Powered by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Web Search by YAHOO!
 

Updated: 1:45 p.m. Wednesday, Oct. 2, 2013 | Posted: 1:45 p.m. Wednesday, Oct. 2, 2013

BP executive: Well could have been sealed sooner

By MICHAEL KUNZELMAN

The Associated Press

NEW ORLEANS —

BP could have ended its massive oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico sooner if it had built a capping stack before the 2010 blowout of its well off the coast of Louisiana, a company executive said under cross-examination Wednesday at a trial over the deadly disaster.

James Dupree, who led BP's efforts to seal its Macondo well, said engineers didn't have the equipment they needed to attack this particular well at the time of the blowout and had to formulate several possible solutions "on the fly." After several other methods failed, BP ultimately used a capping stack to seal the well 87 days after the blowout.

During cross-examination by a plaintiffs' attorney, Dupree said it would have been relatively inexpensive for BP to build a capping stack before the Deepwater Horizon disaster.

"We certainly weren't as prepared as we are today," Dupree said. "We didn't have the equipment to attack a Macondo-type event."

BP's trial adversaries claim the company ignored decades of warnings about the risks of a deep-water blowout and failed to adequately prepare. BP's attorneys insist the company complied with all government requirements and industry standards for spill preparedness, and neither required the company to have a capping device.

Other companies didn't have capping stacks, either, and such a device had never been used before 2010 to contain a deep-water blowout.

Asked by plaintiffs' attorney Brian Barr whether the Macondo well could have been sealed sooner with a pre-built capping stack, Dupree initially answered, "It would depend on what kind of capping stack you built." But he ultimately agreed with Barr that it could have been possible to cap the well sooner if the device had been assembled before the blowout.

He also said how quickly it could be deployed would also depend on removal of debris and preparing the wellhead to receive the capping stack.

Before the 2010 blowout, BP had a 600-page oil spill response plan that only included one page on "source control." It called for assembling a team of experts to devise a way to stop a blowout while relief wells are drilled. Dupree said he never referred to the document while he led the response.

During the first few weeks after the spill, engineers focused on two methods for stopping the flow of oil: Capping the well was one option. The other, called "top kill," involved pumping drilling mud and other material into the Deepwater Horizon rig's blowout preventer.

With the federal government's approval, BP employed the "top kill" method in May 2010. But it didn't stop the flow of oil.

Dupree testified that his decision to proceed with "top kill" was guided by the principle that they shouldn't do anything that could make the crisis even worse.

"I certainly believed that it was a low risk, we would learn a lot and we would potentially kill the well," he said.

Plaintiffs' lawyers claim BP knew the strategy was doomed to fail based on higher flow rate estimates that the company didn't share with federal officials at the time.

Mark Mazzella, a BP employee who led the "top kill" procedure offshore, testified Wednesday that he had been confident it would succeed.

"We wouldn't have tried this if we didn't think it would work," he said.

BP's adversaries argue the company could have stopped the spill much earlier than July 15 if it had used a strategy called "BOP-on-BOP," which called for lowering a second blowout preventer on top of the rig's failed one.

But BP concluded it wasn't a viable option because it could have made the situation worse and hampered other strategies if it failed. Dupree said he had feared it could cause an uncontainable blowout on the seafloor.

BP says the capping stack that later sealed the well was specifically designed to land on the well system above the blowout preventer.

Dupree was BP's first witness for the second phase of the trial, which is divided into two segments. The first focuses on BP's response to the spill. The second, scheduled to start Monday, is designed to help U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier determine how much oil spilled into the Gulf.

The trial's first phase ended in April after eight weeks of testimony about the causes of the blowout.

Copyright The Associated Press

More News

 

Today on MyAJC.com

Hotoberfest kicks off another season of beer festivals

Hotoberfest kicks off season of beer festivals

Looking for something to do this weekend? If you are a beer lover, you might want to check out Hotoberfest 2013 at Historic Fourth Ward Park on North Avenue.

APS superintendent: Close 13 schools

Image hurts, helps in search for new superintendent

The hunt for a new leader of Atlanta Public Schools has picked up steam, with superintendent candidates being targeted from across the country to replace Erroll Davis, who will retire next year.

myajc logo 300x225

New 24-hour Digital Pass: Sample all of MyAJC.com for 99 cents

With a 24-hour digital pass, you can enjoy full versions of premium articles, news updates and access to the AJC online archives.

Irresistible news

Governor compares gay marriage to incest

Pennsylvania Republican Gov. Tom Corbett is in hot water after he compared same-sex marriage to incest in a TV interview.

Comments  (30)  

Tiger mauls employee at animal sanctuary

An Oklahoma woman is recovering after a tiger attacked her at a zoo in Wynnewood about an hour south of Oklahoma City.

Comments  (5)  

AP IMPACT: Families hoard cash 5 yrs after crisis

AP IMPACT: Families hoard cash 5 yrs after crisis

Five years after U.S. investment bank Lehman Brothers collapsed, triggering a global financial crisis and shattering confidence worldwide, families in major countries around the world are still hunkered down, too spooked and distrustful to take chances with their money.

5 achievements that haven't won a Nobel Prize

5 achievements that haven't won a Nobel Prize

The announcements of this year's Nobel Prize winners will start Monday with the medicine award and continue with physics, chemistry, literature, peace and economics.

Latest in news

SAT scores align with family wealth in Georgia.

AJC special report: SAT scores rise with family wealth. A notable exception in state: Norcross High

The AJC education team looked at recently released 2013 SAT scores for metro Atlanta high schools and found something that critics have long said: Scores are closely tied to a factor beyond any student's aptitude: the amount of money their parents have.