Powered by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Web Search by YAHOO!
 

Updated: 7:21 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 3, 2013 | Posted: 7:20 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 3, 2013

Court: Surrogate mom can seek child custody

By SANDRA CHEREB

The Associated Press

CARSON CITY, Nev. —

A lesbian woman who gave birth to a child conceived from a fertilized egg provided by her companion can argue for parental rights in the wake of the couple's breakup, the Nevada Supreme Court ruled Thursday.

The unanimous decision overturns a lower court ruling and allows Sha'Kayla St. Mary to seek joint custody of the child born in June 2008 while she was with her former partner, Veronica Lynn Damon.

Damon provided a fertilized egg, with sperm donated by an anonymous donor. The egg was then implanted in St. Mary, who carried the child to term and gave birth in June 2008.

The birth certificate listed St. Mary as the mother.

After the couple broke up a year later, St. Mary signed an affidavit declaring Damon as the child's biological mother, according to court records.

But in seeking custody, visitation and child support, justices said a Clark County judge erred by determining St. Mary was a "mere surrogate" and by not considering a joint-parenting agreement the couple had signed before the child was born.

In 2011, the judge said St. Mary was entitled to third-party visitation but not custody and noted that previous orders determined she had no biological or legal rights under Nevada law.

Justices disagreed and said the joint-parenting agreement was more than a surrogacy arrangement.

"This case presents a situation where two women proffered evidence that could establish or generate a conclusive presumption of maternity to either woman," Justice Nancy Saitta wrote for the court.

"St. Mary asserts that she is a legal mother of the child in addition to Damon, not instead of Damon," the opinion said. "This claim must be given consideration under the Nevada Parentage Act, which does not preclude the child from having two legal mothers."

It added, "When a child has the opportunity to be supported by two loving and fit parents pursuant to a co-parenting agreement, this opportunity is to be given due consideration and must not be foreclosed on account of the parents being of the same sex."

Justices sent the case back to district court for further proceedings.

Copyright The Associated Press

More News

 

Today on MyAJC.com

Botanical Garden’s ‘scarecrows’ are stuffed with silliness

Botanical Garden’s ‘scarecrows’ are stuffed with silliness

Native Americans are said to have created the first scarecrows on these shores to protect their corn crops from the scavenging black birds.

Paul Howard

DA’s spending of federal forfeiture money in question

Finances of the Fulton County District Attorney’s Office were in such chaos in recent years that even its most basic bills went unpaid.

Comments  (9)  

myajc logo 300x225

New 24-hour Digital Pass: Sample all of MyAJC.com for 99 cents

With a 24-hour digital pass, you can enjoy full versions of premium articles, news updates and access to the AJC online archives.

Irresistible news

Survey respondents choose coffee over sex and booze

The survey by Le Meridien Hotels & Resorts found that 54 percent of people surveyed around the world said they make their first cup of coffee at home, and 78 percent said that instead of giving up coffee, they would rather give up alcohol, social media and sex with their spouse for a whole year.

Deli worker chases armed robber with a machete

RAW VIDEO: Suffolk County Police are searching for a man who recently attempted to rob a Stop and Shop Deli at gunpoint.

Mexican monster truck wreck kills 8, hurts dozens

Monster truck plows into crowd in Mexico, killing 8

WARNING: Graphic video (above) A tragic ending to a monster truck show in Chihuahua, Mexico Saturday night — at least eight people were killed, including a child and dozens of others were seriously injured.

Three-year-old golfer hits amazing trick shots

Move over Rory Mcllroy, there's a new golfing prodigy in town. Three-year old Michael Patton from Dublin, Ireland, showed he may have the skills to pay the bills in the future by performing some delicate chip shots in his living room.

Latest in news

Hair weave theft suspects linked to several smash-and-grabs

Hair weave theft suspects linked to several smash-and-grabs

In a matter of minutes, so-called hair weave thieves have done thousands of dollars worth of damage, using a technique now familiar: Drive a stolen car into a beauty supply store; grab pricey hair extensions; hit the road before police can arrive; make off with up to $60,000 worth of products.