AJC > Sports > Braves > Blog > Archives > 2008 > December > 30 > Entry
Let’s reflect on recent Braves
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Frisco, Colo. _ Mid-vacation greetings from 9,097 feet up in the Rockies, where the snow is deep, the slopes terrific and the sun was bright in a cloudless sky this afternoon at Breckenridge.
The wrists and the rest of my body have survived several days of snowboarding, first at Steamboat Springs (unbelievable powder after 22 inches of snow fell in 24 hours) and then at A-Basin, with our last day on the board set for tomorrow at Copper Mountain.
The only casualty so far was the poor woman I barreled over while out of control on a blue-black run on our first day at Steamboat, (she spoke Spanish, no English, but the universal language of moaning as she pointed to her left leg was enough for us to summon the ski patrol to help her out.)
Anyway, I swore I wouldn’t file anything while on vacation this time, but I just couldn’t bear to see the blog dormant any longer. So I decided to post a quickie that I think might draw an opinion or two from the majority of you out there.
(Oh, before I forget, if you’re ever out this way and you’re a pancake nut like me, you can’t do any better than Winona’s in Steamboat Springs or Log Cabin in Frisco, both restaurants located on the little main streets in those respective towns. The cinnamon rolls at Winona’s are also ridiculously ginormous and delicious.)
(Wait, gotta make one other restaurant recommendation — Mazzola’s Majestic Italian Diner in Steamboat. You don’t expect to find such a great Italian joint in the middle of a relatively isolated Colorado town known for ski slopes and ranches.)
(Then there’s the hot springs at Strawberry Park, where you can step from a 108-degree natural pool into the 45-degree stream that runs alongside it. Yowza… But that’s another story. By the way, triple-paragraph parenthesis, a new record.)
OK, so back to the blog, which we’re going to write while we listen to some old Neil Young with a fire blazing here in the condo. (Neil, Bon Iver, James McMurtry and Uncle Tupelo have provided much of our soundtrack out here. Some stuff just sounds particularly good in the mountains, as does watching “The Shining” on DVD last night, with “Fargo” on tap for tonight.)
I started covering the Braves in 2002, and it’s not been the best seven-year period in recent Braves history, to say the least. They lost in the first round of the playoffs each of the first four seasons I covered them, and they haven’t participated in the postseason since.
But despite the relatively mediocre overall results in that span, we’ve seen some pretty remarkable performances, for and against the Braves. Randy Johnson’s perfect game at Turner Field, Chipper Jones’ 400th homer and, of course, John Smoltz’s 3,000th strikeout and 200th win come to mind.
There were plenty of others, both individual-game performances and seasonal work.
There was Chipper’s three-homer game at RFK Stadium in 2006, Willie Harris’ 6-for-6, two-triple, six-RBI game against the Cardinals in 2007, Arizona pitcher Micah Owings’ 4-for-5, two-homer, six-RBI game at Turner Field, and this past season there was Mark Kotsay’s cycle against the Cubs (only the fifth Brave to hit for the cycle) and Jeff Francoeur’s two-homer, seven-RBI game at the new D.C. ballpark (before his season turned sour).
There were a bunch of dominant pitching performances by Smoltz and Tim Hudson in recent years, Smoltz doing it both as a closer and starter. For seasonal superlatives, there was Smoltz’s 55 saves in 2003, and his 211 strikeouts in 232 innings in 2006.
Among hitters, there was Andruw Jones’ 51-homer, 128-RBI season in 2005, when he was MVP runner-up, and his 41-homer, 129-RBI season in 2006. And who can forget Javy Lopez’s 2003 season, in which the catcher hit .328 43 homers and 109 RBI with a 1.065 OPS, all while skipping batting practice for most of the season because one day during an early slump he hit some soft-tossed baseballs in the indoor batting cage and had a huge day, so he decided to keep that routine.
There was Chipper’s batting title (.364, with a .470 OBP) at age 36 in 2008, following a 2007 season when he hit .337 with 42 doubles, 29 homers, 102 RBI and a .425 OBP to finish sixth in the MVP voting.
We can’t forget Francoeur’s auspicious 2005 arrival, when he hit .300 with 20 doubles, 14 homers, 45 homers (and only 11 walks) in 70 games and made the cover of Sports Illustrated (“The Natural”).
And let’s not overlook the general excellence of young Brian McCann, who is easy to take for granted instead of being appreciated as one of the best hitting catchers to come along in at least a couple of generations.
McCann has a .297 career average and .859 OPS, along with two Silver Slugger awards and three All-Star recognition in all three full seasons in the bigs. He has 80 doubles in the past two seasons, and he’s averaged nearly 22 homers and more than 90 RBI in his three full seasons. Heap is very good, folks.
OK, that’s just the stuff I can think of off the top of my head, since I didn’t bring a media guide or anything else with me on vacation (stats are available at a million places online, of course.)
I know I’ve missed some individual and team moments, some great performances, etc. So let’s hear from you folks which ones stand out for you, which were your favorites, which ones you think were underappreciated or overrated or whatever, be they from the ones I mentioned or others.
Yes, I know you’re all waiting for the Braves to make a move or two to bolster this team for 2009, but can’t tell you that I’m hearing anything right now, simply because I’ve been out of the loop for a week now and not making any calls. Things have been awful slow for most teams this past week or so anyway.
But since I’m off through Jan. 3, there should be something significant for Carroll to cover before then. Something big usually happens when she’s got the team, but it’s been a while and she’s overdue for a Braves headline-making story.
In the meantime, let’s hear your thoughts on what’s stood out these past five or six years. Like I said, as bad as it’s been at times, there have certainly been some memorable performances, too.
Oh, and everybody have a safe and happy New Year. Talk to ya soon.
“PARIS” by James McMurtry
When you land in Paris and they wave you right through
Though your passport picture, doesn’t look much like you
They don’t look at your luggage, they don’t look at your face
‘Cause you pose no danger and you’re such a disgrace
You go out walking down the Champs D’Elysees
And your spirits are sinking, it can happen that way
When you do your best Bogart and they don’t seem to care
They walk right down the sidewalk like you ain’t even there
Lookin’ in the wrong direction
Seein’ it from the inside out
The way you couldn’t wait for Christmas
The way you used to twist and shout
It must be the jet lag, you hope it’ll pass
You check your reflection in the store front glass
Kinda gray at the temples, kinda goes with the hat
Kinda round in the middle but it ain’t even that
It’s nothing you can see, it’s nothing you can smell
But you pose no danger and man they can tell
Lookin’ in the wrong direction
Seein’ it from the inside out
The way you couldn’t wait for Christmas
The way you used to twist and shout
You see it in the mirror in the morning
You feel it in the middle of the night
Sleeping with your eyes wide open
Waking with the shades drawn tight




DEL.ICIO.US
Comments
By JJMac
December 30, 2008 9:02 PM | Link to this
First?
By j
December 30, 2008 9:05 PM | Link to this
1?
By Herman
December 30, 2008 9:06 PM | Link to this
Is this a baseball blog?
By ô¿ô
December 30, 2008 9:10 PM | Link to this
DOB - please tell me the braves are going to bid against the mets for Lowe - have you heard anything??
By Herman
December 30, 2008 9:11 PM | Link to this
can somebody tell me how to find and log on to the ajc garden club blog?
By Sub-Prae
December 30, 2008 9:16 PM | Link to this
Definately loved the Willie Harris duo of leaping catches on the track at Shea. A little overrated but a heck of an exciting momment when he stole that potential homer from Delgado.
The Teixeira acquisition. Lots of false hope, but it sure was fun. He brought so much excitement.
Mike Hampton’s 7 inning effort against San Fran this summer. I was so happy for the guy.
Gary Sheffield’s 2003 season. Mr. Ego, but god he was a great Brave.
I had a lot of fun with KJ’s hit streak this second half.
Frenchy’s walkoff GS off of Cordero in ‘06! That was amazing!
Charlie Mo’s debut. Exciting….just wish that feeling could have lasted a little longer. lol
Beating the Redsox in Fenway 14-0 in ‘07. Smoltz dominating, KJ a single away from the cycle. GREAT game.
Just a few off my head. Have a great new year DOB!
By Thrillhouse44
December 30, 2008 9:17 PM | Link to this
Thanks for the blog, DOB. Make the most of your vacation.
The Baby Braves, although a cheesy nickname, provided an exciting year.
By T to the D
December 30, 2008 9:18 PM | Link to this
Particular performanaces would be too baffling DOB…How ‘bout the emergance of our catcher and the vacuum that was Chuckie James…
By T to the D
December 30, 2008 9:22 PM | Link to this
Herman,
Go to the top of the page where it says “search, and type in “tool”
By Jim
December 30, 2008 9:23 PM | Link to this
Dave:
Thanks for checking-in and giving all of us a place to comment.
Did you see that Mets have reportedly offered Lowe $36 MM for 3 yrs. Sounds like that B’s have that much in their budget and perhaps a bit more - say $40MM for same term.
Please continue to be careful out there.
By VaBravesfan
December 30, 2008 9:23 PM | Link to this
I live in Virginia and only get to attend one series a year. Two best memories: In 2004 I saw Chipper hit 4 homeruns in a 3 game series against the Cardinals. In 2006 I saw Francouer throw Luis Gonzales out at the plate twice in the same game. Cool stuff.
By Steve from OH
December 30, 2008 9:30 PM | Link to this
DOB, thanks for the new blog.
It seems the Mets have offered Lowe 3/36….it seems like now might be a good time to snag Lowe on a relative bargain. We could easily offer more money per year or more years and not damage our long-term prospects very severely if the deal doesn’t work out.
By Herman
December 30, 2008 9:35 PM | Link to this
thanks T to the D but I tried that and all I got was a page with a Lowes tools ad and some other non garden related ads and articles about cell phones in prisons used as tools or weapons. that’s strange. maybe I did something wrong. I’ll try again. thanks again.
By Tomas
December 30, 2008 9:42 PM | Link to this
3years 36million for Lowe what a bargain. I was afraid he wanted 5yrs 80milliom. Wren outbid the Mets, go 3yrs 45 million if necessary.
By David O'Brien
December 30, 2008 9:45 PM | Link to this
Steve and dude with odd screen name: Haven’t made any calls while on vacation, but I’d not be surprised if the Braves get in on Lowe. I really see no reason why they shouldn’t or wouldn’t, unless they’ve got another pitcher in mind who’s a mystery at this point.
By Keith Moon Lives
December 30, 2008 9:49 PM | Link to this
DUNN,DUNN,DUNN !
By Barley Blashmore
December 30, 2008 9:50 PM | Link to this
UUUGH… the mind picture of you nude in a hot spring with other toadies. Yeech!
By Billy Pilgrim
December 30, 2008 9:53 PM | Link to this
In re:Lowe
I don’t see how Wren could see that what the Mets have offered and not get in on Lowe. At that price, or something close to it, Wren could easily fill the LF void and add 2 significant starting pitchers instead of just one. I’d like to see the team sign Kawakami or perhaps take a flyer on Sheets depending on the status of Smoltz & Glavine.
By Billy Pilgrim
December 30, 2008 9:57 PM | Link to this
Thanks for the new blog DOB. You deserve more than whatever you’re getting paid, and we Braves fans are fortunate to have someone as devoted as you are covering our team
By Steve from OH
December 30, 2008 10:00 PM | Link to this
DOB, thanks. Dude, kick back and relax with some Coltrane or Miles Davis instead of making business calls lol.
By How bout that!!!
December 30, 2008 10:01 PM | Link to this
Peavy Negotiations back on!!!!!!!!!!!
NY Post reports that Peavy’s agent said, and I quote, “The Braves are the most likely destination for Jake. We think that something is close. Their last offer was very close to what we wanted. Without getting into specific player’s…..we wouldn’t want anyone thinking we give up confidence….we like that young catcher they have. I think the original package plus him and that young righty in the rotation should get it done. I’m just waiting on Frank at this point. We’re confident he’ll make the right decision for both Peavy and our organization.”
By Desibrave
December 30, 2008 10:03 PM | Link to this
Frank Wren will not make an offer before checking with Lowe the following 1) If he is willing to come to Atlanta? 2) If his wife ok to fly? 3) He and his agent will not keep shopping after getting the fax copy of the Terms
By Random
December 30, 2008 10:04 PM | Link to this
Speaking of Willie Haeeis, this is a reply to like the 969th comment from the last blog (R.I.P.) —
jimmy joe bob:
“You all can laugh, even O’Brien said Willie Harris was a low-risk/ high-reward type guy when the Braves signed him…. if memory serves me right … WILLIE HARRIS turned out to be a starting LF for us. Great.”
&
“The same thing was said about “Wee” Willie Harris - “a spring-trainee invitee to compete for a backupposition; you know the “low-risk high-reward” type of guy. If my memory serves me right (in honor of Iron Chef Kawakami), “Wee Willie Harris was our STARTING leftfielder that year.”
Perhaps it would interest you to know that, after playing 134 games (103 in the outfield) and (31 in the infield) for the Nationals last season, Harris was judged to be the Number One 2008 free agent pick-up by Tim Dierkes of MLB TradeRumors.com.
Dierkes compared Harris’ 2008 salary ($850,000) to his actual value ($15.4 million, based on Harris’ “Value Wins” as calculated by FanGraphs).
By Tomahawkin
December 30, 2008 10:12 PM | Link to this
The Willie Catch at Shea was Dope…
How about 2007 in August the Braves overcame a 8-2 deficit to the Phillies and came back over the last three innings (because of Brett Myers inability to get anyone out) 9-8
That game was funny watching the Phillies fans Vent in digust in the Philly.com/phillies Forum… Too bad the phillies have had the last laugh over the last 2 years…
Also Gotta throw in the B-Macc First Post-season 3-Run Bomb against Roger Clemens in 2005…
Not to Forget the 18 Inning Playoff game in Houston in 2005 In which We Blew many-a-chance to win a late inning dramatic playoff game…
By BravesFanInRockies
December 30, 2008 10:13 PM | Link to this
How bout that
Link, please. Otherwise I’m calling BS.
By 18 Wheels of Love
December 30, 2008 10:17 PM | Link to this
I hope you are spinning this Uncle Tupelo song…one of my fav’s. Have a great trip!
Chickamauga
You’d never leave on your own
Where you’re from and where you’re going
I know these things like I know you hate me now
Catch yourself in mid-air thinking
Your dreams can never be bought
I couldn’t help you then and I guess I can’t help you now
When jousting is for pleasure
Pleasure is way out of hand
The time is right for getting out while we still can
Chickamauga’s where I’ve been
Solitude is where I’m bound
I don’t ever wanna taste these tears again
I don’t ever wanna taste these tears again
Appalachian, so patient
The lessons we’ve traveled
As soon as we’re out we’re kicking our way back in
Fighting fire with unlit matches
From our respective trenches
No authority can clean up this mess we’re in
A miracle might point the way
To solutions we’re after
And avert our chronic impending disaster
Chickamauga’s where I’ve been
Solitude is where I’m bound
I don’t ever wanna taste these tears again
By Random
December 30, 2008 10:18 PM | Link to this
In re: Lowe
How quickly they (Billy Pilgrim, Tomas, Steve from OH, Jim) forget — it takes two to tango. If Lowe don’t want to come here, he won’t come here.
PS: “HaRRis”.
By 18 Wheels of Love
December 30, 2008 10:21 PM | Link to this
Oh, almost forgot.
Favorite from 2008…
It was when Bobby moved that pitcher from the mound to LF for one batter and then moved him back to pitch again. It didn’t work but I liked what Bobby did in that position. For the life of me I can’t remember the players involved.
By BravesFanInRockies
December 30, 2008 10:34 PM | Link to this
18 Wheels,
Wasn’t that Mahay and Bennett? Or Mahay and Soriano?
By BravoMan
December 30, 2008 10:34 PM | Link to this
Wren should think about offering Lowe a competitive offer like 3 years $45 million. If he was willing to go 5 years $80 million for Burnett then this makes all the since in the world. If we were to lose on the war for Lowe im sure that would be a confidence downer but then just go out and sign Kawakami and Smoltz/Glavine. O and as for LF, make the trade for Swisher. It’ll be a perfect fit with his versatility and power.
By Billy Pilgrim
December 30, 2008 10:38 PM | Link to this
Axelrod would never say “we like that young catcher they have”. He doesn’t care who the Padres like and would never refer to them as “we”.
By Atown
December 30, 2008 10:41 PM | Link to this
Without a doubt a very memorable moment(s) was the ‘BabyBraves’ of 05. It just seemed like they kept coming up and coming up. A truly unique and gratifying season after everyone counted us out. I long for those winning days. DOB, thanks for checking in from John Denver land. Look forward to hearing from you when you get back. Cheers!
By kirkinga
December 30, 2008 10:46 PM | Link to this
If the Braves are interested in Lowe, and I hope they are, I don’t want to hear about it.
Given how the offseason has turned out so far, I think it would be better to just find out after both parties have signed on the dotted line.
It does seem from reading ESPN, that the Mets are bidding against themselves at this point, but the BoSox signing Penny was a big surprise.
If Ohman doesn’t sign Bimel would be an excellent replacement.
I think we’ll see a streak of signings here in the next week or two and the Braves will pick up some nice pieces at sensible prices.
By Desibrave
December 30, 2008 10:55 PM | Link to this
Sign Smoltz for a 5Mil + incentives
Get Manny for 1 year 25mil, (give him a hope that Yankees will free up some money next year and sign him for 2010 onwards)
Here is our lineup..,
Anderson Blanco Chipper Manny McCann Francouer KJ Esco
With Manny hitting after him Chipper will once again hit .400 if not .450 this time around…,
Get the speedy guys Anderson/blanco + Chipper on base when Manny is at bat .., If they walk Manny intentionally then McCann (a .300 hitter) will hit bases loaded situation and not Francouer unlike in 2008
Manny will give a 50+ HR, 150+ RBI year for sure..,
Give it a shot in Bobby’s last year..,
If that doesn’t work then give a nice farewell to Bobby get Ned Yost to succeed and start fresh. We have ton of talent in 2010.
Hudson Jurgens Hansen Morton JoJo/Locke will give us a great pitching lineup in 2010..,
What do you say Guys?
By Sub-Prae
December 30, 2008 10:57 PM | Link to this
That Peavy post is BS. “Young Catcher”? Oh I guess that means Tyler Flowers…poor Axlerod. He’s been in a coma for a few weeks? lol
Another awesome moment was September 11th, 2005 at RFK. We lost the lead late, but immediately following Chipper hits a three run jack, and then Andruw goes back-to-back with him on the first pitch he sees. Great memory.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 30, 2008 11:00 PM | Link to this
Did alot of scouring and found absolutely nothing that would indicate the Braves/Peavy talks are back on. In fact, if the talks were to be started back up, it would have to be without Escobar’s inclusion. Back when they talked trade before, there were a few good shortstops on the market that the Braves could have gone after. Now, if Escobar were traded, we would be hurting up the middle, so forget that. And here’s another idea. Does anyone think that we the Braves give a shot at signing Manny Ramirez? Normally, I would shy away from spending that much money on one player. But, if you get the Manny that has something to prove to everyone, he would defintely solve our outfield power problem and give us a legit cleanup hitter. And he just might put out for Bobby Cox.
By I start forrest fires
December 30, 2008 11:01 PM | Link to this
Thanks for the new blog!
Does anyone else get the feeling the Braves aren’t going to make any big moves this year?
Unless they make a blockbuster trade for someone like Brandon Webb then this offseason has been a failure.
The Braves current roster couldn’t compete in a 12 year old school girl soft ball leauge.
I*ts sad to see how far the Braves have fallen. Maybe we will compete again in 2020.
By Sub-Prae
December 30, 2008 11:06 PM | Link to this
DOB, That 2 homer 7 RBI game was in Washington for Frenchy.
By geauxbraves2000
December 30, 2008 11:06 PM | Link to this
The Slide.
Geaux Braves!!
By Eric from MO
December 30, 2008 11:08 PM | Link to this
My favorite moment in the past 6 years was probably the year Smoltz set the N.L. record for saves. I know every night I would watch til the 8th or 9th inning and just get pumped up when Smoltz came in. I wouldnt sit down the whole time.
My worse moment in the past 6 years was when TBS didnt continue their contract with the Braves. I think Im going to cough up the money this year so I can see all the games. OK, I dont know much about MLB and they way they have it set up to watch your team’s games. What channel does someone out of the Atlanta area have to purchase to see the games.
By Sub-Prae
December 30, 2008 11:11 PM | Link to this
I start forrest fires:
Dude seriously, your optimism is killing me.
By Sub-Prae
December 30, 2008 11:15 PM | Link to this
Oh yes! Another great moment was when Smoltz flirted with that NO-NO in ‘07.
Nothing really all that special, but for fans like me it was a rush. How speacial would it be for Smoltz to have a no hitter under his belt? It was fun.
By Eric from MO
December 30, 2008 11:15 PM | Link to this
I have been saying all off-season the Braves should go after Manny and with all of our other deals falling through it only makes more sense. Forget the ace, just sign Manny. He wins where ever he goes. Two years at 50 million. I dont think a one year deal mentioned earlier would do it.
By Desibrave
December 30, 2008 11:16 PM | Link to this
DOB Reflecting on Braves 2008 with a What If Analysis
1) What if Smoltz didn’t have the shoulder issues and won 18games? 2) What if Glavine kept his “never been on DL tag intact” and won 15 games ? 3) What if Hudson didn’t need a TJ and ended up with 18wins 4) What if we didn’t have to trade Teix 5) What if Chipper hit .400 through out the season 6) What if Soriano’s arm was ok and save a few of those 1 run games? 7) and lastly Francouer hit .300 in Bases loaded situation instead of .180 or something that he ended up with having?
It would have been a fantastic year for sports in ATL ., With Falcons reaching Playoffs and Hawks 10games above .500..,
By Jerald Holcombe
December 30, 2008 11:16 PM | Link to this
I remember a few years back at the tail end of the string of division titles and most of the bloggers were b*** and moaning about how they were tired of the Braves failing in the first round of the playoffs. My thoughts were that at least we kept putting ourselves in a position to win. Now, we are less than a .500 team and 2009 doesn’t offer any hope of being better. How many of you realize how spoiled you had gotten? I’m not being defeatist, but something huge would have to happen to get us out of 3rd or most likely 4th place.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 30, 2008 11:22 PM | Link to this
Eric from MO
Not sure if it was supposed to work out that way, but last season I subscribed to MLB.TV Mosaic and didn’t have one blackout of Atlanta games, even though I should have.
By Kentavo
December 30, 2008 11:27 PM | Link to this
Hey Keith Moon Lives, were you jealous to see Pete and Rog honored by the Kennedy Center tonight on CBS?
By Jerald Holcombe
December 30, 2008 11:28 PM | Link to this
Personally, I think Manny might jump at 3 years $65 million. Nobody else is even coming close to those numbers. The Dodgers pulled their 2 year- $45 million deal off the table and it hasn’t been put back. And no other team seems to be trying to sign him.
By bravesfaninmetsland
December 30, 2008 11:28 PM | Link to this
Well there you have it.. This bad streak we’ve been on hasn’t been beacuse of aging pitchers, or injuries, or underperforming outfielders… The downward spiral started because DOB started covering the team. In my best Oberman voice “How Dare You Sir?”
Hahaha or maybe it was all the other stuff. I still have hope. Thanks for the great blogs DOB happy New Year all!
By Henry
December 30, 2008 11:30 PM | Link to this
Best moment in recent years not already recounted above: Kyle Davies’s debut at Fenway.
I agree with kirkinga, I hope the Braves are bidding for Lowe, and I hope Wren has learned his lesson about pursuing these things so publicly. He’s looked really bad this offseason because we knew when he got shot down. I’m sure Schuerholz got shot down plenty of times, too, but he was smart enough to keep it out of the public eye. Not to make your job harder, DOB, but it’s really not in the team’s interest for the whole world to know what they’re thinking all the time.
Having said that, thanks for all your good work these last couple of years on the blog.
By Eric from MO
December 30, 2008 11:31 PM | Link to this
Jerald Holcombe you are exactly right. I remember almost half of them were saying it would be better for us to miss the playoffs for a year or two, never really understood that one. Now that we have missed the playoffs for only three years the world is ending. Alot of you say you would rather be the Marlins, well the Marlins missed the playoffs for 5 years between their titles and they have now missed the playoffs for 5 years since their last one. Most of you are about to die from suffering of missing the playoffs for 3 years, how could you possible survive 5 years.
By kirkinga
December 30, 2008 11:40 PM | Link to this
Orlando Cabrera is still available at SS, but I also doubt the Peavy trade will be revisited.
Looks like the Braves will sign the best option remaining after the Mets are done selecting who they want.
By KC
December 30, 2008 11:40 PM | Link to this
Well, word is that Lowe is seeking 5 years 90 million (18 million per)… and the Mets have offered 3 years 36 million.
I would be surprised if Boras even returns their calls until they indicate a willingness to significantly improve their offer. That said, Boras may not get the money he’s looking for, as he accustom to.
The Mets offer is likely just an entry offer. They’re most likely willing pay in the neighborhood of 15 mill per year (instead of the 12 they offered), and may be willing to add a 4th year if that would get it done.
The Braves can certainly make the same offer, and they should!! The Braves can at least afford to make an offer of 3 years - 45 mill, with a vesting option for a fourth year.
Lowe / Jurrjens / Vazquez / Smoltz / Hanson… could be a pretty darn good rotation.
By Desibrave
December 30, 2008 11:47 PM | Link to this
**To sign Best #1 FA Pitcher available - $161 million to sign Best available 1B FA - $180 million to sign Best #2 FA Pitcher - $82 million
Having David O’Brien reporting Braves - PRICELESS**
By Jerald Holcombe
December 30, 2008 11:49 PM | Link to this
I remember back in 1991, I had a lot of debates with my old military buddy who lives in Minnesota and is a Twins fan. He would give me a rash of crap about the two titles the Twins won in 1987 and 1991 and that was okay. But, he was still giving me hell several years later even though the Twins quickly went back to being doormats and the Braves were several years into their streak. I asked him then if those two world titles kept him warm at night. The same could be said of the Marlins, who would win and then dismatle the team because they couldn’t afford to pay the players. Fact is, we had a chance every year to play into October and that is what I miss. Being all but eliminated with a month to go in the season leaves a taste like Fido’s a$$ in your mouth. That’s not acceptable to me.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 30, 2008 11:58 PM | Link to this
With the economy the way it is, Lowe won’t come close to $18 mil per year. I think I heard where the Mets may be offering $45mil for 3 years. If that is so, bet on the Mets getting him because nobody else will give him that much, including the Braves. I would like to see the Braves go after Ben Sheets and offer him a multi-year deal of 4 years with only the first and maybe the second year incentive laden based on innings pitched. If Sheets could just get over the hump and stay healthy, he would be a great pitcher. Might be worth the chance.
By kirkinga
December 31, 2008 12:21 AM | Link to this
Mets offer Lowe 3 years $36 million, or about 1/3 of what he was seeking in an overall amount.
Do the Braves offer a 4th year? Boras says other teams interested, the Phillies are one but don’t they already have 5 starters? Maybe the Yankees are interested as a back up plan should Pettite not sign.And are the Dodgers playing this like they played Furcal, just waiting to swoop in at the last minute?
By richbrave
December 31, 2008 12:37 AM | Link to this
DAVE:
Whatever you’re paid it ain’t enough. Above and beyond.
LOWE, JURJENS, VASQUEZ - has a nice ring to it.
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 12:38 AM | Link to this
Guess everyone is asleep…guess I will do same. See yall in the morning.
By RJ- California
December 31, 2008 12:43 AM | Link to this
Julio Franco! It was truly amazing to watch him play during his 2 stints with the Braves (2001-2005, 2007). He is one of my all-time favorites (right up there with Smoltzy and Chipper), and I sure do miss the guy. He is the all-time hits leader among Dominican-born players, FYI…that’s impressive.
By daven-Brave
December 31, 2008 1:02 AM | Link to this
Someone please explain to me why we have not done j-#$@% since the JV deal? I do not want to hear how the yanks out-bid us,the Dodgers out-smarted us etc.. Something is not right w/the front office because Wren and the Braves supposedly have the money. Wren obviously does not have the respect that trader -J had. With Bobby not sure how much longer he is going to be around. This is more and more starting to sound like the mid 80’s braves…….My first braves game was a 1971 doubleheader against the Giants as a 5 yr old..My aunt used to be one of the candy-striped shorts ball-girls by the “old picnic tables” in the mid-70’s. So what i am trying to say is. I am not a “drive by fan of the 90’s”. Bandwagon crew who are the first to complain and jump ship at the first sign of the Braves having issues………. I just pray we do not resemble anything like we did in the 80’s or mid 70’s….Young then and could take it. To much of a fan now and my innocense has surpassed me with cynicisim
By uga-brave
December 31, 2008 1:13 AM | Link to this
DOB,
i just got back from killington. never been much of a snowboarder. like i said before you left, it can be hard on your wrists unless you really know how to roll into the mountain when you fall.
with all the braves injuries last year, the last thing we need is the crusading everdayman to snap a wrist and be on the I.R.
sounds like you having a great recharge the batteries trip.
nothing better then watching the snow fall in front of the fire after a day on the slopes. a good glass of scotch or wine aint bad after dinner either. selah.
By Chop Chop
December 31, 2008 1:16 AM | Link to this
I don’t have any favorite on-the-field moments from the last few seasons. It’s been like watching someone slowly bleed their life down a drain, man.
Have a happy freakin’ new year, DOB.
(Fake depressive mood aside, I’ll go with Willie Harris’s 6-for-6. Kinda fun watching a scrub go off on someone for an amazing day. Willie’s managed to carve out something for himself with the Nats. He’s a good guy and deserves the success.)
By uga-brave
December 31, 2008 1:41 AM | Link to this
desi-brave,
with all due respect to your what if post.
if my aunt had, well you know she would be my uncle.
DOB, according to sources the cubs are about to move marquis to colorado for vizquiano. the cubs will also send the rocks $5 million.
they then will move dero the hero (mark derosa ) for prospects, thus freeing up enough money to take on JAKE PEAVY.
time to face the facts, peavy never wanted to come to atlanta.
By Nick
December 31, 2008 1:44 AM | Link to this
I think that sometime between the 4th and the middle of the month , we will see most of the signing happen for all teams. Everyone seems to be trying to outwait each other so as to avoid overbidding. Bargain shoppers on ebay al ltrying to snipe without paying too much.
Love to see us throw a 3 yr $45 mill with a vesting option at Lowe. But, I don’t see it happening…
By A-ville Ranger
December 31, 2008 1:47 AM | Link to this
DOB,you reminded me of the hot springs pool in Ouray Colorado’(Galt’s Gulch for yo Ayn Rand fans ,it was her model for the sitting for ‘Atlas Shrugged).The spring is too hot so on one end of the pool the spring is fenced,on the other end a stream feeds directly into the pool.
I used to go there about once a week back in the 90s when I lived in Western Colorado.It was amazing in the winter.You can get so close to the spring you almost boil or move farther away for cooler water.I’ve been in it while it snowed (it’s uncovered) and it was a very spiritual experience….Also I was banging a massage therapist who worked there.
By uga-brave
December 31, 2008 2:06 AM | Link to this
chop chop,
the funny thing about willie harris’s 6-6 is he did half of it with tim hudson’s bat.
pretty sure he picked up the wrong bat in the rack and kept going.
actually the scary part is willie had a .760 ops with 13 dingers in 370 at bats last season with the nationals.
francoeur had a .650 ops with 11 dingers in 600 at bats.
cant make that kind of stuff up, well at least jeff promised that will not happen again, right?
well that is what at least he told furman bisher.
By Murph
December 31, 2008 2:25 AM | Link to this
Another look back at a disappointing season only further highlights the frustration of this sad, sorry offseason.
Money to spend, prospects to trade, and the only thing the Braves have to show is a new #3 starter. No rumors of anything being in the works, no aces or big outfield bats worth pursuing on the free agent market… going to be a long 2009 Braves fans.
At this point I’d rather see the team save the $40+ million, lower ticket prices, and play the youngsters. Worked for teams like the Marlins and Rays in the past, might work for us.
By Bravo Nam
December 31, 2008 2:54 AM | Link to this
“…but the universal language of moaning…” Sounds like it’s more than just snow you’re enjoying DOB ;)
Thanks for your commitment to the blog…going above and beyond the call of duty by writing during your break!
By semiballcoach
December 31, 2008 7:09 AM | Link to this
lowe for 36 million——the yankees will jump in and drive the price up
By 6-4-3
December 31, 2008 7:13 AM | Link to this
I just saw a trade rumor on a CBS blog in which we would trade Mike Gonzalez and Kelly Johnson to the Angels for Willits, Kendrick and Adenhart. Has anyone else heard about this? Does it have any validity?
Not sure how I feel about it if it were true.
By raymond
December 31, 2008 7:33 AM | Link to this
this article was a waste of time. I can’t believe they pay you to do this, and stop with the stupid song lyrics.
By O'brien
December 31, 2008 8:13 AM | Link to this
We offered 5 years, $80 million to AJ, who had injury concerns. Surely we will get in on the Lowe sweepstakes (3 years, $45 million, 4th year option maybe). Plus it would be nice to see another team lose out on a free agent because of the Braves.
And that still leaves enough money (at least $13 million ) to sign a LF (Dunn, Abreu, Burrell).
By flange1
December 31, 2008 8:26 AM | Link to this
Morning all,
The day just seems so much better when we have a blog to read????
Here is to hoping the Braves get in on D Lowe!
I agree with uga-brave, Peavy is going to the Cubs. It will just take awhile..
HAPPY NEW YEAR to all!
By Chief Nock A Homa
December 31, 2008 8:37 AM | Link to this
DOB,
Thanks for the blog…
When it appears that we could make a run at Ben Sheets on the cheap, why would Wren not take a chance on a one or two year incentive laden deal??
If we make a run at Lowe, as well, we might end up sitting in a pretty good spot if Sheets doesn’t fall apart…
Wouldn’t you agree??
Any thoughts on Schultz’ idea of bringing Andruw back?? To me, it sounds crazy, but it might not be a bad idea either if the Dodgers are going to eat his salary…
Tomahawkin’ Back to the Top!
By Don't Trade Franceour, Sheesh
December 31, 2008 8:43 AM | Link to this
The Braves need to go after Lowe, if only to prevent him from getting a red carpet to the Mets!
Bringing Andruw back wouldn’t be a bad idea…it would be the worst idea.
By Chief Nock A Homa
December 31, 2008 8:51 AM | Link to this
Agreed - keeps Lowe from the Mets if nothing else…
Same idea with Sheets… He kills us every year… It’s worth the small price just to keep him from getting at us a few times a year…
I guess Frenchy will bounce back??
Andruw off the bench is the worst idea??
By getnathan
December 31, 2008 9:04 AM | Link to this
Would Braves consider Manny Ramirez? I mean they could sign him to keep the seat warm for Jason Heyward for 2 years. He could bat cleanup, and Chipper would have a HUGE year. Makes sense?
By jonathan davidoff
December 31, 2008 9:10 AM | Link to this
For $5mil, I would take Andruw and hope he rebounds. Cannot be any worse than what we had last year.
By Random
December 31, 2008 9:11 AM | Link to this
Yeah, the Braves should sign Manny Ramirez to a two-year contract to ensure that Bobby Cox has no regrets about retiring at the end of 2009.
By Efrim
December 31, 2008 9:23 AM | Link to this
There has to be a reason that the Braves have little interest in Lowe. My guess is that they a) Don’t want to be used to drive up the price for a team that Derek actually wants to play for, and b) the Braves might have already heard from Lowe that his first choice to to play for a contender.
Now, some may say “well, adding Lowe will make us a contender”. Right, but my guess is that baseball players don’t look at it like that. They see that the Braves won 72 games last year and have the Phillies and Mets in their division.
That 3 year 36 million dollar offer was the Mets initial offer. They’ll raise it, at some point. I think he’ll end up signing for 3 years and 45 million with a vesting option that is easily attainable. Yankees and Red Sox could get involved, but with the Red Sox signing Penny, that seems less likely. The Yankees could sign him, but I still believe they will ink Pettitte at some point.
By BreckVirgin
December 31, 2008 9:25 AM | Link to this
DOB,
Thoughts on places to stay in Breckenridge? I am going for the first time in February and need some ideas.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 9:35 AM | Link to this
What’s the big deal with keeping Lowe from signing with the Mets? Last I heard, the Phils are the world champs with a really good shot at getting to the playoffs again. If the Braves aren’t gonna do diddly squat to improve enough in an effort to overtake the Phils, then I’ve gotta root for the Mets to do it. I know, it sounds blasphemous to root for the Mets, but I can’t stand the Phillies even more. If we are to go after Lowe, it won’t be to keep him from the Mets, it would be to improve the Braves. As for Peavy, I honestly hope that he does go to the Cubs. It’ll be the last you’ll ever hear of his chances to win another Cy Young. And in an effort to keep the ball from going yard all the time, he may wind up putting a little more torque on his arm and throw his delivery out of whack, or simply blow his arm out, which is gonna happen sooner or later anyway. All in all, I would like to see Lowe or Sheets, but I would much rather see Smoltz return and pitch well. I would also like to see Hanson get his chance. Lastly, Campillo deserves a chance because he pitched well last year. We have the arms to have a reasonable rotation, but we have no power in our offense. We should consider Manny. And I wouldn’t be opposed to getting Andruw back if the Dodgers eat some of his contract. BUT, in no way, form, or fashion would I wanna see that huge clod Adam Dunn in left field for the Braves. He’s got to be the worst outfielder in the game. Between the balls he can’t get to and all the multitude of strikeouts, there simply isn’t an up side to Adam Dunn. At least Andruw can get you an out defensively.
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 9:36 AM | Link to this
Chief Nock a Homa Andruw is a horrible idea. Even the dodgers do pay his contract we would still have to give up something for a .200 hitter. Why would you want a .200 hitter who falls down and strikes out. If you try to claim to get him for late innings defense, did you watch him any last year? Dude is terrible at defense. Even though Blance only batted .250 last year, that is still better. Also, that he bring speed and is still young. Bringing back Andruw would be stupid. Let the Mets have him.
By the way I was probably one of the biggest Andruw supporters when he was here. I dont know how many times I got ripped on this blog for trying to say that he will turn it around and his defense will make up for it. I was one who thought he would go down as the greatest CF of all-time. Sadly, I was wrong. He is just old, not by age, but you watch him and he already looks like Willie Mays at the end of his career. One year may be a fluke, 2 years isnt.
By 18 Wheels of Love
December 31, 2008 9:37 AM | Link to this
Ahhh, reminiscing….
The Little River Band (Graham Goble)
Friday night, it was late, I was walking you home We got down to the gate and I was dreaming of the night Would it turn out right How to tell you girl I wanna build my world around you Tell you that it’s true I wanna make you understand I’m talkin’ about a lifetime plan
That’s the way it began, we were hand in hand Glenn Miller’s Band was better than before We yelled and screamed for more And the Porter tunes (Night and Day) Made us dance across the room It ended all too soon And on the way back home I promised you’d never be alone
Hurry, don’t be late, I can hardly wait I said to myself when we’re old We’ll go dancing in the dark Walking through the park and reminiscing
(Instrumental break)
Friday night, it was late, I was walking you home We got down to the gate and I was dreaming of the night Would it turn out right Now as the years roll on Each time we hear our favorite song The memories come along Older times we’re missing Spending the hours reminiscing
Hurry, don’t be late, I can hardly wait I said to myself when we’re old We’ll go dancing in the dark Walking through the park and reminiscing
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 9:40 AM | Link to this
Am I the only one here that gets driven up the wall by all the non-baseball talk? Geeze dude, you want advice on vacationing? Try a travel agent. Sorry, but that’s the way I see it.
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 9:42 AM | Link to this
jonathan davidoff ANDRUW IS WORSE!!! He couldnt even hit .200 last year a year after batting .220. Dude cant even put the ball in play! All he can do is swing, fall down, and strike out. Why would you give up 5mill when we have youngsters who are already better. By the way they are better defensively too! Andruw is just old.
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 9:52 AM | Link to this
Jerald Holcombe Im sorry but Andruw cant get you an out defensively anymore. As sad as it is to say, Dunn may be better defensively than Andruw.(I hate Dunn by the way) He is just washed up. Go watch some early Dodger games and you will know what Im talking about. He cant even play defense anymore.
Now Im with you on Manny. I have been saying it all off-season. If the Braves want to get back to the post-season sign Manny. He can single handedly beat down the Mets and Phillies. Dude wins wherever he goes. I dont get why people say that the Braves would regret it. Yeah he does stupid things but he is a nice guy (at least seems like it). He is just a big kid. None of his teammates ripped him when he was there and making them win. Besides Braves have had knuckleheads before like Gary Sheffield and Sheffield was considered a far worse teammate than Manny and isnt even close in talent. Manny could go down as the greatest right-handed hitter of all-time.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 9:53 AM | Link to this
Same thing goes for the song lyrics. There’s gotta be a blog for crap like that.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 9:54 AM | Link to this
I think all of the Andruw basing should stop. Have you ever had a bad year or two in you life? Even the last year with the Braves he had 94 RBI’s. How many Braves did that last year? He will hit the big numbers again I just hope its not against the Braves in our on division.
By Lew
December 31, 2008 10:03 AM | Link to this
Jerald-No, it”s you and three others. Get over it. That’s how we do things here and it ain’t going to change. Heard any good music lately? Where do YOU get the best BBQ? Seen any good flicks? My wife and I watched The Illusionist , with Edward Norton last night. Excellent movie. You should check it out sometime.
DOB-Glad someone is having fun with snow-seems all I ever do is pay someone to move it somewhere else.
Two things I doubt anyone will mention-I saw Tom Glavine throw a complete game 7 hit shut out against the Expos in the first game I ever saw in Montreal. I also saw Marcus Giles hit four doubles in an Expos game. Those were high points for me. Also saw Klesko hit two HR in a game-then he had an appendicitis.
I’ve been pretty calm with all of the Non-deals made by the Braves so far. However, if they don’t get off their Assorted gluteus maximii and make a competitive offer for Lowe, then I think I’ll be close to getting upset. I also wonder, considering the price paid, why they didn’t make some kind of play for Brad Penny. For $5-8 mil, the Dude would have been a great signing.
By Efrim
December 31, 2008 10:06 AM | Link to this
To add to my last post, I can’t believe that the Mets are having all of these things fall their way. If they sign Lowe for anything less than 4 years and 60 million, than yes, that is considered falling their way.
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 10:06 AM | Link to this
Austin did you watch any games that Andruw was here in his last season??? Everytime he came to bat he had a least one runner, normally two. If batted halfway decent like .250(not even halfway decent) he could easily had 150 rbis. Also there is a difference between having a down year or two and just being washed up.
By Brad
December 31, 2008 10:08 AM | Link to this
DOB - Winona’s is great. One of the only places to find sweet tea on the western slope. You should give the Butterhorn in Frisco a try as well for breakfast or lunch. Pretty delicious (great pasta salad) although could be really crowded. Giampetro’s in Breck is another liitle Italian place that is ridiculously good for being in a ski town. Lived in Summit for a little while, but moved back to Athens. Man I miss that place.
By Don
December 31, 2008 10:08 AM | Link to this
Surely the Bravis will not PANIC and (1) give big bucks and long years to mediocre players - better off to keep the money and play the young players, (2) give Smoltz (in fortys, 5 significant arm operations, only 1 good year in recent years) or Glavin (also in forty’s, signifcant arm injory, ineffective even before injury) anything but a low base salry (say 1 million) plus incentives, sign either Burrell or Dunn (high K’s, low BA) just because they hit a few HR, sign any injury prone pitcher with the record of our PC. To even consider Andruw is terrible — even at his best was one of the most overrated offensive players in baseball history - was not clutch - much of HR and RBI production in menaingless situations - and now is fat Albert is no longer even good defensively. How could we possible keep our PC when 4 out of 5 of projected starters and almost all of bull pen went down with serious injuries. Also kept TP when show little effectivenss in working with hitters (could be lack of backing by Cox). And above all, keeping Cox makes everything else meaningless - one of all time worst offensive managers in baseball.
By Chief Nock A Homa
December 31, 2008 10:15 AM | Link to this
Eric from MO:
Sounds like you loved Andruw and now he dumped you, and you’re an ex out to rip him apart… You’re up watching him play for the Dodgers??? Those are pretty late nights….
I’m not a big Andruw guy, just saying it could make some sense…
And, from what I’ve read, it wouldn’t be a 5 mil investment… I just read where the Dodgers seem to be willing to eat up to 20 million,leaving about 2 for the team taking him on…
Maybe coming back would be what he needed to get rejuvenated… I mean just a couple of years ago he was killing the ball and playing solid defense…
By StingerSplash
December 31, 2008 10:18 AM | Link to this
Seeing B. Lamar Bonds in person two years ago as he and his giant head and licked bat (thought that only happened on Cheshire Bridge Road) hit two gargantuan bombs, Andruw — before the weight (ahem) of a new contract wore him down — cranked out two mammoth homers and Shea Hillenbrand hit four frozen ropes, going 4-for-5, and the Braves literally outslugged the Gigantes.
By 18 Wheels of Love
December 31, 2008 10:20 AM | Link to this
Hey Gerald, there is a blog for that kind of stuff and you are in it. If you haven’t noticed, we talk basball, BBQ, music and such in here. Maybe if you listened to some Cash, Uncle Tupelo, McMurty, ate some vinegar based BBQ, you might get it.
By Herman
December 31, 2008 10:23 AM | Link to this
ha!!!!! it took some doing but I finally figured it out. T of D was pulling my leg by telling me to type “tool” into the search bar to find ajc’s gardening blog. i tried several times but kept coming up with Lowes and tool stories. very funny but I since found another garden blog and related subjects on ajc but now this one looks like more fun.
maybe somebody here knows do any of the braves players enjoy gardening?
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 10:27 AM | Link to this
No Chief you are completly wrong. I wished Andruw the best of luck, pretty sure i posted it on here. The Braves didnt offer him a contract at the end of the year, it was his only choice.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 10:30 AM | Link to this
Eric from MO- Yes I watched Andrew and I will admit he had alot of chances to do better, but how many people really hit 150 RBI’s. If he would just hit 25 homeruns it would be better than all three of our current outfielders. He’s only 31 and has alot of time left in the majors.Somebody is going to get a DEAL!
By bill
December 31, 2008 10:31 AM | Link to this
One thing is for sure.When you spend alot of time talking about individual accomplishments,it usally means the team is not worth talking about.
By Random
December 31, 2008 10:35 AM | Link to this
Jerald Holcombe: Am I the only one here that gets driven up the wall by all the non-baseball talk?”*
Not by a long shot, but it’s no use to complain.
You’ll be shouted down by those who apparently would prefer to complain about the blog crashing under too many comments.
It’s ironic to consider how many of those “too many comments” are what we would consider superfluously “non-baseball”.
By Bravesfan
December 31, 2008 10:37 AM | Link to this
Ok, here we are at the beginning of the new year and we have traded for Javier Vazquez, signed some back up catcher named Voss, re-signed Greg Norton (WOW), lost out of Peavy, Burnett, & Furcal…GREEEEAAAAATTT!!!!!!! I stated several months ago that the perception of our $40 mill to spend was just that…perception. I was and still am concerned that we are not going to spend our money & take the “we don’t want to just throw money around” approach. I believe that will be the excuse when we don’t sign any player that will help us, and we will start dumping our only stars (Chipper, Smoltz). I can see a “youth movement” that is “two years away” from development.
By jbutler
December 31, 2008 10:38 AM | Link to this
DOB Forget baseball…more importantly before you flee Summit- I recommend Swan Mountain Inn…scrumptious food up against the fireplace- little pricey, but what the heck isn’t up there? Did you hit Palavicino at A-Basin? I’ve had many a yard sale on that run..enjoy!!
By Lew
December 31, 2008 10:40 AM | Link to this
Herman-I don’t know, but Smoltz used to do lawn mower commercials.
By Chief Nock A Homa
December 31, 2008 10:40 AM | Link to this
Eric…
But now you don’t even want to consider having him back?? Even for 2 mil and some nobody minor leaguer in exchange?? It just seems worth the gamble….
I’m with LEW: Why in the world did we not make a run at Brad Penny with the deal he took??? That would have been worth a look, too…
DOB: Why are we so adamant not to work towards a Manny signing?? Bobby, Chpper, Smoltzie, et al have always been able to manage the odd personalities… I don’t care for Manny personally, and I’m sure several of the guys in the locker room probably feel the same, but if it puts us in the chase, isn’t it worth it??
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 10:41 AM | Link to this
Austin he had the worse batting average with RISP. If any decent hitter had the oppurtunities that AJ had they would of had 150 rbis. Yeah he is only 31 but it is a very old 31. His body is broken down.
By AGTfan
December 31, 2008 10:46 AM | Link to this
DOB One of my favorite times in the last so many years was when I discovered this blog. I really do think you’re one of the best writers covering baseball today and we’ve been fortunate to have you cover the Braves. This blog has an awfull lot of great contributors (including a few Mets Trolls) and a few total idiots. I won’t name any names either way. I’m sure that I, personally have fallen into the total idiot category more than I’ve made it into the great contributor one. Regardless, reading this blog has been one of my favorite pastimes this last year and has helped to ease my homesickness up here in Illinois. I look forward to another year of following the blog and the Braves even if it turns out to be a year to let the young players find their way.
A parting gift to you is a musician to check out. There’s a guy named Zach Williams living in Brooklyn now but originally from Acworth. Based on what I’ve seen of your tastes, I think you’ll like him. Check out [zachwilliams.com].
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 10:46 AM | Link to this
Jerald, I agree Im not a fan of non baseball stuff, but some on here are and there is actually no rule against it. Acually DOB kind of encourages it with the song lyrics at the beganing of every blog. So just do what i do, when I see a post like that I quickly stop reading that post and move on.
By ncscoots
December 31, 2008 10:50 AM | Link to this
Am I the only one here that gets driven up the wall by all the non-baseball talk? Geeze dude, you want advice on vacationing? Try a travel agent. Sorry, but that’s the way I see it.
Newbie. Post a link to the RROE for this guy.
A sad fact that some come here and are disappointed at non-baseball posts. But this isn’t a baseball blog…it’s a blog with a unifying theme of baseball. Big difference.
I wonder if the folks who complain about the non-baseball content think that the forum went along for oh-so-many years discussing nothing but baseball and, suddenly, upon their arrival, became something else. Or would that be a simply too narcissistic viewpoint for believeability?
By Herman
December 31, 2008 10:53 AM | Link to this
Random and Jerald maybe I picked the wrong time to join a baseball blog with my gardening and blogging interest. sorry I’ll keep it just about baseball.
will the Atlanta braves win it all this year? go braves!!!!
By hoot
December 31, 2008 10:56 AM | Link to this
The Braves will need a capable left hander in the rotation to compete in the NL east. Three possibilities: Oliver Perez, Jonathan Sanchez, Andy Petitte (maybe also Eric Bedard- gamble). One of these… maybe even two, and a right handed lf bat would take the Braves into the spring in pretty good shape; especially if the bat is above average.
By Chief Nock A Homa
December 31, 2008 11:02 AM | Link to this
ncscoots:
If you look at the top of the blog, I think you’ll see where it reads “BRAVES BLOG”…
Unless “Braves” has suddenly turned into a singular word to mean “blog with a unifying theme of baseball”, you have the sad fact correct, but are the one that has the misunderstanding…
Don’t get me wrong - I don’t hate the other interests on the blog, but let’s get it right… This is a beat blog about the Atlanta Braves….
By Bring Me the Head of Deforest Kelley
December 31, 2008 11:04 AM | Link to this
A slingshot around the sun and you’re in timewarp. Dammit I’m no rocket scientist, but I did happen to find a copy of this same blog from NEXT year at the unclaimed inbox next to the transporter pad…
Let’s reflect on the 2009 Braves:
-first 100 loss season since 1990.
-contended all year with Nationals for Last Place in the NL East.
-18 different pitchers used in starting rotation. Only one (Jair Jurjjens) put together a winning record and an ERA under 4.00.
-Javier Vasquez pitched 4 complete games in 2009, to highlight a season in which he went 4-13 with an ERA of 5.15.
-Francouer improves his batting average… to .245.
-Bobby Cox quoted as saying “I’m very proud of my players and what they accomplished this year. We just missed a few breaks along the way. A ball drops here or there, or we get a couple more calls at the plate, and we’d be playing in October.”
-Frank Wren indicates the Braves are only a player or two away from fielding a competitive team. “The problem is”, as he describes it “only half of our roster is composed of native Georgians. We really need a couple more Georgia-born players on our staff, because they feel more comfortable playing at home.” Trade rumors circulate that Kyle Davies is on Wren’s wishlist for 2010 because “Kyle pitched a lot innings with the Royals in 2009, and we need that kind of workhorse in our rotation.”
-Schureholz makes statements regarding three other talent agencies about their unethical, immoral, childish behavior during negotiations and issues ultimatums that they shape up, or they risk not dealing with the Braves in the future. The agencies don’t bother to respond.
-Tom Glavine still on the comeback trail for 2010.
By Random
December 31, 2008 11:06 AM | Link to this
Don: “Smoltz (in fortys, 5 significant arm operations, only 1 good year in recent years)”
Are you still spreadin’ your ignorant effin’ lies?
Let me repeat my initial rebuttal:
Smoltz has had good to great seasons three out of the last four — 2005, 2006 & 2007:
667.1 IP, 577 Ks, 135 uiBBs, 3.22 ERA, 1.14 uiWHIP.
He logged over 200 IP each year, with ERAs between 3.00 and 3.50 and WHIPs between 1.15 and 1.20.
(I’ll let other denizens address your slanderous slurs against the manager and coaches.)
Y.A.I.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 11:13 AM | Link to this
We all talk about how much we need pitching, but has anyone really looked at last year stats. We only had two guys with 85, and 87 rbis and we didn’t even have a guy with 30 homeruns. We lost over 25 games by 1 run. Our pitchers would have looked alot better with some run support. WE NEED A BIG BAT!!!!!!
By Steve from OH
December 31, 2008 11:13 AM | Link to this
Chief NAH: DOB is in charge of the blog, and what he says goes. Deal with it. If he wants to have music/food/whatever discussions, it’s his perogative. Doesn’t matter what he titles the blog, if he decides to have a music discussion, well, that’s just tough tomatoes. If you can’t deal with it, post on Bradley’s blog or something.
By nolie
December 31, 2008 11:14 AM | Link to this
Same thing goes for the song lyrics. There’s gotta be a blog for crap like that. Jerald
the scroll-wheel is your friend dude.
By Payroll
December 31, 2008 11:15 AM | Link to this
Can someone explain something to me?
Why aren’t we going after Derek Lowe or any other free agent?
As it stands right now:
Hudson - 13 million
Chipper - 11 million
Vasquez - 11.5 million
Soriano - 6.1 million
McCann - 3.5 million
Ross - 1.5 million
Norton - 800 K
That is 47.4 million in 7 players for 2009.
Here is the arbitration eligible guys with projected 2009 salaries:
Gonzalez - 2.4 million in 2008 (4 million in 2009)
Kotchman - 1.45 million in 2008 (2.5 million in 2009)
Infante - 1.4 million in 2008 (2 million in 2009)
Diaz - 1.22 million in 2008 (1.8 million in 2009)
Francoeur - 460 K in 2008 (1.5 million in 2009)
Johnson - 430 K in 2008 (2 million in 2009)
That is 13.8 million for 6 arb. eligible players. Let’s assume it may jump up to 15-17 million as my estimations were just that, guesses.
61.2 million for 13 players. Let’s call it 63 million. Then there are 12 players making close to the league minimum. Let’s give those players an average of 450 K. So add on 5.4 million to 63 million.
68.4 million so far for the Braves 2009 payroll. Round it up to 70 million. The payroll last year, according to Cots was 102 million. They aren’t taking into account Kotsay and Hampton’s contracts(7 million of Hampton was already paid for and 4 million of Kotsay was being paid for by the A’s). So our payroll was really 91.4 million. Round up to 92.
So we have roughly 22 million annually to spend on additions to this team. Add to it the Braves said that they would increase payroll, so figure another 8 million to get the number to 30 million annually.
70 million currently, with room for a 100 million dollar payroll.
But wait, part of Tim Hudson’s contract may be paid for by insurance. So add on like 8-10 million of potential spending there too.
Like I said to open this post, the Braves have the money to go after Lowe. They also have the money to sign Adam Dunn and Oliver Perez too.
Lowe - 15 m per year
Dunn - 13 m per year
Perez - 12 m per year
That is 40 million and a 110 million dollar payroll for 2009. Minus Hudson’s insurance money and you have a 100 million dollar payroll.
Should the Braves be cautious because these contracts will have to be paid in 2010 and beyond? Sure. But Wren said they plan on competing in 2009. If he wasn’t serious about that, than he should of never said it. OR the Braves are feeling the economic crunch and have re-assessed their stance on 2009….
PAYROLL
By flange1
December 31, 2008 11:16 AM | Link to this
Efrim and Lew,
I have been very pro- Frank Wren this off season even with the unfortunate turn of events we have seen on at least 3 deals.
I think he tried hard on Furcal, AJ and Peavy and things just didn’t go our way.
But I am little miffed why we were not in on Brad Penny.
I will be more miffed and a bit frustrated if the Braves are not at least to a small extent in on D Lowe if nothing more than to drive the price up for the Mets.
The teams goal was to upgrade their pitching and with the best of the best either already signed or not available by trade, the Braves MUST look into the remaining FA or look to the trade market.
Maybe we can work another trade for a decent pitcher.
The other option is for FW to come out and tell us the team has changed its prognosis for 2009, and instead of contending, will be looking to gain experience for some of the younger players.
I don’t want to bash FW, but I am ready for him to make a move even if the Braves are shot down again.
Thoughts?
By Lew
December 31, 2008 11:16 AM | Link to this
Random-Too many comments are non baseball? You mean like your 10:35 post to Jerald?
Bravesfan-How much younger should we get, do you think? Are you aware that unless we do sign Glavine or Smoltz that we have only two players (Chipper and Norton) who are over 31 years old? That there are only nine players on the 40 man roster over 30? Are you aware that as currently constituted (without Shafer, even) that the average age of the Braves is 26.8 years old?
Are you aware that other than Chipper, Soriano and Vasquez have the only large contracts, hence there ain’t anyone to dump for salary purposes?
Dude, if you’re really that big a Braves fan, you should know this. We’re already a young team with damn few large salries.
By AGTfan
December 31, 2008 11:18 AM | Link to this
I wonder if the folks who complain about the non-baseball content think that the forum went along for oh-so-many years discussing nothing but baseball and, suddenly, upon their arrival, became something else. Or would that be a simply too narcissistic viewpoint for believeability?
Scoots,
Are you implying that this blog existed before I got here? I can’t believe that.
It’s the flavor added by the non-baseball, non-Braves stuff that makes this one of the best sports blogs anywhere. I would guess that it’s fairly successful with the DOB format, since it gets about a gazillion hits a day. And that’s just me checking to what’s new.
By Eware
December 31, 2008 11:23 AM | Link to this
DOB, I was in Copper for the past week. I couldn’t believe how wide open the slopes were. People at the resort we thanking us for coming out this year, blaming their poor numbers on the economy.
For those that enjoy skiing/snowboarding - now is the perfect time to go. My family and I never waited in line at the lifts, which is unbelievable.
I hope you had as much fun as we did, DOB.
By Eric from MO
December 31, 2008 11:23 AM | Link to this
Chief 2 million is to much. I dont want him taking up a roster spot. Why do you think the Dodgers want to get rid o him.
By Steve from OH
December 31, 2008 11:26 AM | Link to this
flange, I’m not too miffed about Penny (injury and conditioning were concerns, I believe), but I’m with you on Lowe. I hope FW is secretly bidding on him. I’m reading that the Mets probably won’t go higher than 3/40, in which case, we’d better be able to step in and outbid them. Lowe, to me, is the best available option right now, and we’ve got a chance to get him at a relative bargain.
If we let the Mets sign him at 3/36-40, then I will call that a bad move by FW.
By Efrim
December 31, 2008 11:29 AM | Link to this
Flange1
But I am little miffed why we were not in on Brad Penny.
We are probably going to ink John Smoltz, so that is already one injury risk that we are going to give guaranteed money to. I’m hoping Wren can get more of a sure thing than Brad Penny. And Penny, again, cited his desire to play for a contender.
By Chief Nock A Homa
December 31, 2008 11:32 AM | Link to this
Steve from OH:
Thanks for the tip on DOB being in charge - didn’t realize that… Thought it just randomly popped up form time to time…
Actually, it’s a property of the AJC if you want to get technical about it…
BTW… Please make sure to FULLY read someone’s post before lighting them up…
If you read what I wrote, you would see that I didn’t say anything that would cause a normal poster to “go off” on my post…
As a matter of fact, here it is again so you can read it clearly this time:
“Don’t get me wrong - I don’t hate the other interests on the blog, but let’s get it right… This is a beat blog about the Atlanta Braves….”
You can see, again, that it’s not that I hate the other interests, but the FACT is, that it is a BRAVES beat blog…
That’s all that I pointed out…
BTW….. DOB doesn’t name the blog - the AJC does… I’m sure if DOB wanted to name the blog something like “Braves, Music, Food and More,” the AJC would NOT approve it… You think??? I mean, seriously, get real….
By sam
December 31, 2008 11:32 AM | Link to this
This has been a wierd offseason for the Braves but I’m still optimistic that something is happening behind the scenes. Is there going to be a Braves Fanfest this year? Oh and Happy New Year Stamper!
By Random
December 31, 2008 11:34 AM | Link to this
In the meantime, let’s hear your thoughts on what’s stood out these past five or six years.
Apr 25, 2008, at NY Mets, James Jurrjens’ first road win for the Braves, where he totally lost his composure in the face of several questionable ball-strike calls, and then totally regained it, throwing 5 perfect innings out of 6.
First and scond innings — three up, three down.
Third inning — Anderson and Casanova single, Pelfrey and Reyes ground out.
Two outs, runners at second and third.
Castillo walks.
Wright walks, Anderson scores.
Beltran walks, Casanova scores.
Church walks, Castillo scores.
Pagan strikes out.
Fourth, fifth, sixth innings — three up, three down.
Quite a demonstration of regaining control of self and game for a rookie, and a good preview of his future.
By Chief Nock A Homa
December 31, 2008 11:35 AM | Link to this
Eric:
Your position is understood… I think 2 mill is worth the leap for the possibility, but, who knows…
But, I have to say that I don’t understand your comment “Why do you think the Dodgers want to get rid of him?”
With that kind of logic, no team would ever sign a player that another team is trying to trade after having a bad year…. You know what I mean??
By Efrim
December 31, 2008 11:36 AM | Link to this
Payroll
Not bad. But I think that point about having to pay these guys past 2009 is important. Yes, Wren said he wanted to compete. But he never said he wanted to rid the Braves of any payroll flexibility past 2009 as players like Johnson, Escobar, Kotchman, McCann and Francoeur get paid more.
All that said, the Braves should still be able to sign(or trade for) two players to 8 digit deals while still being able to manage the payroll from 2010 and beyond.
By Original Jon
December 31, 2008 11:40 AM | Link to this
How does 3 years of losing, after 14 straight Division Titles make a non contender? Im sick and tired of hearing how players want to play for a contender but dont want to play for us. We would be a contender if that player would just sign or get traded to us. But they dont see it that way I guess, they just look at the past few years and think, ‘Oh heck, Atlanta isnt going to win anything anytime soon, so I will sign elsewhere, even if it means taking less money to do so’. All the while forgetting the fact that we have a good team, just had too many injuries to our starting staff. Heck, were not the Pirates or Royals, so why diss us?
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 11:48 AM | Link to this
Efrim,
Happy New Year.
You also have to wonder if Liberty doesn’t want to sign many guys to long-term deals because they’re going to sell as soon as they’ve gotten all the tax benefits they can realize from buying the Braves. They’ll want to keep the farm system strong because that offers the next owner a lot of value down the road. But you don’t want a lot of money tied up in lengthy contracts for older players. (Which is why the Cubs might be a tough sell, especially in the current economy.)
When might Liberty decide to pull the trigger — 2010, 2011?
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 11:50 AM | Link to this
Sorry Lew, I completely didn’t realize that this is the AJC Sports page and that music, vacationing spots, and all other non-sports stuff belongs here. Please forgive me.
By O'brien
December 31, 2008 11:54 AM | Link to this
Are the Braves not interested in Manny because of his defensive shortcomings, because of his attitude, or because he’s a Boras guy, or all of the above?
I agree he has issues, but he puts up numbers every year. And if its only a 2 year deal, I think Chipper, Cox and Smoltz could keep him under control.
And since the Dodgers are exploring Dunn, I think Manny could be bought for cheap because there is no market for him. Manny will be playing with a chip on his shoulder, trying to prove to the rest of the league that they were wrong for not giving him the contract he wants.
And then we could always trade him next season if he’s not working out. Plus a 2 year deal, 3rd year team option ($16-$20 mil per) would not block our prospects.
And Manny would help make the Braves relevant again. Nobody talks about the Braves anymore (3 straight years without a playoff appearance). It’s all about the Mets, Phillies, Yankees, Red Sox etc.
Comments?
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 11:56 AM | Link to this
Jerald Holcombe,
C’mon, it’s New Year’s Eve. Where’s the holiday spirit?
By The Artist Formerly Known as Too Hot For Teacher
December 31, 2008 11:58 AM | Link to this
I really liked the year before all the baby braves hit. i really liked the energy that Charles Thomas brought - he ended up being a one hit wonder but it was fun. Wasn’t it skip that called our OF the “kudzu crew” with JD Drew, Andrew, and Chucky T in the OF - there weren’t many balls that hit the OF grass the second half of that year.
I personally will also never forget the Randy Johnson game. I watched it sitting on the coach in the Coca Cola sky field and when Eddie Perez walked out to pinch hit for Hampton (who was dominant that game as well) the guy sitting near me wen ballastic - “Eddie Perez! Eddie Pereze! It’s like we’re not even trying!” He may have been the only person in the stadium NOT pulling for Randy.
I also remember when Smoltz nailed a game down in late Sept one year to pass the Phillies for first place in the East and he went nuts and the stadium went nuts, and the state of GA collectively gave the state of Philadelphia the finger.
By Random
December 31, 2008 12:01 PM | Link to this
Lew: “Too many comments are non baseball? You mean like your 10:35 post to Jerald?”
Nope — that was on the meta-baseball level. (And you may consider this one meta-meta-baseball.)
8-)
PS: Braves should sign Smoltz; Lowe; Kawakami; and either Abreu, Dunn or Bradley. (Back to non-non-baseball.)
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 12:04 PM | Link to this
Pardon me all, I didn’t mean to start anything. I just voiced an opinion that this is a baseball blog and should be just that. By all means, continue sloppin it up. Maybe that’s why so many of the knowledgeable guys that used to be here decided to leave.
By Jack G
December 31, 2008 12:06 PM | Link to this
Does not matter who the braves sign, as long as Cox and his coaches are on the field, results will be the same in 09 as they were in 08.
Cox and coaches are one of the reasons that all the free agents are not signing with the Braves—-No one wants to play for an over the hill has been manager
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 12:07 PM | Link to this
Folks, Manny has more than “issues.” He quit on the Red Sox during the middle of the summer. He decided when he wanted to play and when he didn’t. When the Sox unloaded him, they paid his entire salary. They essentially gave him away just to get rid of him, fully realizing that Ortiz might not get healthy and by doing that they may be walking away from a deep run in the playoffs.
I understand that he may be one of the half-dozen greatest right handed hitters since WWII, if not ever. But he’s a cancer on the clubhouse. Gary Sheffield’s an Eagle Scout compared to Manny.
You want T.O.-style drama with the Braves? Sign Manny. Not. going. to. happen.
By flange1
December 31, 2008 12:10 PM | Link to this
CNOH and Jerald,
Guys you are fighting a losing battle. Lots of us have been here for years and the theme to this blog has always been the same.
It is not going to change because newbies like you guys want it to change.
If you don’t like it, either do like Nolie said and scroll right on by it, or just find another blog you like better.
Sorry if you are offended by this, but that is the way it is because DOB said so……
By The Goche
December 31, 2008 12:13 PM | Link to this
No DOB is not paid to write on music or BBQ or places to eat when on vacation.
But he is also not paid to write 2 or 3 blogs a week, when nothing is happening in the first place. In fact, most beat writers either don’t blog at all, or do it only very summarily to appease their bosses.
He is certainly not paid to write a blog when he is literally on vacation. Especially since literally nothing is currently happening. I mean, Wren is on vacation too, so even if anything is happening let’s just say Frank is probably not taking calls from reporters right this second.
This guy goes way above and beyond what is necessary. The biggest factor in why this blog is good is because this guy actually interacts with the readers.
Most blogs, especially by old media people, are just short news bursts that come with a message board. Dave actually reads all these comments and answers questions.
I wish someone could figure just how much time DOB has spent on this blog in the last year. What does he get for it? Nothing more than he would get if he just filed his stories like the old style beat writers.
If this guy is going to spend all this extra time on us, I think he deserves the chance to insert his own personality in the blog.
If you don’t like the music or the BBQ, you can feel free not to read the baseball part either. Because they don’t come separately and there is no reason they should.
What’s especially pathetic is that you whine about this now of all times. THERE IS NOTHING TO BLOG ABOUT! Literally nothing, just go to mlbtraderumors.com and see for yourself. There is nothing interesting happening anywhere.
But despite that our beat writer came in off the slopes to post up a new blog, just to give us somewhere to discuss.
Maybe we can get lucky and one day we can get a beat writer who has no personality, just a baseball blogging robot, that sure sounds fun.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 12:19 PM | Link to this
In reference to Andruw Jones, he did have a crappy season last year for the Dodgers. But, wasn’t he injured for a good portion of the year? And didn’t he get booed big time by the Dodger denizens when he started out in a slump. Andruw has always been a little immature in his thinking. He didn’t want to change his hitting style when he was here and he resisted at every turn, but he had good production numbers most of the time. It also didn’t help that he had a hitting instructor like Pendletion, who in my opinion is the absolute worse in baseball at his job and who gets waaay too much camera time during games. Andruw is unhappy with the Dodgers and he has Scott Boras to thank for that. He should fire Boras and go back to listening to his father in contractual matters. I am one of the few that believe that Andruw would benefit by coming back to Atlanta. And for those of you that think that Andruw can’t play defense anymore, are you freakin’ kidding me?
By Random
December 31, 2008 12:32 PM | Link to this
nolie: “the scroll-wheel is your friend dude.”
True.
I wish DOB (and many others) had remembered that back when Shaun and I (and a few others) were trying to have a discussion about MVP criteria. You know — Major League Baseball MVP?
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 12:33 PM | Link to this
ncscoots Sorry to burst your bubble, but I’m not a newbie. I was posting on these blogs before DOB and Chop Chick came along. I just stopped posting for one reason or another. Too many posts in one blog is one reason and way too busy is another one. When I go back to work next week, I’ll probably go back to just reading posts again. But just to reiterate, maybe I’m an a*******hole, but not a newbie.
By J
December 31, 2008 12:38 PM | Link to this
if the dodgers were really willing to pay around 20MM out of 22.1MM owed to AJ and it wouldnt cost any top prospects then i would Love to see the braves bring him back - why not take the chance? just my thought.. and Hopefully they push hard for Lowe
2010 - hudson Lowe JJ Hanson vazquez seems pretty damn good to me
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 12:39 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
Aside from his failure to make adjustments, which you noted, I wonder if Andruw is breaking down because of the innings he piled up in CF over the years (he became a a regular at at age 19, after all) and the way he attacks the baseball with no regard for his body. He’s had knee, back and shoulder problems for several seasons and essentially refused to take time off, even to leave in the final innings of blowouts; it was only in 2008 that he had to take significant time away. He couldn’t simply rest a few days and heal enough to get back out there.
I’m also not convinced TP is an awful hitting coach. To be sure, he’s not a my-way-or-the-highway guy like Charlie Lau. But it was in 2005, after all, that Pendleton convinced Andruw to change his stance and he then had his two best seasons as a HR hitter.
Andruw then went back to his old ways and see what happened. Maybe it’s TP’s fault that Andruw stopped listening …
The point is, between Andruw’s stubbornness and the possibility that he’ll be a very old 32 in April, I don’t want him back with the Braves. Unless we play him in RF every day and trade Frenchy.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 12:42 PM | Link to this
We all talk about how much we need pitching, but has anyone really looked at last year stats. We only had two guys with 85, and 87 rbis and we didn’t even have a guy with 30 homeruns. We lost over 25 games by 1 run. Our pitchers would have looked alot better with some run support. WE NEED A BIG BAT!!!!!!
AustinBrave Thank you. You make a very valid point and that is why I think the Braves should at least consider the possibility of signing Manny Ramirez. With a player of his caliber batting cleanup, maybe Bobby wouldn’t feel compelled to overuse his bullpen so much and allow his starters to go further in games.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 12:44 PM | Link to this
Jerald- Amen to that. Andrew will be a star somewhere next year why not here.
By Random
December 31, 2008 12:45 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies: “Folks, Manny has more than “issues.” He quit on the Red Sox during the middle of the summer. He decided when he wanted to play and when he didn’t.”
You know, that sounds a LOT like Babe Ruth’s last season with the Red Sox.
What the heck ever happened to him, anyway — has anybody heard recently?
By TommyP
December 31, 2008 12:48 PM | Link to this
What does everyone think about the new MLB Network?
I believe it begins Jan.1st?????
It’s available to 50 million households which is over 4 times as many as the NFL Network when it started.
I, for one, can not wait for it to air.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 12:51 PM | Link to this
What has Terry Pendleton done for the Braves in the past few years. Team home runs 2nd worst in NL 130. I think he’s the problem.
By Henry
December 31, 2008 12:53 PM | Link to this
Andruw didn’t just have a lousy year with the Dodgers in 08; it was the continuation of the horrible season he had with the Braves in 07. Have you forgotten the picture of that horrible swing he developed? Completely off-balance, completely ineffective. I lost count of the weak grounders to short turned into rally-killiing DPs.
I love what Druw did for this team for 11+ years before that, but he’s not the answer to any rational question at this point.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 12:55 PM | Link to this
Jerald- The only thing about Manny is can he be a team player. Teams win titles not players.
By Fred
December 31, 2008 12:56 PM | Link to this
Here are 2 of my favorite memories of the 14 consecutive division titles.
1) Galarraga’s return from cancer, including his making the all-star game in Atlanta and (if I recall correctly) a homerun in his first game back.
2) Standing in line for post-season tickets at the old stadium in 1991. I was a college freshman at the time and skipped my morning classes to wait in line all morning. The spirit and excitement down there was incredible.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 1:02 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies
But remember that Sheffield WAS an eagle scout when he played for Bobby. The same could happen with Manny. The fact remains that 2009 will not get any better unless we get someone to light up the scoreboard. Manny is the only one available that can do that. I wouldn’t be opposed to Abreu, but he’s just not dominant. Dunn is the worst defensively and watching someone strikeout 2 or 3 times a game is not my idea of sport entertainment. Burrell is just too iffy.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 1:08 PM | Link to this
flange1
There’s that word “newbie” again.
By Glorydays
December 31, 2008 1:10 PM | Link to this
DOB
Can you prove that you and Mark Bradley are not the same person? I think not!!
By flange1
December 31, 2008 1:11 PM | Link to this
Efrim,
You are right that FW might be into signing Smoltz and not wanting another injury prone guy to deal with like Penny.
I would still like to see FW court Lowe and or Ben Sheets at least a little.
By Jersey Gil
December 31, 2008 1:12 PM | Link to this
TommyP Here in Jersey the MLB Network just start yesterday, They just show some clip of old great games, and old some great Moment like the Sid Bream slide at home, that make me cry….This MLB Network going to be Great…Tommorow at 6:00 Pm is the First “Hor Stove” show. The Network also planning to Show the WBC from all venue.
By TheManMike
December 31, 2008 1:16 PM | Link to this
I love all the trash talk from folks who dont know the way this blog, and others work. Its a Braves Blog. For Braves Fans. Not a Baseball Blog for Baseball fans. DOB is our BOY! I enjoy his posts and am saddened when there are days misssed. I watch this blog and Falcons blog daily, and its simply NIGHT AND DAY in comparison. This is a fun, insightful, stupid-go-lucky blog and I LOVE IT! And apparently so do MANY MANY Others, as this blogs seems to ALWAYS get hammered with comments. Look at Falcons blog, THEY ARE IN THE PLAYOFFS AND ONLY LIKE 25 COMMENTS! HAHA..Laughable.
DOB - Keep up the great work. Keep the music coming. These ney-sayers will ALL whither away when the season starts. Do they not understand its WINTER?!?!
GO TO BED!
Hers a GREAT SONG:
“Subterranean HomeSick Blues” - Bob Dylan
Johnny’s in the basement Mixing up the medicine I’m on the pavement Thinking about the government The man in the trench coat Badge out, laid off Says he’s got a bad cough Wants to get it paid off Look out kid It’s somethin’ you did God knows when But you’re doin’ it again You better duck down the alley way Lookin’ for a new friend The man in the coon-skin cap In the big pen Wants eleven dollar bills You only got ten
Maggie comes fleet foot Face full of black soot Talkin’ that the heat put Plants in the bed but The phone’s tapped anyway Maggie says that many say They must bust in early May Orders from the D. A. Look out kid Don’t matter what you did Walk on your tip toes Don’t try “No Doz” Better stay away from those That carry around a fire hose Keep a clean nose Watch the plain clothes You don’t need a weather man To know which way the wind blows
Get sick, get well Hang around a ink well Ring bell, hard to tell If anything is goin’ to sell Try hard, get barred Get back, write braille Get jailed, jump bail Join the army, if you fail Look out kid You’re gonna get hit But users, cheaters Six-time losers Hang around the theaters Girl by the whirlpool Lookin’ for a new fool Don’t follow leaders Watch the parkin’ meters
Ah get born, keep warm Short pants, romance, learn to dance Get dressed, get blessed Try to be a success Please her, please him, buy gifts Don’t steal, don’t lift Twenty years of schoolin’ And they put you on the day shift Look out kid They keep it all hid Better jump down a manhole Light yourself a candle Don’t wear sandals Try to avoid the scandals Don’t wanna be a bum You better chew gum The pump don’t work ‘Cause the vandals took the handles
By Lew
December 31, 2008 1:17 PM | Link to this
Jerald-No need to apologize. If you don’t like the non baseball stuff, then skim past it or find an all Baseball blog where you’ll be happier-or just talk about Braves and most likely someone will respond to you.
This is one of the more popular blogs around. A good bit of the reason that we constantly go over 1000 posts per blog is that many of us enjoy talking about other topics-especially when there isn’t a damn thing going on and we do get tired of talking up the same old tired projected trades-some of which make no sense whatsoever.
It’s your prerogative to talk nonsense deals if you want, but many of us would rather compare notes on good music, movies, literature and food, so I refer you back to my first paragraph.
Random-Meta meta baseball? Do I feel a fluctuation in your BABIP on the horizon?
By Whatever
December 31, 2008 1:17 PM | Link to this
But it was in 2005, after all, that Pendleton convinced Andruw to change his stance and he then had his two best seasons as a HR hitter.
Willie Mays widened Andruw’s stance, not Terry.
Chipper and McCann have their daddies so Terry can’t take credit for them. Has Terry made any one better? He should be fired just because he was the overseer when two of the franchise’s biggest talents, Andruw and Frenchy, tanked. He also couldn’t curb the dramatic decline of Giles. He also hasn’t somehow gotten one more year out of a vet, hasn’t made a starter out of a utility guy, hasn’t launched KJ, Frenchy or Escobar into studs.
Why does Terry still have a job as a hitting coach? The Braves need to hire Daddy McCann and Larry Wayne Jones, Sr. because they’re the only ones making our hitters better. FIRE TERRY!
No one wants to come here because Bobby won’t commit to more than a year at a time. Bobby, in addition to his boobery when it comes to tactical decisions, has now become a liability in attracting talent.
I got a simple policy at my work: no one is allowed to have one foot in and one foot out the door. If you are nice and give me two weeks notice, and say you’ll work the next two to make sure the work gets done, I say don’t do me no half asked favors homey. I’ll pay for those two weeks but here’s a box, get your sh!t and get the hell out NOW. No good work will get done while you’re on your two week farewell tour. No one is allowed to have one foot in, one foot out. Get the hell out.
The Braves need to climb back up the mountain. Bobby won’t make it to the mountain top, When you’ve let yourselves fall back to rock bottom like the Braves have, the sole focus of everyone in the entire franchise should be on reaching the mountain top. This one year contract b.s. by Bobby is Bobby’s way of saying he ain’t got any plans to scale it all the way back up the mountain with the rest of the franchise. The talent that wants to sign contracts or be traded here knows that so they are running away. Cox is a liability. The Braves need to cut their losses. Fire Bobby Cox!
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 1:18 PM | Link to this
Personally, I don’t credit Andruws physical problems with playing all the time. His weight has more to do with his problems than anything else you can suggest. I would love to see him get serious about his health.
By Herman
December 31, 2008 1:19 PM | Link to this
no way!!!!! Jerald you were blogging here before anybody even before Mr. Ob? That must be many years. did the blog just change all of a sudden recently to allow other interests like food and music and vacations? I’m a “newbie” too but like you not an a* either. well, maybe if you ask those pests in my garden they would think so. Ha!!!!!
back to the braves now. Random, are you serious? you must be a newbie to baseball like me but so you know, Babe Ruth died many years ago. He was great and he was called “the babe”!!!
By Salty Dawg
December 31, 2008 1:23 PM | Link to this
raymond
this article was a waste of time. I can’t believe they pay you to do this, and stop with the stupid song lyrics.
Then don’t read it. There are plenty of pure mlb blogs out there, so find one and enjoy.
Efrim
There has to be a reason that the Braves have little interest in Lowe. My guess is that they a) Don’t want to be used to drive up the price for a team that Derek actually wants to play for, and b) the Braves might have already heard from Lowe that his first choice to to play for a contender.
Unless, of course, the team he actually wants to play for is a division rival. In that case, getting in the mix is a win-win situation. If the Braves don’t get him, at least they can make the Mets overpay for him. Not making an offer and letting the Mets pick Lowe up on the cheap while retaining payroll flexibility is worst case.
Jerald Holcombe
*Am I the only one here that gets driven up the wall by all the non-baseball talk? Geeze dude, you want advice on vacationing? Try a travel agent. Sorry, but that’s the way I see it. *
No, but it is what it is. Call it local flavor. Again, there are plenty of bland mlb-only blogs out there. But frankly, there isn’t enough going on in baseball to fill a blog right now. I’m much more annoyed by people who post questions or scenarios that have been discussed ad nauseum than people who post their favorite local BBQ joint.
Jerald Holcombe
Same thing goes for the song lyrics. There’s gotta be a blog for crap like that.
There is and you’ve found it. Enjoy.
By Doug
December 31, 2008 1:24 PM | Link to this
The Cubbies signed Aaron Miles and looks like they might move DeRosa. How about bringing him back to play LF or 2B?
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 1:25 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
If Bobby can get Manny to act like an Eagle Scout, then he has no business in baseball. He should be a special envoy to the Middle East!
Whatever,
Didn’t realize that about Willie Mays. If that’s right, I stand corrected. All I remember was that at the time Joe Morgan was raving about how TP had worked with Andruw. And since Joe and Willie are so close, I figured he would have given the Say Hey Kid props were that the case.
By Jerald Holcombe
December 31, 2008 1:25 PM | Link to this
Can Manny be a team player? I’ll answer that by saying that when he played for Cleveland you never heard a peep. Also, after he signed that huge contract with Boston, how many years elapsed before trouble started. Is it quite possible that the Red Sox actually quit on Manny and not the other way around. Manny also played great for the Dodgers without mishap. I’m think “much ado about nothing”.
By Doug
December 31, 2008 1:31 PM | Link to this
Sorry… looks like DeRosa is headed to Cleveland. Figures.
By Herman
December 31, 2008 1:32 PM | Link to this
isn’t Bobby Cox a gardener too and he has a farm too?
By Lew
December 31, 2008 1:35 PM | Link to this
I live in New England and the Red Sox Soap Opera is always front and center up here.
The Red Sox were in the process of suspending Manny for being Manny, when they dumped him-even eating his salary- to the Dodgers. The Dude had flat out refused to play in games and had alienated almost every other person in their clubhouse, just because he wanted his contract renegotiated.
The Dude can hit, but give up on this Pipe Dream. There is no way Bobby Cox or the Braves are ever going to let Manny be Manny in Atlanta. Y’all b!tch and moan when Chipper misses games for very real injuries. How do you think you’ll deal with a player who misses games for headaches, hangnails and contrived situations that bother no one except him? Believe me, that’s what you’ll end up with.
Sheff may have been a pain in the @$$, but at least he was willing to play-and he wasn’t even making $25 million or more a year.
By Salty Dawg
December 31, 2008 1:38 PM | Link to this
Regarding Frank Wren:
Damn I hope he has some things working and is just keeping it close to the vest because of recent events. Otherwise this is going to be the most depressing off season I can recall in many years. Honestly I think he will get something done, but as the days tick by I am less and less convinced that it will be anything substantial.
Regarding Andruw Jones:
If the Dodgers are willing to pick up $20 mil, why not bring him back. If he turns things around, even modestly, it will be worth the investment. If he doesn’t, we aren’t out that much. At this point, Andruw has all of the incentive in the world to get in shape and fix his problems at the plate.
Regarding Man Ram:
Why not give it a shot? I don’t see him taking a deal from Atlanta, but if the goal is to improve the team as much as possible, he is arguably the most impactful player available. This is a guy that can put an entire team on his shoulders and win games. This is a guy that can bail pitchers out and win games in late innings. This is a guy that can make the difference in those one-run games we all grew to dread last season. Again, this is a guy who has all of the incentive in the world to repair his reputation.
By Lew
December 31, 2008 1:42 PM | Link to this
If Manny was such a good boy on the Dodgers, then why aren’t they re-signing him? Enquiring minds want to know. If they can afford to eat about $16 mil of Andruw’s salary, seems to me that picking up the tab for Manny being Manny shouldn’t be overly prohibitive-especially since the Red Sox paid for his L.A. Pennant drive..
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 1:44 PM | Link to this
I think theirs going to be a BIG TRADE but everything will be quite until its a done deal. I think something is going on between Toronto and Atlanta. Just wait to you see Halladay, and Rios as a Brave. Then everyone will think Wren is a hero. Braves will win the division
By Shaun
December 31, 2008 2:00 PM | Link to this
Salty Dawg, I don’t see how next season is likely to be worse than 2008. May not be much better but it shouldn’t be worse.
I don’t know if re-acquiring Andruw is such a good idea. Even if the Dodgers pick up a huge portion of his salary, the Braves are still using up a roster spot on a player that could be well beyond finished. Apparently he’s even far from the defensive player he once was. Also if you have a player who was once as good as Andruw, any manager would be tempted to give him more chances than they probably should. Andruw may be worth a look for some teams but I can’t think of many (any?).
Regarding Manny, if the Braves could some how get him for pennies on the dollar, sure. But that’s not going to happen. Plus, a) he adds nothing on defense or on the basepaths and b) he’s probably going to be more expensive and provide less band for the buck than other players the Braves could insert in leftfield over the next several seasons.
Manny is still a great hitter. He’s probably going to be a great-to-good hitter for a few more seasons. But he’s not likely to remain one of the top hitters in the game for many more seasons. And, again, he doesn’t add anything on defense or on the basepaths…in fact, he probably harms his team in those areas.
By Original Jon
December 31, 2008 2:01 PM | Link to this
AustinBraves Toronto is not trading Halladay and Rios to us, so stop it.
By Hytest
December 31, 2008 2:03 PM | Link to this
I Don’t understand………..I read MLB trade and ESPN rumors. What in the HE77 are the BRAVES doing. All these signings with other teams.. The Braves have all their payroll clean and they are on vacation….Sitting on the hands. We lost almost 100 games and we lost 3 pitchers and we have done nothing…………..
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 2:03 PM | Link to this
Cubs trade DeRosa and Marquis and dump $9mill in salary to set up Peavy trade. Braves to late again.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 2:10 PM | Link to this
Original Jon- Can a true Braves fan not Dream. The world is made of Dreams.
By Salty Dawg
December 31, 2008 2:11 PM | Link to this
Lew
If Manny was such a good boy on the Dodgers, then why aren’t they re-signing him? Enquiring minds want to know. If they can afford to eat about $16 mil of Andruw’s salary, seems to me that picking up the tab for Manny being Manny shouldn’t be overly prohibitive-especially since the Red Sox paid for his L.A. Pennant drive..
Coletti has already stated that Manny is their first choice. I think the Dodgers are playing hard ball with Bora$$ because there is NO market for Manny and the Dodgers are in the driver’s seat for a change. I don’t recall what Bora$$ was initially looking for, but didn’t he essentially laugh off the Dodgers’ first offer without even responding (I think 2/$45 or something)? Now the Dodgers have all of the leverage. Also, and this is just my speculation, the Dodgers may be hit harder by the economy than many teams because so much of the housing bust has been in SoCal. Maybe it matters, maybe it doesn’t. Either way, I think the Dodgers want Manny back, but they are in a unique situation where they can basically set the price.
By Shaun
December 31, 2008 2:14 PM | Link to this
Lew, I think the Dodgers are still the favorites for Manny. I think the stalemate with Manny is because he is represented by Boras; he wants a big contract; and he’s an older player who, for all his strengths, also has glaring weaknesses.
I’m guessing no team is going to just hand over what Manny and Boras are asking. They are going to offer what they think a soon-to-be 37-year-old, one-dimensional player is worth (or maybe a little more in order to compromise). But they aren’t going to agree to Manny and Boras’ first number.
Manny’s antics certainly don’t help but the major reason teams aren’t jumping for the chance to sign Ramirez is because he’s 37 and very much one-dimensional.
By Salty Dawg
December 31, 2008 2:15 PM | Link to this
Hytest
I Don’t understand………..I read MLB trade and ESPN rumors. What in the HE77 are the BRAVES doing. All these signings with other teams.. The Braves have all their payroll clean and they are on vacation….Sitting on the hands. We lost almost 100 games and we lost 3 pitchers and we have done nothing…………..
Exactly why I think the Braves are working something on the sly. I can’t imagine FW is sitting around oblivious to what is going on and I can’t imagine that JS would let him do it. The Braves have been burned publicly a couple of times already and I wouldn’t be surprised if they are working a deal or two and just being tight lipped about it.
By BravoMan
December 31, 2008 2:18 PM | Link to this
Yes the cubs signed Miles so they could trade DeRosa for prospects to use in the Peavy trade. Peavy never wanted to come to Atlanta so I don’t want to hear that any of our misfortunes this offseason is Frank Wren’s fault. You can’t change Peavy’s mind if he wants to go to Chicago and that’s fine. I do think the Braves should make an offer but if Wren does this and Lowe decides he wants to play on the East Coast, which he has said before, then it may prove pointless. I know im getting a little impatient as well with all these dealings happing and little has happened for us since Vazquez, but Wren said he would aquire two SP and an OF this offseason and I believe he will keep his word. Maybe he’s being secrete about a trade or dealing now because our recent misfortunes of Burnett and Furcal didn’t turn out so well. If I know Wren I bet he’s scheming right now to get a deal done.
By Jim
December 31, 2008 2:24 PM | Link to this
DeRosa’s ‘09 contract - last year - $5.5. He could have played LF for B’s in ‘09 under “Furcal thinking” of a couple of weeks ago. 21 HRs, 87 RBIs in ‘08. Not sure what Cubs got for him in terms of minor league pitchers - but after Miles signing, this was a salary dump for Cubs.
Kendrick, etc. for KJ, Gonzo rumor that someone mentioned above seems like a bad deal. Willits has no power, so only duplicates what B’s already have - Anderson/Blanco/Shafer. Actually Shafer might have a bit of power; and probably more a few years out.
By j-school dropout
December 31, 2008 2:24 PM | Link to this
I still think we should make a pitch to Manny, if for no other reason, to make the Dodgers pay more for him. We owe them one. And if we got Manny, we might not need so much pitching. Chipper and Manny would be a serious offensive punch, and we could always put in another fielder late as a defensive sub. Personally, I think this is what the Braves need. When you can’t get pitching, you need to score runs in buckets.
By Shaun
December 31, 2008 2:24 PM | Link to this
AustinBraves, would the Braves trading for Peavy necessarily be a good move for them?
Everyone seems to take for granted that a Peavy trade would enormously improve the Braves’ chances. Don’t get me wrong, I’m all for getting Peavy if the deal is right. But say the Braves trade for Peavy, post poor to mediocre records over the next few seasons while the players they traded for Peavy develop into good major leaguers, and a few years down the road when Peavy is on the decline they fall a few wins short of a playoff berth because they lacked the depth they would have had had they not pulled the trigger on a Peavy deal back in 2008.
Again, I’m all for the Braves acquiring Peavy if the deal is the right one. But it’s also the type of deal that could backfire, which is why it didn’t get done in November.
By bigjohnchopfan
December 31, 2008 2:40 PM | Link to this
Thanks for some great dining tips.
Please point me to the baseball blog.
Suckers.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 2:42 PM | Link to this
I don’t know if the Peavy trade would be good if we give up alot of talent. I think at this point I would rather trade for a BIG BAT or two(Maybe Dye). Then I would resign Smoltz and Glavine. Not a bad rotation. Smoltz, JJ, JV, Campillo, Tommy Hanson and maybe Glavine and don’t forget Hudson in late July. We could win with this if we could score some runs.
By ernesto
December 31, 2008 2:45 PM | Link to this
DeRo would have been a good pick up for hte Bravos, in that he could spell Chipper at 3rd, play outfield or play 2nd - sure looks like the Cubs are making room to take another shot at Peavy.
Happy New Year to the blog!
By Whatever
December 31, 2008 2:47 PM | Link to this
Didn’t realize that about Willie Mays. If that’s right, I stand corrected. All I remember was that at the time Joe Morgan was raving about how TP had worked with Andruw. And since Joe and Willie are so close, I figured he would have given the Say Hey Kid props were that the case.
Your first mistake was listening to Joe Morgan. Your second mistake was believing anything Joe Morgan said. Your third mistake was not knowing that when he’s given the choice between crediting two different black guys, being Joe Morgan and all, he will naturally credit the wrong black guy.
By Ron Roberts
December 31, 2008 2:51 PM | Link to this
**By Hytest
December 31, 2008 2:03 PM | Link to this
I Don’t understand………..I read MLB trade and ESPN rumors. What in the HE77 are the BRAVES doing. All these signings with other teams.. The Braves have all their payroll clean and they are on vacation….Sitting on the hands. We lost almost 100 games and we lost 3 pitchers and we have done nothing…………..
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 2:03 PM | Link to this
Cubs trade DeRosa and Marquis and dump $9mill in salary to set up Peavy trade. Braves to late again.**
Guys, chill out; the peace and quiet from Tomahawk Territory tells me the Braves have circled the wagons, clamped down on the leaks and are working quietly from here on out. That’s been the Schuerholz way, and while he’s let Frank Wren do business his way, I think FW has either learned his lesson or had it spelled out for him by JS…just a hunch.
By AustinBraves
December 31, 2008 2:57 PM | Link to this
Ernesto- I this point Dale Murphy would be a good pick up.
By Hytest
December 31, 2008 2:58 PM | Link to this
The Braves were claming to have more money to spend than anyone(except Yankees) this off season. To DATE we have bought some egg pie for Wrens face and gave Pendelton a raise………and cut payroll by 30 million……….
By Threadkiller
December 31, 2008 2:59 PM | Link to this
Ok; I have a good one for ya! It seems on MLBTR there are a couple of players willing sign short term contracts. How about this wild idea? Giambi at 1b, Dunn in Rf, Manny in Lf Frenchy in Cf, Kotchman Bench for 1 year. It will be bombs away at the Ted!! Chipper 30 Hr 100 Rbi, Dunn 40 Hr 100 Rbi, Manny 35 Hr 120 Rbi, Giambi 35 Hr 100 Rbi.
Lineup: KJ Escobar Chipper Dunn Manny Giambi McCann Frenchy Pitcher
Happy New Year Everyone!!
By N Nine
December 31, 2008 3:06 PM | Link to this
Wren is quietly cooking up something for 2009. Towers did say he would quietly negotiate Peavy. Just matter of time before someone gets Peavy. I think. Lets close out this rotten year and bring in another year of baseball, hopefully a better year….
Happy 200NINE to the blog!!!
By TooManyTopics
December 31, 2008 3:08 PM | Link to this
But just to reiterate, maybe I’m an a*hole, but not a newbie. Jerald
OK I’ll accept that
By the best moment
December 31, 2008 3:11 PM | Link to this
Andruw Jones took a walk-off WALK on 4 PITCHES two seasons ago…the only way that would be topped is if frenchy does it this year…
my friends and I still talk about that game..
By Hytest
December 31, 2008 3:11 PM | Link to this
Hytest is Hytest………I read the blog daily just haven’t posted in a long long time. I’m just tired of the waiting, almost 90 days since the season was over for us and the 3 best pitchers on the market are signed(Lowe almost to make 4 Randy Johnson to make it 5)I think if the Braves wait long enough they might can get damon Moss or Maybe Charlie Leybrant can still pitch. He was always good for 12 wins……
By Jerry
December 31, 2008 3:12 PM | Link to this
KJ dropping the pop up this past year.
By Mr J
December 31, 2008 3:20 PM | Link to this
Threadkiller,
It would have to be “bombs away at the Ted” just to make up for the runs that outfield lineup would let in. Horrific defense. Really.
By Luv 2 hate me
December 31, 2008 3:21 PM | Link to this
The Braves are tired of making the first offer and getting ripped in the end by other teams. This time they will sit back wait for teams to make their offers then they can have the last say. If Atlanta makes an offer and Lowe turns it down then it’s not about the money. It then becomes a fact that players don’t want to play for Braves like in 90’s. Boy those were the good ole days.
By ADC
December 31, 2008 3:23 PM | Link to this
Threadkiller, if I weren’t a Braves fan I’d love that idea. To think of Giambi, Dunn, and Manny all playing “defense” would be tremendous. It would completely redefine Bill Simmons’ unintentional comedy scale.
But there’s no way Dunn hits cleanup over Manny. And McCann should bat fifth, he’s better than Dunn and Giambi.
By Herman
December 31, 2008 3:24 PM | Link to this
maybe frank wren will post on the blog all of his ideas for trades to see what we think?
did I make a funny? i can catch on pretty quick to braves baseball blogging. garden blogs are dull compared to this one but sometimes an ornamental flower gardener jumps all over a vegetable gardener (we call them vg’s) so it can be pretty exciting too but not quite as hand wringing if you know what I mean. : )))
By Random
December 31, 2008 3:29 PM | Link to this
santa3247 has dropped the following pearls of wisdom re Kawakami on “the Blog of the Chick of the Chop”:
“Hi, I’m Seong-Ho,Yoon living in Jinhae City southkorea now.”
…
“Kawakami Kenshin? he is Ace of Junichi Dragons Japan, and over the Okajima Hideki of Boston I think. But too much weight training must make him weak player just like Jeff Franceour&Brandon Jones.”
“Do you remember last year’s news about them “They appeared in front of fans with body twice size of before through weight training” ^:^”
“Appropriate weight training is important and training coach can’t know the exact amount, only the player self can know well.”
“May the force of Messiah be with you”
Lew: “Do I feel a fluctuation in your BABIP on the horizon?”
‘At’s right, big ‘un, you gots to hit ‘em where they ain’t — I know that now.
Herman: “back to the braves now. Random, are you serious? you must be a newbie to baseball like me but so you know, Babe Ruth died many years ago. He was great and he was called “the babe”!!!”
Welcome aboard, kid — good to hear you’ve heard of Babe Ruth.
But I’ll bet you (and a few others here) didn’t know that the Babe pulled the same kinds of stunts back in 1918 and 1919 that Manny Ramirez pulled last year, and for similar reasons — to get a better contract (more $$$ and more years). The Babe faked injury to avoid pitching, sat out ball games in protest, refused to play sometimes, left the team for days at a time and threatened to sit out the 1920 season. (He also punched his manager and an umpire in two separate incidents.) His salary demands and on- and off-the-field misbehavior were primary motives in the Red Sox selling him to the Yankees.
Sound familiar? Sound like any other ex-Sox we might know or have heard of?
Shaun: “[Manny] adds nothing … on the basepaths”
Bite your tongue, OPS-Boy — he adds a base-runner, don’t he?
By Threadkiller
December 31, 2008 3:29 PM | Link to this
I know or deffense would suck! But who cares when we score 10-12 runs a game!
By Random
December 31, 2008 3:42 PM | Link to this
AustinBraves: “I think at this point I would rather trade for a BIG BAT or two (Maybe Dye).”
Holy Cats, AB!!!
Dye’s got TWO BIG bats?!?!?
By brian
December 31, 2008 3:50 PM | Link to this
DOB speaks and the denizens return. Thanks DOB and enjoy your vacation.
Lets not forget the revolving right field prior to Francoeur - Sheffield then JD Drew, or the magical reclaimation projects in the starting rotation like Jaret Wright.
By beachcomber
December 31, 2008 3:56 PM | Link to this
DOB - Thanks for the new blog - just back from high altitude myself - the Smokies rather than the Rockies.
In the DOB era, Chipper’s batting crown was special - particularly after a heart breaking near miss last year.
Your blog also made me think of two things - a special book I received for Christmas - Feinstein’s Living on the Black. With a few exceptions (wasting a couple pages on hacks like O’Reilly and Obermann and confusing Birdie Tebbits and Lew Burdette - how do you do that?) it is an exceptional book dealing with the ‘07 seasons of Tom Glavine and Mike Mussina. Recommend it for every baseball fan.
Your pancake reference made me want to give an RIP for the legendary Robby’s here on Florida’s west coast. Unmatched pancakes and a special memory - my kids only up close and personal with Murph when he was with the Phils.
Enjoy a well deserved vacation.
By mets fan in atlanta
December 31, 2008 4:07 PM | Link to this
Haha, i’ve been lurking quietly-i’ve been coming on here most days cause this is the best way for me to keep up with the rumor mill, cause i’m not going to look at all the websites myself.
Saying that, it is wishful thinking that the Braves are “quietly” working on some “big” deals, and that’s why yall haven’t heard anything. When DOB says Frank Wren is on vacation, i think he means it. They know the offseason has a been a bust and i think he truly has went somewhere to get away from it all.
Have you heard any other team publicly mention that their GM is on vacation right now? You think Minaya has been taking it easy on the slopes somewhere? Get real Braves fans, yall will be lucky to end up with any free agent who is looking for a multi-year contract. I think what is more likely is that the Braves will wait until the end of January/early February and sign several players to one-year contracts (3-5 million apiece) that got forgotten by everyone else. May even find a hidden gem in there. But a Manny, Lowe, or Dunn????? Keep dreamin.
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 4:37 PM | Link to this
It’s official, folks. Fuentes is now an Angel.
So those half-baked schemes a few of us dreamed up to sign Fuentes and then trade Gonzo for an OF bopper are done.
By Whatever
December 31, 2008 4:53 PM | Link to this
If you can’t take a leak in your own backyard, you’re living too close to town.
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 4:57 PM | Link to this
Also, not to end 2008 on a total downer, but the Cubs just traded Mark DeRosa to Cleveland for a AAA closer and two guys who haven’t pitched above A ball.
Sure, Frank, we know you could use some time with your family, but help us out here!
By Whatever
December 31, 2008 5:01 PM | Link to this
How about this wild idea? Giambi at 1b, Dunn in Rf, Manny in Lf Frenchy in Cf, Kotchman Bench for 1 year
That’s like tryin’ to fish a wet noodle up a bobcat’s arse.
By Mark
December 31, 2008 5:30 PM | Link to this
Please get the Braves new ownership that loves them and wants to win Please…
By Herman
December 31, 2008 5:41 PM | Link to this
Random no way!!!! I always thought “the babe” was maybe a beer drinker and hot dog eater but did not know any of that other information. did you see that on tv or a book??? do you believe any of it? no way!!!!!!!
bet you didn’t but i did know that “the babe” did like to grow veggies in his back yard garden - mostly turnips, blueberries, carrots and cabbage. I like blueberries but not turnips or cabbage.
By woogidy
December 31, 2008 5:43 PM | Link to this
Astros Braves 2005 game 5, 18 innings def most memorable moment. It was a bad one.
By ncscoots
December 31, 2008 5:46 PM | Link to this
Jerald, mea culpa, good buddy, re the “newbie” tag. I just made an assumption based on the post’s content. My mistake.
I will say this…I had pretty much the same reaction when I first came here (“What’s all this other stuff?”), but that lasted about a day and a half. The eclectic content posted in those days was a joy, and that has been the reason I’ve kept coming back. There’s a much higher percentage of baseball-related stuff these days as opposed to then, so that at least should make you happier, LOL.
As to the loss of knowledgeable posters due to content, baseball or otherwise, well, that may be true. Or not. Guess it all goes to perspective and your definition of “knowledgeable”.
By Braves Fan in PA
December 31, 2008 5:52 PM | Link to this
Most memorable Braves moment goes back a while… Some one can look it up I don’t remember exact dates but it was around the 4th of July against the Mets I believe in Atlanta. Game tied extra innings out of position players and Rick Camp left in to hit for himself (I believe his avg was in the .000 range +/- a little :) ). He hits a home run to tie the game or give braves the lead. I think they end up losing it later though. Then as promised at about 4am they set off fireworks.
By Murphy
December 31, 2008 6:04 PM | Link to this
For me it was in 2004 when Charles Thomas came out of nowhere to provide a spark. He was out of Western Carolina which is where I went to school. Not many of those guys make it to the big leagues, so I thought that was cool.
By Frank Wren
December 31, 2008 6:14 PM | Link to this
As if my off season hasn’t been going bad enough - some old jerk on a snowboard, trying to relive his youth, ran over my kids nanny and broke her leg. Now I’m stuck watching my kids rather than making some very important phone calls.
I hope that guy realizes he single handidly cost us the ace pitcher I was on the verge of acquiring!
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 6:52 PM | Link to this
Buster Olney’s now hearing that guys like Giambi and Abreu may have to settle for one-year deals.
Giambi’s a DH now, period. And I’d stay away from him even if he could play a little D because of the whole ‘roids mess.
But Abreu, for one year (heck, even two) at a reasonable salary would be a very nice addition as a LF.
My fear is, he’ll sign a relatively cheap deal with someone else and the Braves won’t find anyone better to play left. It’s been that kind of offseason.
By JB
December 31, 2008 7:12 PM | Link to this
Frank Wren impersonator you really need help with your imagination or just put down the booze. DWI…Drunk Writer Imbicile
By Random
December 31, 2008 7:12 PM | Link to this
mets fan in atlanta — who cares what you say?
Herman — Eff off, you twit.
By David O'Brien
December 31, 2008 7:19 PM | Link to this
Eware: Copper was fantastic, though there were some lines today, unlike when you were here last week.
Every place up here has lines right now, but it wasn’t bad today, considering the perfect conditions (sunny, 28 degrees, almost no wind). I had Copper and A-Basin people tell me it’s busiest they’ve been all year, the period between Christmas and New Year’s.
More people are arriving in droves, too. Just ran into a van full of Alabama folks (they drove up; van had Alabama plates) as we were turning in our snowboards and they were renting theirs. Dude had a ‘Bama hat on, liked it when I told him “Roll Tide.”
Made it through four days of ‘boarding with no injuries, no wrist problems, no nothing. So we’ll be back blogging up a storm soon enough. And yes, we’ll make sure to provide even more music and food discussion for those of you perturbed by that (I love it, the silly indignation some express over something they have no control of).
OK, going to eat a big ol’ burger at Moosejaw bar/restaurant here in Frisco now while we watch the second half of the KU-Minnesota game on NFL Network.
Later.
By BravoMan
December 31, 2008 7:23 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies, I heard that rumor today also but I might not sure how interested in giving a playing a one year deal right now. Im thinking a two three year deal would fit nice for an outfielder considering we’ll be a much better team next year with the return of Huddy and the possible debut of Hanson. I notised a lot of you are big on the possibility of Dunn or Abreu, but I think that’s just too many lefties in our lineup. I think we should consider Burrell for 2 or 3 years. But I wouldn’t be surprised if we didn’t sign any other FAs other than Smoltz/Glavine. Seems to me like Wren would perfer to trade than pick from what’s left of the FAs. But like i have no idea cuz he’s been so secretive. mets fan in atlanta, I don’t know what’s going on in your head other than you’re a stubborn mets fan that’s upset that your team team chocked 2 years in a row. And i know what you’r gonna say “your team hasn’t done any better”, but guess what 14 straight titles, 5 pennants, and a world series championship mean anything to you? Why don’t you just worry bout your New York Muts and not Frank Wren and the Braves.
By Frank Wren
December 31, 2008 7:23 PM | Link to this
JB
Imbicile ??
Perhaps you meant Imbecile? I believe it’s your round. Cheers.
By uga-brave
December 31, 2008 7:26 PM | Link to this
for the few on here whining about the content of the blog, dont read it.
pretty sure this thing will survive without you.
one thing i am sure of, this blog is great because of DOB.
he interacts with many of us, answers questions, and reads pretty much every post.
as for smilin frank. time to think outside the box.
offfering equivalent money to A list free agents has not worked.
heck i dont blame furcal, or burnett. if the braves really wanted either of them they would of upped the ante.
i said in september, that you would hear these words in march, “not fiscally responsible,” “not in the best interest of the franchise,” “we made every attempt to improve ourselves,” and finally, “we really like our core, we think we can compete with our young nucleus.”
wren might need a class in public relations. if you are gonna say, “full speed ahead,” in the media you better better deliver.
there is still time, but the natives grow impatient.
By Random
December 31, 2008 7:42 PM | Link to this
BravoMan: “I heard that rumor today also but I might not sure how interested in giving a playing a one year deal right now.”
???????
By Gut
December 31, 2008 7:48 PM | Link to this
While we may be sour on Furcal at this time, what about his unassisted triple play? I believe that was the summer of ‘03. I know that play hinges on incredible luck but it was still pretty cool to watch live.
By BravesFanInRockies
December 31, 2008 7:52 PM | Link to this
Random,
And I thought I was cranky today.
By Joe
December 31, 2008 7:53 PM | Link to this
Easily forgotten is a dominant pitching performance at the Ted by none other than Mike Hampton (yes… THAT Mike Hampton) in what I believe was one of his last pitching appearances before what became a 2 year vacation. Not only did he pitch a complete game shutout, but he also faced the minimum batters possible (27) and hit a home run to boot in the same game. I know everyone remember the nightmare that was Mike Hampton here, but just a reminder that it wasn’t ALL bad times with him…. Happy New Year everyone!
By Yars
December 31, 2008 7:56 PM | Link to this
I see us going to spring training with no major additions. Perhaps Wren will take that approach. Waiting to see what players such as Schafer, Hanson, Diaz, & even Frenchy bring to the table the first couple weeks of games. Regarding that KJ to the Angels rumor, yeah I read that online too. I hope that rumor has zero substance. now playing: fire woman by the cult.
By BravoMan
December 31, 2008 7:58 PM | Link to this
Random, That was refering to BravesFanInRockies rumor bout the fact that Abreu and Giambi may have to settle for one year deals and i dont think the Braves are too interested in giving a one year offer to major players like that. 2 years at the least. The second part of my comment was referring to the mets fan in atlanta’s ignorant comments. O and I just saw that the Orioles made their final offer to Kawakami if anyone was wondering bout that.
By Dent
December 31, 2008 8:05 PM | Link to this
I dont think that chasing just any remaining free agent is the way to go. I think the Braves will go after value type targets. Im thinking like an Austin Kearns could be a guy we could get who has upside and is still young enough. As far as pitching, I would not go after Lowe. I would take a flyer on Sheets 1yr w option or Oliver Perez. The thing on Perez is we may be able to get him for a three year contract. He is still young. I know he is not the popular choice but a few years ago I would have traded for him.
The thing that most of us have to remember is that Wren cant afford to be emotional about getting a free agent. Only we get to do that.
Happy New Year to all!
By JasonInFL (Formerly ME)
December 31, 2008 8:11 PM | Link to this
I hope FW remembers to come off of vacation!!
By Random
December 31, 2008 8:46 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies: “And I thought I was cranky today.”
Not so’s we could tell.
:->
BravoMan — Oh, okay.
By MEB
December 31, 2008 8:54 PM | Link to this
I’m surprised no one has mentioned the chopping bovine now reigning high above the left field stands. There may be more embarrassing displays in a stadium somewhere but I don’t think so. At least my little four year old grandaughter thinks it’s pretty cool or weird… whatever!
Memorable moments from last years mess started with the home opener with the Pirates. After forcing extra innings with a miracle five-run ninth, the Braves fell to the Pirates in 12 innings. Tom Glavine returned in an Atlanta uniform for the first time in six years. My son and I unfortunately left in the top of the ninth (it was cold) and listened on the way back to the hotel. I’m sure if we had won that game the season would have been a huge success.
GO BRAVES!!!
By JB
December 31, 2008 9:15 PM | Link to this
Hey Impostor Frank the nut houses are filled with great spellers. Ease off the Meds.
By nolie
December 31, 2008 9:37 PM | Link to this
Hey Impostor Frank the nut houses are filled with great spellers. Ease off the Meds. JB
hmmm..so as long as you can’t spell, you’re not crazy ? Kewl !
By Wayn-o
December 31, 2008 11:53 PM | Link to this
Since there is no more Ace pitchers to pick up (unless Peavy falls from purgatory) Why not go after Manny? Short term 2 year deal? We don’t need long term with a stacked outfield in the minors, we have the $$ & need a power bat, plus the protection he would give Chipper!
Why not?
By Don!
January 1, 2009 12:43 AM | Link to this
DOB — enjoy the vacation. I don’t think you’re missing much.
With that having been said, do you think the Cubs deal today was a precursor to a Peavy deal? I think it was.
Later,
Don!
By GTgirl
January 1, 2009 12:45 AM | Link to this
Maybe because Manny doesn’t want a short term contract and he’s not exactly been a club house favorite with previous teams… But with that said, I would love to have a hitter like him in the middle of the order next year.
By uga-brave
January 1, 2009 3:01 AM | Link to this
GTgirl,
the jackets just got killed by a bunch of ORKIN people wearing purple and gold.
so the jackets want rings for beating georgia once every eight years.
fine by me, paul johnson is a fine man, but i heard a couple of his radio interviews, THE DUDE IS KIND OF FULL OF HIMSELF ALL OF A SUDDEN.
note to paul johnson, you played a WILLIE MARTINEZ coached defense.
willie does not qualify, NOTE TO PAUL JOHNSON,
georgia jacked up 40, LSU jacked up 40.
congrats to the nerd herd for beating the dawgs this year.
you absolutely exposed our weakness. WILLIE MARTINEZ.
By Terry Mcguirk
January 1, 2009 3:08 AM | Link to this
ugabrave, do you think DOB has access to a mini fridge up there on the slopes?
By Brian Dennehy
January 1, 2009 3:09 AM | Link to this
…anything you’d like to keep cool.
By uga-brave
January 1, 2009 3:58 AM | Link to this
no accountability,
in the end TERRY is comfortable with what happens.
he has no owner to answer for.
liberty does not care, mcjerk likes his job he will not fire anyone.
we need a owner, one that cares.
one that wonders why we cant sign a free agent.
smilin frank said two starters and a corner outfielder, right?
guess what frank, at this point you have failed.
40 million to spend, right frank.
dunn and sheets would not hurt.
dunn has hit 40 a year for the last three years and sheets is worth the gamble.
either do something, or quit wizzing in our ears and tell us it is raining.
By Terry Mcguirk
January 1, 2009 4:18 AM | Link to this
ugabrave, we like our young core.
By Doin' Good
January 1, 2009 4:29 AM | Link to this
Ignore UGA Terry, he’d just a sour old drunk who pops up most every night to whine and rant, and leave a love note for Dave or Braveheart once in awhile. We know that you really care and that you and John and Frank and Bobby are doin’ your level best.
By TrippyHippie
January 1, 2009 4:36 AM | Link to this
My favorite moments of the last few years?
2006: Watching Dumb-Chuck win 12 games and then go install storm windows all off-season. Old-school to the extreme—too bad it screwed up his shoulder.
2007: Waiting for Hallmark channel to announce the premiere of “Just Keep Pitching—the Buddy Carlyle Story” as the quintessential story of reclamation and redemption unfolded before our very eyes.
2008: Watching Jair Jurrjens pitch his heart out while the rest of the team went up in flames around him. That kid’s a gamer.
By Tomas
January 1, 2009 4:53 AM | Link to this
Hey everybody HAPPY NEW YEAR. I hope you all enjoy a fantastic year, and have fun.
By Wayne in Utah
January 1, 2009 5:48 AM | Link to this
Happy New Year Braves fans.
A few thoughts. Why would the Cubbies trade DeRo if not to go after Peavy? I haven’t figured that one out yet.
And why sign Miles if they are pursuing Brian Roberts.
I would like to see the Braves make a 3 year, 45 Million dollar offer to Lowe. Gotta overpay or be left out in the rain. I expect him to want to go to the NE though.
Either make a play for Brian Roberts, or sign Abreu for a couple of years and for about 20 million. If the O’s want to deal Roberts, make them an offer, and maybe move KJ to left and skip Abreu.
I sense some bargains on the horizon.
Last thought. If Scott Boras is so smart, why would he let Tex sign with the Yankees. That just took out your biggest pawn to up the ante for Manny?? Puzzling.
I think sometimes Scott over plays his hand. (couldn’t happen to a nicer guy.)
I would love to see the Dodgers hold to the 2 year offer for Manny. Also, wouldn’t it be funny for Andruw to end up in NY w/ the Muts! That would guarantee us a better shot at second place.
Nite (or mornin’) folks! Check back in later……
Glad to hear you are having a great time Dave!
By uga-brave
January 1, 2009 5:50 AM | Link to this
love note for DOB and BRAVEHEART, you are right.
bravey and the crusading man have forgot more about baseball than i will ever remember.
scoots is a wordsmith, so add him to the equation.
uga, predicted the fall of bear stearns and leaman brothers a year and a half ago.
if you dont believe me ask flange1.
so if you question my credibility, or my knowledge, scrool up a little when i called the derosa trade and the marquis trade.
now as far as a good drink, i have a basement full of about close to 500 bottles of wine .
for all you dawg fans i went to sonoma last year and met TERRY HOAGE.
HE has a nice little winery out there, and has a vintage, called the BLOCK, and THE PICK.
IF you dont get it you ain’t GEOERGIA.
flange knows the the old oddysey in athens.
R.E.M. rockville, thunder road by the boss, and some old cheesy great rock n roll.
flange i also knew kim stephens, who is now ed tolley’s lead counsel in athens.
goldberg was there, so was a decent runningback named tim worley.
either way intel, mot , oracle, cisco, and texas intstruments, add microsoft are trading at all time low multipes.
seriously this as cheap as it might get.
no debt or exposure to the toxic debt.
cash rich companies. lean into the wind if you have a pair.
wealth changing times. but then again?
By JasonInFL (Formerly ME)
January 1, 2009 7:33 AM | Link to this
Whither FW and Bravo news?
By Max 14
January 1, 2009 8:35 AM | Link to this
A Braves memory I have is from 1998. The Braves won 106 games that year. They faced the Padres in the NLCS. The Padres won the first three games of the series, and the Braves were on the verge of being swept in game 4 trailing in the 8 or 9th inning. Ozzie Guillen ties it up off a Klesko single, and Galarraga delivers a grand slam to blow it open. Braves also won game 5, but lost the series. Anyway, Galarraga kept it alive and gave them a chance.
By mantuan
January 1, 2009 9:33 AM | Link to this
Dave:
If it isn’t too late, you might try the Butterhorn there in Frisco for Breakfast. Excellent place to eat.
My favorite place to ski in CO that I can reach “easily” (a relative term) is Vail but Breck is a also quite good.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 10:50 AM | Link to this
Wayne in Utah According to ESPN, the trades the Cubs made were to gain enough flexibility to sign Milton Bradley. Of course, I ain’t buying it. I still think in a few days that Peavy will be sent packing.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 10:56 AM | Link to this
uga-brave You are wrong that Tech exposed our weakness with Willie Martinez. That was exposed very early in the season. It would be so great to play defense like the dawgs used to play defense.
By SoWeGa Fanatic
January 1, 2009 11:01 AM | Link to this
The Babe faked injury to avoid pitching, sat out ball games in protest, refused to play sometimes, left the team for days at a time and threatened to sit out the 1920 season. (He also punched his manager and an umpire in two separate incidents.) His salary demands and on- and off-the-field misbehavior were primary motives in the Red Sox selling him to the Yankees.
However, you failed to mention the Sox were strapped for cash at the time, plus that was a far,far different era.
By SoWeGa Fanatic
January 1, 2009 11:37 AM | Link to this
*Last thought. If Scott Boras is so smart, why would he let Tex sign with the Yankees. *
Perhaps 5% of $180 million had something to with it. $9 million to say, “OK, sign”. I’d take that.
By Random
January 1, 2009 12:12 PM | Link to this
JEB: “DAP I didn’t see where anyone answered your question about a bad back and a bus ride. I have dealt with back issues so I’ll take the liberty to help.”
Can you hook me up with a copy of the Dec 19, 1956 PLAYBOY?
By brian
January 1, 2009 12:19 PM | Link to this
Salty - Andruw had all the incentives to get into shape and turn things around a few years ago in his walk year. Instead he stayed out of shape and refused to listen to his coaches or make adjustments. Why would he change now?
By Samuel Alex
January 1, 2009 12:21 PM | Link to this
Here i my take…The Braves should sign Manny being Manny at $28Million per year for 2 years. That is not hard to swallow. Been a Braves fans since 1955 and I seen lots of players come and go. Plus they should sogn Lowe for 3 years for $50 Million. Well what do you think. Let’s not talk about past performances….it’s the present you got to think about.
By Random
January 1, 2009 12:21 PM | Link to this
*SoWeGa Fanatic: *”However, you failed to mention the Sox were strapped for cash at the time, plus that was a far,far different era.”
I don’t deny it, but that was not my point.
I was just saying that ManRam has done nothing different than the Babe ever did.
“Different era” — what’s your point? That the Babe’s behavior was more acceptable then than Manny’s is now? Or less?
I would think less.
By Smoky Joe Wood
January 1, 2009 12:35 PM | Link to this
There’s just a tiny handful of decent free-agent starters left out there: Lowe, O. Perez, Sheets, and R. Wolf. Despite this fact, the petulant duo of Wren/Schuerholtz have chosen to take one of those, Wolf, off the table. He’s not an ace, but he’s solid, affordable, and a lefty, and would make our team better. You don’t cut off your nose to spite your face. Furcal was not personal; it was business. Sleazy business, but still business. Bonehead move by the “braintrust”.
DOB has said that Wren is more likely to trade for a LF. That makes no sense to me, with solid options out there like Abreu, Dunn, and (marginally) Derek Anderson who won’t cost you any pieces. The Braves just don’t have the depth to trade right now, and they can’t afford to make any more prospects-for-aging-player deals a la the Vazquez deal, because Schuerholtz made far too many of those kind of deals in his last desperate years. For example, even Prado for Swisher robs us of our best backup at multiple positions, with no middle infielders in the system who are ready.
With money to spend and no great surpluses, we need to fix our holes through free agency—not trades. And the free agent pool gets shallower every day. Meanwhile, Wren fiddles while Atlanta burns.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 1:04 PM | Link to this
Random In reference to your claims that Babe Ruth refused to pitch and so on and so forth, I find that stuff so hard to believe. I think I’ve read every book about the Babe since my childhood, and I’m 52. But, this is the age of the Internet and I’ll delve into it to see what I can find out. The Babe was a hard drinking, hard partying, fighting self-absorbed piece of sheot. But to my knowledge, he never refused to play and never quit. And the only reason given for him being sold to the Yankees for $125,000 was because owner Harry Frazee of the Red Sox needed the money
By cj
January 1, 2009 1:09 PM | Link to this
smokey joe wood~ You have 3 out of 4 correct, Randy Wolf is no option, he’s below average when he’s healthy so no real upside there, at least Sheets has a huge upside if he’s healthy which is probably not realistic. If they are going to sign a free agent pitcher instead of trading for one, I myself hope to God it’s Lowe.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 1:09 PM | Link to this
Jerald
And the only reason given for him being sold to the Yankees for $125,000 was because owner Harry Frazee of the Red Sox needed the money
This is correct. He needed the money to fund a play he was backing. I can’t remember the name of the play bit it was something, something Nannette I believe.
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 1:14 PM | Link to this
Anders—it was No, no, Nanette, I believe.
Smoky Joe: Wolf offers no real upside. He’s not what we need.
By JKP
January 1, 2009 1:24 PM | Link to this
I’m actually glad the Braves have not over-spent this off season. Sure Burnett won 18 games, but a 4.07 ERA is not worth almost $16 mil/year for 4 years. Wren, and the Atlanta fans need to embrace the fact that the Braves are in a rebuilding phase. The playoffs are possible next year, but not probable. Save the money…develop the young talent. Let’s talk pennant again in 2 years or so.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 1:24 PM | Link to this
All I could find out about Babe Ruth was that he’d been suspended a few times by Commissioner Landis for various things. I also found out that he was heartbroken when he found out that he was sold to the Yankees. Doesn’t exactly sound like a man who would refuse to pitch for his team.
By Bill
January 1, 2009 1:31 PM | Link to this
Wren fiddles while Atlanta Burns. Smokey Joe Wood…Agree 100%.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 1:33 PM | Link to this
For the Braves to get Lowe they need to be prepared to over pay. He wants to pitch for a contender. As ironic as this sounds, what the Braves have in their favor with Lowe is that Boras is his agent. Any other agent might pass on more $’s to put his pitcher on a better team.
The Mets have offered 3 years at $36 mil with a vesting 4th, so figure full value at $48 - 50 mil. The Braves will have to gaurantee a 4th year with a full contract value at about $52 - 55 mil. I don’t think the Mets will go there. That should get it done for the Braves. I’ve heard the Phils are sniffing around too but I have no idea if that’s real and if so, what level of interest they have. It doesn’t seem serious to me - but who knows? After all, who saw the Yanks coming out of no where for Tex?
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 1:35 PM | Link to this
According to Wikipedia, when Ruth was with the Red Sox, he jumped the team several times and held out prior to the 1919 season for a $20,000 increase in pay. So, there looks to be a measure of truth in what Random stated. I was amazed to find out also that Frazee had planned to trade the Babe to the White Sox for “Shoeless” Joe Jackson, but the Black Sox Scandal stopped that.
By brent a.
January 1, 2009 1:39 PM | Link to this
looks like the MLB network is available on Directv.
I hope it provides something useful.
There’s nothing on TV anymore. :)
By Anders
January 1, 2009 1:54 PM | Link to this
Jerald
Please don’t tell me Boras’ grandpappy was The Babe’s agent!
By rip van wren
January 1, 2009 2:03 PM | Link to this
ive been asleep for so long, what year is this?
do they still play baseball in america??
is there still an america
hey at least we signed norton
lets trade for halladay and eat guillens overflated contract , what will we have to give them ? the gwinnet braves
By Anders
January 1, 2009 2:08 PM | Link to this
Jerald
I was amazed to find out also that Frazee had planned to trade the Babe to the White Sox for “Shoeless” Joe Jackson, but the Black Sox Scandal stopped that.
Good stuff. I’ve never heard this before. So let’s review. It’s widely believed that Babe Ruth put baseball on the map after he went to the Yanks and hit all those home runs into his customized short porch - correct? Therefore, had the White Sox trade for The Babe gone through who knows if baseball ever reaches the popularity it did back then and still holds today?
So in the end the Black Sox scandal may have very well been good for baseball. I’d like to run that by acclaimed baseball historians George Will or Peter Gammons for their thoughts.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 2:11 PM | Link to this
I don’t know what it is about Frank Wren. First, he probably volunteers too much info, thus setting himself up for failure. then he offers no info, which lends to the aura of doing nothing at all. It would be nice if he would at least tell us that he’s working on a deal or two.
By Blog Ref
January 1, 2009 2:22 PM | Link to this
But frankly, there isn’t enough going on in baseball to fill a blog right now. I’m much more annoyed by people who post questions or scenarios that have been discussed ad nauseum than people who post their favorite local BBQ joint.
99% of the baseball topics being discussed now fall into that “ad nauseum” category. Frankly there isn’t anything new, except the AJ talk(an ok idea for only $2million).Jerald was right, many of the better bloggers are staying away, not because of the non baseball stuff(that’s what makes this a great blog), but because they are smart and recognize there isn’t much to say.I mean talking about Manny, or Dunn, and now rehasing Peavy? Ad Nauseum.
Only the idiots who like to drive of the comment count are posting over and over again. So vain they’re making DOB post a make shift blog on his vacation! Horrible People. Leave that man alone and be stingy with your comments. Of course it’s always fun to see just how big a jerk Lew is. If there is a more smarmy, thuggish person on the blog he hasn’t yet posted.Who will be the next blogger who has to smack down Lew?
Oh for something fresh, some topics not beat to death. Please, please, please, no more 1. Braves are doomed; 2. Frank Wren is no good; 3. Let’s play the kids(ain’t we doin that allready); 4.Adam Dunn; 5. Jake Peavy; 6.Manny(for the luv of pete, it ain’t happenin); 7. My EQa is better than your OPS sabermertic-staty b.s.;8. Andrew Jones is no good; 9. Jeff Francouer is no good; and 10..ANY TOPIC COVERED ALREADY IN 10 CONSECUTIVE BLOGS OR MORE.
I wish some of the better bloggers would say more, but then y’all are smart enough to know when there’s something worth sayin and when there ain’t. So until things pick up i guess we have to put up with the blabbermouths and newbies. Oh and a-hole Lew of course. Sigh
By Blog Ref
January 1, 2009 2:25 PM | Link to this
The Mets have offered 3 years at $36 mil with a vesting 4th, so figure full value at $48 - 50 mil. The Braves will have to gaurantee a 4th year with a full contract value at about $52 - 55 mil. I don’t think the Mets will go there
FAIL (see Furcal, Raphael)
By J
January 1, 2009 2:36 PM | Link to this
anders
Boras is tex agent and i am pretty sure he took less money to sign with them over the nats - not always with boras is it the highest offer. i think the braves would have to offer something like 4/60 if they want to get Lowe - that would still leave enough money to get a LF And bring smoltz back. - if Wren has no Trades close to being worked out that noone has heard about then i think it would make no sense for them not to overpay a little to get Lowe. If they were willing to give Burnette 18MM a yr who is a injury risk - why not throw something like 4/64 if they have too to get Lowe?
By LuisG
January 1, 2009 2:45 PM | Link to this
Some individual moments I can recall:
Greg Maddux reaching 15 wins for the 16th straight year in ‘03 (passing Cy Young); Chipper hitting for extra-bases in 14 consecutive games in ‘06, his 2000th hit at Cleveland in ‘07; Yunel’s debut at Wrigley in ‘07.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 2:50 PM | Link to this
Blog Ref
I’m throwing my review flag into the bloggisphere. I’d like you to review my whole 1:33 post before making a ruling. Please re-read this line:
As ironic as this sounds, what the Braves have in their favor with Lowe is that Boras is his agent. Any other agent might pass on more $’s to put his pitcher on a better team.
Therein lies the difference between the “Furcal, Raphael” case and the “Lowe, Derek” case.
Now, I’m not saying it’s a slam dunk that Lowe takes the money and goes to the Braves, just that based on his agents history it’s possible.
If he passes on the money too then I believe the Braves need to completely forget about contending for two to three years. Unload the likes of Chipper for youth, forget signing Smoltz, Glavine et al and move on. If you’ve followed my blogs since October I’ve been leaning this way all along. The glory days of the Braves are gone and the market is reflecting this.
By LivininAL
January 1, 2009 3:08 PM | Link to this
The Braves off season efforts appear colder than the Colorado snow. Maybe there will be a Spring thaw and things will start to happen. Now appears hibernation time.
By JasonInFL (Formerly ME)
January 1, 2009 3:24 PM | Link to this
The glory days of the Braves are gone and the market is reflecting this.Anders
And the glory days of the Mets have yet to come…ever.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 3:39 PM | Link to this
Jason
And the glory days of the Mets have yet to come…ever
Not sure about the “ever” part, but I don’t think the Mets will ever win 14 titles in a row. The Braves certainly deserve full respect for that but that doesn’t mean anything in today’s market which i believe is what we’re discussing. At least most of us.
By Moby Grape
January 1, 2009 3:44 PM | Link to this
Save the money…develop the young talent. Let’s talk pennant again in 2 years or so. JKP
what do all you folks think they are gonna do with all this money they save? Put it toward next season? I bet that ain’t gonna happen. The team is already too young with almost no veteran leadership and just about no long-term expensive contracts. We need to sign a few veterans though they don’t need to be stars. Frank’s original plan still makes sense, another steady starting pitcher and an outfielder with some pop even if only a platoon guy to swap with Diaz. Let’s do it!
By Random
January 1, 2009 3:46 PM | Link to this
Blog Ref: “Oh for something fresh, some topics not beat to death.”
I, too (like Anders), would like to request a instant replay review of your Ad Nauseam call.
I always (okay — usually; often? sometimes?) try to bring some value-added material, whether it’s new info or a fresh perspective. (In addition, of course, to lame jokes and merciless ridicule of YAIs. And gratuitous DOB-bashing. (JK, DOB!).)
Please check out my comments above on: Willie Harris having been judged to be the Number One 2008 free agent pick-up; Kawakami perhaps having bulked up too much, a la Francoeur last year (courtesy of santa3247); and the eerily fits-like-a-glove comparison between the on- and off-field behavior of the Babe and ManRam, both dumped by the Red Sox for many common reasons.
But forget about me — I want to hear some more about “just how big a jerk Lew is”. That never gets old.
Thanks in advance.
By Moby Grape
January 1, 2009 3:50 PM | Link to this
It would be nice if he would at least tell us that he’s working on a deal or two. Jerald
no it wouldn’t. Just how would that be any different? It would still be setting up all the children for another disappointment causing me to have to scroll past untold hundreds of whining posts. Stick with the JS formula. Keep quiet until you have a signature on a dotted line.
By Lew
January 1, 2009 4:04 PM | Link to this
Smarmy and thuggish? Who will be the next person to knock me down? Certainly not some mentally challenged @$$whole without the nads to use his real name when posting garbage.
By Doc Holiday
January 1, 2009 4:15 PM | Link to this
OK Braves, it is a new year, get to work and make some signings………..could you please???
By Doc Holiday
January 1, 2009 4:21 PM | Link to this
I checked the braves official site and they put there a preview to the braves lineup for next year. It brings up a question in my mind. They are suggesting Anderson as our regular CF. Where does this comes from? In my mind Blanco should have that starting job until Anderson beats him. Opinions??????
By Random
January 1, 2009 4:33 PM | Link to this
Pepperidge Blogs Remembers
By uga-brave
December 10, 2007 4:52 PM | Link to this
bosnian baller, mcfann,
the lasik surgery was done to make the portions on McCann’s plate look bigger than they actually are.
Priceless!
…
By uga-brave
January 18, 2008 1:24 AM | Link to this
i know certain current braves, and former braves (blauser, lemke, brad clontz) they all hang out at T,J’S ON holcomb bridge.
to a man they think CHUCK N DUCK is the 4th dumbest brave of all time.
1 brian hunter 2 wes helms 3 john rocker 4 chuck james
Now that he’s gone, do you think Mike Hampton would crack the top five?
chrisklob, Braveheart and I would like to know.
;->
By JB
January 1, 2009 4:37 PM | Link to this
Anderson did just that at the end of the year, beat Blanco out of the job and moved Blanco to left field for most of September. It was fun to watch Anderson play and the Braves win more often once he began playing and hitting leadoff
By Efrim
January 1, 2009 4:43 PM | Link to this
They are suggesting Anderson as our regular CF. Where does this comes from? In my mind Blanco should have that starting job until Anderson beats him. Opinions??????
I’d rather Blanco than Anderson. I’d like one of them to get the job so Jordan Schafer can get some more development time in Triple A. I’m for Tommy Hanson starting in Gwinnett as well. I’d like to see a little more of Morton and Reyes.
By Random
January 1, 2009 4:49 PM | Link to this
“Every day from now to Spring Training, MLB.com/Live will air classic games on Baseball’s Best. Smoltz’s [6 Apr 08] win over Santana and the Mets can be seen Friday at 3 p.m. ET.”
from Braves.com
By Random
January 1, 2009 4:56 PM | Link to this
Doc Holiday: “I checked the braves official site and they put there a preview to the braves lineup for next year. It brings up a question in my mind. They are suggesting Anderson as our regular CF. Where does this comes from? In my mind Blanco should have that starting job until Anderson beats him. Opinions??????”
Mark Bowman is smarter than you?
Nah.
Quien sabe?
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 4:56 PM | Link to this
Efrim—I’d like to see Hanson start in AAA as well, although I would like to see Schafer play lights-out in ST and win the CF job outright. But I do agree that we should give Charlie and JoJo another good, long look.
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 5:03 PM | Link to this
But let me add that I do think Schafer needs more development time, but I just don’t like our chances with Anderson/Blanco starting a significant amount of time in center.
But I do see that Blanco is hitting for some power in winter ball, so who knows? I agree with you that if I had to “pick my poison,” so to speak, I’d pick Blanco.
By Salty Dawg
January 1, 2009 5:04 PM | Link to this
Doc Holiday
I checked the braves official site and they put there a preview to the braves lineup for next year. It brings up a question in my mind. They are suggesting Anderson as our regular CF. Where does this comes from? In my mind Blanco should have that starting job until Anderson beats him. Opinions??????
I doubt seriously that either of them is going to be handed CF. More likely both will get time in CF during spring training and whichever is more capable at that time will take the field during the season. No way is this one of those “his spot to lose” situations because neither has established themselves yet.
By Frank
January 1, 2009 5:08 PM | Link to this
This memory has nothing to do with the Braves but my best memory was of 2007 when….
the Met’s ended up losing the NL East on the last day of the season and then the Phils (didn’t just get beat in the playoffs) but they got swept. SWEPT!!!!! Swept by the Rocks in the playoffs.
I thought…”Yes, there is a God”!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That was a one helluva memory!
By Salty Dawg
January 1, 2009 5:08 PM | Link to this
Moby Grape
no it wouldn’t. Just how would that be any different? It would still be setting up all the children for another disappointment causing me to have to scroll past untold hundreds of whining posts. Stick with the JS formula. Keep quiet until you have a signature on a dotted line.
I couldn’t agree more. With JS you never knew what he was involved with until it was pretty damn close to being a done deal. The biggest problem for Wren this off season is that he publicly announced what he intended to do and then was publicly embarrassed when the deals he was trying to make fell through.
By Efrim
January 1, 2009 5:24 PM | Link to this
Steve from OH
I think Schafer will eventually be our CF in 2009. But I’d just like him to gain back those 2 months he lost because of that suspension and whatever time he lost in winter ball. Losing those at bats hurt his development as well.
Whether it is Anderson or Blanco, doesn’t really matter too much to me, the Braves aren’t going to get much from either in terms of offense. Which makes adding a LF bat that isn’t in a platoon with Matt Diaz that much more important. I really believe that it should be considered just as much as a priority as the starting pitcher we need. I think a lot of people are counting on McCann and Chipper to hit in the middle of our order, which they will, but they’ll both miss 25-30 games because of injury(Chipper) or need for rest(McCann and Chipper). So we need a consistent force in the middle of our order…preferably right handed, but I’ll settle for a lefty like Dunn if need be.
Sorry for the rant, but I worry that the Braves will be concerned about defense in left field, when they really should be looking for middle of the order power.
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 5:27 PM | Link to this
A quick search confirms that Blanco is hitting .349/.464/.512 in 172 Dominican Winter League at-bats. Definitely helps his standing.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 5:29 PM | Link to this
Salty Dawg,
Yep. Wren raised expectations by saying exactly what he wanted for 2009 in October. By failing to deliver by the end of the Winter Meetings, he looked like he was in over his head.
You can say it’s a long way ‘til April, but if the opening day LF is Diaz or Blanco and the #3 starter is Campillo, then Wren has at a minimum failed to provide the upgrades he promised.
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 5:31 PM | Link to this
I worry that the Braves will be concerned about defense in left field, when they really should be looking for middle of the order power.
Completely agree.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 5:35 PM | Link to this
Efrim
Happy New Year.Did you see the reports on ESPN that the Giants are aggressively pursuing Manny Ramirez? I guess the Giants feel relatively speaking that he’s a step up from the guy they used to have in left. Manny only cheated one team last year while Bonds cheated all of baseball when he played.
By Steve McP
January 1, 2009 5:38 PM | Link to this
Frank Wren’s first job should be to sign Ohman.
We must have the money because of the lack of spend so far. No longer trying to fit his salary around the big money guy, whoever Braves sign to start will not be costing as much as Burnett.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 5:41 PM | Link to this
And because the Braves/MIB/BBQ blog has opened 2009 with waaaay too much baseball, here’s a prediction for you college football fans:
Even though Georgia Tech has just finished its first season under Paul Johnson, the program will start a long and steady decline unless or until he abandons the option and installs a more flexible offense. (Could be a pro-style, could be a spread, could be some combination, doesn’t matter.) Tech’s high water mark may have been the Georgia win.
Why?
Johnson will not be able to recruit top-flight, NFL-caliber athletes to Tech to play offense if they keep running the option.
NFL linemen have to be able to pass-protect, and that means learning to read blitzes during games.
NFL wide receivers have to catch passes. NFL QBs have to be able to not just throw the ball but read coverages.
You don’t get that experience if you throw the ball eight or 10 times a game.
He had a remarkable season this year with Gailey’s guys, who were recruited to play in a pro-style offense. The weirdness of the scheme worked this year because he had superior athletes and the option typically drives opposing defensive coordinators nuts. It’s like winning with trick plays. Works for awhile but people figure it out.
The talent pool will dry up when recruits figure out the only offensive players with any chance to earn a living playing football are the tailbacks.
So my fearless prediction is — Tech will install a more balanced offensive attack within one or two years or Johnson will be gone soon after that.
By Random
January 1, 2009 5:47 PM | Link to this
Ben Nicholson-Smith of MLBTR:
Derek Lowe was “hardly overwhelmed” by the Mets’ three year $36MM offer, Mike Puma of the New York Post heard from a baseball source. Tony Massarotti of the Boston Globe heard from a source of his own that Lowe’s “likely to continue shopping for a more desirable offer.”
It’s uncertain who would make such an offer, since Massarotti writes that the Yankees, Red Sox and Phillies are not currently interested in Lowe.
As a result, the Mets could end up in what Puma calls a “protracted stare down” with Scott Boras and his client.
By Rich W
January 1, 2009 5:50 PM | Link to this
For Left Field ….how about continuing the Furcal to 2B, Johnson to Left by substituting Prado for Furcal? Though Prado is certainly not Furcal, he can hit fairly well and field at least acceptably. If Johnson was a good candidate for LF with Furcal coming, why not now? Of course he’s not the “big bat” we’d all like, but the “big bat” might not be coming. And there is Diaz against certain pitchers too. Thoughts?
By BravoMan
January 1, 2009 5:54 PM | Link to this
Look no one knew about the Vazquez trade until it was a done deal. JS obviously told Wren, or he figured out for himself, that it’s not supposed to be so public. I wouldn’t worry about the whole LF defence conflict. With Francoeur in RF and Anderson/Schafer/Blanco in CF, that’s already a good defencive OF. We can give up some defence for some power. And im tired of anyone on here that thinks that Diaz will be our opening day LF and Campillo will be our #3 starter. We’ve got a month til pitchers and catchers report and half the market’s still out there. It’s starting to pick up as of late but haven’t you notised that alot of other teams aren’t be very active either. With our economy how it is right now they’re trying to get a good bargan. A deal or two is coming shortly. As for Lowe it seems like he’s kind of ticked at the Mets now lol. I don’t see the harm in at least giving him an offer of around 13-15 mil for 3yrs with a 4th year option and go from there. As for our LF problem, I really think it’s going to be a trade for Swisher or someone like Winn(who recently became avalible because of SF’s strong interest in Manny). Neither of them are superstars but I believe a team only needs one superstar and ours just won the batting title…be patient Braves fans…
By AustinBraves
January 1, 2009 5:55 PM | Link to this
Just a thought. How about a trade for Barry Zito I know the Giants want to trade him and I think they are willing to eat alot of his salary. To bring him to Atlanta and pitch with his good friend Hudson may make him the pitcher of old. If we could get him cheap I think its worth the chance. Maybe we give up Morton or JoJO.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 5:56 PM | Link to this
As ironic as this sounds, what the Braves have in their favor with Lowe is that Boras is his agent. Any other agent might pass on more $’s to put his pitcher on a better team.
Are you kidding me? Boras ALWAYS looks for the top dollar. He could care less where the player winds up. Look at the history. And just to stem the tide of bloggers that want the Braves to sign Lowe and my own wishes that they go after Manny, I turn your attention to comments made by Schueholz when Maddux was sent packing. JS made the statement back then that the Braves didn’t like dealing with players represented by Boras because of the way he drives up the prices. Lastly, in reference to who should be the 2009 CF for the Braves. It’s not gonna be either Blanco or Anderson if it can be helped. The Braves need a stick and an excellent defensive centerfielder and unless he just blows his chance, look for Shafer.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 5:58 PM | Link to this
Random
About your 5:47 post. And there’s Wren’s shot. That’s what I was saying earlier today. He waited to long on Burnett imo.The yanks were distracted withh CC, that’s when he should have forced Burnett’s hand. He shouldn’t let it happen again on Lowe. “Overwhelm” him. Apparently that’s what he’sooking for. But give him an immediate deadline. That would be my play. If Boras wants to shop a Braves offer, tell him to pi$$ off. Tell him publicly too to reduce his leverage with others. I know that part sounds self serving but that’s not how I mean it.
By Random
January 1, 2009 5:58 PM | Link to this
Gerry Fraley of the SportingNews.com:
Atlanta: Braves general manager Frank Wren can salvage what has been a frustrating offseason — no shortstop Rafael Furcal, no righthander Jake Peavy, no righthander A.J. Burnett — by adding a corner outfielder with power. Atlanta’s outfield produced only 27 homers last season, fewest for a full season by an outfield since six clubs had 27 or fewer in 1992. That included 19 homers by the Chicago White Sox.
The Braves have also not given up hope of signing free-agent righthander Derek Lowe, though the Mets reportedly offered Lowe a three-year, $36 million deal. If the Braves land Lowe, they will consider themselves lucky for missing out on Burnett.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 6:01 PM | Link to this
Random Lowe also stated that when all is said and done, that he believes tat he will be signing with the Mets. Read that in ESPN rumors.
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 6:05 PM | Link to this
Are you kidding me? Boras ALWAYS looks for the top dollar. He could care less where the player winds up…
Well, that is his job, isn’t it? And he does it well. Besides, the PLAYER is the one that must sign the contract, so the PLAYER ultimately decides where he goes. Boras cannot force a player to sign for a team he doesn’t want to.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 6:14 PM | Link to this
AustinBraves,
It doesn’t matter if Zito would think it’s really neato to pitch with his old buddy Hudson.
He has a terrible contract, and he’s signed for five more years. I’m also not sure he’s any better right now than JoJo Reyes.
I’d rather see them sign Randy Wolf, even if his agent is Arn Tellem. You could get Wolf for two or three years, not pay him a lot, and get better production than you would for Zito.
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 6:16 PM | Link to this
To follow up on my last post, EVERY agent looks for top dollar. The agent’s job is to get the best offer from every team interested, so that his client may choose which one to take. An agent that can’t get top dollar isn’t a good agent.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 6:19 PM | Link to this
Jerald
Are you kidding me? Boras ALWAYS looks for the top dollar. He could care less where the player winds up
I 100% agree with you. That was my point. By offering more $’s the Braves might be able to get Lowe even though he’s said he wants to pitch for a contender.
JS made the statement back then that the Braves didn’t like dealing with players represented by Boras because of the way he drives up the prices.
This is part of the Braves past that needs to die. They aren’t in the position anymore to eliminate talent just because who they are represented by. Take a look at Boras’ and the Wasserman groups client list’s. Are the Braves really ready to say they will never sign one of those guys? What does that do to the prices you have to pay for the guys that are left?
By Steve from OH
January 1, 2009 6:21 PM | Link to this
BFIR, I’d rather just see them give Reyes the ball every five days than see them sign Wolf (or trade for Zito). Wolf…is just a bad idea. Can’t see why anyone would want him.
On a side note, by signing Lowe, we would make it more likely that the Mets sign one of Perez, Wolf, or Garland, which of course would be great for us, seeing the Mets tie up years and money into bad pitchers like Garland and Wolf.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 6:23 PM | Link to this
Rich W,
The only reason you’d put Prado at 2B and move Johnson to LF is because you can’t find a LF who can hit better than Prado. You’re not improving the offense. You’re moving people around, and in my opinion weakening the offense, when the goal is to upgrade it.
I would actually hope that the Braves think they can do better than Diaz, at least as a platoon partner. There are plenty of free agent OFs out there who can produce more against right handed pitching than Diaz.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 6:28 PM | Link to this
This is part of the Braves past that needs to die. They aren’t in the position anymore to eliminate talent just because who they are represented by.Anders
Agreed, unfortunately. Since TBS isn’t showing 150+ games a year, the Braves don’t have the national exposure and natural following that the Mets, Dodgers, Yanks, Cubs and BoSox have. I think the team lost a lot of bargaining leverage when the TBS connection went away.
They have to start acting more like the mid-market team they are and not expect players will sign with them because of the streak, or Bobby Cox, or whatever.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 6:29 PM | Link to this
Steve from OH,
Yes! We should start a lobbying campaign for the Mets to sign Garland!
By Random
January 1, 2009 6:31 PM | Link to this
Also from Fraley, TSN.com:
[The Fillies] are also trying to give away disappointing righthander Adam Eaton. The Phillies will absorb $8 million of the remaining $9 million guaranteed Eaton and want nothing in return.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 6:38 PM | Link to this
If the Phils would pay about $12 million of the $9 million due to Eaton, you might consider him …
By Salty Dawg
January 1, 2009 6:42 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies
Salty Dawg,
Yep. Wren raised expectations by saying exactly what he wanted for 2009 in October. By failing to deliver by the end of the Winter Meetings, he looked like he was in over his head.
You can say it’s a long way ‘til April, but if the opening day LF is Diaz or Blanco and the #3 starter is Campillo, then Wren has at a minimum failed to provide the upgrades he promised.
You and I agree with regards to Wren being too vocal/public about his intended moves. But I disagree with the rest of your statements. First of all, I don’t think that Diaz (possibly as a platoon) would be the worst thing in the world. Secondly, I think Campillo is going to surprise a lot of they naysayers out there next season. Looking at his history it would have been a miracle for him not to taper off last season. Prior to last season I think the most innings he’d pitched in a season was like 25. Not to mention he wasn’t very far removed from TJ surgery according to something I read here on the blog. Thirdly, I don’t recall Wren ever promising to do anything. I remember him detailing the moves he wanted to make to fill the obvious weaknesses of the team, but I don’t ever remember a promise. To date I think he’s done pretty much all he could to meet his goals but has been unsuccessful. I just don’t think he would be drawing as much heat if he had played it close to the vest, but I also think that anyone with a brain could have identified the holes we needed filled anyway.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 6:59 PM | Link to this
Salty Dawg,
We’re probably not disagreeing about much. When a GM so specifically states his goals, how different is that from making a promise to the fan base? His success or failure can be judged on whether he accomplished those goals.
I also agree that Diaz may be a fine platoon player — and he’s on the roster and affordable — but even in 2007, he was primarily a lefty-masher. They need more from the corner OF spots against RHP.
Campillo remains an unknown. He’s also unlike anyone else in baseball now that Maddux is gone. He did pitch a full load in 2007 between AAA and the majors, not that far removed from TJ surgery.
I’m not sure you can count on him getting away with the stuff he has for 30+ starts and 180+ innings. I’d love to be proved wrong. I’d love it even more if they signed or traded for another proven starter, and let Campy’s contributions be a bonus, rather than something they’re relying on every fifth day.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 7:00 PM | Link to this
In case anyone hasn’t noticed, USC’s pretty good.
By Da' Braves-# 3 Pro Team in Atlanta
January 1, 2009 7:22 PM | Link to this
Stockbridge boy Kyle Davies pitching 5 great innings in Boston for a win in major league debut.
By Efrim
January 1, 2009 7:57 PM | Link to this
Anders
If the Giants are willing to spend the money, than it is a great move for them. They need a run producer in the middle of their order. They have the pitching and the NL West can probably be won by the Dodgers, D-Backs or Giants.
By Moby Grape
January 1, 2009 8:03 PM | Link to this
Which makes adding a LF bat that isn’t in a platoon with Matt Diaz that much more important. Efrim
what’s so important about not having a platoon? I’ll be thrilled with one if they can combine for .280 20 HR and 85 RBI+. I fail to understand what so many here have against platoons when they have such a long history of success.
By Moby Grape
January 1, 2009 8:16 PM | Link to this
Prior to last season I think the most innings he’d pitched in a season was like 25 SaltyDawg
huh? he pitched as much or more in ‘07 than he did in ‘08. Doesn’t matter where it was. There was really no excuse for him to tire that badly. He has a good assortment of pitches but none are all that special. I think the league caught up to him. I’ll be damned disappointed if he is a regular in the starting rotation next summer
By Efrim
January 1, 2009 8:22 PM | Link to this
Moby Grape
If the “.280 20 HR and 85 RBI” produces a .280/.330/.450 line, then your expectations for our LF-middle of the order hitter are different than mine. Braves don’t need a Matt Diaz/Garrett Anderson platoon next year, unless they plan on battling for third place. I know you didn’t bring up Anderson, but I am just using the cheapest left handed hitting LF out there as an example.
By Lew
January 1, 2009 8:37 PM | Link to this
Campillo missed all of 06 with TJ surgery, came back and pitched about 140 something innings in 07, pitched Winter Ball in 07 and then pitched 158 innings for the Braves in 08. Dude was worn out by the end of last year. 300+ IP AND Winter Ball a year after TJ surgery? Pretty amazing if you ask me.
By ncscoots
January 1, 2009 8:44 PM | Link to this
I’ll be damned disappointed if [Campillo] is a regular in the starting rotation next summer
I’m with Moby on this one. Campillo in the starting rotation will mean that the Braves couldn’t two starters better than he. That, boys and girls, will not be good news.
I like the guy, but I think he’ll be more effective in small doses. As a long reliever, or even spot starting, I believe he would be great. But 30 starts? No, thanks.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 8:50 PM | Link to this
Lew
Campillo, Castillo. Both coming off of surgeries. Both hit the wall late last year. Could be looking at bounce back seasons in ‘09. Hey, I like your theory. I think I’ll apply it as well.
Thanks.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 9:10 PM | Link to this
BTW, folks, been watching MLB Network, which is showing Don Larsen’s perfect game from the 1956 World Series. Between several innings, Costas has the battery in the studio with him, Larsen and Yogi. Very cool. 15 future Hall of Famers were involved in that game. And as Costas said, one guy who didn’t make the HOF had the best game of anybody.
Plus, the announcers were Mel Allen and … Vin Scully! What a wonderful sport.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 9:12 PM | Link to this
I was about to say Yogi deserved a Presidential Medal of Freedom or a Congressional Gold Medal, but he’s already won both. And clearly earned them. What a national treasure.
By Moby Grape
January 1, 2009 9:14 PM | Link to this
If the “.280 20 HR and 85 RBI” produces a .280/.330/.450 line, then your expectations for our LF-middle of the order hitter are different than mine Efrim
I did not say anything about cheapest and I have absolutely no interest in Anderson.My point was that it might be more likely that they can pick up a guy who can hit righties well and add him to Matt’s .310/.355 or so against lefties. I think it is highly unlikely that they are going to sign the kind of big bopper 155 game starter that you want. A platoon could be a reasonable substitite.
Some on here act like its a brand of shame. Tell that to the Yank,Orioles etc who won a lot of games with several platoons goping at different positions.
They kept Diaz, he is not versatile or athletic enough to ever play center so he is not their 4th outfielder on a regular basis. I think that in itself tells us which way the wind could be blowing.
By Mark
January 1, 2009 9:16 PM | Link to this
Maybe all the braves play up to each ones potential and we win division by like 20 games..isnt that what its about liveing up to potential…
By Mark
January 1, 2009 9:18 PM | Link to this
I forgot to ask does anyone know if comcast will have that new baseball channel and if so how much money??
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 9:27 PM | Link to this
Mark,
All I can say is check your local listings. MLB Is on DirecTV (which I subscribe to), but the home page says it will be on Comcast, Time Warner and other cable systems. No extra charge, at least on DirecTV (just like the NFL Network).
By Braveheart
January 1, 2009 9:28 PM | Link to this
BTW, folks, been watching MLB Network, which is showing Don Larsen’s perfect game from the 1956 World Series. Between several innings, Costas has the battery in the studio with him, Larsen and Yogi. Very cool. 15 future Hall of Famers were involved in that game. And as Costas said, one guy who didn’t make the HOF had the best game of anybody
They’d better keep the Mickey Mantle orgasms from Bob Costas and Billy Crystal to a minimum on that channel. The last thing I need is anymore of Costas and Crystal acting like Meg Ryan in a diner at the mere mention of the Mick’s name.
By Doc Holiday
January 1, 2009 9:30 PM | Link to this
Salty Dawg
I agree that Blanco has not established himself as the regular CF, but you would have to agree that being 3rd on the team in OBP with .360+, just behind Chipper and McCann (players with more than 400AB), tied with yunel and ahead of KJ, is quite an accomplishment. For a rookie or a player so young, that says a lot of him. I would give him more chance to proof himself than JF (at least as we speak).
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 9:31 PM | Link to this
Moby
Nothing wrong with platoon players. Garret Anderson’s not a very productive guy vs. lefties or righties. In recent years, Jr. Griffey and Jim Edmonds have shown great lefty/righty splits.
If either one would be willing to become a platoon-only LF, the Braves could get some excellent production with Diaz on the other side.
By TennesseePaul
January 1, 2009 9:31 PM | Link to this
that, boys and girls, will not be good news
Yes. But don’t dare think of letting you believe that this was a failure on Frank Wren’s part. He is a flawless GM if there ever was one.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 9:33 PM | Link to this
Braveheart,
FWIW, Costas isn’t listed as one of the network’s primary on-air personalites. But I’ve always said, if you don’t like what they’re showing, or who’s there, no one’s forcing you to tune in.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 9:34 PM | Link to this
Anders Problem is that if you overwhelm Lowe by offering him tons more money, you end up making a very fiscally unsound move that could hurt your club in the future. I agree with you that the Braves need to get off their high horse when it comes to agents they won’t deal with. Between Wasserman and Boras, that’s a lot of players being represented. As a matter of fact, Moylan is represented by Tellem. Does that mean that he is automatically out the door when the time comes?
BravesFanInRockies If the Phils would pay about $12 million of the $9 million due to Eaton, you might consider him …
Your math is a bit off:-)
I keep hearing about Matt Diaz in a LF platoon, but that’s because of Bobby Cox. fact is, Diaz can hit anything thrown his way. In his career, he’s hitting .307 against righties with 384 ABs, and .328 with 408 ABs gainst lefties. I wouldn’t have a problem with Diaz playing everyday. In regards to the starting rotation, I’m praying that Smoltz is ready to go at the start of the season. I would love for the Braves to take a chance on Ben Sheets, for better or worse. It’s not like the Braves have never rolled the dice before on pitchers. Their history is loaded with bad moves. Might as well try one more time. No move is gonna be as bad as trading for that loser Len Barker in 1983, or trading Bedrock to Philly and then he wins the Cy Young as a closer. At any rate, Sheets is worth the gamble. A rotation of Sheets/Smoltz/Jurrjens/Vasquez/and Hanson or Campillo would be good. But if we can’t get Sheets, then I can live with Campillo as the 5th starter.
By Anders
January 1, 2009 9:46 PM | Link to this
Braveheart
very funny 9:28 post. I was thinking the same thing.
I wonder what outlets like ESPN will do about this? I’ll be honest, I’m more likely to turn on MLB.com first now so I don’t have to sit through all the NBA and college stuff on ESPN. I doubt I’m alone.
Lastly, John Heyman is on there too. That guy is on SI.com, WFAN Radio, MLB.com and another outlet that is slipping my mind. How does he decide where to break a story? We could solve the employment issues if he would just stick to one job and allow others to work!
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 9:51 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
Yup, I’d love to see the Braves go for Sheets. High risk, high reward. And how would that be different than what they tried with Burnett — for a lot more money?
As for Diaz, we must be looking at different sites for his split statistics. Baseball Reference says his career splits vs. lefties are .328/.361/.508 and his number vs. righties are .288/.325/.381.
The guy kills lefties and is merely OK vs. righties. I could say he’s no better than Francoeur vs. righties, but in fact, Frenchy’s not that good against righties or lefties …
So if you were deciding who to play and who to bench as a platoon guy, you’d actually bench JF. Against everybody. Ouch.
By Braveheart
January 1, 2009 9:53 PM | Link to this
FWIW, Costas isn’t listed as one of the network’s primary on-air personalites. But I’ve always said, if you don’t like what they’re showing, or who’s there, no one’s forcing you to tune in
I wholeheartedly agree with you on that. As Howard Stern always says, turn the station ….. if I’m gonna offend you, why are you sticking around to get offended? But, man, Crystal and Costas really got carried away with that Mickey Mantle thing for a while there.
By Moby Grape
January 1, 2009 9:56 PM | Link to this
I keep hearing about Matt Diaz in a LF platoon, but that’s because of Bobby Cox. fact is, Diaz can hit anything thrown his way. In his career, he’s hitting .307 against righties with 384 ABs, and .328 with 408 ABs gainst lefties. *Jerald8
I’d prefer someone with more power sharing the LF duties with him. Matt’s S% against righties is not all that hot. Find me a guy who can slug .500+ against right handed pitching, puhleeese.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 10:01 PM | Link to this
Anders,
MLB Network sounds wonderful. I’m a big college football and college hoops fan, but I tell ya, if MLB consciously covers the entire sport and doesn’t focus so tightly on the Yanks, the BoSox and (yes) the Mets, I’ll watch it often.
You understand why ESPN has that bias — it’s in their back yard, they dedicate an hour a day of their programming to baseball, and New York and Boston teams have the huge markets and the fanatical followings, but there are a couple dozen other teams and their stories deserve telling, too.
By Salty Dawg
January 1, 2009 10:07 PM | Link to this
Jerald Holcombe
I keep hearing about Matt Diaz in a LF platoon, but that’s because of Bobby Cox. fact is, Diaz can hit anything thrown his way. In his career, he’s hitting .307 against righties with 384 ABs, and .328 with 408 ABs gainst lefties. I wouldn’t have a problem with Diaz playing everyday. In regards to the starting rotation, I’m praying that Smoltz is ready to go at the start of the season. I would love for the Braves to take a chance on Ben Sheets, for better or worse. It’s not like the Braves have never rolled the dice before on pitchers. Their history is loaded with bad moves. Might as well try one more time. No move is gonna be as bad as trading for that loser Len Barker in 1983, or trading Bedrock to Philly and then he wins the Cy Young as a closer. At any rate, Sheets is worth the gamble. A rotation of Sheets/Smoltz/Jurrjens/Vasquez/and Hanson or Campillo would be good. But if we can’t get Sheets, then I can live with Campillo as the 5th starter.
Good point regarding Diaz. A lot of people overlook the fact that the guy can (and has) hit well against both lefties and righties. I never really understood Bobby’s propensity to platoon so much. Especially when you factor in that the hitter is likely to only face the starting pitcher 2 times per game, maybe 3, before the bullpen takes over. But I too would not mind seeing Diaz take the field as an every day player, or at least given the opportunity. I also won’t be surprised or disappointed to see Campillo in the rotation this year. Gotta think he will only improve over last year and be able to stay effective deeper into the season than last being more adjusted to a full season. Bobby Cox always spoke very highly of Campillo and unless he craps the bed in spring training and someone else steps up, I think we will see him in the rotation.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 10:21 PM | Link to this
Salty Dawg,
I wouldn’t say Diaz has hit well against righties for a corner OF. His power numbers against righties aren’t at all impressive, and face it, the Braves OF is mighty anemic.
As a platoon player, he’s a good choice. I’d put him out there vs. lefties every chance I got. But the Braves really need somebody who can mash the ball vs. RHP. And Diaz hasn’t shown he’s that guy. Nor has Frenchy. The team needs a bat.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 10:22 PM | Link to this
Especially for a team that lost 90 games in 2008 and has missed the playoffs three straight years, I would certainly hope the Braves would not be complacent regarding their offense.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 10:26 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies As for Diaz, we must be looking at different sites for his split statistics. Baseball Reference says his career splits vs. lefties are .328/.361/.508 and his number vs. righties are .288/.325/.381.
Your numbers may be more true than mine because mine are from 2006-2008. Anything before that didn’t seem too relevant to me. As for Francoeur, lets just hope that he turns it all around in 2009. He has too much talent to have another season like 2008. If he doesn’t improve, it’ll be a long year. On another note, with all the players we keep mentioning as getting playing time, we need to remember the great play of Omar Infante.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 10:27 PM | Link to this
Watching halftime at the Orange Bowl. Barry Switzer’s zoot suit may induce seizures.
But for a calming effect, here come the Doobie Brothers!
By MEB
January 1, 2009 10:33 PM | Link to this
I don’t know how much of Harold Reynolds I can stand but it looks like we are going to get a mega dose. This being a MLB production I’m also not sure how critical they will be of players and management. At least ESPN and other outlets can be critical as they want. Will they be able to do this on the MLB Network? I don’t know but I’m thinking not so much.
Well at least the classic games and Costas interviews with Hall of Fame greats will be entertaining.
Is anybody on cable getting the broadcast in HDTV? I have Time-Warner and we are not getting HD. Dang!!!
GO BRAVES!!!
By Dixie Dawg
January 1, 2009 10:40 PM | Link to this
Lord, this has been an uneventful offseason. I hope the Falcons can prolong their season cuz I don’t think we are goin to have anything to look forward to for the 09 season.
It’s sad how nobody wants to come here. This once proud dynasty is no longer the Braves that we knew.
I wish the Braves would blow up the team and rebuild. Maybe we’ll be competive in a couple of years.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 10:46 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies Especially for a team that lost 90 games in 2008 and has missed the playoffs three straight years, I would certainly hope the Braves would not be complacent regarding their offense.
Not gonna argue this point because we all know it has to improve over the lousy year our outfield had in 2008. But, if there is no legitimate hitter out there, then what can you do? I totally disagree with anyone who thinks that Dunn is the answer. I’ve seen that guy play defense and it’s just not fair to subject a fan to that. Then there’s all those freakin strikeouts. No thanks! Burrell’s not much better. I would take Abreu but haven’t heard the first rumor about him. I did hear today that the Giants are considering going after Manny Ramirez. If that actually does happen, then the Giants may need to dump the salary of someone like Randy Winn in order to be able to afford high dollars to Manny. Winn would a nice piece to add. Whaddaya think?
By Mitchie-san
January 1, 2009 10:50 PM | Link to this
My favorite moment over the past few years is not a Braves memory either. Well, it does include a former Brave…
Watching Carlos Beltran get turned into frozen pizza on that Adam Wainwright curveball to eliminate the Mets.
I hear he is still standing there with the bat on his shoulder….
By Braveheart
January 1, 2009 10:52 PM | Link to this
Diaz was something the Braves could afford because we first had Andruw and then had Tex.. We also somewhat knew what we were gonna get from Frenchy, even with his limitations.
That was the thing about Andruw that folks never appreciated. He gave us + corner production from an up the middle slot. Offensively and defensively, Andruw allowed the Braves to take shortcuts at corner slots. His offense and defense was so good, the Braves didn’t always need + value offensively and defensively at the corners. McCann and, to a degree, Javy have also afforded the Braves that luxury over the last 15 years (at least offensively).
Besides McCann, the Braves are no longer getting offensive value from an up the middle position that is the equivalent of + value for a corner guy. Escobar and KJ give + value for middle infielders that merely rises to the level of an average corner. Even though McCann does give + offensive value relative to a corner, he only gets out there 80% of the time, so his value offensively relative to an everyday corner is not all that much more than an average everyday corner.
If you’re not getting value up the middle that is considered + for a corner, it becomes even more imperative to get that + value for a corner from an actual corner.
Andruw is no longer allowing the Braves the luxury of cutting corners. Kotchman is not Tex and only gives average or slightly below value offensively for a corner. There’s no telling what Frenchy will do next season. Will he get back to being an average corner, a below average corner or a woeful corner? It likely doesn’t matter ‘cause he likely won’t give + value —— and even if he does, that ain’t something the Braves could ever reasonably foresee or count on before the season starts. Who knows what they’ll get in center. It likely will not even be average value offensively for a centerfielder.
Without an up the middle guy giving + value for a corner and without a corner besides Chipper giving + offensive value for a corner, I don’t see how the Braves could go into next season with Diaz being slotted to get any significant time in left. Not with Frenchy also on the team.
Tthe Braves likely would be better off trading Frenchy, getting a + corner bat for right and platooning someone with Diaz in left. To me, Diaz in a platoon with some other dude is more of a sure thing to be an average corner next season than Frenchy. if they don’t go out and get some big time centerfielder, I don’t see how Frenchy and Diaz are both on the team when the season starts. Neither gives the hope of giving, at best, anything more than average value for a corner.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 11:08 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
Winn would be an intriguing choice. He’s not a power hitter, and that’s what the Braves ideally need.
But he does other things well — gets on base, has gap power, steals bases without ever getting caught, plays solid D.
In an odd way, he’d give you the same kind of offense you would get from Rafael Furcal. I don’t know what the Giants would want in return, but chances are, not much — it would basically be a salary dump.
I’d rather sign Edmonds or Griffey or trade for Jermaine Dye (if he doesn’t cost too much in return).
But Winn would improve the offense in different ways.
Besides, he could play RF if Frenchy flops (again)!
By Braveheart
January 1, 2009 11:12 PM | Link to this
I wish the Braves would blow up the team and rebuild. Maybe we’ll be competive in a couple of years
Rebuild? Huh? Most of them are still in their club controlled seasons ….. McCann, Kotchman, KJ, Escobar, Infante, Nitram, Blanco, Frenchy, Diaz, Schafer, Anderson, Morton, Reyes, Campillo, Boyer, Acosta, Bennett, Hanson, Soriano, Gonzalez, Moylan, Jurrjens
……. and that’s the best of the best of our major league ready kids. Those are the ones good enough to be in the majors. Lately, the Braves haven’t exactly been shy about having kids who aren’t even ready on the team. Are you really dying to see the kids who weren’t deemed good enough to get time last year on a 90 loss team going nowhere? I ain’t.
The issue last season was that their vets weren’t healthy, the major league kids they were already grooming didn’t blossom into studs, and the Braves had no one in the AAA or AA level that could step in and be respectable major leaguers. The answers aren’t in the minors. They need to get some healthy + value vets and get some of the kids already here to become + value guys as well.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 11:19 PM | Link to this
Braveheart
You use the phrase “average value” alot in your last post. What do you define as “average value”? And are you talking about your definition of “average value” of a position player? In all my years being a fan of baseball, I’ve never seen “average value” determined by anyone inside the sport. Please, enlighten me.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 11:19 PM | Link to this
Braveheart,
You have to wonder if the Braves could get anything more than a bucket of balls for Francoeur after 2008. I’m afraid they’re stuck with him for at least the early part of 2009. If he rebounds, then you can move him at the deadline or after the season. If instead he stinks the joint up, they’ll be out of it by the All Star break and they can bench him or dump him then.
That’s why I prefer getting a platoon partner for Diaz (again, Griffey or Edmonds) if they have no intention of signing Dunn or Burrell to hit cleanup and play LF every day.
Also, my guess is the front office believes Schafer will win the CF job in the spring. If he plays the way he’s supposed to, they could get, say, Blanco’s on-base performance along with some decent power (10-15 HR, 35 2B or so).
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 11:29 PM | Link to this
Now, this is really weird. The Dodgers are reworking Andruw’s contract so that they can a) unload him and b) sign Manny.
From what I can gather, the Dodgers will do something like buy an annuity so that Andruw will get all his money, just over a longer period of time. But in return, Andruw’s contract for 2009 will be worth less, making him more attractive to another team.
Please, God, don’t let the Braves be that team.
But Coletti is essentially saying the Andruw signing was a huge mistake.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 1, 2009 11:31 PM | Link to this
It amazes me how so many of you are willing to sh?tcan Francoeur after having such a crappy season lasy year. You act like what he did previous to 2008 was an aberration. This is the same guy who came up in 2005 and hit .300 for the second half of the season. Then, he drove in more than 100 runs each in 2006 and 2007. And you wanna give up on something like that. You are ready to believe that 2008 was the real Jeff Francoeur? You people need help. Lots and lots of help.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 11:40 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
Braveheart can speak for himself, but the usual idea is that you need to get premium offense from at least four spots on the field: 1B, 3B, LF, RF. It’s a bonus to get plus production from the other “defensive” positions, too, of course. But if you’re lacking offense at one of the premium positions, you have to make it up someplace else. And you can’t really afford to get below average offense from any of the premium spots.
In 2008, the Braves got a plus at 3B, C, 2B and (maybe) SS. But below average from 1B (after Tex left), and all three OF spots.
The way the roster is currently constructed, the Braves face the same questions they had at the end of 2008. Kotchman has the potential to put up Mark Grace-like numbers or even better, but he hasn’t done it at the major league level yet. Schafer keeps being compared to Grady Sizemore, but again, he has to produce. Frenchy and Diaz are question marks, to be kind.
Without any fresh additions, everyone other than Chipper and Heap will need to have a career year in 2009 to make this team competitive. I’d feel better if they added some talent.
By csg
January 1, 2009 11:42 PM | Link to this
Jerald, the guy sucks. He’s posted a sub .300 OBP twice in 4 years. His power numbers continue to drop every year. When your hitting behind Chipper, McCann, Renty, Escobar, KJ, and Tex you should be able to drive in 100 runs.
By Braveheart
January 1, 2009 11:45 PM | Link to this
You use the phrase “average value” alot in your last post. What do you define as “average value”? And are you talking about your definition of “average value” of a position player? In all my years being a fan of baseball, I’ve never seen “average value” determined by anyone inside the sport. Please, enlighten me
In an average run environment, an average positional player should have an ops around .760. An average corner bat should be around .800. An average middle infielder and centerfielder should be around .720. An average catcher should be around .700. Every 40 or so ops points above or below for each position relative to the average dude at those positions should roughly be worth around +/- 10 runs. There’s a sh!tload of literature out there that describes this stuff in much better detail than I can.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 1, 2009 11:48 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
If Francoeur doesn’t rebound to at least 2007 levels in 2009, then he’s Brad Komminsk, Version 2.0, and probably out of baseball. Plenty of tools but no head for the game. Or at least no ability to figure out the difference between a pitch he can hit and one he can’t.
By Braveheart
January 2, 2009 12:02 AM | Link to this
BFIR, your 11:40 describes perfectly what I was trying to say.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 2, 2009 12:07 AM | Link to this
Braveheart, thanks. Now I’m outta here until next time.
By Moby Grape
January 2, 2009 12:18 AM | Link to this
Then, he drove in more than 100 runs each in 2006 and 2007. And you wanna give up on something like that. You are ready to believe that 2008 was the real Jeff Francoeur? You people need help. Lots and lots of help. Jerald
obviously you are not into modern stats or you wouldn’t have that question, so it’s probably not worth explaining to you past the point of saying that even in those years he was a flat-even average hitter with an OPS+ right around 100. So even if he bounces back to around that level, he is not anything special, and there is the possibility that he won’t come back that far. If you can’t get past BA/HR/RBI then you’ll think he’s just peachy.
By uga-brave
January 2, 2009 12:55 AM | Link to this
for all the prospect huggers out there?
read BRAVEHEART’S 10:32 post.
dead on.
i loved andruw. say this or that what he was or not, but he played everyday.
he played a defensive position. no one in the n.l. played a better cf.
never understood the bashing of andruw in his last season here.
yeah he had a rough ride, but he hit one less homerun then our entire outfield last year.
if one more person says diaz coming back is a plus, i will persoanally give bay area steve one of my great bottles of obans.
bay area steve, that will be a 20 year old bottle.
face the facts, why do you think js kicked himself upstairs.
he knew liberty was a lame duck owner.
so give the the job to ollie north (smilin frank) everyone needs someone to make their past accomplishments look better.
By uga-brave
January 2, 2009 1:10 AM | Link to this
braves fan in the rockies,
well done.
we are a plus at maybe three offensive positions.
bravey’s point is dead on. andruw was the rock.
we put guys like drew, sheff, tucker, gerald williams, chuck thomas, sanders, diaz, among others around him.
other then drew or sheff, none of any of those guys were first name guys.
By BravoMan
January 2, 2009 1:25 AM | Link to this
Okay Braves fans I got an idea. I know coming into this offseason our primary need was pitching. And in my opinion it still is, but I think I figured out our OF problems. Someone mentioned Randy Winn earlier. I like the idea of aquiring him because he can be the lead-off man we nearly had in the man whom I will not speak off(Furcal). He shouldn’t cost that much in a trade. He can also play CF and LF. I was one of the people earlier who thought adding Nick Swisher to our ballclub would benifit us. He’s versitile and he has power. Lets say we trade for Swisher and Winn. Either one can play CF or LF. Winn is a free agent after this year and therefore he wouldn’t block our young stud outfielders from coming to the Bigs. Swisher can play all OF spots and 1B, so if we had to we could trade Kotchman. As for pitching, keep an eye on the progress of Smoltzie and Glavine. We should have some focus on Lowe now but the guys old and wants a long term deal. We could take a look at Sheets for no more than 2 yrs. Then theres always Kawakami and Perez to check out too. We have a lot of options. And if our finances can allow this we should think about making this our line-up and aquiring one more starter. What do yea think?
1.R.Winn-CF 2.Y.Escobar-SS 3.C.Jones-3B 4.N.Swisher-LF 5.B.McCann-C 6.J.Francoeur-RF 7.C.Kotchman-1B 8.K.Johnson-2B
By KC
January 2, 2009 1:31 AM | Link to this
SURELY we’re going to make a pitch to D.Lowe!
We have to. The Mets initial offer - while it will certainly be improved by the Mets - shows that Lowe’s price tag is going to be attainable.
He won’t get anything close to the 18 million per season over 5 years that Boras says he wants for Lowe.
3 years 45 million might get it done, and the Braves can certainly afford to make that offer. If the Braves want any reasonable assurance of being competitive next year… they must make that offer.
By uga-brave
January 2, 2009 2:01 AM | Link to this
kc,
not fiscally responsible, not in the best interest of the frachise, we tried to make a couple of moves but we really like our core.
remember those thoughts or words.
smilin frank is already practicing them.
By N8
January 2, 2009 2:23 AM | Link to this
“never understood the bashing of andruw in his last season here.” uga-brave
For me personally? It was never about Andruw the player. It was never really about Andruw the person. It, however, was about Andruw the SCOTT BORAS CLIENT!
Andruw (under Boras’ nazi command, no doubt), wanted a king’s ransom in his walk year. After stinking it up (and it DID stink), for over a year, he and his agent should not have been such greedy pigs.
Period.
That being said, if the Dodgers would be interestd in eating about 90 percent of his contract to rid themselves of Andruw, I’d take him back to play LF and possibly platoon with Brandon Jones while batting 8th. LOL!
By J
January 2, 2009 2:38 AM | Link to this
i do not know why there is no faith in Frenchy - in his last 100 ABs he did bat around 290 and he is still very young.
By Frank Wren
January 2, 2009 2:43 AM | Link to this
Look, we like our young core ugabrave.
By ô¿ô
January 2, 2009 3:03 AM | Link to this
Any Chance the Braves might be interested in AJ if he becomes a free Agent?? I am sure he would love to come back to Atlanta and he should not cost much at all.
By Braveheart
January 2, 2009 3:10 AM | Link to this
1.R.Winn-CF 2.Y.Escobar-SS 3.C.Jones-3B 4.N.Swisher-LF 5.B.McCann-C 6.J.Francoeur-RF 7.C.Kotchman-1B 8.K.Johnson-2B
How is Randy Winn and Nick Swisher much different than going into last year with Mark Kotsay and Matt Diaz? The Braves need a big bat. Winn and Swisher are nice and all but Winn is not a leadoff hitter and Swisher is not a cleanup hitter. That’s really the issue here.
One thing I could see the Braves doing is asking 10 to bat 4th. I think that was maybe the direction they were heading with the Furcal fascination. The Braves don’t currently have any guys who seem destined to become true leadoff or cleanup hitters. Escobar and KJ, however, if they take their games to the next level, could become suitable enough #3 hitters.
Throughout his career, 10 has always been the prototypical major league #3 hitter. When he was healthy and young that meant .300/30/100 year in and year out. Now that he’s old and often injured, he has had to be content with .300/.400/.550 when he’s ready and able. But maybe he needs to change that a bit based on team need and defining his legacy.
10 has reached a level of mastery in his game that he could easily adjust to add more power to his game if he wanted to as a cleanup hitter. He can do whatever he wants with a bat in his hand now. He’s always been somewhat like Tom Brady - he can Wes Welker the D or Randy Moss the D depending on what the D gives him, what the team needs or what he wants to do. Last year, he seemed content to just Wes Welker them to death in his quest for a batting title.
10’s got his batting title now. He has somewhat built enough of a cushion to maintain a .300 batting average for his career. He’s entered the legacy defining stage of his career. All he’s got left is winning another World Series and going for 3000 hits and/or 500 homers. 3000 hits would likely take him another 5 seasons to reach. He could get to 500 in 3 or 4 seasons. He’s already one of the five best switch hitters and five best third baseman in the history of the game. 3000 and 500 are critical for his legacy. He’s a HOFer regardless. 500, however, sits him on the third base throne alone with Eddie Mathews and Mike Schmidt. He needs magical numbers like 3000 and/or 500 to sit comfortably on the switch hitting throne with Mantle, Rose, and Murray.
It wouldn’t shock me to see him take the ‘99 tricks out of his shed taught to him by Baylor and go for broke trying to hit 500 homers. Maybe he will sense time is running out and that 500 is more reasonably achievable than 3000. He has been hitting the weights hard this winter.
It could work out well for his legacy and for this 2009 team if they don’t get themselves another legit #4 quality hitter and if Escobar or KJ take their games to the next level. I really could see 10 throwing more bombs to Moss next year instead of settling for underneath throws to Welker like he did last year.
Of course, he could always keep on being the prototypical #3 hitter he’s always taken immense pride in being. I’m afraid, however, that if he does, time may run out and he may never get to 3000 or 500. Since 3000 seems a long shot anyway, he might as well go 500 or bust.
By BA
January 2, 2009 3:38 AM | Link to this
Braveheart, sir- you’re on quite a roll this evening. By this 10 batting cleanup theory, Abreu would make sense (to me) as a #3 hitter in left field.
But what I really liked was the stuff earlier about players values (corners vs. middles). Using these standards, does Dunn qualify as an above average corner? I’m no stat guru, but hitting .240-something and striking out 140 times stinks, walks or not.
I agree that with Schafer and Frenchy, we could survive a Dunn or a Burrell defensively, but would they really solve the problem, or just give opposing pitchers a third batter (with Frenchy and KJ) to strike out the side?
On an unrelated subject, middle relief is one of my concerns that I never see discussed here. Oh-man pitched 148 innings last year, and Boyer’s era was revolting. Who’s going to be as effective as Oh-man? If you’re going to bring back the Ugly Stick, you might as well pay the Oh-man.
-I will now serve a voluntary 24 hour suspension for breaking rule number (?) and addressing a veteran out of turn.-
By Bill
January 2, 2009 9:12 AM | Link to this
Jerald-agree-Please God, no to A Jones!!!
Yea, Francoeur is so great nobody wants him. Diaz and A Jones more crap. Man we really look good. Fans will pack the stands……across town at AAA.
By rico carty
January 2, 2009 9:25 AM | Link to this
Braveheart, EXCELLENT 3:10 AM post. Very good analysis of Chipper’s legacy, etc. I too want him to get 500/3000, but time may be running out on 3000 with his reduced AB. If he did get both, then only he and Eddie Murray would be switchhitters with both. Chipper’s a Hall of Famer right now, if he walked away, but I’d love to see him get those marks if possible.
He is such a great player that he could slide into the cleanup spot and slightly adjust his game. Maybe our best option is to play some small ball with Anderson/Schafer/Gorkys (any way he is a possibility this year?) leading off, then Escobar of KJ 2nd and the other 3rd in front of Chipper. If we don’t land a real cleanup hitter, that may be the best option. Another anemic year for power hitting, but our best bats would be 2-5 and maybe score a few runs.
Still can’t believe Furcal screwed us like that.
By Dadgum
January 2, 2009 9:42 AM | Link to this
Happy New Year to all…if ever a new year was ever needed it is this one.
Been a while since I posted due to the holidays et al. but a few things I see unfolding. First, Lowe ain’t signing with Atlanta. He has, I believe, officially turned down the Mets 36 mil/3 offer and looking for AJ Burnette type money. Can’t see the Braves going there.
Those that opine that maybe Sheets will be the answer, well no. He will command about 10 mil + and a good bet not to finish the season. In addition, he will go to Texas if Texas wishes to take that gamble. Not even in the weirdest scenarios can I see Sheets in a bRaves uniform.
While the Braves would have preferred to sign a top free agent to go with Vazquez as a starter it appears that isn’t likely to happen. With Wolf guilty by association and Garland coveted by the Mets I can’t see where the Braves gain much by signing another 2nd or 3rd tier pitcher.
This could very well be the year we have to trade at mid-season if we are still in the hunt. Smoltz may or may not be in our plans. A rotation of Jurrjens, Vazquez, REyes, Morton, Hanson may have to suffice. I am not expecting the Braves to acquire any other pitchers at this point unless Wren pulls a rabbit out of the hat. Time to go with youth and a lot of it.
Since I was reading up on the Braves free agents I noticed that Tim Hudson will be a free agent after 2010 with a 12 mil mutual option. Now that will be an interesting call for either the team or player. Does he pitch well enough in ‘10 that he tests the waters or poor enough following surgery that the Braves don’t pick up the option. Personally can’t see him with Atlanta past ‘10 but it’s early. Maybe Atlanta will be a good enough team and he will pitch well in ‘10 where they will both want each other. Who knows but it will be interesting. Just throwing this out there since we have rehashed every other scenario over multiple blogs for months.
Rock on
By keylargo
January 2, 2009 9:51 AM | Link to this
This is from an article by Ken Gurnick of MLB.com
Jones finished the season hitting .158 with three homers and 14 RBIs, playing in 75 games. Not exactly what the club had in mind when it signed him to the highest annual salary in club history. Nor was it expected that Jones would arrive in Spring Training noticeably overweight, slow of foot and bat speed. And he compounded it with poorly chosen words about not caring what the fans thought about his play.
Hot Stove
Jones, 32 in April, is a 10-time Gold Glove winner and five-time All-Star, but the Dodgers saw none of that. He vowed before leaving the club to report to 2009 Spring Training in better shape. He also said he would play winter ball in the Dominican Republic, where he has played five games, hitting .188 with no extra-base hits and eight strikeouts in 16 at-bats. He went home for the holidays, but the club expected him to resume playing in the Dominican Republic next week.
At the time Jones left the club, Colletti was asked if he remembered another player to fall so far so fast.
*”I can’t think of one and I’ve tried for the last five months,” he said. *
In my opinion, there is no circumstance that would allow AJ back on this team. Anyone who thinks he has anything in mind other than collecting the $22 million Scott Boras conned the Dodgers out of is delusional.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 10:10 AM | Link to this
rico carty, I have Chipper as the second best switch hitter ever behind Mantle.
We Braves fans seem to take Chipper for granted.
Many fans, even Braves fans, do not like Chipper. A lot of it is probably because of the personal problems early in his career, which is understandable. Also, the Braves did not go deep into the playoffs that often after Chipper’s second season. Chipper was seen as the leader of the team and therefore became an easy scapegoat, it seems. Chipper also has a very relaxed swagger that comes across as lackadaisical and arrogant. However, looking at the evidence, we can clearly see Chipper doesn’t deserve the criticism he’s received as a baseball player.
Whatever you think of his attitude or his early-career philandering, Chipper Jones is an all-time great. Not only is the statistical evidence telling, when you listen to or read about Chipper Jones being interviewed he sounds like one of the smartest baseball minds ever to play the game. He honestly seems like the type of guy who could become a solid manager or even general manager one day.
So don’t let the swagger fool you. Don’t be swayed by the things in Jones’ personal life that may influence your opinion of him. No matter what you think of him or how he carries himself, Chipper Jones is one of the greatest players you’ve ever seen.
By Steve from OH
January 2, 2009 10:34 AM | Link to this
Shaun, exactly. And even if Chipper’s personal hiccups bother you, that should be negated by his willingness to take less money to stay with the Braves. The dude re-structured his contract to help free up cash for the Braves…if that’s not a team player, I don’t know what is. The dude is an all-time great on the field and (though I don’t know him personally) seems to be a pretty good guy off the field. There shouldn’t even be any debate.
By ncgary
January 2, 2009 10:38 AM | Link to this
id like to see sheets too, why not take a 3 year gamble , even if he has tj surgery you still have an ace for half the contract.. 3years 40 million would get it done , i think.the potential is there. besides its not my money. lol, why youre at it offer bradley a contract too , and hope the med ward isnt needed,
or trade the gwinnet braves for halladay and rios
lol
i know im and idiot
lol
By proeye
January 2, 2009 10:46 AM | Link to this
I think the problem is that the Braves can’t figure out what kind of ball club they are going to be. We have transitioned from a free spending championship caliber team, to a limited spending shadow of a ball club, to a transitioning team with $$$ that can’t figure out what it wants to do.
As far as approaches, we have the Marlins and Twins on one end and the Yankees and Red Sox on the other. Note that all four have won WS with their approaches more than once since divisional play. It seems to me that the past two off seasons, the Braves can’t figure out which end of the spectrum they are going to play closer to. I realize that they probably can’t be exactly like any of those teams but they can at least try to come up with a plan! I think be spack dab in the middle basically gets you nowhere.
Why go into an auction without at least trying to beat out other teams for your prize? They did this twice. Why set this arbitrary limit and lose out on what could have been your difference maker? It’s not like the other teams were that far off from your offer. Why go into a trade without thinking you may have to go beyond your original pre-determined arbitrary limit?
Basically the Braves have been embarrassed. They are not the same team they were a decade ago when they could pretty much get whatever they wanted. YES there IS a spending limit or we would have had our men by now. The Braves are no longer one of the top 3 teams in the majors in spending.
Okay, there is some more “off season” still to come, but I’m not holding my breath. Wren has not done a very good job so far.
Really, this could all be a result of the economy but it’s not like anyone is going to admit that. I haven’t heard anyone in management talk about this. Seems to me that this off season is no different than the last 3. It’s like everyone is playing this cat and mouse game to see who makes the first move(s).
By AustinBraves
January 2, 2009 10:53 AM | Link to this
The Red Sox have just announced that Clay Buchholz is on the market. Maybe a future Ace. The best thing about him is that you would have him tied up for 6 years. Maybe a gamble if you don’t have to give up the farm. What does everyone think?
By DAP
January 2, 2009 10:54 AM | Link to this
don from new years eve: Smoltz (in fortys, 5 significant arm operations, only 1 good year in recent years)
dont look at stats much hunh? you have to go back to 1988 (smoltz’s rookie year) to find a non-injury season that wasnt good.
to everyone complaining about the blog, the content, the vacation info, the food and music stuff…you do realize that DOB is on vacation, right? you guys are absolute jerks. im sure you realize this, DOB, but very few of us feel that way, and are grateful that you would take the time to write a blog on your vacation. you care about what you do, and it shows. thanks, youre the best.
braveheart How is Randy Winn and Nick Swisher much different than going into last year with Mark Kotsay and Matt Diaz? The Braves need a big bat. Winn and Swisher are nice and all but Winn is not a leadoff hitter and Swisher is not a cleanup hitter.
winn would actually make a pretty good leadoff hitter. decent power, solid OBP, and good defensively in the outfield. id rather have swisher, who has more power, and good on base ability. plus, he has a very team friendly contract. i wouldnt bat him cleanup though. id bat swisher 5th and let mac cleanup. sandwiched between chipper and swisher, two switch hitters with power, i think he would do well.
By raymond
January 2, 2009 11:05 AM | Link to this
After watching our lack of activity in the off season I can only come to the conclusion that the Braves have decided to go with the youngsters and save money. Even if they decided to spend money, who would want to come to Atlanta. I’m sure we could get someone here if we overpaid them but that is not going to happen. I’ll make a prediction, if Smoltz makes it back you will see him or Chipper wave their no trade status and be traded to a contender by the All Star break so we can pick up some more cheap prospects. This is not the same Braves of the Ted Turner era, but I wish ole Ted was still here, I would even put up with Jane ( something Ted could not do).
By JC from UT
January 2, 2009 11:19 AM | Link to this
SHAUN: Your post about Chipper could not be more dead on. I hope he doas finish his playing career with the Braves and then slide into being a caoch for a couple years then manager. He would be grat to replace Bobby if the gap in years wasn’t so big. There is no reason why he cannot be the lifelong Braves icon much the way Ernie Banks is with the Cubs or Mickey Mantle/Yogi Berrs is with the Yankees.
By Steve McP
January 2, 2009 11:25 AM | Link to this
Why would the Braves want to sign Nick Swisher?
In 2008 he had the worst batting average among players with at least 502 plate appearances, the number needed to qualify for the batting title. His BA was . 219, slugging .410
Frenchy with his BA of .239 and 434 slugging has been much maligned on this site, yet he out performed according to these stats - yes Swisher did hit more homers, but I can’t imagine the frustration of watching him get out in important situations.
By Bill
January 2, 2009 11:27 AM | Link to this
Shaun—You are right on…Chipper is the Best!! Mad Dog, Chipper and Smoltz are very smart baseball men, all three would be a great Mgr. All three 1st class.
No, to Winn and Swisher.
By JC from UT
January 2, 2009 11:28 AM | Link to this
AustinBrave: Who are you giving up for Buchholtz? The article said Boston is looking for a young star. Would Yunel qualify? They might be looking for a SS since they were looking into Hanely Rameriz. How about Yunel and Francouer for Buccholtz and JD Drew? Drew had a great year here before and seemed to really like BC and Chipper. Maybe boston will eat some of Julio Lugo’s contract and he can replace Yunel at ss
By Bill M.
January 2, 2009 11:30 AM | Link to this
Would the Braves consider trading McCann? Sherman is writing some crazy rumors. What would the Red Sox’s have that would make the Braves better? I’m all for it, if it would make Braves alot better.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 11:41 AM | Link to this
csg You’re losing it bub. Just because we had guys on base ahead of Francoeur doesn’t mean anything unless he brings them in, and that is why we have a stat like RISP. Since Francoeur has been in the bigs, he has had guys in scoring position. In 2005, he hit .338. In 2006 he hit .320. In 2007 his RISP was .341. Last year his RISP dropped all the way down to .192. That is the only reason why we are even having this discussion. If Francoeur had followed suit last year with his other years, he would still be one of the most untouchable players on the roster. The way you react with the year he last year, it’s a good thing that Chipper didn’t have 1 bad year early in his career. He would’ve blasted him too.
By ozzie
January 2, 2009 11:41 AM | Link to this
If there is a LF platoon in 09 with Diaz and anyone else expect a photo copy of 2008 with lots of one run losses.
Diaz is a scrappy player with no power (apart from BP) and is marginal defensively.
The Braves cannot draw snake eyes in the rotation and LF this off season.
If they do 4th or even last place is where they are headed.
That will kill attendance and put Wren on the hot seat IMHO.
They don’t need to win the division or even the WC but coming in close to dead last with another 90 loss season is not acceptable for a 95mm payroll.
Liberty has no loyalty to Wren so I cannot see them being happy with half empty stadiums and irate fans.
Wren needs to get Dunn and his lock 40hrs b/c no one on the Braves will even sniff that number.
By Random
January 2, 2009 11:41 AM | Link to this
Jerald Holcombe: “It amazes me how so many of you are willing to sh?tcan Francoeur after having such a crappy season lasy year. You act like what he did previous to 2008 was an aberration. This is the same guy who came up in 2005 and hit .300 for the second half of the season. Then, he drove in more than 100 runs each in 2006 and 2007. And you wanna give up on something like that. You are ready to believe that 2008 was the real Jeff Francoeur? You people need help. Lots and lots of help.”
Check out this Baseball Prospectus Player Profile of Francoeur for a deeper and more informed analysis of his career, in particular its downward trajectory from pretty much Day One.
Here are some excerpts:
He made steps toward this [maturing at the plate] in 2007, at least at first glance. He jumped his line up to .293/.338/.444, which appeared to be an improvement thanks to the increased OBP (and a rise in his walk rate to 6.1 percent). Once you notice that his BABIP (.342, similar to his first season’s, and above expectations generated by a line-drive rate of 19.4 percent) and ISO (down to .151, the second season in a row with a significant drop in power) were out of whack, any optimism begins to fade.
Neither of these issues were taken care of in 2008. Francoeur had the worst season of his professional career, hitting all of .239/.294/.359, with walks in 6.1 percent of his plate appearances, and a .120 ISO fit for a light-hitting middle infielder, not for a corner outfielder who’s built like a home-run factory… .
The lack of plate discipline is at the root of his stagnating development. Francoeur knows and understands the problem, but the way he has gone about trying to solve it—taking pitches just because he knows he needs to, rather than learning which pitches to take and when—is keeping him from reaching his full potential, or in the case of 2008, even a sizable fraction of it. His continued struggle against right-handers also looms large, as hitters who can’t deal with them aren’t very valuable as everyday players.
As a 25-year-old heading into 2009, Francoeur still has time to improve his game and deliver a peak worthy of the hype surrounding his first years as a professional. As of now though, he is a disappointing player who may have his heart in the right place—he has tried to rectify the situation—but who has failed to deliver on his promise. An extended stay in the minors may be best for all involved—the Braves fancy themselves a contender for the NL East title, and if not for their injuries in 2008, would have been in the mix with the talent on hand—as Francoeur needs to learn basic strike-zone judgment before he’ll be able to make it as a productive right fielder at the plate. —Marc Normandin
Jeff’s plate discipline is a major, major concern, and unfortunately he has done literally nothing to show any hint of improvement. In his rookie season, he swung at 34.7 percent of pitches thrown out of the strike zone. In 2006, this rose to 36.7 percent, and over the last two seasons, to 36.7 and 36.3 percent. Granted, he has not gotten any worse in this regard, but maintaining the status quo in this situation is not a positive. Curiously enough, his rates of swinging at pitches in the strike zone have declined, from 85.8 percent in 2006, to 76.1 percent in 2008. Francouer still cannot lay off of pitches he shouldn’t be swinging at, and is keeping the bat on his shoulder on called strikes. I don’t know how anyone can truly succeed like that. Compounding the problem is that Francouer is now seeing more pitches out of the strike zone. And why not? If opposing pitchers know he can’t resist them, why bother giving him anything in the zone? Even with an increasing rate of contact on balls out of the zone, his overall numbers speak volumes for the type of contact he is managing.
Frenchy’s 2008 performance even earned him a demotion to Triple-A during the season. Prior to being sent down around Independence Day, he was hitting .234/.287/.374, with eight home runs. Upon returning a week later, Jeff hit .245/.303/.340. He improved his on-base percentage despite still posting a poor split-mark, but continued to exhibit less power. Francoeur is just 24 years old, but he does not walk, strikes out far too often, seems to rely on BABIP fluctuations to get him on base, and has shown very alarming signs in his fading power-hitting game. The formula for his success remains the same: he needs to lay off of outside pitches, which will cause pitchers to throw into his wheelhouse more often, giving him ample opportunity to get his bat on the ball. This will lead to an increased rate of walks, a higher OBP, and hopefully, a higher SLG. If he cannot make these adjustments, even his above-average defense will not keep him on the field for 162 games on a team seriously trying to contend. —Eric Seidman
Also, you cannot gloss over the fact that his isolated power (ISO, or SLG minus AVG) has steadily decreased year after year after year. (2005 — 2008: .249, .189, .151, .120).
All that having been said, Francoeur did end last season with 28 hits (8 doubles) in 98 ABs, good for .286/.333/.416. I believe that most here would consider that would be a fair 2009 start for him, particularly when compared to his 2008 season totals (.239/.294/.359), or even his career numbers (.268/.312/.434).
By DAP
January 2, 2009 11:52 AM | Link to this
steve McP Why would the Braves want to sign Nick Swisher?
well, first of all, that would be impossible, since he isnt a free agent.
but trading for swisher would be a good move for several reasons. first of all, he can play all three outfield positions, and 1st base. only is CF is he not excellent defensively, and even there he is serviceable. defensive versatility is a plus.
he is signed for the next three years at an average annual salary of $7mil, and has a club option of a 4th year, with a $1mil buyout. so a very team friendly contract.
also, he is pretty good offensively. he had a pretty bad year with chicago, but has shown the ability to get on base at a high rate and hit alot of homers. he hit 35 in 2006. also, look at his .219 BA in 2008 next to his .332 OBP. .332 isnt great, but to me, this shows he has the ability to take pitches and get walks. he has very good plate discipline. hes only 28, and had a rough year with a manager he didnt like, and i think he is going to bounce back.
by the way, comparing swisher to frenchy is just silly. first of all, frenchy had no where near the .434 slug% you cited. he slugged .359 in 08, with a .294 OBP. a .653 OPS.
swisher on the other hand, out-OBP francouer by about 40 points (.332OBP) and out slugged him by 50 points (.410slg%) for a .742 OPS.
but, you say fenchy out performed swisher. whatever, man.
again, id love to have swisher, i think he will bounce back and have a good season. hes got it in him.
By Anders
January 2, 2009 11:53 AM | Link to this
Jc from UT*
How about Yunel and Francouer for Buccholtz and JD Drew? Drew had a great year here before and seemed to really like BC and Chipper. Maybe boston will eat some of Julio Lugo’s contract and he can replace Yunel at ss
Sure, and the Red Sox can bailout the big three auto makers while they’re at it.
BTW- It was reported that Boston planned on using Ramirez in center not at SS where they are happy with Jed Lowrie. They were going to make Elsbury part of the trade. I doubt they would be interested in Yunel.
Now if the Braves wanted to trade Chipper for Buchholz plus and build around that trade I’d bet Boston would listen. After all they were ready to move things around to fit Tex in. He’s just the protection Big Papi needs. Hard decisions these but Wren needs to sell high, especially when the market won’t allow him to buy.
I know, I know I’m a blasphemer for thinking such things!
By AustinBraves
January 2, 2009 11:58 AM | Link to this
JC from UT- You would need to give up Yunel for sure, but I haven’t given up on Francouer. I like Drew but what type of salary and contract does he have? For sure Boston would do anything to get rid of Lugo maybe eat 90% of salary. Maybe Yunel and Morton for Buchholtz and Lugo.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 11:58 AM | Link to this
Braveheart There’s a sh!tload of literature out there that describes this stuff in much better detail than I can.
Okay, maybe there is, but just goes to show that some writers have too much time on their hands. My only criteria is that we have at 3rd base and catcher two of the best in the business. Escobar is a .300 hitter and Johnson is still improving. Kotchman hasn’t does as well since be traded, but he is great defensively and I hope he hits better in 2009. I expect Francoeur to bounce back and Diaz can hit period. Give us a quality CF and we could have a really good offensively club again like we had in 2007. Staying healthy is the key.
By Random
January 2, 2009 12:05 PM | Link to this
Dadgum: “Lowe ain’t signing with Atlanta. He has, I believe, officially turned down the Mets 36 mil/3 offer and looking for AJ Burnette type money. Can’t see the Braves going there.”
If they “went there” for Burnett, why in the world wouldn’t they go there (or farther, $$$-wise), for Lowe, by most (all?) accounts the better of the two???
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 12:06 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies If Francoeur doesn’t rebound to at least 2007 levels in 2009, then he’s Brad Komminsk, Version 2.0
Oh hell no! We will not, and I repeat will not compare Jeff Francoeur to that piece of crap Brad Komminsk, who NEVER, EVER showed an ability to play baseball in the bigs. As a matter of fact, he was the sole responsibility of Hank Aaron, who swore that Komminsk would be great. Just goes to show that just because you used to hit homers doesn’t mean that you can grade talent.
By KC
January 2, 2009 12:11 PM | Link to this
Simplifying the Franoeur situation…
We can talk about plate discipline and all of this sh!t until we’re blue in the face. But here’s the bottom line:
Francoeur was an excellent hitter and run producer in 2007. Over the winter, he got himself in football shape and took the field in 08 intent on hitting more homeruns… and it screwed him up. Royally.
Before the season during batting practice, Chipper watched him hit and busted on him by saying “lose an Andruw, gain an Andruw”. Ouch.
That says it all.
Plate discipline be damned. All Francoeur has to do is rid his mind of all things 2008, and pick up where he left off in September of 07’.
Sometimes good players have seasons like this, and the only thing that can fix it is several months away from the game, and a fresh start the next season. Just ask Tim Hudson.
By Steve McP
January 2, 2009 12:15 PM | Link to this
My bad on the SLG - .434 is Frenchy’s career figure.
I just worry that we could have another guy who gets out when it matters, and becomes very frustrating for the fans, we had Andruw doing that in 07 and then Frenchy last year - maybe a change of scenery will invigorate Swisher, adding 20+ homers would be great, as long as he gets some of them in important situations.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 12:17 PM | Link to this
Moby Grape So even if he bounces back to around that level, he is not anything special, and there is the possibility that he won’t come back that far. If you can’t get past BA/HR/RBI then you’ll think he’s just peachy
Mark my words, if he bounces back to the same levels before 2008, not one of you will be complaining about Jeff Francoeur. I know that because I don’t recall reading anything negative from this blog in 2007. But maybe DOB can shed some light on that for me in case my memory is a little hazy. And of course, you guys started calling him Frenchy in an adoring sort of way. Somebody besides me was pleased with the guy.
By Random
January 2, 2009 12:18 PM | Link to this
Braveheart There’s a sh!tload of literature out there that describes this stuff in much better detail than I can.
Jerald Holcombe: “Okay, maybe there is, but just goes to show that some writers have too much time on their hands.”
Also “goes to show” that they’ve thought about it a lot more than you have, and very likely know a lot more than you about what they’re talking about.
Simply shrugging them off or dismissing them out of hand suggests a willful ignorance on your part.
“I expect Francoeur to bounce back”
On the basis of what — wishful thinking?
I think you mean “you hope Francoeur bounces back” — as do we all, my friend, asduwial.
By Anders
January 2, 2009 12:22 PM | Link to this
Random and Dadgum
I haven’t seen any reports that Lowe has officially turned down the Mets offer. It was reported that he was underwhelmed which is no suprise. All that is is a signal from Boras to the rest of the market that Lowe is still open for business. Now, I think he’ll get more than the Mets offered but I would be shocked if anyone offered him near what Burnett got.
I also think the market is too quiet for him. Someone’s lurking out there ready to pounce - Could be Wren? We’ll see.
By Jim
January 2, 2009 12:38 PM | Link to this
Come on back soon Dave - we need a factoid out of Wren to give us some hope.
Let’s hope the B’s are trying to do something big with Toronto. Lots of opportunity there to help the B’s and also let the blue birds regenerate as they go through business issues related to death of owner and the stiff competition that team will face anyway in ‘09 in its division.
By DAP
January 2, 2009 12:39 PM | Link to this
steve mcP I just worry that we could have another guy who gets out when it matters,
swisher makes outs less often than andruw and frenchy, so swisher would be better than either of these guys were. also, let me just point out that swisher’s career slg% leads frenchy’s by about 20 points.
jerald holcomb if he bounces back to the same levels before 2008, not one of you will be complaining about Jeff Francoeur. I know that because I don’t recall reading anything negative from this blog in 2007.
thats probably because 2007 was seen as jeff improving. bloggers were happy with his performance and expected him to continue to improve in 2008. if he gets back to his 2007 numbers, i think most here will be happy, but if he stays there for his entire career, there will be much lamenting on what could have been.
By Bill
January 2, 2009 12:54 PM | Link to this
Go to SportingNews.com and read Chipper and the Braves can’t depend on Free Agents. Good stuff.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 2, 2009 12:59 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
Francoeur was called up in 2005 as a sheer emergency. Raul Mondesi and Brian Jordan could not play any more, and the Braves had moved Kelly Johnson to the OF because there was nobody on the major league roster who could hit a lick.
Frenchy showed every indication he would be an average or perhaps slightly above average major leaguers. His minor league OPS was .808 — a little better than the career minor league OPS of — that’s right — Brad Komminsk (.792), who arrived in Atlanta with a lot more fanfare. I saw Komminsk play in the minors, and like Frenchy, he looked like the real deal.
Frenchy wasn’t the most anticipated Braves prospect since Komminsk — Chipper was, and as a SS with an .874 OPS, there was reason to believe Chipper would be really special. Frenchy was brought because there was nobody else the Braves could turn to, and Time Warner wouldn’t give the front office two nickels to go out and get a veteran hitter. That’s the only reason Mondesi and Jordan were on the roster that year, period.
To his credit, Frenchy has not been overmatched to the degree Komminsk was from the day he reached the major leagues. But he has a lot of work to do to rebound. I hope it happens because I want the Braves to win.
By Random
January 2, 2009 1:25 PM | Link to this
KC: “Simplifying the Franoeur situation…
“We can talk about plate discipline and all of this sh!t until we’re blue in the face. But here’s the bottom line:
“Francoeur was an excellent hitter and run producer in 2007.”
If that’s your bottom-line, then you’re oversimplifying.
You’re dumbing it down, in fact, and we’re all the dumber for it (to the extent we buy what you’re peddling).
Francoeur simply was not an “excellent” hitter in 2007.
Except for Andruw, JF had more PAs with runners on base than any other Brave, and more runners on base in those situations than any other Brave. His 2007 BABIP demonstrates that he simply got lucky in 2007.
JF’s been on a hitting decline since 2005. It’s that “simple”.
So sure, he was better in 2007 than in 2008 — that’s not saying much; and sure, he was better in 2007 than Andruw was — that’s not saying much either. Neither are in any way an indicator of “excellence”.
By Anders
January 2, 2009 1:28 PM | Link to this
The words of Chipper Jones:
Ten or 15 years ago, we could lure people to Atlanta strictly on reputation. You knew we were going to win, and we had a bunch of good players. Players would shun money from New York and take less to come here. For the past three seasons, we’ve kind of been on the downslide and not making the playoffs, so you can’t do that anymore. We can’t compete monetarily, so the only way we’re going to get players in here to play and win is to force them—and that’s done by trading
Hmmm… Sounds like even Chipper himself agrees with what “old Crazy Anders” has been saying for months and months. The lure of Bobby Cox and the Braves organization is dead.
Then there was this interesting tidbit:
The downside to trading is that it weakens your minor league system. But the only way that we are going to win now is through trades
Hmmm.. Sounds like Chipper wants the Braves to trade some valued prospects now to force good players to come to Atlanta. Stay tuned.
By DAP
January 2, 2009 1:38 PM | Link to this
chipper jones frm the sportingnews.com article mentioned above:
“We won for 14 consecutive years, and you never, ever saw any bulletin board material. And now that these two teams are on top of the division, they can’t keep their mouths shut. Just go play baseball. It’s Cole Hamels now. It was Jimmy Rollins and Carlos Beltran the past couple of springs. These two teams are constantly going at each other verbally. You know, win with class, lose with class. Just keep your mouth shut and go play your game. “
love the quote from chipper, and its exactly how he plays. when he hits a homers, he just drops head head and runs, with no expression until he reaches the dugout. he celebrates there, laughs with teammates, has a good time, but on the field, its all business. he does not disrespect or show up the other team.
By Thrillhouse44
January 2, 2009 1:40 PM | Link to this
Anders, don’t pull anything patting yourself on the back there, chump.
By DAP
January 2, 2009 1:41 PM | Link to this
anders Sounds like even Chipper himself agrees with what “old Crazy Anders” has been saying for months and months. The lure of Bobby Cox and the Braves organization is dead.
who here has argued that point? ive read braves fans say that more than ive seen you say it.
By 74 Georgia grad
January 2, 2009 1:48 PM | Link to this
As someone who grew up devouring baseball stats and still has a great appreciation for the game’s numbers, there are times when I just want to scream at some of you spouting the latest and trendiest statistical offerings: WTF is that gibberish you’re citing.
The Braves much-maligned RF is a favorite target of the blog’s modern stat-heads, mostly because he has an aversion to taking four balls in a single at bat. During a recent discussion about Francouer, one person (a reasonably knowledgeable one if I remember correctly) opined that he was the worst corner outfielder in baseball based on his 2008 numbers, and wasn’t that special in the preceding seasons.
The reason for Francouer’s dismal ranking was one of baseball’s new 3-letter acronyms that make we want to utter one of several 4-letter words every time I come across them — OBP. Thanks to OBP & OPS, the modern baseball expert has discarded every other baseball stat relating to offense, with players judged solely on those 2 numbers.
What crap.
Francouer drove in 100 runs each of his first 2 full seasons, but as all of us troglodyte baseball fans have come to learn, RBIs are an inconsequential stat because they are too dependent on external factors. Obviously, there is a degree of truth to that, but in their zeal to boil down a hitter’s worth to one or two numbers, the modern statheads ignore an array of stats that provide better insights to a hitter’s production than the all-encompassing 3-letter acronyms.
The reason Francouer drove in 100 runs in ‘06 and ‘07 was because he hit over .300 both seasons with RISP and was among the league leaders in 2-out RBI. But since his almighty OBP was under .300 in ‘06 and his slugging percentage dropped in ‘07, he really wasn’t that good a player, because we all know that are RBIs are not an accurate reflection of a hitter’s worth and RISP is based on too few opportunities to be taken seriously.
For hitters like Francouer who spend most of their nights hitting somewhere in the 5-6-7 spots in the batting order, getting on base is a secondary concern to driving in runs. The fact that he doesn’t walk is not that big a deal, especially in comparison to a hitter at the top of the lineup, whose job it is to get on base.
Evaluating players primarily on the basis of those 3-letter acronyms is absurd, in part because it eliminates context. Such as:
Runners on 2nd & 3rd and 2 outs, #6 hitter at the plate. The pitcher is not going to issue an intentional walk, but is going to pitch around the hitter.
Scenario A: The hitter patiently takes his 4 balls to load the bases, and the next batter, a weaker hitter, pops up. According to the modern stathead, the #6 hitter has done his job perfectly; his OBP is 1.000. Did he help his team? Not really.
Scenario B: Instead of taking pitches a few inches off the plate, the #6 hitter decides to be aggressive, and dumps on outside pitch into the outfield for a 2-run single. According to the modern statheads, this result is no better than Scenario A, since he reached 1st base in either event.
Obviously, he also could have made an out, but the final result for the team is the same as had he taken the walk.
For those who downgrade the significance of RBIs, unless you can site a more modern version of Joe Carter, give it a rest. If a guy drives in 110 runs and hits .225 with RISP, then you have a case. If he drives in the same number of runs but hits .320 with RISP, there is no way you can disparage his accomplishment no matter what some of those 3-letter acronyms say.
Francouer more than did his job his first 2 1/2 seasons with the Braves. He was putrid last year and the team suffered as a result. Unless he has completely forgotten how to hit, unlikely considering his age and previous level of performance, he should be a very productive player again this season, regardless of what the those 3-letter acronyms tell us.
By Thrillhouse44
January 2, 2009 1:50 PM | Link to this
Anders, another thing: has anyone here argued the fact that Atlanta can’t lure free agents based on winning the way they used to? I know many others have stated the same thing in a much classier, less pompous manner than you have. (I don’t remember you ever saying it, but I’m not arguing that.) Regardless, it’s not a shock that the free agents aren’t begging to go to Atlanta; especially with Bobby nearing the end of his reign. But, according to you, we should all bow down and throw endearment towards “crazy old” d-bag Anders because he came on here and announced it for us.
Anders, today is Friday. Will you please post telling me how right I am so I can feel complete? Please!
By Trip K
January 2, 2009 1:56 PM | Link to this
Hopefully Wren is Looking into Sheets more than Lowe - sheets is a better pitcher and only 30.
and i would love to see the braves try to trade for someone like Clay Buchholz or Phil Hughes
braves sign sheets and trade chipper for Clay then sign ty wiggy. that would leave plenty of money to sign smoltz and a LF Also.
would make a very good roatation for now and even better future
how about 2010 sheets hudson JJ Hanson Buchholz
trade vazquez next winter. and lock up the young guns.
just talking out of my azz though.
By Doc Holiday
January 2, 2009 2:04 PM | Link to this
Plate discipline be damned. All Francoeur has to do is rid his mind of all things 2008, and pick up where he left off in September of 07’.
It might be easy to say that KC, but now he is in the Black hole, getting out of it could be easy, but it could also be impossible. It could be more than just a mental approach.
By DAP
January 2, 2009 2:10 PM | Link to this
74 Georgia grad
dont disregard those three letter stats so quickly, old man.
OBP is perhaps the most basic and telling offensive stat you can use. think about it. the best possible offense (or player) would be one that never made an out, weather with a hit, a walk, whatever (impossible, and the game would take forever, literally but still…) and the worst offense (or player) imaginable would be one who made an out ever single time.
the first senerio is a player with a 1.000 OBP, and the second is a .000 OBP. the closer to 1.000, the better.
thats it and pretty basic. its the most fundamental thing to an offense. not making outs, and a great measure of how valuable a player is.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 2:19 PM | Link to this
Bill Yea, Francoeur is so great nobody wants him
Were we shopping him? Nope. How do you know what the market for him would be if he isn’t being shopped. Furthermore, I doubt the front office would want to shop him.
Dadgum
Tim Hudson’s option year is 2010. It’s a $12mil mutually agreed upon option based on number of innings pitched in 2009. Now, considering the fact that he won’t reach those innings pitched in 2009 because of his surgery, I’m pretty sure that he will be a free agent at the end of 2009. That’s not to say that the Braves don’t do something to retain him, but it’s not likely unless he were to actually come back in August and pitch well enough convince the front office that it’s a good move.
DAP to everyone complaining about the blog, the content, the vacation info, the food and music stuff…you do realize that DOB is on vacation, right? you guys are absolute jerks. im sure you realize this, DOB, but very few of us feel that way, and are grateful that you would take the time to write a blog on your vacation. you care about what you do, and it shows. thanks, youre the best.
Geez dude, nobody’s said anything in that regard in days now. Why bring it back up. Let it go. I voiced an opinion and that is all it was. Go on to something else.
KC Plate discipline be damned. All Francoeur has to do is rid his mind of all things 2008, and pick up where he left off in September of 07’
Thank you
By Doc Holiday
January 2, 2009 2:24 PM | Link to this
love the quote from chipper, and its exactly how he plays. when he hits a homers, he just drops head head and runs, with no expression until he reaches the dugout. he celebrates there, laughs with teammates, has a good time, but on the field, its all business. he does not disrespect or show up the other team. DAP
You might be right, but not 100% IMO. That could be a problem sometimes, it has been discussed here many times. The lack of fire is not always a good thing. I agree talking so much trash is not the best way, but not showing a single emotion aint either, there has to be some balance between the 2.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 2:26 PM | Link to this
Random Also “goes to show” that they’ve thought about it a lot more than you have, and very likely know a lot more than you about what they’re talking about
Also helps to get paid to micro manage stats til they’re coming out of your ears. Me, I’ll stick to the human angle and what my eyes are telling me. Is that okay with you?
By DAP
January 2, 2009 2:29 PM | Link to this
jerald holcomb just catching up on the blog today, and wanted to make sure DOB knew he was appreciated from posting on his off day, even though a few idiots were giving him a hard time. if it doesnt apply to you, move on.
also, i cant find anywhere that says hudson’s option has anything to do with innings pitched? its not a vesting option, that i can tell, just a mutual option. where are you getting your info?
By DAP
January 2, 2009 2:31 PM | Link to this
doc holliday i think youre right. a good balance is important. i still respect chipper very much for the way he plays, though.
By Anders
January 2, 2009 2:33 PM | Link to this
DAP and Thrillhouse
who here has argued that point? ive read braves fans say that more than ive seen you say it.
Bull, most of you guys have only come to this conclusion once Hampton, Peavy, Burnett and Furcal left the Braves at the altar. I’ve been saying this for over a year and most would tell me players love to play for Cox and prefer Atlanta over New York because of the cost of living etc… Why are so many of you upset about Peavy, Burnett and Furcal if you knew they wouldn’t come anyway.
You guys are really something. Even DOB didn’t write about the lure being gone until about 5 blogs ago. Go look it up if you want.
Just for the record I’ve also been saying this Chipper thing ain’t done. If the Braves don’t make some kind of move he’s not gonna be happy sitting through another 90 loss season. Plus he saw the money they offered Burnett and Furcal - You think he wants to continue giving discounts to play with prodigies for the next couple of years? Or did you already say that too?
By Braveheart
January 2, 2009 2:36 PM | Link to this
Also helps to get paid to micro manage stats til they’re coming out of your ears. Me, I’ll stick to the human angle and what my eyes are telling me. Is that okay with you?
Jerald, you could get away with that if you weren’t suggesting lineups that will barely score 4 runs a game.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 2:42 PM | Link to this
74 Georgia grad, the problem with your analysis is that you are assuming what Francoeur did with RISP should count over two times as much as when he comes up without runners in scoring position.
Now, I’ll grant you that Francoeur should get some extra credit, if you will, for what he did with runners in scoring position. But should what he did then count over two times as much as what he did other times?
In 2007 he came to the plate 208 times with RISP. He came to the plate 488 times with either no runners on or with a runner only on first. In those 208 plate appearances, he did hit .341.
You are criticizing those who weigh on-base or out percentage and slugging percentage heavily when judging a player’s contributions at the plate, yet you want to say 208 plate appearances are over twice as valuable as his other plate appearances.
Last I checked, outs are pretty darn important in baseball, as are bases. And on-base and slugging measure both, which is why some view those stats as extremely important to judging what a player does at the plate.
By Efrim
January 2, 2009 2:42 PM | Link to this
Francoeur was an excellent hitter and run producer in 2007.
No, he wasn’t.
By DAP
January 2, 2009 2:44 PM | Link to this
anders bull yourself. unless chipper has been agreeing with you for a year, you have no point.
“the lure” hasnt mattered until this offseason anyways, since the braves havent had money to spend since time warner took over. and most of the time, they not only didnt have much to spend, but were cutting back.
any talk about “the lure” being gone has been premature until this offseason, because the braves really had very few chances to make competitive offers to big free agents.
p.s. almost every acquisition (trades, mostly) i can think of recently came with guys saying how excited they were to play for bobby cox and the braves.
By KC
January 2, 2009 2:50 PM | Link to this
RANDOM: “Francoeur simply was not an “excellent” hitter in 2007.”
2007: .293, 19 homers, 105 RBI, 40 doubles…
I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree.
By Steve from OH
January 2, 2009 2:51 PM | Link to this
Also helps to get paid to micro manage stats til they’re coming out of your ears. Me, I’ll stick to the human angle and what my eyes are telling me. Is that okay with you?
Some of the stats are a bit much, I’ll give you that, but unless you can watch every inning of every game for every team played, I’ll stick to objective analysis.
74 Ga grad:
OBP and OPS are neither complicated nor wrong. The other stuff, like AVG, RISP, and even RBI can be useful, but only when a hitter has demonstrated the basic ability to not make outs and hit for power. Once those criteria have (even marginally) been met, we can start looking at more subjective metrics to “round out” our player, so to speak. But no amount of RBIs, RS, SB, etc will compensate for a sub-.300 (or even .310-.320) OBP. Period. The hitter’s #1 job is to not make outs, and hitters like that are just not good at not making outs.
When the Josh Andersons and Jeff Francoeurs (who, for some strange reason, I’m still holding out hope for) of the world are manning 2/3 of your outfield and are OPSing .750 and .650, you’re not going to win. Period.
And for the record, the Frenchman’s OPS was 3% better than the league average last season, which is perfectly acceptable (but not great by any means). That’s why people were ok with it and hoping for improvement this season. No one was getting ready to name their kids Jeffy Jr, but he wasn’t hurting the team. This year he killed us.
By Doc Holiday
January 2, 2009 2:53 PM | Link to this
DAP
I also respect chipper. Maddux, Chipper, Smoltz and Glavine are the only superstars that have played for atlanta (not for the money) in the last 2 decades, for a significant amount of time. Some might add AJ, but IMO he never looked as a complete star to me, he had power numbers for sometime, but to me, he is (was) a star, not a superstar (if you could make a difference between the 2.
By Steve from OH
January 2, 2009 2:55 PM | Link to this
But to whoever suggested Frenchy was an “excellent” hitter in ‘07, he wasn’t. He was average-at-best. Please refer to Shaun’s 2:42.
By Thrillhouse44
January 2, 2009 2:55 PM | Link to this
Just for the record I’ve also been saying this Chipper thing ain’t done. Anders
If this “Chipper thing” is done, will you come on here and loudly admit that you were wrong? Or will you disappear the way you have the past two Septembers?
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 2:59 PM | Link to this
Also helps to get paid to micro manage stats til they’re coming out of your ears. Me, I’ll stick to the human angle and what my eyes are telling me. Is that okay with you?
Exactly. Maybe for some just “sticking to the human angle and what their eyes are telling them” is just fine. But when you are running a team or trying to gain knowledge about players, you may want to rely on statistical evidence.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 2:59 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies Frenchy showed every indication he would be an average or perhaps slightly above average major leaguers
Correction: Francoeur was being looked at to be the future leader of the Braves. At no point during his development did I read anything about him being just a serviceable outfielder. He was brought up from AA because of his potential. Otherwise, the Braves would’ve yanked someone from Richmond.
74 Georgia grad
Thank you for breaking it down for these people. I didn’t have the energy to do it, but my sentiments exactly.
DAP *the first senerio is a player with a 1.000 OBP, and the second is a .000 OBP. the closer to 1.000, the better.
thats it and pretty basic. its the most fundamental thing to an offense. not making outs, and a great measure of how valuable a player is*
OBP is not even viable unless you hit in the top 3 spots. The 4-6 spots are mainly run producers. The only other thing I’ll add is that your #3 hitter should be a hybrid of both, scoring a lot of runs as well driving in a lot of runs.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 3:06 PM | Link to this
RANDOM: “Francoeur simply was not an “excellent” hitter in 2007.”
KC: 2007: .293, 19 homers, 105 RBI, 40 doubles…
I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree.
ME: Isn’t it funny how the same folks who criticize others for relying on a few stats themselves rely on only a few stats…highly context-dependent ones at that?
KC, what does a .293, 19 homer, 105 RBI, 40 doubles like tell us? It tells us the rate at which Francoeur got a hit in his non-walk, non-sac plate appearances. It tells us how many of two types of hits he got: homers and doubles. It tell us how many runs he drove in without telling us how often many opportunities he had to drive in runs or how easy or difficult it was for him to drive in those runs.
That line doesn’t tell us how many outs he cost the Braves. It doesn’t tell us how many bases he accrued. It doesn’t tell us how often he got on base. All of these are very important aspects of offense yet batting average, homers, RBI, and doubles don’t tell us about those things.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 3:06 PM | Link to this
DAP (http://www.bravesnewsworld.com/2005/03/01/tim-hudson-extension/)
This link is where I got my info.
By N8
January 2, 2009 3:07 PM | Link to this
Doc Holiday
While I agree with you about the “lack of fire” that haunted us in the past (mostly in the post-season), there is something to be said with letting your play on the field do the talking.
Chipper is right. The Braves won the division 14 years in a row, and NEVER talked about being the team to beat. They let the other teams chasing them say that the road to the NL East goes through Atlanta.
There’s a difference between being outspoken and arrogant (in not down right cocky), then being quietly confident in your ability to win. Which both Chipper and the past Braves teams did for 14 years in a row.
Chipper is right. Teams should WIN with class and LOSE with class. Unfortunately, for the past 3 seasons, the Braves have had to do the latter.
By Steve from OH
January 2, 2009 3:08 PM | Link to this
OBP is not even viable unless you hit in the top 3 spots. The 4-6 spots are mainly run producers. The only other thing I’ll add is that your #3 hitter should be a hybrid of both, scoring a lot of runs as well driving in a lot of runs.
This is the silliest thing I’ve read in quite some time. Getting on base and driving in runs aren’t mutually exclusive. But every single hitter should be able to not make outs. A walk is INFINITELY better than an out. And in case you haven’t noticed, base hits do count towards OBP.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 3:13 PM | Link to this
OBP is not even viable unless you hit in the top 3 spots. The 4-6 spots are mainly run producers. The only other thing I’ll add is that your #3 hitter should be a hybrid of both, scoring a lot of runs as well driving in a lot of runs.
So, it’s okay for the 4-6 hitters to cost the team tons of outs? Guess what? Three outs and no baserunners is a scoreless inning. Anyone who realizes this (I’m assuming everyone here), should realize the importance of judging hitters and teams by on-base percentage.
Also, there’s the little fact that in the 100-plus years of baseball history, the teams with the highest on-base percentages tend to be the teams that score the most runs.
By KC
January 2, 2009 3:14 PM | Link to this
Random: As far as my “over-simplifying Francoeur’s problems/the solution…
There are many - MANY - examples in baseball of very good players (who were neither aged nor injured) having a terrible year; a season long slump that they simply couldn’t shake. And in the majority of these cases, the players bounce back the next year.
Just a few examples:
• Tim Hudson is the most recent example in a Braves uniform.
• Smoltz had problems in 94 (though not quite to the extent of Hudson or Frenchy).
• Clemens had a poor season in 93, but bounced right back.
• Mike Schmidt hit .251 with only 21 homers back in 78’, and hit 45 homeruns the next year.
• Mark McGwire hit .201 in 1991 (steroids and all)
Some people are talking as though it’ some fundamental flaw in Francoeur’s overall ability (such as his lack of plate discipline) that causes his problems in 07… leading them to the conclusion that he won’t be able to recover. But that makes no sense to me, given that these supposed flaws were present in his first 3 (very successful) seasons.
It is FAR more likely - nearly certain, in fact - that his problems were similar to those faced by all of the above players (and many more) in their worst seasons.
Often times, slumps are like quicksand. The more you try to do to get out of it, the worse your situation gets. He was never able to get his head straight and get out of it in 08.
Is it possible that he’ll never regain pre-2008 form? Sure, it’s possible. But I consider it highly unlikely. And I am willing to bet on that if you’re up for a friendly wager.
By DAP
January 2, 2009 3:15 PM | Link to this
jerald holcombe OBP is not even viable unless you hit in the top 3 spots. The 4-6 spots are mainly run producers. The only other thing I’ll add is that your #3 hitter should be a hybrid of both, scoring a lot of runs as well driving in a lot of runs.
totally 100% wrong. this shows a poor understanding of baseball.
it is true that high OBP guys usually hit a the top, and guys who have good power but not alot of on bae ability usually hit lower in the order, and its also true that #3 hitters are usually a good combo of both power and on base and are usually the best hitter on the team.
what is so incorrect about your statement that that OBP only matters for top of the order guys, and for 6, 7, 8 hitters it doesnt matter.
did you ever think that 6, 7, 8 hitter bat low because they arent high OBP guys and not vice versa? and, wouldnt it be great if every 6, 7, 8 hitter on your team suddenly became able to get on base like top end guys, making them basically all #3 type hitters?
OBP matter no matter where you hit in the lineup. it is improtant for a baseball player to have a good OBP.
By DAP
January 2, 2009 3:18 PM | Link to this
jerald holcomb
here is the sentence about the option from that article:
“The option in 2010 would be worth $12 million if exercised and carries a $1 million buyout, making the total package potentially worth $58 million.”
that doesnt say anything about a vesting option or anything about innings pitched. i believe the option is a straight-up mutual option, period.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 2, 2009 3:24 PM | Link to this
Jerald,
I wasn’t talking about what the Braves wanted Francoeur to become. I was talking about what his performance suggested, and that was a decent, everyday big leaguer and not a star.
The Braves’ brass was also convinced that Komminsk was going to be the next Dale Murphy, and we all know how that turned out.
If the front office elevates someone to stardom without evaluating whether he can play the game, then the front office needs some housecleaning.
You also wrote:
Me, I’ll stick to the human angle and what my eyes are telling me. Is that okay with you?
Fine. But that’s how the Braves evaluated Komminsk (and to a lesser extent, Francoeur).
He’s Roy Hobbs. Five tools. Cannon for an arm. Can hit the ball a mile. Graceful in the field. At some point, though, it’s also important to ask yourself — Does he understand the strike zone? Can he lay off unhittable pitches? Can he drive balls that aren’t in his wheelhouse? Does he make adjustments at the plate?
Your eyes can tell you some of that, and I actually give a lot more credit to the human element than some stats fans, but stats give you an objective way of telling if your eyes are deceivng you.
By Lew
January 2, 2009 3:29 PM | Link to this
Jerald-Dude, no matter how correct you are about Frenchy, you’ll never get the doom and gloomers to agree with you. Several of us have tried, but since he’ll never win an OBP or Slg% Crown (oh wait-there is NO such thing), he’ll never be acceptable to many. They DO offer Crowns for BA, HR and RBI, but they don’t count anymore. You can thank Fantasy Baseball for that one.
Random-Got to agree with you on that one. Lowe is worth what they offered for Burnett much more than Burnett is.
Mark-I didn’t see a reply to your question, though I might have missed it. Comcast in New England has the MLB channel and there is NO additional cost. They don’t have an HD channel and no one was sure if they would, but the visuals are great and they actually discussed some different topics-like The Roberto Clemente Award-thought that was nice for a change. I don’t have much interest in watching vintage games, but the channel should be better than having only ESPN. That is a certainty. No Chris Berman can’t be all bad.
By Steve from OH
January 2, 2009 3:30 PM | Link to this
Fangraphs recently did an article entitled “Is Schafer a future star?. They think he’s at least an above-average player, with a chance to be a superstar if he can hit lefties. They draw comparisons to Grady Sizemore, and talk about Schafer’s outstanding defense.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 2, 2009 3:32 PM | Link to this
Lew,
Happy New Year. I’m sure I qualify as a doom and gloomer to you, but that comment about Chris Berman was a gem.
By Anders
January 2, 2009 3:40 PM | Link to this
DAP
anders bull yourself. unless chipper has been agreeing with you for a year, you have no point
I never said Chipper agreed with me for a year? What are you talking about? I’ve been saying for more than a year the magic is gone. Now DOB, Chipper and apparently the rest of you are finally saying it.
p.s. almost every acquisition (trades, mostly) i can think of recently came with guys saying how excited they were to play for bobby cox and the braves.
Yep, and every acquisition by the Ynaks come with the guy saying how he’s wanted to play in pinstripes all his life - do you see the transparency in these things?
I’d ask you to think about when was the last time 4 or 5 guys the Braves actively sought turned their backs on the Braves in one off season - some for less money? Everything else is just words.
Plus you have Smoltz’s agents shopping for $ values. I know DOB tells us that’s just due diligence. But he also told us he had a good source who said Peavy wanted to come to the Braves and Furcal was looking forward to coming back to play for Bobby Cox and live in his house in Atlanta. How’d that turn out? Not saying DOB wasn’t told those things, just saying things aren’t always what they seem.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 3:41 PM | Link to this
Is it possible that he’ll never regain pre-2008 form?
KC, well I hope he’s much better than .280/.320/.463, which is what he did pre-2008.
Francoeur has yet to show much plate discipline plus his power is not all that great for a corner outfielder. I think that’s why some people aren’t all that optimistic about Francoeur becoming a superstar.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 3:42 PM | Link to this
Braveheart Jerald, you could get away with that if you weren’t suggesting lineups that will barely score 4 runs a game
Did I suggest any lineups? I don’t think I did.
Shaun 74 Georgia grad, the problem with your analysis is that you are assuming what Francoeur did with RISP should count over two times as much as when he comes up without runners in scoring position
Okay, let’s go with it. In 2007, Francoeur’s avg leading off an inning was .308. His avg with noone on base was .285.
Steve from OH But to whoever suggested Frenchy was an “excellent” hitter in ‘07, he wasn’t. He was average-at-best*
In 2007, he was tied for 24th in batting at .293. 11th in RBIs with 105. And if I remember right, he led the majors in avg with RISP at .341. If that is your idea of “average”, then I suggest that you look at some of the stat sheets available and look at all the great players that fell short of Francoeur’s numbers that year.
By Anders
January 2, 2009 3:47 PM | Link to this
Thrillhouse
If this “Chipper thing” is done, will you come on here and loudly admit that you were wrong? Or will you disappear the way you have the past two Septembers?
I was here this past September. As a matter of fact I made it a point to be on the blog the whole afternoon of the last day of the season. Not sure if there is an archives type access to this blog but if there is maybe someone could share how it works so Thrillhouse can go and validate my presence here. I received many kudos for being here that week as well as the next. I hope you don’t view this as me being pompous again as all I’m doing is answering you calling me out.
I was away the last week of 2007 in Las Vegas and San Diego on business. That couldn’t be helped. I did return the very next day however.
BTW- If the “Chipper Thing” does happen do I have your word not to call me pompous for reminding you of my thoughts?
By Lew
January 2, 2009 3:47 PM | Link to this
BravesFanInRockies-Happy New Year, to you, too. Nah, you’re just confused about Francoeur-otherwise you’re one of the good guys. Didn’t you read earlier? I’M the jerk-and smarmy and thuggish. Maybe I should go cry or scourge myself. Do you have some thumb screws I could borrow? Maybe some sackcloth and ashes? Anyone have an extra Iron Maiden? Somehow I doubt the Blog Ref would be satisfied if I just listened to Piece of Mind or Number of the Beast real loud. I feel so bad.
Steve-I saw Shafer play center last year (with Anderson in right) during Spring Training. They constituted one of the best defensive outfields I’ve seen in some time. I think they had Blanco in left at the time. Shafer will have you forgetting a good bit of Andruw’s prowess. The Kid is exceptional coming in on balls and plays deeper than Andruw did.
By Steve from OH
January 2, 2009 3:48 PM | Link to this
Jerald-Dude, no matter how correct you are about Frenchy, you’ll never get the doom and gloomers to agree with you. Several of us have tried, but since he’ll never win an OBP or Slg% Crown (oh wait-there is NO such thing), he’ll never be acceptable to many. They DO offer Crowns for BA, HR and RBI, but they don’t count anymore. You can thank Fantasy Baseball for that one.
Once again, I feel that you’re showing a profound misunderstanding of so-called “stat-heads,” and, it seems, fantasy baseball as well. OBP is the base skill a good hitter needs to have. Without it, a hitter is probably hurting his team. Jeff’s 2007 OBP was marginally acceptable, and his RBI/HR/BA totals were good, so (in my eyes), he was an acceptable player. Not great, maybe not even good, but not hurting our team by any means. And it’s not our fault that there’s no OBP crown. I blame Murry Chass and Ozzie Guillen. And I don’t even need to talk about Jeff’s 2008. We all like home runs and RBI as much as the next guy, but we know that there aren’t enough HR/RBI in the world (realistically) to compensate for a sub-.300 OBP. That’s really not that complicated or outrageous, is it?
And I an NOT a doom-and-gloomer. J’Accuse, Monsieur!
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 3:56 PM | Link to this
Several of us have tried, but since he’ll never win an OBP or Slg% Crown (oh wait-there is NO such thing), he’ll never be acceptable to many. They DO offer Crowns for BA, HR and RBI, but they don’t count anymore. You can thank Fantasy Baseball for that one.
Really? Every fantasy league I’ve played in overvalues batting average, homers, RBI and undervalues OBP and SLG…if they even include them. What kind of fantasy leagues are you playing in where they count the stats that are actually important in real life?
Do they offer anything if a player leads the league in homers or RBI? Do they even give a player anything if he wins the batting title? I’m not so sure. They may give him some sort of trophy. I’m assuming you mean the triple crown. But does the fact that players who lead the league in AVG-HR-RBI get recognized actually mean that those are the most important offensive stats? This goes to show how powerful tradition is.
By athensmatt
January 2, 2009 4:00 PM | Link to this
My favorite performance of any Brave in recent memory is when Jair Jurrjens was asked by a reporter if he was excited about facing fellow Curacao native Andruw Jones. His reply was “Yeah, and I’m also excited about striking him out.”
Jurrjens went on to strike him out THREE TIMES that game.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 4:02 PM | Link to this
Okay, let’s go with it. In 2007, Francoeur’s avg leading off an inning was .308. His avg with noone on base was .285.
His average with no one on was .285 with a .321 on-base. That’s not good.
His average with a runner on first was .235 with a .297 on-base. That’s worse.
Batting avearge only tells us how often he got a hit in his non-walk, non-sac plate appearances. It doesn’t tell us how many bases he gained or how often he avoided outs.
By Thrillhouse44
January 2, 2009 4:05 PM | Link to this
BTW- If the “Chipper Thing” does happen do I have your word not to call me pompous for reminding you of my thoughts? Anders
It depends on how you remind us, dude. If you check your attitude, I absolutely will.
I forgot that you were here this past September - respect for that.
I never said Chipper agreed with me for a year? What are you talking about? I’ve been saying for more than a year the magic is gone. Now DOB, Chipper and apparently the rest of you are finally saying it.
DAP and I pointed out earlier that you were not the only to say that some of the lure was gone. Your snarky reply was that you had boasted of this for over a year. I believe that is what DAP was referencing.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 4:05 PM | Link to this
Also, there’s the little fact that in the 100-plus years of baseball history, the teams with the highest on-base percentages tend to be the teams that score the most runs Shaun
really? Then just to be curious, what was the OBP of the 1918 White Sox?
what is so incorrect about your statement that that OBP only matters for top of the order guys, and for 6, 7, 8 hitters it doesnt matter DAP
You have the amazing ability to not see what you are reading. Reread what I said and you see that I said that the 4-6 hitting are MAINLY for driving in runs. Of course, you would like for them to get on base, but getting the runs in in front of them is what matters most. Getting walked is not what the 4-6 hitters are looking for. And please, if you don’t agree with me, then that’s great. Don’t agree, but don’t question a man’s ability to understand the game. I’ve been devouring Braves baseball since 1966 and even managed 3 consecutive Little League teams with different players each year to a 55-3 record and 3 district titles. I do know at least a little about baseball.
By BravesFanInRockies
January 2, 2009 4:07 PM | Link to this
Lew,
Nope. Fresh out of thumb screws. Not sure if they have them on eBay, either!
And I for one am looking forward to seeing Schafer play next year. I hope he’s not completely overwhelmed by major league pitching early on, otherwise he’ll probably start the year in Gwinnett.
I’m not expecting a Jay Bruce-style debut. But hey, if he hits as well as Gregor Blanco did coming out of ST 2008, he’ll probably win the CF job. And he’s someone who does show the potential to be a special player.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 4:17 PM | Link to this
Batting Average vs. On-Base Percentage: Bringing Data to the Debate
From the author’s work and some comments he left on his site:
“…36% of the variance in team wins is explained by team on-base percentage, while only 22% of the variance in team wins is explained by batting average.”
“I wanted to show how one statistic, on-base percentage, is more important (in terms of helping a team win a game) than the traditional gold standard statistic in baseball: batting average.”
“So I looked at this year’s data and plotted each team’s batting average and on-base percentage against their total wins, so that I could see how much correlation there is. Each dot on the scatterplot represents one baseball team’s mark so far this year. What I found is that as I suspected, batting average isn’t as good a predictor of winning as on-base percentage.”
Notice he’s not saying on-base percentage is the only important stat or that it’s the only one anyone should look at or even that batting average should be ignored. He’s simply stating on-base percentage correlates with winning better than batting average.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 4:18 PM | Link to this
here is the sentence about the option from that article:
“The option in 2010 would be worth $12 million if exercised and carries a $1 million buyout, making the total package potentially worth $58 million.”
that doesnt say anything about a vesting option or anything about innings pitched. i believe the option is a straight-up mutual option, period DAP
I don’t know how you could miss it, but you did. I’ll reprint it in it’s entirety.
As expected, the Braves inked their new ace Tim Hudson to an extension in the nick of time. With Hudson’s self-imposed March 1st deadline for getting a deal done only hours away, the pitcher signed on the dotted line. What was originally rumored to be a three-year extension with two option years ended up being a four-year extension with one option year (a mutual option tied to the number of innings he logs during the 2009 season).
After making $6.75 million this year, Hudson will pull down an average of almost $12 million a year from 2006 through 2009, a total of $47 million over four years. He’ll take home a cool $10 million as a signing bonus immediately, followed by $4 million in 2006, $6 million in 2007, and $13 million each in 2008 and 2009. The option in 2010 would be worth $12 million if exercised and carries a $1 million buyout, making the total package potentially worth $58 million.
By KC
January 2, 2009 4:19 PM | Link to this
Shaun: I like your selective statistical argument.
What you didn’t mention about his pre-2008 performance was the fact that he drove in over 100 runs in each of his first 2 seasons, and if you project his rookie season out to a full year’s work, he did it in 2005 as well.
In 05, 06, 07 combined, he had 1,550 at-bats. If you divide that 640 at-bats (a typical number for him in a full season)… here’s what he averaged over his first 3 seasons:
.280, 26 homers, 105 RBI, 35 doubles.
Again, I’m available for wagering on his 2009 performance.
By Anders
January 2, 2009 4:21 PM | Link to this
Thrillhouse
Come on guy. I take a lot of crap on here. I get that my remarks wrankle you guys but I get 10 times what I give as I should being that it’s a Braves blog. I’ve developed a thick skin on here. I do get sarcastic and like to take shots at guys when I get the chance, but who doesn’t? I mean, have you met the blogmaster?
Anyway, I don’t name call (I was called a D..bag by either you or DAP, I forget which), I don’t do the north/south thing and I stay away from political stuff. So I think I play fair and will continue to do so.
For the record I think you and DAP have been pretty fair with me in the past too. We have our run in’s but that’s what fans do. No problem with that from this end.
By AZBravoFan
January 2, 2009 4:25 PM | Link to this
Someone mentioned the Jurrjens moment of striking out Andruw 3 times. My favorite Jurrjens moment was his first game at Shea when he had what was should clearly have been called strike 3 to end an inning, then briefly lost his cool and ended up walking in a couple runs. Shea was going nuts, the game was slipping away. Then after some visits from Roger and Mac and Chipper, he settled down, got out of the inning without any further damage, and went on to win the game. I think he grew up a whole lot that inning.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 4:25 PM | Link to this
really? Then just to be curious, what was the OBP of the 1918 White Sox?
Jerald Holcombe, the 1918 White Sox finished 6th. They ranked 4th in on-base and 6th in runs.
Maybe you are thinking of the 1919 White Sox, who threw the World Series. They ranked 2nd in OBP and 1st in runs.
Or maybe you’re thinking of the “Hitless Wonders,” the 1906 White Sox. They finished 5th in OBP and 3rd in runs. However those rankings are somewhat deceiving. Their OBP was .295 in a league that posted a .303 on-base. They scored 3.7 runs per game; the league average was 3.67 runs per game. So they were basically an average scoring team with an average on-base percentage. They won because of pitching.
By Shaun
January 2, 2009 4:33 PM | Link to this
What you didn’t mention about his pre-2008 performance was the fact that he drove in over 100 runs in each of his first 2 seasons, and if you project his rookie season out to a full year’s work, he did it in 2005 as well.
KC, yes, but we all know RBI are highly context-dependent. In other words, he drove in that many runs mostly because of the lineup he was in and the playing time he received.
I’ll wager Francoeur will be around the projections found here or here
I’ll put these projections up against most other projections, especially those made by just eyeballing.
By Jerald Holcombe
January 2, 2009 4:36 PM | Link to this
His average with no one on was .285 with a .321 on-base. That’s not good Shaun
I’d like to have a whole team of .285 hitters
1n 2007: leading off .308, bases loaded .364, scoring position with 2 outs. .333, none on .285, runners on .303, RISP .341 What else do you want!
By Thrillhouse44
January 2, 2009 4:44 PM | Link to this
Anders, gotcha and I apologize for the d bag comment.
By Steve from OH
January 2, 2009 4:46 PM | Link to this
I’d like to have a whole team of .285 hitters
You’