24 PM | Link to this

It looks like the Falcons have decided that if Ryan looks good this week against Tn., he will be the starter. This realy has not been a competion as claimed by Coach Smith, its been more of a test to see if Ryan is ready. The other three QB’s did not get much playing time with the first team. It will be interesting to see how much time DJ gets in the final game.

By Owner

August 18, 2008 8:34 PM | Link to this

Hey JOe, why don’t you take your sorry butt somewhere else. For the record, Matty Ice was the nickname given to him in college. So JOe, learn to spell and do your research before you come on here spewing your ignorance.

By Unbiased_Blogger

August 18, 2008 8:37 PM | Link to this

7-WINS ARE LOOKING PRETTY GOOD STOP YOUR CRYING ATL FANS YOU WANTED THIS TYPE OF QB EVER SINCE 2001 AND NOW YOU GOT YOUR WISH. HE NEEDS TO EARN THAT 72-MILLION AND LETS SEE HOW BAD VICK REALLY WAS.**

By Owner

August 18, 2008 8:43 PM | Link to this

7 wins is all that Vick and his $130 million got us. Did he earn it???? Ignorance is bliss on these blogs.

By Rod

August 18, 2008 8:48 PM | Link to this

If MR goes out and gets his head taken off by defensive end and we have to watch Joey we won’t watch. Keep Shockley as ryans backup.

By GT GRAD

August 18, 2008 8:51 PM | Link to this

Matt Ryan appears to be the best we have based strictly on performance. He will grow and benefit more by playing than sitting/watching. I say play him as much as possible in preaseason and get him ready for the regular season.

I wonder if Redman looked adequate/good last year because he knew Petrino’system inside and out? He has not looked very good so far in preseason.

DJ Shockley is a great person and very atheletic; I just do not think he is consistent or accurate enough to play QB in the NFL. He really has not shown much so far in the high school scrimmage or preseason games (this year or previous years).

Harrington is our second best QB and should be a lock at the 2nd string spot. Matt Ryan can learn mor from Harrignton than the other two; he has already gone through a very similar situation. I sincerely think he learned a lot from his experiences/misakes in Detroit.

By Tennesseetitanfan

August 18, 2008 9:02 PM | Link to this

Mr Ryan meet Mr Haynesworth!

By salty dawg

August 18, 2008 9:19 PM | Link to this

We should get him out as soon as possible. ATL fans are pretty understanding and patient with QBs.

Perhaps, but opposing d backs aren’t so patient. There is no reason in the world to take a $72 million gamble. The team has too many weaknesses to really compete this year, so call it what it is - a rebuilding year. Let the young guy get a year of NFL experience under his belt and the team get a little more solid instead of sending the lamb to slaughter. Harrington or Redman would make better options and probably perform better out of the gate anyway.

By STH No More

August 18, 2008 9:28 PM | Link to this

Heck yeah. Start Matty Ice! He’s supposed to be the ultra-talented, uber QB of the future, all the intangibles, game-changing phenom, right? So why all the skepticism all of a sudden? I thought he had all the tools above and beyond all the QBs for the last few years. He is so far beyond that, isn’t that what the draft analysts said? So why is there any doubt that Ryan is ready to lead the Falcons to the playoffs right now? I expect him to change the game completely. he’s that good, right? Isn’t that what we’ve been told by the AJC sportswriters and the Falcons front office? Matt is waaaaaay better than any QB in Falcons history. Anything less than the playoffs this year, and he’ll be a bust. I expect him to overcome any shortcomings on the offense. That is what is expected for an athlete of his tremendous talents. I don’t know why all of a sudden people don’t believe he can be what he has been touted as since the draft. Really perplexing why there is doubt now.

By Chuck D

August 18, 2008 9:34 PM | Link to this

Hey STD, why are you so angry all the time??

By JHD

August 18, 2008 9:38 PM | Link to this

I don’t see the reason for rushing Ryan out there. Judging from Turner’s performance the other night. Defensive coordinators are going to focus on stopping/containing him by placing 8 guys in the box and forcing Ryan beat them through the air which will probably lead to picks and/or sacks. Let a veteran QB start and see how the season progresses. If we start 0-4, 1-5, 2-6, then bring Ryan in.

By salty dawg

August 18, 2008 9:43 PM | Link to this

The falcons lied. The coach said that all quarterbacks will get a chance to start. I don’t want to believe that the falcons are racists but not giving DJ a fair chance to start with the starting unit makes you believe it.

Waahhh. They’re all racists because they didn’t let a black qb start. Oh wait, wasn’t MV7 black??? Didn’t they give him an ungodly contract to be the future of the team? Didn’t they keep playing him even after he repeatedly played sloppy and showed his a55? How does that mesh with your “Falcons are racists” theory? Is it just possible that they are looking at performance on the practice field and each qb’s time in preseason games to make that determination? No, that wouldn’t be the smart thing to do would it? I wanted DJ to come back this season and earn the spot as much as the next guy, but if he isn’t up for it, I want the guy who is. How many times can you play the damn race card?

By JR Doyle

August 18, 2008 10:04 PM | Link to this

Front office reeks signing QB for $72 million who doesn’t have arm strength to throw a 10 and out…kind of reminds me of June Jones or Bob Lee.

DJ has best arm strength but front office reeks by only playing him with the no block and no catch 4th stringers.

By Foshizzle

August 18, 2008 10:07 PM | Link to this

Redman has only thrown like 10 passes in the preseason. It’s a little nuts to say he’s looked bad or overwhelmed. He just needs more throws to get in a groove.

By Steve T

August 18, 2008 10:20 PM | Link to this

I am finished with the falcons until Blank keep his nose out of what is going on. It is his push to start Ryan. I do not like weak armed QB and Ryan does not have the strong arm, hence the int for 6. Some people say he looked good in the two minute drill. I say the colts was playing prevent defense which means Ryan could complete the underneath stuff. However, when he got in the red zone, they slammed the door. You may not believe me; I told one of my co-workers what I would do to defend against Ryan and the Colts did it to a T. Folks get used to the pick six because the colts exposed his biggest weakness. What I suspect is teams will force him to throw the deep pass.

Another thing that Ran showed in the first two games is he is SCARED. You say he was nervous, but, be an old defensive lineman, I saw feared. When he pulled out early he was scared. If you put him behind a weak O-line, he will be shelled shocked.

By L. T.

August 18, 2008 10:23 PM | Link to this

How long does one turn his or her eye’s for what is happening in the Falcon Nation… Open competition for the QB position give me a break… This team is still being mis-managed.. The speed of the game will tell the true.. Once the play start s? The Play will speak for itself everyone in God’s country will and should respond with disguise.. Defense wins Championships.. this team still miss the boat.. I have defended this team for over 40 years.. …. I will say it clearly RACISM, and STUPIDITY.. Still Clouds our Success as a Race of United PEOPLE….

By Steve T

August 18, 2008 10:31 PM | Link to this

From a coaching standpoint, Redman looks the best. He was getting good zip and touch on his passes. DJ has not been given a fair shot. He has been treated the worse. He and Red will be picked up by other teams. The Pats could really use Redman. DJ may get signed by the Colts to be Manny back up. DJ will get another shot with a team that could use a game breaking QB.

By micah

August 18, 2008 10:35 PM | Link to this

My problem with people saying Ryan has been the best QB so far is the fact that all the other QBs haven’t been afforded the same chances that he has. He hasn’t played with 3rd or 4th string players like everybody else has, but yet he’s the best QB so far? Give me a break. When All 4 QBs are given the same chance then we can make the comparisons.

By braja

August 18, 2008 10:35 PM | Link to this

Enough with DJ.He is not NFL QB.In a few days you going to se him on practice squad or been cut.I love Georgia football to but reality is on first place.I will be very sopriced if he makes teem.

By Scott

August 18, 2008 10:41 PM | Link to this

Everyone blogging here is offering an opinion about who the starter should be based on “who gives us the best chance to win” theory. Don’t waste your time!! This team is gonna win 4 to 5 games max with any of the 4 at QB.

So this season is entirely about building for the future, period. Ryan is the guy, so you have to figure out WHEN to get him in there.

Here’s how I see it: Harrington has been somewhat “showcased” in order to try to work a trade (Minnesota perhaps?) even for a late round pick - he will not be on this roster; DJ will make the team, but will be thoroughly buried on the bench as 3rd stringer (Dawg fans stop screaming that he’s not getting a shot…he’s played a grand total of ONE YEAR as a starter in the last 6 years, he’s not there yet); Redman should be the starter because he’s the most prepared; Ryan will likely start by week 3 or so.

For me, I want to see the VERY young OLine gel together a little under regular season game conditions BEFORE I trot out the $70 million man. Sorry Redman, you’re likely an expensive tackling dummy. Look at the likely starting line: Baker, Blaylock, Stepanovich, Dahl and Clabo (Less than 10 years experience COMBINED!!).

It really doesn’t matter who the QB is right now…they’re gonna RUN the ball with Turner, Norwood and Mughelli.

By John

August 18, 2008 10:45 PM | Link to this

Matt Ryan has a long way to go. I’m hopeful that he is everything that we want him to be, but he has not overly impressed this preseason. Let’s not forget that in the first game, he was basically saved by some very good work by Roddy White.

DJ Shockley, contrary to Bravia’s post, is a solid backup QB option who could develop into something more. Let’s not forget how highly regarded he was out of high school and even at points in his college career. Yes, his local status makes us all want to root for him, but is a guy with potential really any worse as a third stringer than a guy like Harrington who has had multiple chances with three different teams and failed to achieve with any.

By No Faith In Ryan??

August 18, 2008 11:19 PM | Link to this

So nobody has faith in Ryan?? I thought he was supposed to have unparalleled talent? I thought he was a unique, without equal, unmatched QB with off the chart intangibles? Now y’all acting like he’s just a regular average rookie QB. Why don’t you believe he’s the dynamic QB you said he was when he was drafted? Why don’t you believe in him anymore? He’s not like other rookie QBs! He’s supposed to be better than that according to the reasons for drafting him. He’s a phenomenal talent that is not like other rookie QBs. Now y’all scared?? Sounds like you doubt his ability to carry this team. Why?? Why don’t you believe in Matt?? Why? You can’t compare him to other rookie QBs, he is way above all that. I heard Dimitroff, or was it Blank? Well one of them said that.

By PMC

August 18, 2008 11:52 PM | Link to this

This is a great decision. He’s won the job period. He gives the falcons the best chance to win.. which says more about where the other QB’s are on this team really. If he can’t handle it. He’s not worthy of 73 Million dollars and the people that put him there are not worthy of their positions. He can do it. He’s going to be awful at times, and he’ll look better at times. But at this point with all the money invested and NOTHING else to start over him. Go for it. Prove Sam Baker can be a left tackle. Dimitroff looked at the team decided they were at least 3 years away and drafted a QB… guess what, they’ll get another one in the 3rd round or so next year for depth. This team is light years away from competing right now further than last year even so they might as well take their lumps with thier best chance to win. If it fails. It’s just another in a long line of failed Falcons draft picks. Wouldn’t be anything new. We’ve seen them come and go. I’ll be a falcons fan longer than Matt Ryan will have a career.

By drmondo

August 18, 2008 11:53 PM | Link to this

The reason Ryan is getting this start and has played more against 1st stringers could just be because he’s a rookie and the future of the team, not because he’s going to be the starter from the beginning. The coaches certainly want to see how the kid reacts to NFL level competition. Redman and Harrington have plenty of tape on them. I’m sure the coaches have a better idea how they’ll do than the rookie. Shockley has tape too and I think the fact that he’s been a 3rd stringer/ practice squad player plus the fact he hasn’t lit up opposing teams this preseason has hurt his chances. Redman is probably still the starter, with Ryan getting groomed for his eventual takeover. Unless he really goes wild this game, I still bet he’s the 2nd stringer on opening day. DJ has to really show something this game or he’ll end up on the practice squad (is he still eligible?) or cut.

By Boo Boo

August 19, 2008 12:47 AM | Link to this

I just keep thinking of how Steve Bartkowski came in number one and they threw him to the wolves, behind a poor offensive line. Bart didn’t come around until the O-line gelled into Mike Kenn, RC Thieleman, Jeff Van Note, Warren Bryant and Dave Scott (4 years after he was drafted #1).

Comparisons between Ryan and Vick cannot be made, because Vick didn’t need a line for long. Ryan is not a runner.

It makes me wonder why the power rankings still have the Falcons last in the league. Are the Falcons secretly ready to produce a line that can protect a QB and allow the backs to run for 200 yards in a real NFL game each week?

I just think that we need to make the O-line prove it can make a winner out of Chris Redmond or Joey Harrington, before we watch a franchise QB go down for the season because of the seven sacks per game, for a month of Sundays. We can go 0-4 and still have the promise of what Ryan can do, if he’s kept on the bench at the start. That’s better than 0-4 and looking at a repeat of last season, if no one can block for him.

By GHunt

August 19, 2008 12:58 AM | Link to this

Coach Smith wants to avoid a QB controversy. DJ will not be allowed to play behind the first string O-Line.

Shockley will have to wait until Mat Ryan prove he can not handle the job. 72M is too much money to pay for a clip board holder. DJ will have to wait for his break. In all likelyhood, it will come sooner rather than later.

This will be a long season for our Falcons,however the season will be lost before the owner, the GM and the coach regret their decision to start the bonus baby.

By Regal1_Got 1

August 19, 2008 1:13 AM | Link to this

I think final ticket sales before the beginning of the season will tell the tale of who actually starts. A seventy plus million dollar investment has been made. Remember, Mr. Blank is still a business man whom just happens to own a football team. Think about it.

By ROB i

August 19, 2008 1:21 AM | Link to this

I’m not really sure how many football fans out there know what they’re talking about so allow me to enlighten you!! When there is an OPEN COMPETTION it means the best person, regardless of experience will get the job. In this case that person is Matt Ryan!! He has shown the most composure he has the best numbers and most importantly he’s won the confidence of his teammates and coaches. Yes he is young and has a lot to learn but there is no doubt that he’s our best option. None of the other three quarterbacks has the ceiling he has and none have his presence or savvy! And he’s just a rook!! So what does that tell you about our other options?? He’s the guy for the job now and for the future. everyone wants to bash our offensive line but i think your going to see a DRASTIC improvement this year both in the pass protecting and the running game. Not to mention the defense is swarming to the ball and playing with more energy than i’ve seen EVER! So watch for the birds to fly higher than you think this year. 7-9 maybe 8-8!!

By Birdy

August 19, 2008 1:29 AM | Link to this

The Falcons appeare to be afraid to find out how Shockley would do with the starters for an extended period of time. They’re forced to prop up Ryan because of the cash they spent on him.

It seems as if Ryan lacks an NFL arm so that will limit his success. Have the Falcons drafted another Joey Harrington?

By Darryn

August 19, 2008 1:48 AM | Link to this

I think they should wait to start Ryan until week 3 or 4; just work him in to the actual speed of the NFL. If Ryan is the best QB in the bunch, right now Harrington is #2. DJ looks like the odd man out right now, but anything can change with 2 preseason games left.

For those who said Harrington had too many chances: this will be his 7th NFL season, and this will be his 7th head coach he will be playing for (8th if you count the 1 month he was with the lions when Marenelli was hired). It showed he has something there.

By Unbiased_Blogger

August 19, 2008 3:31 AM | Link to this

**THIS CLOWN SHOW IS MAKING VICK LOOK LIKE AN MVP :)

By kj

August 19, 2008 6:47 AM | Link to this

Hmmmm DJ huh? why? 3 coaching staffs have seen him work and not given him a chance and he could beat out David Green at UGA so why does everyone think he is the next great thing? Give it a rest the kids 6’ nothing and doesn’t have the skill set to be an NFL QB. Keep in mind he’s playing against 4th string crap too

By ray

August 19, 2008 6:56 AM | Link to this

While Ryan may not be ready to be the starter, I’m also worried about our back-ups. Shockley hasn’t looked great, but he’s also gotten limited chances. Harrington…ugh. He has confidence issues and didn’t show me anything good last year. He’s a back-up’s back-up. I don’t know about Redman. Sure missing Schaub right about now….

“This clown show is making vick look like an MVP”

It takes true skill to top some of the most idiotic things said on this blog. This statement is proof of such skill…

By marko

August 19, 2008 6:57 AM | Link to this

I’m not surprised, you don’t pay a guy seventy-two million to warm a bench. A strong running game should take some of the pressure off Ryan. I just wish he had a tight end that could actually catch a pass. It has’nt gotten much attention, but our defense could surprise a lot of people. Even without a pass rush, the secondary has looked pretty solid. I don’t worry much about preseason losses as nobody will remember these games in November. It appears to me that Smith and Co. have a plan.

By CHOP

August 19, 2008 7:21 AM | Link to this

been last QB in two games not fair put DJ with first team c what happen

By Damon

August 19, 2008 7:47 AM | Link to this

Didn’t the “Gunslinger” (Brett Favre) throw the same, exact pass in the NFC Championship versus the NYGz? Y’all act like that pass is completed 99% of the time by NFL QB’s. Matt was looking that way the entire time. A DB is supposed to jump that route.

DJ Shockley had ample chance to impress, with Game-Winning drives in both games. Except he throws a pick (with his strong arm, and all) and drops it on the carpet last week. Has anything made you think, honestly, “Hey, he needs a chance to play with the starters”? He can’t shine against trash.

By Same Ole Falcons

August 19, 2008 7:50 AM | Link to this

Hey Unbiased Blogger, last year in like week 10, On ESPN the question Chris Berman asked was “who is his team’s MVP” and without hesitation, not even a second of hesitation, you already know who Tom Jackosn named. He hadn’t stepped foot in Atlanta the whole season but it was clear to Jackson who the Falcons MVP was. Nuff said.

By bigeasy830

August 19, 2008 7:58 AM | Link to this

I do not think that Matt Ryan is ready too start the season as a starting QB in the NFL, but oh well it is what it is. The Falcons will run the ball most of the time and just have Matt Ryan manage the team and try to not put him in situations that lead to turnovers the way Pittsburg did in Big Ben’s first year. Michael Turner and Norwood both may have 1000 yards this seasons. To all you DJ haters, DJ played with 3rd and 4th stringers, no way he was going to produce playing with those stiffs. He was never given a fair shot ,but oh well it is what it is.

By NCFalconFan

August 19, 2008 7:58 AM | Link to this

Will someone please explain to me the fascination with DJ Shockly on the AJC Blog?

DJ has had opportunity to “show up” in both preseason games, could have one against the Jags, but he failed to deliver.

By RA

August 19, 2008 8:00 AM | Link to this

Damon, that’s a very cheap shot at Shockley. Every other quarterback the Falcons have including Joey Crappington has been given a shot with the first or second string offense. Shockley is out there having to make his bones with a bunch of has been’s and never will be’s. And I saw one of those interceptions you were talking about, bounced right off the man’s hands, up in the air, and then it was picked. Happened to just about every other quarterback the Falcons threw out there last week as I recall. My point is this. Shockley might have been up against trash, but it’s hard to shine when you’re floating in it. I think they should give the man his release and let him catch on with a team that’s actually going to give him a chance.

By bigeasy830

August 19, 2008 8:14 AM | Link to this

If you people think that the QB position was an open competition then you were tricked by slick Arty again. The Falcons have been better as sellsmen than as a football team since he bought the team. Matt Ryan will be the Qb, that has been the plan all along. Thats why he was given all that money. Joey, Chris and Dj never had a chance. Chris Redmond played 1 series in his only start. Joey threw the ball only 3 times and Dj played with the scrubs in the 4th quarter. Matt Ryan got the majority of snaps to get him ready for the season opener. i think most fans just wanted the Falcons to be honest about it. Everyone has been bashing MV7 because he lied. Well what about the entire organization. They have been lying to all of us for some time.

By Dave

August 19, 2008 8:15 AM | Link to this

You know I find it pretty funny how many Falcon fans buy into David Carr and Matt Ryan going into the same situation which is an absolute lie. David Carr was the first player drafted by an expansion team this team had zero talent on offense or defense. From day one Matt Ryan has a much better offensive line to help him. Matt Ryan has an excellent receiver in Roddy White. Matt Ryan has an excellent fullback to block for him in Ovie. Matt Ryan has an outstanding set of running backs in Turner and Norwood. It is almost laughable to compare what David Carr had to deal with and what Matt Ryan has at his disposal to help him. I have not even talked about the defensive side of the ball which also is vastly superior to what the Houston Texans had as an expansion team.

By jeanE

August 19, 2008 8:19 AM | Link to this

I’m not surprised at all, this is what they’ve been planning all along. They’re mind’s been made up since they drafted him. Good luck with that. I’ve seen nothing from Ryan that suggests all of this awesomeness he’s supposed to possess. And DJ is a great kid, great story, but way too raw! If Ryan went down, Joey should be running this offense. Not DJ! Let’s see Ryan start the season, any bets on how long it will be before he goes down? He’s built like a twig, puny arms and all. The defense is very worrisome, except for Abe we got nothing on that d-line. Grady can fall on someone but can’t chase. J. Anderson is absolutely pathetic, just sad that we wasted a 1st round pick on him. And if B. Finn is cut c/c we’re stuck with Joe Horn’s guaranteed salary I am so done with this team! That’s your fault McKay, yet another reason you no longer have anything to do with personnel! It is so hard to be a fan of this team.

By marko

August 19, 2008 8:26 AM | Link to this

This isn’t meant as a cheapshot at unbiased, but anybody on this planet that really thinks they’re unbiased ought to be sharing a padded cell with the guy who thinks he’s Jesus. I prefer the Falcons cheerleaders with the bigger pom poms. I’m just biased that way.

By Tito

August 19, 2008 8:37 AM | Link to this

For those b*** and moaning about starting DJ Shockley, get over it. It doesn’t matter if he is playing witht eh first team of the fifth team, Shockely is TERRIBLE.

DJ doesn’t even enter into the equation.

Wake me up when DJ Shockley’s QB rating gets out of the single digits

You dawg fans are a joke and an embarrassment to the rest of us real falcons fans.

GO FALCONS!

By some1who watches

August 19, 2008 8:49 AM | Link to this

I am speaking as a last time season ticket holder. I can see why they are pushing to start this punk, it’s all about the money they stupidly paid him. As for me I am like most other fan’s I like wins. It’s not about money or race. I truly feel that the Falcons will be big time looser’s if the think this wet behind the ears kid is our future. The last game was so boring, i rather go see high school games

By no name

August 19, 2008 9:10 AM | Link to this

Ryan is the starter?? I thought last week the coach said each QB will have a chance to play with the 1st team offense…everyone has had that chance except for Shockley and it looks like he won’t get that chance on Friday either. Shockley is not getting a fair chance…looks like they want to make the QB situation all WHITE, like the Braves!

By sickfan

August 19, 2008 9:10 AM | Link to this

NO NO NO. This is stupid falcon garbage as usual. Play Redman and if we suck let Ryan play. Redman is clearly better right now,and rookies routinely get killed and play poorly. It makes nooooo sense.

By some1who watches

August 19, 2008 9:20 AM | Link to this

well said bigeasy

By Theedge

August 19, 2008 9:21 AM | Link to this

Put the DJ crackpipe down people. His 5.6 qb rating is real and he is not an NFL QB. The guy he couldn’t beat out at UGA is not an NFL QB. He will be cut and placed on practice squad.

By M Ryan

August 19, 2008 9:23 AM | Link to this

What’s with the nickname? Why do sports people feel compelled to give jocks nicknames? It makes them and anyone else who uses those nicknames sound like I.Q. challenged idiots.

By Birdfan

August 19, 2008 9:30 AM | Link to this

Why is the decision of who plays at quarterback have to do with race? If Finneran gets cut at receiver, is that because he’s white and the majority of successful receivers in the NFL are not? No. Its because the coaches deem him not good enough to make the team and an injury risk.

Shockley played a great year at UGA his senior year, and that’s it for him. David Greene, the prize of UGA fans, is a loser on a practice squad somewhere, and DJ played 2nd fiddle to him. Turn off the TV on Sundays and stick to UGA on Saturday if your college allegiances dictate who you want to play for the Falcons, real Falcons fans are sick of hearing it.

This is unbelievable to read. May the best players play, regardless of color. The ignorance regarding that and the fact that Vick put himself in jail and out of the Falcons lineup is truly unbelievable.

By Space Mountain

August 19, 2008 9:34 AM | Link to this

It does not make a difference who the starter is. In Mularkeys offense it starts and ends with the running game. If Turner and Norwood can get a combined 150-200 yards average and the o-line does a half decent job of keeping defenders away from the quarterback the birds have a chance of winning. The quarterback will have the ability for play action and high percentage passes. If Matty Ice flat out wins the starter job then its his. From what I have seen so far none of the other qbs have outperformed him. Anyway I have more concerns on defense than offense. They definetely need to generate alot more pressure on the opposing qb than they have so far.

By michaelgee

August 19, 2008 9:41 AM | Link to this

In game 1 Shock threw the game loser into the crowded endzone on 3rd down for an INT.

In game 2 Shock had a 5.6 QB rating, pathetic by any standard. A 5.6 QB rating won’t get you a start at Slippery Rock.

Why throw away a start to a QB who has not impressed anyone since leaving Athens. DJ has had plenty of chances.

Give DJ a chance elsewhere but don’t handcuff the team who needs to be developing unity and a rythm for the opener.

Before the Colts preseason game during QB warm ups, on every throw Matt’s receivers never had to break stride to catch a pass. While DJ’s targets had to jump, stop and step back to catch DJ’s passes, some were so high over the receiver’s heads that they never even touched the ball. That tells me that DJ isn’t accurate even in practice throws. Then during the game DJ throws so hard the receivers can’t catch the ball.

I say don’t waste a start on Shockley, we need to move forward if we move at all.

By Cadman

August 19, 2008 9:42 AM | Link to this

For all the posts saying DJ has not been given a fair chance, he gets his chance to start at Baltimore. Read the article! We should have a better idea of what Ryan can do after Friday and if he should be the starter. Let’s see what he and the offensive line can do against the Titans defense. Never the less, I think Blank would like Ryan to be the starter in order to try and put more butts in the seats at the Dome. Whoever starts, I’m just ready to get the season started, get beyond last year, and show the Falcons are not the worst team in the league.

By Reality Time

August 19, 2008 9:52 AM | Link to this

Cut the racism crap. 90% of the team is black. Has it now been mandated that the Atlanta quarterback must be black also? I’m a Dawgs fan, I am a DJ Shockley fan, but he is not a starting quarterback in the NFL. Tell me another team where the 4th in depth quarterback starts a preseason game, they don’t. Get over it.

By Carlos21

August 19, 2008 9:58 AM | Link to this

I am not a UGA fan but I am a Falcons Fan. But to say that their have been an equal opporutunity at the first team among the QB’s is definte not true. So what ever the Falcons are doing is definitely not giving DJ a true shot.

By PMC

August 19, 2008 10:04 AM | Link to this

Shockley is starting the 4th preseason game with the starting offense.

He’ll get his shot people give it a rest. He’s probably going to make it to the practice squad or on someone elses team somewhere. Unfortunately just like the Florida game where he had an unfortunate knee injury the one last year really hurt him. He’ll get a shot in the 4th game to get some game tape for other teams to look at. Relax.

By toshie

August 19, 2008 10:05 AM | Link to this

Someone said these guys made Vick look like an MVP. I wouldn’t know about that you will need to contact the Federal Prison.

By reggie

August 19, 2008 10:06 AM | Link to this

I think the falcons are making a big mistake putting Matt Ryan in a starter position so soon. He has shown that the game is too fast for him right now. I think the falcons will not finish above .500 this season due to the fact the falcons organization believes that matt is going to save them some how. Dj shockley is the best bet for the falcons. And remember that Mike Vick is still on the roster.

By Troy

August 19, 2008 10:06 AM | Link to this

Let Ryan start the season. He has already shown going flashes of improvement in both games…. Granted he has made some bad decisions.. But the offense is going to be run dominant scheme if Turner and Norwood can carry the ball 30-35 times a game and control the clock than they have a chance to win against Detroit.

By 1st team defense

August 19, 2008 10:13 AM | Link to this

Well, It really doesn’t matter, the falcons will at best be 2-14. When the starting QB goes against each teams #1 defense it will be a bloodbath!

By Joe Horn

August 19, 2008 10:27 AM | Link to this

Anyone seen Mike?

By Hamp

August 19, 2008 10:30 AM | Link to this

I think in amy other ofense except jax. I would not start ryan. This offense is rookie friendly. The OL has been suprisingly good and I think the Falcons will have a good year. I am also suprised at how well the D has played, But Smitty brings a D that doesn’t need superstars his D’s are team Defense S, Jax never had superstar CB though resheen is pretty good. I am concerned with the pass rush because you can’t ask DEION to cover a guy for eight seconds so that is a concern but I am also suprised at how well Kory B is playing he has progressed every week. I was pulling for J Anderson but he looks like a bust I say move his butt into the takle rotation and let Someone else come off the edge. PLEASE BE TRUE FANS AND SUPPORT YOUR TEAM. WITH ALL OF THE YOUNG TALENT WE WILL BE ALOT BETTER NEXT YEAR BUT IF THEY COME OUT EVERY WEEK AND PLAY HARD THE SCHEDULE IS FAVORABLE AND WE WILL GET SOME WINS!!! GO FALCONS

By No Faith In Ryan

August 19, 2008 10:37 AM | Link to this

All we heard was that Matt Ryan was NFL-ready, that he played in a pro-style offense at Boston College, that he was the best of the best there ever was, and now all of a sudden its “the Falcons shouldnt rush Ryan”……..What?!?! How is it rushing Ryan when he was “NFL ready” when he was drafted. He got drafted and we in pre-season and now he’s NOT NFL Ready anymore?? If he is as good as he was proclaimed to be, then there should be no hesitation to start him. What’s the fear? Don’t you have faith in his capabilities? Did his “intangibles” disappear? He’s supposed to be better than Vick who started his second season. Well if he’s better, then he should be starting in his FIRST season. Why is there hesitation to let him prove his ability on the field? What’s the problem?

By bigeasy830

August 19, 2008 10:40 AM | Link to this

By Cadman, you must not understand the dynamics of the preseason, The starter for game 3 in your preseason schedule will be your regular season starter barring injury. Game 4 means nothing. The team just want to get out of game 4 without suffering any major injuries. Michael Turner and Norwood have looked great in the preseason, but how will they look when teams start to scheme and put 8 in the box. The Qb must be able to make a few throws. That INT by Matt rRyan was also due to lack of arm strnght by the young man. I think he will be a good NFL QB, but he is not ready to start the season. I wish they would start Redmond an let Matt sit a year and learn by watching and work on his body. I am not stupid. I know this Matt Ryan is the QB of the future for the Falcons, you do not draft him that high and then watch him waste away because some fans like myself would rather have a 7th round pick with a history of knee injuries in there. So, lets concentrate on what is best for the franchise, and that is lets not throw this young and talented QB to the wolves. I think Smith and his coaching staff will do a great job to protect the young QB, but they I also know they have to answer to someone else who is more concerned with selling the franchises image rather than winning games. Wins will put the butts in the seats. Al Davis said it perfectly, “Just win baby”.